A Changing Terrain of Knowledge and Power: A Social Epistemology of Educational Research
Abstract
In the past decade, important struggles about the production of knowledge have taken place in history, the social sciences, and education. These struggles involve more than the “knowledge interests” that Habermas pointed to in the 1970s; instead, they point to important epistemological ruptures in the doctrines of “reason” that have dominated social and political debates since the late 19th century. This questioning reaches into the presuppositions of progress and power underlying intellectual work.
This article explores some of the main features of the controversies about knowledge by turning first to certain assumptions that guided social theory at least since the 19th century. The assumptions relate, for example, to the focus on human action (and agents) as purpose or explanation of theory, to the conceptualization of space and time, to the introduction of change as a problem of the administration of time (the control of process and development), and to the inscription of political and social doctrines of progress into science. My interest here, however, is not only in the disciplinary struggles, but also in the changing social conditions that make these debates possible. I look at the systems of reasoning in educational studies as social practices—what I have previously called “a social epistemology.” When we examine current discussions against 19th century assumptions about social theory, we are able to understand that the stakes of educational research are social and political as well as epistemological.
Get full access to this article
View all access and purchase options for this article.
References
Anderson B. Imagined communities: Reflections on the origin and spread of nationalism 1991 Rev. ed London Verso
Baker B. Popkewitz T and Brennan M. Childhood-as-rescue in the emergence and spread of the U.S. public school. Foucault's challenge: Discourse, knowledge and power in education New York Teachers College Press in press.
Barrett M and Phillips A. Destablizing theory: Contemporary feminist debates 1992 Stanford, CA Stanford University Press
Bauman Z. Legislators and interpreters: On modernity, postmodernity and intellectuals 1987 Ithaca, NY Cornell University Press
Bercovitch S. The American jeremiad 1978 Madison University of Wisconsin Press
Berger P. The sacred canopy: Elements of a sociological theory of religion 1969 New York Doubleday Anchor Books
Berger P. Pyramids of sacrifice, political ethics and social change 1976 Garden City, NY Anchor Books
Berger P, Berger B, and Kellner H. The homeless mind: Modernization and consciousness 1973 New York Vintage
Bernstein R. The new constellation: The ethical-political horizons of. modernity/postmodernity 1992 Cambridge, MA MIT Press
Bourdieu P. Nice R. Distinction: A social critique of the judgment of taste 1984 Cambridge, MA Harvard University Press
Bourdieu P and Passeron J. Nice R. Reproduction in education, society and culture 1977 Beverly Hills, CA Sage
Bourdieu P and Wacquant L. An invitation to reflexive sociology 1992 Chicago The University of Chicago Press
Boyer R. Boyer R and Drache D. State and market: A new engagement for the twenty-first century?. State against markets: The limits of globalization 1996 New York Routledge 84-116
Braudel F. Matthews S. On history 1980 Chicago The University of Chicago Press
Burbules N and Berk R. Popkewitz T. Critical thinking and critical pedagogy: Relations, differences, and limits. Critical theory in educational discourse Durban, South Africa Heinemann in press.
Bury JB. The idea of progress: An inquiry into the origin and growth 1932 New York Macmillan
Castel R. Burchell G, Gordon C, and Miller P. From dangerousness to risk. The foucault effect, studies in governmentality 1991 Chicago University of Chicago Press 281-298
Cherryholmes C. Reading research. The Journal of Curriculum Studies 1993;25:1-32
Crary J. Techniques of the observer: On vision and modernity in the nineteenth century 1990 Cambridge, MA MIT Press
Dean M. Critical and effective histories: Foucault's methods and historical sociology 1994 New York Routledge
DiMaggio P. Classification in art. American Sociological Review 1987;52:440-455
Drewek P. Popkewitz T and Kazamias A. The educational system, social reproduction and educational theory in Imperial Germany. Educational knowledge: Changing relationships between the state, civil society, and the educational community New York The State of New York University in press.
Dreyfus H and Rabinow P. Michel Foucault: Beyond structuralism and hermeneutics 1983 Chicago University of Chicago Press
Dumm T. Democracy and punishment: Disciplinary origins of the United States 1987 Madison University of Wisconsin Press
Durum T. Gooding-Williams R. The new enclosures: Racism in the normalized community. Reading Rodney King: Reading urban uprising 1993 New York Routledge 178-195
Ellsworth E. McCarthy C and Crichlow W. I pledge allegiance: The politics of reading and using educational films. Race, identity and representation in education 1993 New York Routledge 201-220
Ellsworth E. Martusewicz R and Reynolds W. Representation, self-representation, and the meaning of difference: Questions for educators. Inside/out: Contemporary critical perspectives in education 1994 New York St. Martins 99-108
Englund T. Rethinking curriculum history–towards a theoretical reorientation. 1991 April Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association Chicago
Fendler L. Popkewitz T and Brennan M. What is it impossible to think? A genealogy of the educated subject. Foucault's challenge: Discourse, knowledge and power in Education New York Teachers College Press in press.
Foucault M. The order of things: An archaeology of the human sciences 1973 New York Vintage Books
Foucault M. Gordon C. Power/knowledge: Selected interviews and other writings by Michel Foucault, 1972–1977 1980 New York Pantheon
Foucault M. Rabinow P. What is enlightenment?. The Foucault reader 1984 New York Pantheon 32-50
Foucault M. Hurley R. The care of the self: The history of sexuality 1988a;Vol. 3 New York Vintage House
Foucault M. Martin L, Gutman H, and Huttan P. The political technology of individuals. Technologies of the self 1988b Amherst University of Massachusetts Press 145-162
Fraser N. Sex, lies, and the public sphere: Some reflections on the confirmations of Clarence Thomas. Critical Inquiry 1992;18:295-612
Gee J, Hull G, and Lanskear C. The new work order: Behind the language of the new capitalism 1996 Boulder, CO Westview Press
Giddens A. Social theory and modern sociology 1987 Stanford, CA Stanford University Press
Giddens A. The consequences of modernity 1990 Stanford, CA Stanford University Press
Gilroy P. The Black Atlantic: Modernity and double consciousness 1993 Cambridge, MA Harvard University
Habermas J. McCarthy T. The theory of communicative action: Reason and the rationalization of society 1981;Vol. 1 Boston Beacon Press
Habermas J. McCarthy T. The theory of communicative action. Lifeworld and system: A critique of functionalist reason 1987;Vol. 2 Boston Beacon Press
Hacking I. Burchell G, Gordon C, and Miller P. How should we do the history of statistics?. The Foucault effect: Studies in governmentality 1991 Chicago The University of Chicago Press 181-196
Hamilton D. Towards a theory of schooling 1989 London Falmer Press
Harvey D. The conditions of post-modernity: An enquiry into the origins of cultural change 1990 Cambridge, MA Blackwell
Herman E. The romance of American psychology, political culture in the age of experts 1995 Berkeley University of California Press
Hultqvist K. Popkewitz T and Brennan M. A history of the present on children's welfare in Sweden. Foucault's challenge: Discourse, knowledge and power in education New York Teachers College Press in press.
Hunter I. Rethinking the school: Subjectivity, bureaucracy, criticism 1994 New York St. Martin’s Press
Jay M. Downcast eyes: The denigration of vision in twentieth-century French thought 1993 Berkeley The University of California Press
Joas H. Pragmatism and social theory 1993 Chicago The University of Chicago
Kuhn T. The structure of scientific revolutions 1970 2nd ed Chicago University of Chicago Press
Kuttner R. The end of laissez-faire: National purpose and the global economy after the cold war 1991 New York Alfred A. Knopf
Ladwig J. Academic distinctions: Theory and methodology in the sociology of school knowledge 1996 New York Routledge
Lalvani S. Photography, vision, and the production of modern bodies 1996 Albany, NY SUNY Press
Lekachman R. Greed is not enough, Reaganomics 1982 New York Pantheon Books
Luchmann T. The invisible religion: The problem of religion in modern society 1967 New York The Macmillan Company
Lundgren U. Between education and schooling: Outlines of a diachronic curriculum theory 1991 Geelong, Australia Deakin University
Marx L. The machine in the garden: Technology and the pastoral image in America 1964 New York Oxford University Press
Meyer J, Ramirez J, and Soysal Y. World expansion of mass education, 1870–1980. Sociology of Education 1992;65:128-149
Mitchell T. Colonizing Egypt 1988 New York Cambridge University Press
Napoli D. Architects of adjustment: The history of the psychological profession in the United States 1981 Port Washington, NY Kennikat Press
Nicholson S. Gender and history, the limits of social theory in the age of the family 1986 New York Columbia University Press
Nisbet R. History and social change 1976 New York Oxford University Press
Nisbet R. History and the idea of progress 1980 New York Basic Books
O'Donnell J. The origins of behaviorism: American psychology, 1876–1920 1985 New York New York University Press
Pinar W. McCarthy C and Crichlow W. Notes on understanding curriculum as a racial text. Race, identity and representation in education 1993 London Routledge 60-71
Popkewitz T. Paradigm and ideology in educational research, social functions of the intellectual 1984 London & New York Falmer Press
Popkewitz T. A political sociology of educational reform: Power/knowledge in teaching, teacher education, and research 1991 New York Teachers College Press
Popkewitz T. Rethinking decentralization and the state/civil society distinctions: The state as a problematic of governing. Journal of Educational Policy 1996;11:27-51
Popkewitz T. The production of reason and power: Curriculum history and intellectual traditions. Journal of Curriculum Studies 1997;29 2 131-164
Popkewitz T. The spacial politics of educational knowledge: Constituting the urban and rural teacher New York Teachers College Press in press.
Popkewitz T and Pitman A. The idea of progress and the legitimation of state agendas: American proposals for school reform. Curriculum and Teaching 1986;1:11-24
Richter M. Conceptual history (Begriffsgeschichete)and political theory. Political Theory 1986;14:1219-1230
Riley D. Am I that name?. Feminism and the category of “women” in history 1988 Minneapolis University of Minnesota Press
Robbins B. Secular vocations: Intellectuals, professionalism, culture 1993 New York Verso
Robertson R. Featherstone M, Lash S, and Robertson R. Globalization: Time-space and homogeneity-heterogeneity. Global modernities 1995 London Sage 25-44
Rorty R. Philosophy and the mirror of nature 1979 Princeton, NJ Princeton University Press
Rose N. Governing the soul 1989 New York Routledge, Chapman & Hall
Ross D. The origins of American social science 1991 New York Cambridge University Press
Rueschemeyer D and Skocpol T. States, social knowledge, and the origins of modern social policies 1996 Princeton, NJ Princeton University Press
Shapiro M. Violent cartographies: Mapping the culture of war 1997 Minneapolis The University of Minnesota Press
Silva E and Slaughter S. Serving power: The making of the academic social science expert 1984 Westport, CT Greenwood Press
Skowronek S. Building a new American state: The expansion of national administrative capacities, 1877–1920 1982 New York Cambridge University Press
Soja E. Postmodern geographies: The reassertion of space in critical social theory 1989 London Verso
Stone L. Popkewitz T. A prolegomenon to “pragmatist criticism.”. Critical theory in educational discourse Durban, South Africa Heinemann in press.
Tiles M. Bachelard: Science and objectivity 1984 Cambridge, UK Cambridge University Press
Wager W. The idea of progress since the Renaissance 1969 New York John Wiley & Sons
Wagner P. The sociology of modernity 1994 New York Routledge
Wallerstein I. Geopolitics and geoculture: Essays in the changing world-system 1990 Cambridge, UK Cambridge University Press
Wallerstein I. Unthinking social science: The limits of nineteenth-century paradigms 1991 Cambridge, UK Polity Press
West C. The American evasion of philosophy: A genealogy of pragmatism 1989 Madison University of Wisconsin Press
Wittgenstein L. Pitcher G. The philosophical investigations: A collection of critical essays 1966 2nd ed Notre Dame, IN University of Notre Dame Press Originally published 1953.
Wittrock B, Wagner P, and Wollman H. Wagner P, Weiss C, Wittrock B, and Wollmann H. Social science and the modern state, policy knowledge and political institutions in Western Europe and the United States. Social sciences and modern states: National experiences and theoretical crossroads 1991 Cambridge, UK Cambridge University Press 28-85
Woody T. New minds: New men? The emergence of the soviet citizen 1932 New York The Macmillan Company
Young R. White mythologies: Writing history and the West 1990 New York Routledge
Young R. Colonial desire: Hybridity in theory, culture and race 1995 London Routledge
Cite article
Cite article
Cite article
OR
Download to reference manager
If you have citation software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice
Information, rights and permissions
Information
Published In
Article first published: December 1997
Issue published: December 1997
Authors
Metrics and citations
Metrics
Article usage*
Total views and downloads: 683
*Article usage tracking started in December 2016
Altmetric
See the impact this article is making through the number of times it’s been read, and the Altmetric Score.
Learn more about the Altmetric Scores
Articles citing this one
Receive email alerts when this article is cited
Web of Science: 0
Crossref: 0
-
Improving Researchers’ Capacity to Address Injustice: An Introduction ...
-
The Unbearable Unaccountability of Academia: A Critical Review of Impl...
-
Making psychology “count”: On the mathematization of psychology
-
Geschlecht und Modellierung von Rollenbildern
-
Generative Dissensus in a Youth-Led Coalition-Building Enterprise
-
La educación en tiempos del COVID desde la epistemología social de Tho...
-
The Education Systems of the Americas: Introduction
-
Troubling the Waters: A Critical Essay on Black Male Role Models and M...
-
Inventing other spaces for European education: Summer School in Europe...
-
Legitimising the need for another curriculum reform and policy framing...
-
The Education Systems of the Americas: Introduction
-
The Politics of Metrics in Education: A Contribution to the History of...
-
The return of moral questions: expanding social epistemology in music ...
-
Where Critical Policy Meets the Politics of Education: An Introduction
-
Embedding Education Research in the European Economic Imaginary?
-
Public scholars, legitimation, and the “subject of history” predicamen...
-
Pedagogiken och lärarna
-
Religion or Citizenship? Beyond the Binary; Lessons after a Century of...
-
Doing Critical Policy Analysis in Education Research: An Emerging Para...
-
From Subhuman to Human Kind: Implicit Bias, Racial Memory, and Black M...
-
Introduction: Critical Approaches to Education Policy Analysis
-
Culturally Responsive Experimental Intervention Studies...
-
Sins of Omission
-
Objects of Protection, Enduring Nodes of Difference...
-
Introduction
-
Trash or Treasure? Re-conceptualizing My Ruins as a Tool for Re-imagin...
-
Double gestures of inclusion and exclusion. Notions of learning outcom...
-
What future for educational research in Europe? Political, epistemolog...
-
The Potential of Communities of Practice as Contexts for the Developme...
-
The Limits of Role Modelling as a Policy Frame for Addressing Equity I...
-
The aporia of undecidability and the respo...
-
On Human Kinds and Role Models: A Critical Discussion about the Africa...
-
Interrogating planning’s power in an African city: Time for reorientat...
-
Restoring Washed Out Bridges so ELearners Arrive at Online Course Dest...
-
“Same Old Stories”: The Black Male in Social Science and Educational L...
-
Was Progressive Education Progressive?
-
Culturally Significant Signs, Symbols, and Philosophical Belief System...
-
Trends and possibilities of postmodern curriculum research: Reviews an...
-
Spaces of social inclusion and exclusion—A spatial approach to educati...
-
Education Policy as a Practice of Power...
-
Towards a New Concept of Research
-
Les politiques et les pratiques en éducation : un couplage problématiq...
-
The Re-historicisation and Increased Contextualisation of Curriculum a...
-
Rethinking the History of Ontario Day Nurseries: Loci for Intervention...
-
Continuing Rethinking The History of Ontario Day Nurseries: Loci for I...
-
Designing New Media Education Research: The Materiality of Data, Repre...
-
“Governing the Soul” through Remolding the Self: The American Approach
-
The Alchemy of the Mathematics Curriculum: Inscriptions and the Fabric...
-
Professional Knowledge, Teacher Education and Self-Study*
-
Mapping transformations in educational subjectivities: working within ...
-
Partnerships, the Social Pact, and Changing Systems of Reason in a Com...
-
Enveloping pedagogies: the codification of instructional technologies
-
Higher Education's Self-Reflexive Turn
-
The Responsible Anarchist: Postmodernism and social change
-
The Penetration of Educational Leadership Texts by Revelation and Prop...
-
Institutionalisation of Educational Sciences and the Dynamics of Their...
-
Making Sense of a New Curriculum Text within Competing Discourses and ...
-
Students and Educators Learning Within Relationships
-
Moving beyond a Deficit Perspective with Qualitative Research Methods
-
Teaching Freedom? Postmodern Perspectives
-
How Principals of Autonomous Schools in Israel View Implementation of ...
-
Pssssst! What does one call a set of non-empirical beliefs required to...
-
Chapter 6: Epistemological Diversity in Research on Preservice Teacher...
-
Exploring an emerging landscape: A metaphor for university academics w...
-
Rejoinder: in the United States of America, in Both Our Souls and Our ...
-
Musings on Willower's “Fog”: A Response
-
The Culture of Redemption and the Administration of Freedom as Researc...
-
Caught in the Paradigm Gap: Qualitative Researchers’ Lived Experience ...
-
Culturally Significant Signs, Symbols, and Philosophical Belief System...
Figures and tables
Figures & Media
Tables
View Options
Get access
Access options
If you have access to journal content via a personal subscription, university, library, employer or society, select from the options below:
loading institutional access options
AERA members can access this journal content using society membership credentials.
AERA members can access this journal content using society membership credentials.
Alternatively, view purchase options below:
Purchase 24 hour online access to view and download content.
Access journal content via a DeepDyve subscription or find out more about this option.
