Abstract
Over the last two decades an increasing emphasis has been placed on the importance of controlling for phylogeny when examining cross-species data; so-called comparative methods. These methods are appropriate for testing hypotheses about correlations between evolutionary events in the history of a clade and adaptive responses to those changes. When this approach is applied to extinction risk, possible correlations between evolutionary changes in, for example, body size or habitat specialisation and some measure(s) of current threat status are examined. However, there may be a mismatch here between the results of such studies, and the real, pragmatic needs of species conservation. This kind of approach certainly adds to our knowledge of some fundamental processes, but it is more difficult to see how this can be applied to conservation decision-making. For more practical purposes a decision-tree approach can be extremely useful. This paper illustrates the use of a contrasts based analysis of extinction risk compared with a decision-tree analysis for Galliformes (Aves). While the contrasts analyses concur with some general macroecological trends found in other studies, the decision-tree models provide lists of species predicted to be more at risk than current assessments would suggest. We argue that in practical terms, decision tree models might be more useful than a macroecological linear model-based approach.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
InstitutionalAuthorNameAmerican Ornithologists’ Union (1998) Check list of North American birds American Ornithologists’ Union Washington, DC
J.F. Bell (1999) Tree-based methods A.H. Fielding (Eds) Machine Learning Methods for Ecological Applications Kluwer Academic Boston, MA and London 89–106 Occurrence Handle10.1007/978-1-4615-5289-5_3
InstitutionalAuthorNameBirdlife international (2000) Threatened Birds of the World Lynx Ediciones and Birdlife International Barcelona and Cambridge, UK
J. Brashares (2003) ArticleTitleEcological, behavioural and life-history correlates of mammal extinctions in West africa Conserv. Biol. 17 733–743 Occurrence Handle10.1046/j.1523-1739.2003.01592.x
Brom T.G. and Dekker R.W.R.J. 1992. Current studies on megapode phylogeny. In: Dekker R.W.R.J and Jones D.N. (eds), Proceedings of the First International Megapode Symposium, Christchurch, New Zealand, December 1990. Zoologische Verhandelingen 278: 7–17.
D.M. Brooks S.D. Strahl (2000) Currasows, Guans and Chachalacas: Status, survey and conservation Action Plan for Cracids 2000–2004 IUCN Gland, Switzerland and Cambridge, UK
S. Cramp K.E.L. simmons (1980) Handbook of the Birds of Europethe Middle East and North Africa Vol. 2 Oxford University Press Oxford, UK
R.W.R.J. Dekker R.A. Fuller G.C. Baker (2000) Megapodes: Status, Survey and Conservation Action Plan 2000–2004 IUCN and World Pheasant Association Gland, Switzerland and Cambridge, UK and Reading, UK
J. Delacour (1977) The pheasants of the world EditionNumber2 Spur Publications Hindhead, UK
J. del Hoyo A. Elliott J. Sargatal (1994) Handbook of the Birds of the World Barcelona Lynx Ediciones
J.B. Dunning SuffixJr. (1993) CRC Handbook of Avian Body Masses CRC Press London
J. Felsenstein (1985) ArticleTitlePhylogenies and the comparative method Am. Nat. 125 1–15 Occurrence Handle10.1086/284325
D.O. Fisher I.P.F. Owens (2004) ArticleTitleThe comparative method in conservation biology Trend. Ecol. Evol. 19 IssueID7 391–398 Occurrence Handle10.1016/j.tree.2004.05.004
R.A. Fuller J.P. Carroll P.J.K. McGowan (2000) Partridges, Quails, Francolins, Snowcocks and Guineafowl: Status, Survey and Conservation Action Plan 2000–2004 IUCN and the World Pheasant Association Gland, Switzerland and Cambridge, UK, and Reading, UK
R.A. Fuller P.J. Garson (2000) Pheasants: Status, Survey and Conservation Action Plan 2000–2004 IUCN and the World Pheasant Association Gland, Switzerland and Cambridge, UK, and Reading, UK
T. Garland P.H. Harvey A.R. Ives (1992) ArticleTitleProcedures for the analysis of comparative data using phylogenetically independent contrasts Systematic Biology 41 IssueID1 18–32
A. Grafen (1989) ArticleTitleThe phylogenetic regression Philos. Trans. R. Soc. Ser. B 326 119–157 Occurrence Handle10.1098/rstb.1989.0106 Occurrence Handle1:STN:280:DyaK3c7jvFamug%3D%3D
A.H. Harcourt S.A. Coppeto S.A. Parks (2002) ArticleTitleRarity,specialization and extinction in primates J. Biogeogr. 29 445–456 Occurrence Handle10.1046/j.1365-2699.2002.00685.x
P.H. Harvey M.D. Pagel (1991) The Comparative Method in Evolutionary Biology Oxford University Press Oxford
R.N. Holdaway (1999) Introduced predators and avifaunal extinction in New Zealand R.D.E. MacPhee (Eds) Extinctions in Near Time: Causes, Contexts and Consequences Plenum Press New York 189–238 Occurrence Handle10.1007/978-1-4757-5202-1_9
K.C.R. Howman (1979) Pheasants: Their Breeding and Management K. and R. Books Edlington, UK
Johnsgard P.A. 1983. The Grouse of the World. Croom Helm Ltd.
P.A. Johnsgard (1988) The Quails, Partridges and Francolins of the World Oxford University Press Oxford, UK
P.A. Johnsgard (1999) Pheasants of the World: Biology and Natural History, 2nd edn Swan Hill Press Shrewsbury, UK
D.N. Jones R.W.R.J. Dekker C.S. Roselaar (1995) The Megapodes Oxford University Press Oxford, UK
K.E. Jones A. Purvis J.L. Gittleman (2003) ArticleTitleBiological correlates of extinction risk in bats Am. Nat. 161 601–614 Occurrence Handle12776887 Occurrence Handle10.1086/368289
Jones M.J., Fielding A.H. and Sullivan M.S. 2005 (this issue). Analysing extinction risk in parrots using decision trees. In: Sullivan M.S. and Marsden S.J. (eds.), 2005. Extinction Risk: Predicting, Assessing, Prioritising and Redressing. Biodiversity and Conservation.
Keane A., de L., Brooke M.D. and Mcgowan P.J.K. (in press). Correlates of extinction risk and hunting pressure in gamebirds (Galliformes). Biol. Conserv. 126 (2): 216–233.
R. Kimball E.L. Braun P.W. Zwartjes T.M. Crowe J.D. Ligon (1999) ArticleTitleA molecular phylogeny of the pheasants and partridges suggests that these lineages are not monophyletic Mol. Phylogenet. Evol. 11 IssueID1 38–54 Occurrence Handle10082609 Occurrence Handle10.1006/mpev.1998.0562 Occurrence Handle1:CAS:528:DyaK1MXhvVGgs7w%3D
Lee D.C. and Marsden S.J. 2005 (this issue). Accumulation of knowledge and changes in Red List classifications within the family Galliformes. In: Sullivan M.S. and Marsden S.J. (eds.), 2005. Extinction Risk: Predicting, Assessing, Prioritising and Redressing Biodiversity and Conservation.
W.-Y. Loh Y.-S. Shih (1997) ArticleTitleSplit selection methods for classification trees Stat. Sinica 7 815–840
V. Lucchini J. Hoglund S. Klaus J. Swenson E. Randi (2001) ArticleTitleHistorical biogeography and a mitochondrial DNA phylogeny of grouse and ptarmigan Mol. Phylogenet. Evol. 20 IssueID1 149–162 Occurrence Handle11421655 Occurrence Handle10.1006/mpev.2001.0943 Occurrence Handle1:CAS:528:DC%2BD3MXksF2murg%3D
S. Madge P.J. Mcgowan (2002) Pheasants, Partridges and Grouse: A guide to the Pheasants, Partridges, Quails, GrouseGuineafowl, Buttonquails and Sandgrouse of the World Christopher Helm London
K. Norris N. Harper (2004) ArticleTitleExtinction processes in hot spots of avian biodiversity and the targeting of pre-emptive conservation action Proc. R. Soc, Lond. Ser. B 271 123–130 Occurrence Handle10.1098/rspb.2003.2576
M. Pagel (1999) ArticleTitleInferring the historical patterns of biological evolution Nature 401 877–884 Occurrence Handle10553904 Occurrence Handle10.1038/44766 Occurrence Handle1:CAS:528:DyaK1MXntFymtL8%3D
A. Purvis A. Rambaut (1995) ArticleTitleComparative analysis by independent contrasts (CAIC): an Apple Macintosh application for analysing comparative data CABIOS 11 IssueID3 247–251 Occurrence Handle7583692 Occurrence Handle1:STN:280:DyaK28%2FptVSktw%3D%3D
R.N. Reed R. Shine (2002) ArticleTitleLying in wait for extinction? Ecological correlates of conservation status among Australian elapid snakes Conserv. Biol. 16 451–461 Occurrence Handle10.1046/j.1523-1739.2002.02283.x
R.E. Ricklefs G.W. Cox (1978) ArticleTitleStage of taxon cyclehabitat distribution, and population density in the avifauna of the West Indies Am. Nat. 112 875–895 Occurrence Handle10.1086/283329
C.L. Sibley J.E. Ahlquist (1990) Phylogeny and Classification of Birds: A Study in Molecular Evolution Yale University Press New Haven, USA
C.L. Sibley B.L. Monroe SuffixJr. (1990) Distribution and Taxonomy of Birds of the World Yale University Press New Have, USA
C.L. Sibley B.L. Monroe SuffixJr. (1993) A Supplement to Distribution and Taxonomy of Birds of the World Yale University Press New Haven, USA
I. Storch (2000) Grouse: Status, Survey and Conservation Action Plan 2000–2004 IUCN and the World Pheasant Association Gland, Switzerland and Cambridge, UK, and Reading, UK
M.S. Sullivan F. Gilbert G. Rotheray S. Croasdale M.J. Jones (2000) ArticleTitleComparative analyses of correlates of red data book status: a case study using European hoverflies (Diptera: Syrphidae) Anim. Conserv. 3 91–95 Occurrence Handle10.1111/j.1469-1795.2000.tb00233.x
E.K. Urban C.H. Fry S. Keith (1986) The birds of Africa NumberInSeriesVol. 2 Academic Press London
J.E.M. Watson R.J. Whittaker T.P. Dawson (2004) ArticleTitleHabitat structure and proximity to forest edge affect the abundance and distribution of forest-dependent birds in tropical coastal forests of southeastern Madagascar Biol. Conserv. 120 IssueID3 311–327 Occurrence Handle10.1016/j.biocon.2004.03.004
J.R. Young C.E. Braun S.J. Oyler-McCance J.W. Hupp T.W. Quinn (2000) ArticleTitleA new species of Sage-Grouse (Phasianidae: Centrocercus) from south-western Colorado Wilson Bull. 112 IssueID4 445–453 Occurrence Handle10.1676/0043-5643(2000)112[0445:ANSOSG]2.0.CO;2
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Sullivan, M.S., Jones, M.J., Lee, D.C. et al. A Comparison of Predictive Methods in Extinction Risk Studies: Contrasts and Decision Trees. Biodivers Conserv 15, 1977–1991 (2006). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10531-005-4315-2
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10531-005-4315-2