All the philosophers, divines and doctors of the law were assembled in court for
the trial of Mullah Nasruddin. The accusation was a serious one; he had been going
from town to town saying, “Your so-called religious leaders are ignorant and
confused.” So he was charged with heresy, the penalty for which was death.
“You may speak first,” said the Caliph.
The Mullah was perfectly self-possessed. “Have paper and pens brought in,” he
said, “and give them to the ten wisest men in this august assembly.”
To Nasruddin’s amusement, a great squabble broke out among the holy men as to who
was the wisest among them. When the contention died down and each of the chosen
ten was equipped with paper and pen, the Mullah said, “Have each of them write
down the answer to the following question: WHAT IS MATTER MADE OF?”
The answers were written down and handed to the Caliph who read them out. One
said, “It is made of nothing.” Another said, “Molecules.” Yet another, “Energy.”
Others, “Light,” “I do not know,” “Metaphysical Being” and so on.
Said Nasruddin to the Caliph, “When they come to an agreement on what matter Is,
they will be fit to judge questions of the spirit. Is it not strange that they
cannot agree on something that they themselves are made of, yet they are unanimous
in their verdict that I am a heretic?”
It is not the diversity of our dogmas
but our dogmatism
that does the damage.
Thus, if each of us did what we are firmly persuaded
is the will of God
the result would be utter chaos.
Certainty is the culprit.
The spiritual person knows uncertainty -
a state of mind unknown to the religious fanatic.
🙂
All the philosophers, divines and doctors of the law were assembled in court for
the trial of Mullah Nasruddin. The accusation was a serious one; he had been going
from town to town saying, “Your so-called religious leaders are ignorant and
confused.” So he was charged with heresy, the penalty for which was death.
“You may speak first,” said the Caliph.
The Mullah was perfectly self-possessed. “Have paper and pens brought in,” he
said, “and give them to the ten wisest men in this august assembly.”
To Nasruddin’s amusement, a great squabble broke out among the holy men as to who
was the wisest among them. When the contention died down and each of the chosen
ten was equipped with paper and pen, the Mullah said, “Have each of them write
down the answer to the following question: WHAT IS MATTER MADE OF?”
The answers were written down and handed to the Caliph who read them out. One
said, “It is made of nothing.” Another said, “Molecules.” Yet another, “Energy.”
Others, “Light,” “I do not know,” “Metaphysical Being” and so on.
Said Nasruddin to the Caliph, “When they come to an agreement on what matter Is,
they will be fit to judge questions of the spirit. Is it not strange that they
cannot agree on something that they themselves are made of, yet they are unanimous
in their verdict that I am a heretic?”
It is not the diversity of our dogmas
but our dogmatism
that does the damage.
Thus, if each of us did what we are firmly persuaded
is the will of God
the result would be utter chaos.
Certainty is the culprit.
The spiritual person knows uncertainty -
a state of mind unknown to the religious fanatic.
🙂