Page MenuHomePhabricator

[Goal] Begin table of contents A/B test
Closed, ResolvedPublic

Description

Background

We would like to A/B test the completed table of contents feature to identify whether it increases usage and reduces the need to scroll to the top of the page

Notes

This ticket will track all blockers for the ToC A/B test

Related Objects

Status Subtype Assigned Task
Resolved ovasileva
Resolved ovasileva
Resolved ovasileva
Resolved ovasileva
Resolved Esanders
Resolved Spike bwang
Resolved BUG REPORT Edtadros
Resolved Jdlrobson
Resolved ovasileva
Resolved Jdrewniak
Resolved ovasileva
Resolved ovasileva
Resolved Edtadros
Resolved ovasileva
Resolved Jdlrobson
Resolved cjming
Resolved ovasileva
Resolved ovasileva
Resolved ovasileva
Resolved Edtadros
Resolved BUG REPORT Jdlrobson
Resolved BUG REPORT nray
Resolved Edtadros
Resolved BUG REPORT nray
Resolved jwang
Declined jwang
Resolved jwang
Resolved jwang
Resolved ovasileva
Resolved jwang
Resolved Jdlrobson
Resolved BUG REPORT ovasileva
Resolved ovasileva
Resolved ovasileva

Event Timeline

ovasileva triaged this task as High priority.Mar 18 2022, 3:25 PM
ovasileva created this task.

Can I turn it on if I am not selected?

@Patriccck, the A/B test will only be performed on the early adopter (test) wikis. As I can see, you mostly edit Czech Wikipedia, which is not on that list yet.

First, I would recommend enabling Vector 2022 in your global preferences. Then:

  • If you go to Czech Wikipedia, you will see all our improvements, including the new table of contents.
  • If you go to any of the test wikis, you will see all the previous improvements, and you will only have a 50% chance of seeing the new table of contents.

The big plus to Vector 2022 was regaining the ~15% of screen widthe taken up by the left-hand menu for displaying real content. If it now means losing ~30% to the ToC, with no way to turn it off, I'm switching back to the legacy Vector.

Subscribing so I can see when my days as a guinea-pig are over and I can switch back again.

The effects on screen width are really bad right now, I agree. I was also surprised to see that overflow of long titles is not handled at all at this point. Well, I'll be patient.

@Cabayi @XanonymusX please join us over at T306660 to discuss the issue of the table of contents on narrow screens. If you can include a screenshot, as well as details about your workflow (why do you make your screen narrow, do you need the table of contents when your screen is narrow, etc.) that would be super helpful.

I was also surprised to see that overflow of long titles is not handled at all at this point. Well, I'll be patient.

thanks for this feedback. can you let us know what specifically is bothering you, and any ideas you have regarding possible improvements?

I was also surprised to see that overflow of long titles is not handled at all at this point. Well, I'll be patient.

thanks for this feedback. can you let us know what specifically is bothering you, and any ideas you have regarding possible improvements?

Well, long titles are simply hidden when they reach the right border; no ellipsis, not even some padding. The traditional TOC simply became bigger the longer the titles were. There are generally two options: overflow hidden with an ellipsis or word-break. I'm not sure what the best solution would be here, but anything is better than the current situation..

@XanonymusX interesting...long titles/section links should be wrapping. if not, that's a bug. can you include a screenshot of what you're seeing? for me I see this:

Screen Shot 2022-04-26 at 11.09.18 AM.png (229×317 px, 20 KB)

Ah, sorry, I should have said long words in titles! Of course titles wrap at spaces, that is not the issue.

Ah, sorry, I should have said long words in titles! Of course titles wrap at spaces, that is not the issue.

ah ok, thanks for the clarification. I will go search for an example, however if you already have one please add a screenshot and a link here.

Works for me? https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tasaday

Screen Shot 2022-04-26 at 8.34.45 AM.png (860×540 px, 86 KB)

(This seems a little off topic so perhaps we should start a new ticket?)

ok I think I see what you mean:

before after
Screen Shot 2022-04-26 at 11.33.42 AM.png (423×377 px, 44 KB)
Screen Shot 2022-04-26 at 11.34.13 AM.png (314×480 px, 69 KB)

@XanonymusX task is here: https://phabricator.wikimedia.org/T306913
thanks for catching this

The A/B test is enabled everywhere so moving goal to sign off.