What Bandwagons Bring: Effects of Popular Management Techniques on Corporate Performance, Reputation, and CEO Pay
Abstract
This paper examines some of the important organizational consequences of popular management techniques. Using informational reports on quality, empowerment, and teams, as well as a measure of the implementation of total quality management programs, we found that companies associated with popular management techniques did not have higher economic performance. Nevertheless, these same companies were more admired, perceived to be more innovative, and rated higher in management quality. Higher pay was also given to chief executives when their companies were associated with these management trends. These results provide strong support for institutional theory, demonstrating how both internal and external legitimacy can be gained by using popular management techniques. They also extend institutional theory from its usual emphasis on organization-environment relations to new within-firm dynamics.
Get full access to this article
View all access and purchase options for this article.
References
Abrahamson E. 1991 “Managerial fads and fashions: The diffusion and rejection of innovations.” Academy of Management Review, 16: 586–612.
Abrahamson E. 1996 “Management fashion.” Academy of Management Review, 21: 254–286.
Abrahamson E., Fairchild G. 1999 “Management fashion: Life-cycles, triggers, and collective learning processes.” Administrative Science Quarterly, 44: 708–740.
Allen V. L. 1965 “Situational factors in conformity.” In Berkowitz L. (ed.), Advances in Experimental Social Psychology: 133–175. New York: Academic Press.
Barkema H. C., Gomez-Mejia L. R. 1998 “Managerial compensation and firm performance: A general research framework.” Academy of Management Journal, 41: 135–145.
Barley S. R., Knight D. B. 1992 “Toward a cultural theory of stress complaints.” In Staw B.M., Cummings L.L. (eds.), Research in Organizational Behavior, 14: 1–48. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press.
Barley S. R., Kunda G. 1992 “Design and devotion: Surges of rational and normative ideologies of control in managerial discourse.” Administrative Science Quarterly, 37: 363–399.
Baron R. M., Kenny D. A. 1986 “The moderator-mediator variable distinction in social psychological research: Conceptual, strategic, and statistical considerations.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 51: 1173–1182.
Beatty R. P., Zajac E. J. 1994 “Managerial incentives, monitoring, and risk bearing: A study of executive compensation, ownership, and board structure in initial public offerings.” Administrative Science Quarterly, 39: 313–335.
Cole R. E. 1999 Managing Quality Fads: How American Business Learned to Play the Quality Game. New York: Oxford University Press.
Crystal G. S. 1991 In Search of Excess: The Overcompensation of American Executives. New York: Norton.
Davis G. F. 1991 “Agents without principles? The spread of the poison pill through the intercorporate network.” Administrative Science Quarterly, 36: 583–613.
Deephouse D. L. 1996 “Does isomorphism legitimate?” Academy of Management Journal, 39: 1024–1039.
DiMaggio P. J. 1991 “Constructing an organizational field as a professional project: U.S. art museums, 1920–1940.” In Powell W.W., DiMaggio P.J. (eds.), The New Institutionalism in Organizational Analysis: 1–40. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
DiMaggio P. J., Powell W. W. 1983 “The iron cage revisited: Institutional isomorphism and collective rationality in organizational fields.” American Sociological Review, 35: 147–160.
Easton G. S., Jarrell S. L. 1998 “The effects of total quality management on corporate performance: An empirical investigation.” Journal of Business, 71: 253–307.
Elsbach K. D. 1994 “Managing organizational legitimacy in the California cattle industry: The construction and effectiveness of verbal accounts.” Administrative Science Quarterly, 39: 57–88.
Fisher A. B. 1996 “Corporate reputations comebacks and comeuppance.” Fortune, March, 6: 90–97.
Fombrun C. J. 1996 Reputation: Realizing Value from the Corporate Image. Boston: Harvard Business School Press.
Fombrun C. J., Shanley M. 1990 “What's in a name? Reputation building and corporate strategy.” Academy of Management Journal, 33: 233–258.
Hackman J. R., Wageman R. 1995 “Total quality management: Empirical, conceptual, and practical issues.” Administrative Science Quarterly, 40: 309–342.
Haunschild P. R. 1993 “Interorganizational imitation: The impact of interlocks on corporate acquisition activity.” Administrative Science Quarterly, 38: 564–592.
Haunschild P. R., Miner A. S. 1997 “Modes of interorganizational imitation: The effects of outcome salience and uncertainty.” Administrative Science Quarterly, 42: 472–500.
Jacoby S. M. 1984 Employing Bureaucracy: Managers, Unions and the Transformation of the Labor Process. New York: Columbia University Press.
Jensen M. C., Meckling W. H. 1976 “Theory of the firm: Managerial behavior, agency costs, and ownership structure.” Journal of Financial Economics, 3: 305–360.
Jensen M. C., Murphy K. J. 1990 “CEO incentives—It's not how much you pay, but how.” Harvard Business Review, 68(3): 138–149.
Johns G. 1999 “A multi-level theory of self-serving behavior in and by organizations.” In Sutton R.I., Staw B.M. (eds.), Research in Organizational Behavior, 21: 1–38. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press.
Kerckhoff A. C., Back K. W. 1968 The June Bug: A Study of Hysterical Contagion. New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts.
Lawler E. E. 1992 The Ultimate Advantage: Creating the High Involvement Organization. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Levitt B., March J. G. 1988 “Organizational learning.” Annual Review of Sociology, 14: 319–340. Palo Alto, CA: Annual Reviews.
Lorsch J. W., Maclver E. 1989 Pawns or Potentates: The Reality of America's Corporate Boards. Boston; Harvard Business School Press.
Mace M. L. 1971 Directors: Myth and Reality. Boston: Harvard Business School Press.
Main B. G. M., O'Reilly C. A., Wade J. 1995 “The CEO, the board of directors, and executive compensation: Economic and psychological perspectives.” Industrial and Corporate Change, 4: 293–332.
March J. G., Olsen J. P. 1976 Ambiguity and Choice in Organizations. Bergen: Universitetsforlaget.
McGuire J. B., Schneeweis T., Branch B. 1990 “Perceptions of firm quality: A cause or result of firm performance.” Journal of Management, 16: 167–180.
Meyer M. W., Gupta V. 1994 “The performance paradox.” In Staw B.M., Cummings L.L. (eds.), Research in Organizational Behavior, 16: 309–369. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press.
Meyer J. W., Rowan B. 1977 “Institutionalized organizations: Formal structure as myth and ceremony.” American Journal of Sociology, 83: 340–363.
Meyer J. W., Rowan B. 1983 “The structure of educational organizations.” In Meyer J.W., Scott W.R. (eds.), Organizational Environments: Ritual and Rationality: 71–97. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
Meyer J., Scott W. R. 1983 “Centralization and the legitimacy problems of the local government.” In Meyer J.W., Scott W.R. (eds.), Organizational Environments: Ritual and Rationality: 199–215. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
Nisbett R., Ross L. 1980 Human Inference: Strategies and Shortcomings of Social Judgment. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
Ocasio W. 1994 “Political dynamics and the circulation of power: CEO succession in U.S. industrial corporations, 1960–1990.” Administrative Science Quarterly, 39: 285–312.
Oliver C. 1991 “Strategic responses to institutional processes.” Academy of Management Review, 13: 79–90.
O'Reilly C. A., Main B. G. M., Crystal G. S. 1988 “CEO compensation as tournament and social comparison: A tale of two theories.” Administrative Science Quarterly, 34: 21–37.
Palmer D. A., Jennings P. D., Zhou X. 1993 “Late adoption of the multidivisional form by large U.S. corporations: Institutional, political, and economic accounts.” Administrative Science Quarterly, 38: 100–131.
Pastor J. C., Meindl J. R., Hunt R. 1997 “The quality virus: Interorganizational contagion of TQM.” In Alvarez J. L. (ed.), The Diffusion and Consumption of Business Knowledge: 201–218. London: MacMillan.
Pedhazur E. J. 1982 Multiple Regression in Behavioral Research. New York: Harcourt Jovanovich.
Pfeffer J. 1981 “Management as symbolic action: The creation and maintenance of organizational paradigms.” In Cummings L.L., Staw B.M. (eds.), Research in Organizational Behavior, 3: 1–52. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press.
Pfeffer J. 1994 Competitive Advantage Through People: Unleashing the Power of the Workforce. Boston: Harvard Business School Press.
Pfeffer J., Sutton R. I. 1999 “The smart-talk trap.” Harvard Business Review, 77(3): 134–142.
Pfeffer J., Sutton R. I. 2000 The Knowing-Doing Gap—How Smart Companies Turn Knowledge Into Action. Boston: Harvard Business School Press.
Ruef M., Scott W. R. 1998 “A multidimensional model of organizational legitimacy: Hospital survival in changing institutional environments.” Administrative Science Quarterly, 43: 877–904.
Salancik G. R., Pfeffer J. 1978 “A social information processing approach to job attitudes and task design.” Administrative Science Quarterly, 23: 224–253.
Salancik G. R., Pfeffer J. 1980 “Effects of ownership and performance on executive tenure in U.S. corporations.” Academy of Management Journal, 23: 653–664.
Scott W. R. 1995 Institutions and Organizations. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Selznick P. 1949 TVA and the Grass Roots. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Shapiro E. C. 1995 Fad Surfing in the Boardroom. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.
Sherif M. 1936 The Psychology of Social Norms. New York: Harper and Row.
Staw B. M. 1975 “Attribution of the ‘causes” of performance: A new alternative interpretation of cross-sectional research on organizations.” Organizational Behavior and Human Performance, 13: 414–432.
Staw B. M. 1980 “Rationality and justification in organizational life.” In Staw B.M., Cummings L.L. (eds.), Research in Organizational Behavior, 2: 45–80. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press.
Tolbert P. S., Zucker L. G. 1983 “Institutional sources of change in the formal structure of organizations: The diffusion of civil service reform, 1880–1935.” Administrative Science Quarterly, 28: 22–39.
Wagner J. A., Gooding R. Z. 1987 “Effects of societal trends on participation research.” Administrative Science Quarterly, 32: 241–262.
Westphal J. D., Gulati R., Shortell S. M. 1997 “Customization or conformity? An institutional and network perspective on the content and consequences of TQM adoption.” Administrative Science Quarterly, 42: 366–394.
Westphal J. D., Zajac E. J. 1998 “The symbolic management of stockholders: Corporate governance reforms and shareholder reactions.” Administrative Science Quarterly, 43: 127–153.
Zald M. N., Denton P. 1963 “From evangelism to general service: The transformation of the YMCA.” Administrative Science Quarterly, 8: 214–234.
Zbaracki M. J. 1998 “The rhetoric and reality of total quality management.” Administrative Science Quarterly, 43: 602–638.
Zucker L. G. 1977 “The role of institutionalization in cultural persistence.” American Sociological Review, 42: 726–743.
Cite article
Cite article
Cite article
OR
Download to reference manager
If you have citation software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice
Information, rights and permissions
Information
Published In
Article first published: September 2000
Issue published: September 2000
Authors
Metrics and citations
Metrics
Journals metrics
This article was published in Administrative Science Quarterly.
VIEW ALL JOURNAL METRICSArticle usage*
Total views and downloads: 1900
*Article usage tracking started in December 2016
Altmetric
See the impact this article is making through the number of times it’s been read, and the Altmetric Score.
Learn more about the Altmetric Scores
Articles citing this one
Receive email alerts when this article is cited
Web of Science: 473 view articles Opens in new tab
Crossref: 0
-
Vicarious Empowerment as a Novel Mechanism for Empowering High Power D...
-
Revisiting the scope and suggesting novel domains of institutional the...
-
The Wheel Comes Full Circle? An Integrated View of Organizational Resp...
-
Latecomers’ Isomorphic R&D Strategy and the Relationship With Performa...
-
Beyond “twokenism”: Organizational factors enabling female directors t...
-
Foreign Independent Directors (FID) on Chinese Firms: The Isomorphism ...
-
Pollution Stigma and Manufacturing Firms’ Disengagement Effort: Intera...
-
Fits and Misfits: The Impact of Individual Differences on Psychologica...
-
Measuring individual legitimacy perceptions: Scale development and val...
-
To Be or to Seem: The Role of Environmental Practices in Corporate Env...
-
Governance monitors or market rebels? Heterogeneity in shareholder act...
-
From Doing Good to Looking Even Better: The Dynamics of CSR and Reputa...
-
Order in the Court: How Firm Status and Reputation Shape the Outcomes ...
-
“They Are All Organizations”: The Cultural Roots of Blurring Between t...
-
Social Influence and Politics in Organizational Research...
-
The Sociopolitical Implications of Firm Reputation...
-
Following fashion: Visible progressiveness and the social construction...
-
Explaining SME engagement in local sourcing: The roles of location-spe...
-
The Right Strategy? Examining the Business Partner Model's Functionali...
-
Irrational Exuberance for Market-based Reform: How Federal Turnaround ...
-
Assessing Managerial Power Theory...
-
Footnotes to Research on Management Innovation
-
The Role of External Involvement in the Creation of Management Innovat...
-
The effects of firm reputation and status on interorganizational netwo...
-
The Too-Much-of-a-Good-Thing Effect in Management
-
Stretching Concepts: The Role of Competing Pressures and Decoupling in...
-
Empowerment—Fad or Fab? A Multilevel Review of the Past Two Decades of...
-
Co-construction of management concepts: Interpretative viability as op...
-
The active client: The boundary-spanning roles of internal consultants...
-
Dual Identities in Social Ventures: An Exploratory Study
-
Accounting Executives and it Outsourcing Recommendations: An Experimen...
-
‘One mirror in another’: Managing diversity and the discourse of fashi...
-
From Fashion to Virus: An Alternative Theory of Organizations’ Handlin...
-
The Emperor is Still Naked: How Intelligence-Led Policing Has Repackag...
-
‘Being yourself ’ in the electronic sweatshop: New forms of normative ...
-
Organizational Reputation: A Review
-
Does the Market Respond to an Endorsement of Social Responsibility? Th...
-
Moving Beyond Conventional Wisdom...
-
Così Fan Tutte? Adoption and Rejection of Performance-Related Pay in I...
-
An Organizational Impression Management Perspective on the Formation o...
-
Constraints on the Control Benefits of Brokerage: A Study of Placement...
-
Hiding the Evidence of Valid Theories: How Coupled Search Processes Ob...
-
Reflections on a Reflective Cycle: Building Legitimacy in Design Knowl...
-
Strategy tools as boundary objects
-
Employee-management Techniques: Transient Fads or Trending Fashions?
-
A Political Mediation Model of Corporate Response to Social Movement A...
-
Putting Consumers to Work...
-
Values, Interests, and the Capacity to Act...
-
The Multiple Logics of Conformity and Contrarianism: The Problem With ...
-
Training Failure as a Consequence of Organizational Culture
-
Management as a (Self) Confidence Trick: Management Ideas, Education a...
-
Statistics as Fetishes...
-
The effects of administrative innovation implementation on performance...
-
How symbolic remuneration contributes to the legitimacy of the company...
-
Growth and Survival of International Joint Ventures: An External-Inter...
-
The Impact of Strategic Persistence on Executive Compensation
-
Communalities and Distinctions in the Measurement of Organizational Pe...
-
An Ecological Perspective on Leadership Theory, Research, and Practice
-
Keeping it all in the Family: The Role of Particularistic Relationship...
-
Technical Efficiency or Adaptation to Institutionalized Expectations? ...
-
The Scripting of Total Quality Management within its Organizational Bi...
-
The Relationship between Perceptions of Corporate Citizenship and Orga...
-
The Adoption of Management Ideas and Practices...
-
Organizational Competence and Firm-Specific Tobin's q: The Moderating ...
-
Longitudinal Organizational Research and the Third Scientific Discipli...
-
Process Management and Technological Innovation: A Longitudinal Study ...
-
Empowerment and Managerial Labor Strategies: Pragmatism Regained
-
Mobilizing the Logic of Managerialism in Professional Fields: The Case...
Figures and tables
Figures & Media
Tables
View Options
Get access
Access options
If you have access to journal content via a personal subscription, university, library, employer or society, select from the options below:
loading institutional access options
Alternatively, view purchase options below:
Purchase 24 hour online access to view and download content.
Access journal content via a DeepDyve subscription or find out more about this option.
