The disentanglement of interest politics: Business associability, the parties and policy in Italy and Greece
ORAZIO LANZA,
KOSTAS LAVDAS,
Corresponding Author
KOSTAS LAVDAS
University of the West of England, UK
Kostas A. Lavdas Department of Politics, Faculty of Economics and Social Sciences, University of the West of England, Bristol BS16 1QY, UK Phone: +44 117 976-3869; Fax: +44 117 976-3870; E-mail: [email protected]Search for more papers by this author
ORAZIO LANZA,
KOSTAS LAVDAS,
Corresponding Author
KOSTAS LAVDAS
University of the West of England, UK
Kostas A. Lavdas Department of Politics, Faculty of Economics and Social Sciences, University of the West of England, Bristol BS16 1QY, UK Phone: +44 117 976-3869; Fax: +44 117 976-3870; E-mail: [email protected]Search for more papers by this authorAbstract
Abstract. The article explores changes in the politics of business associability in Italy and Greece, focusing in particular on a set of comparable domestic and European developments that have played the roles of stimuli for the slow but unmistakable transformation of interest politics. Against a background of intense politicization, changes that are taking place since the 1980s suggest that organized interests become disentangled from the linkages which sustained party colonization and state dominance. Changes in interest politics were facilitated by the transition to a majoritarian system (in Italy) and party alternation (in Greece). The disentanglement we refer to would be difficult under conditions of sharing–out government; conversely, alternating governments facilitate changes in the relationships between interests, parties and policy–making. Apart from the domestic sources of change, the article argues that shifts in interest politics are the combined outcome of wider challenges and of the impact of Europeanization. On the basis of this analysis, we speculate that the disentanglement of interest politics may be conducive to national policy adjustment in two possible scenarios. Either by enabling intersectoral agreements over policy issues or by freeing national policymaking from the burden of oligopolistic coalitions — a social democratic and a neoliberal scenario respectively.
References
- Aglieta, R. (1979). Verso l'lntersind, in F. Peschiera (ed.), Sindacato, industria e stato negli anni del centrismo: Storia delle relazioni industriali in Italia dal 1948 al 1958, Vol. 2. Firenze : Monnier.
- Alacevich, F. (1996), Le relazioni industriali in Italia: Culture e strategie. Roma : La Nuova Italia Scientifica.
- Amato, G. (1976), Economia, politica e istituzioni in Italia. Bologna : Il Mulino.
- S. Andersen & K. Eliassen, eds. (1993), Making policy in Europe: The Europeification of national policy-making. London : Sage.
- Bermeo, N. (1995). Classification and consolidation: Some lessons from the Greek dictatorship, Political Science Quarterly 110): 435–452.
- Charalambis, D. (1985), The military and political power: The structure of power in post-civil war Greece. Athens : Exantas (in Greek).
- Charalambis, D. (1989), Clientelist linkages and populism: Extra-institutional consensus formation in the Greek political system. Athens : Exantas (in Greek).
- Chiesi, A. (1994). Il systema dell associazzioni industriali e le specificita del caso italiano, in A. Martinelli (ed.), L'azione collettiva degli imprenditori italiani. Milano : Comunita.
- R. Clogg, ed. (1981), Greece in the 1980s. London : Macmillan.
- R. Clogg, ed. (1991), Greece 1981–89: The populist decade. London : Macmillan.
- Coleman, W. & Grant, W. (1988). The organizational cohesion and political access of business: A study of comprehensive associations, European Journal of Political Research 16(5): 467–487.
- Coleman, W. & Jacek, H. (1989). Capitalists, collective action and regionalism: An introduction, in W. Coleman & H. Jacek (eds.), Regionalism, Business Interests and Public Policy. London : Sage.
- G. Contogeorgis, ed. (1977), Social and political forces in Greece. Athens : Exantas/Hellenic Political Science Association (in Greek).
- R. D'alimonte, ed. (1998). Special Issue: The Italian elections of 1996: Competition and transition, European Journal of Political Research 34(1): 1–174.
- N. Demertzis, ed. (1994), Greek political culture today. Athens : Odysseas (in Greek).
- Diamandouros, P.N. (1993). Politics and culture in Greece, 1974–91: An interpretation, in R. Clogg (ed.), Greece 1981–89: The populist decade. London : Macmillan.
- Drakos, G. (1981), The National Bank and the Izola. Athens : published by the author (in Greek).
- Fabbrini, S. (1994), Quale democrazia: L'Italia e gli altri. Roma / Bari : Laterza.
- Ferrante, M. (1996), Transizione politica e ruolo delle associazioni, Il Mulino, settembre-ottobre.
- Friedman, A. (1996). The economic elites and the political system, in S. Gundle & S. Parker (eds.), The New Italian Republic. London : Routledge.
- Grant, W. & Marsh, D. (1977), The Confederation of British Industry. London : Hodder & Stoughton.
- Graziano, L. (1973). Patron-client relationships in southern Italy, European Journal of Political Research 1(1): 3–34.
10.1111/j.1475-6765.1973.tb01281.x Google Scholar
- S. Gundle & S. Parker, eds. (1996), The New Italian Republic. London : Routledge.
- L. Hancher & M. Moran, eds. (1989), Capitalism, culture, and economic regulation. Oxford : Clarendon Press.
- Hine, D. (1996). Italian political reform in comparative perspective, in S. Gundle & S. Parker (eds.), The New Italian Republic. London : Routledge.
- Intersind (1988), Trent'anni di vita sociale Italiana: LTntersind, Quaderni di Industria e Sindacato 23.
- L Katsoulis, T. Giannitsis & P. Kazakos, eds. (1988), Greece towards 2000. Athens : Papazisis (in Greek).
- Kitromilides, P.M. (1995). Europe and the dilemmas of Greek conscience, in P. Carabott (ed.), Greece and Europe in the modern period: Aspects of a troubled relationship. London : King's College Centre for Hellenic Studies.
- Koutsoukis, K.S. (1995). Sleaze in contemporary Greek politics, Parliamentary Affairs 48): 688–696.
- Kravaritou, Y. (1994), European employment and industrial relations glossary: Greece. London : Sweet & Maxwell.
- Ladrech, R. (1994), Europeanization of domestic politics and institutions: The case of France, Journal of Common Market Studies 32.
- Lanza, O. (1995). Gli eletti: Il ricambio dei parlamentari, in G. Pasquino (ed.), L'alternanza inattesa: Le elezioni del 27 marzo 1994 e le loro consequenze. Soveria Mannelli : Rubbettino.
- Lanzalaco, L. (1990), Dall'impresa all associazione. Le organizzazioni degli imprenditori: la Confindustria in prospettiva comparata. Milano : Angeli.
- Lanzalaco, L. (1993). Interest groups in Italy: From pressure activity to policy networks, in J.J. Richardson (ed.), Pressure groups. Oxford : Oxford University Press.
- Lanzalaco, L. (1995), Istituzioni, interessi organizzati e partite politici: Ipotesi a partire dal caso italiano, Quaderni di Scienza Politica 1.
- Lanzalaco, L. & Urgani, G. (1992), Imprenditori inEuropa. Roma : Sipi.
- LaPalombara, J. (1964), Interest groups in Italian politics. Princeton : Princeton University Press.
10.1515/9781400877836 Google Scholar
- LaPalombara, J. & Pirzio Ammassari, G. (1968). L'intervento elettorale della Confindustria, in M. Dogan & O.M. Petracca (eds.), Partiti politici e strutture sociali in Italia. Milano : Comunta.
- Lavdas, K. (1996). The political economy of privatization in southern Europe, in D. Braddon & D. Foster (eds.), Privatization. Aldershot : Dartmouth.
- Lavdas, K. (1997), The Europeanization of Greece: Interest politics and the crises of integration. London : Macmillan.
- Lavdas, K. & Mendrinou, M. (1999), Politics, subsidies and competition: The new politics of state intervention in the European Union. Cheltenham : Edward Elgar.
- Leonardi, R. & Wertman, D. (1989), Italian Christian Democracy: The politics of dominance. London : Macmillan.
10.1007/978-1-349-08894-2 Google Scholar
- Lijphart, A. (1984), Democracies: Patterns of majoritarian and consensus government in twenty-one countries. New Haven , CT : Yale University Press.
10.2307/j.ctt1ww3w2t Google Scholar
- C. Maier (ed.) (1987), Changing boundaries of the political. Cambridge : Cambridge University Press.
- A. Manoukian, ed. (1968), La presenza sociale del PCI e delta DC. Bologna : II Mulino.
- Maraffi, M. (1990), Politica ed economia in Italia: La vicenda dell'impressa pubblica dagli anni trenta agli anni cinquanta. Bologna : Il Mulino.
- Maraffi, M. (1994). L'organizzazione degli interessi industriali in Italia, in A. Martinelli (ed.), L'azione collettiva degli imprenditori italiani. Milano : Comunita.
- A. Martinelli, ed. (1994), L'azione collettiva degli imprenditori italiani. Milano: Comunita 1994.
- Mattina, L. (1991), Gli industriali e la democrazia: La Confindustria nella formazione dell'Italia repubblicana. Bologna : Il Mulino.
- Mattina, L. (1993). La Confindustria di Abete: Dall'alleanza con la DC all'appello multipartitico, in S. Hellman & C. Pasquino (eds.), Politica in Italia, Edizione 1993. Bologna : Il Mulino.
- Mattina, L. (1994). Gli attori economici: Vinci tori e vinti, in I. Diamanti & R. Mannheimer (eds.), Milano a Roma. Roma : Donzelli.
- Mavrogordatos, G. (1988), Between Pityokamptes and Prokroustes. Athens : Odysseas (in Greek).
- Mavrogordatos, G. (1993). Civil society under populism, in R. Clogg (ed.), Greece 1981–89: The Populist Decade. London : Macmillan.
- Mendrinou, M. (1994). European Community fraud and the politics of institutional development, European Journal of Political Research 26(1): 81–101.
- Mendrinou, M. & Nicolacopoulos, I. (1997), Interests, parties and discontent in the public mind. Paper presented at the Workshop on ‘Clientelist politics and interest intermediation in Southern Europe’, ECPR Joint Sessions, Bern.
- C. Mershon & G. Pasquino, eds. (1994), Italian politics: Ending the First Republic. Boulder , CO : Westview Press.
- M. Moran & M. Wright, eds. (1991), The market and the state: Studies in interdependence. London : Macmillan.
- Morisi, M. (1992), Le leggi del consenso: Partiti e interessi nei primi Parlamenti della Republica. Soveria Mannelli : Rubbettino.
- L. Morlino, ed. (1991), Costruire la democrazia: Gruppi e partiti in Italia. Bologna : Il Mulino.
- Morlino, L. (1996), Crisis of parties and change of party system in Italy, Party Politics 2.
- Moussis, N. (1969), Greek Industrialists and the Association of Greece with the Common Market. Athens : Skouras.
- Mouzelis, N. (1978), Modern Greece: Facets of Underdevelopment. London : Macmillan.
- Mouzelis, N. (1990), Post-Marxist Alternatives: The construction of social orders. London : Macmillan.
10.1007/978-1-349-12978-2 Google Scholar
- Panebianco, A. (1997), Guerrieri democratici. Bologna : Il Mulino.
- G. Pasquino, ed. (1995), L'alternanza inattesa: Le elezioni del 27 marzo 1994 e le loro consequenze. Soveria Mannelli : Rubbettino.
- Perulli, P. & Catino, M. (1997), Le organizzazioni di rappresentanza imprenditoriale: verso uno sperimentalismo istituzionale, Stato e Mercato 50.
- D. Rometsch & W. Wessels, eds. (1996). The European Union and member states: Towards institutional fusion. Manchester : Manchester University Press.
- Sapelli, G. (1995), Southern Europe since 1945. London : Longman.
- Schmitter, P.C. (1995). Organized interests and democratic consolidation in Southern Europe, in R. Gunther et al. (eds.), The Politics of Democratic Consolidation: Southern Europe in Comparative Perspective. Baltimore , MD : The Johns Hopkins University Press.
- I. Scholten, ed. (1987), Political stability and neo-corporatism. London : Sage.
- SEV. Bulletin. Various dates (in Greek).
- Spourdalakis, M. (1988), The rise of the Greek socialist party. London : Routledge.
- Spourdalakis, M. (1996), PASOK's second chance, Mediterranean Politics 1.3.
- Tsoucalas, C. (1986), Social development and the state, 2nd edn. Athens : Themelio (in Greek).
- Vassallo, S. (1994), Il governo di partito in Italia. Bologna : Il Mulino.
- Vaxevanoglou, A. (1994), The Greek capitalists 1900–1940: Social and economic approach. Athens : Themelio (in Greek).
- Wessels, W. (1992), Staat und (westeuropäische) Integration: Die Fusionsthese. Politische Vierteljahresschrift 23, Sonderheft.
- Zan, S. (1997), La crisi delle associazioni di rappresentanza. Il Mulino, marzo-aprile.
