5,696
Views
14
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Historiographical Review

The debate on ‘Americanization’ among economic and cultural historians

Pages 107-130 | Published online: 08 Mar 2010
 

Abstract

Beginning with an analysis of the debate on the usefulness of the concepts of ‘Americanization’ and ‘Westernization’, this essay reviews the recent research on the European-American relationship during the Cold War that has dealt with the cultural impact of the United States upon Europe. The second half is devoted to a discussion of relevant work on this subject in the fields of economic and business history. Overall, the article tries to bring out that those who have applied the concept of ‘Americanization’ to their research on cultural and/or economic history have been well aware of the complexities of trans-Atlantic relations in this period, whether they were viewed as a two-way exchange or as a process of circulation.

Notes

 [1] CitationTocqueville, Democracy.

 [2] CitationStead, Americanization of the World. This article is not concerned with the domestic Americanization movement of the early twentieth century and the question of the integration of immigrant populations into the United States.

 [3] CitationWestad, Global Cold War.

 [4] CitationCostigliola, Awkward Dominion.

 [5] CitationNehring, ‘“Westernization”’.

 [6] Visit http://www.ghi-dc.org/conpotweb/westernpapers/ for all conference papers. See also CitationDoering-Manteuffel, Wie westlich sind die Deutschen?

 [7] CitationKrieger, German Idea of Freedom. For recent expressions of this position see, e.g. CitationSchildt, Ankunft im Westen.

 [8] CitationDower, Embracing Defeat; CitationWard and Yoshikazu, eds., Democratizing Japan; CitationSchaller, The American Occupation of Japan; CitationNishida, Wiederaufbau.

 [9] CitationJarausch and Siegrist, eds., Amerikanisierung und Sowjetisierung; CitationMarkovits, Uncouth Nation; CitationStephan, ed., Americanization and Anti-Americanism; CitationRevel, Anti-Americanism; CitationHollander, ed., Understanding Anti-Americanism; CitationRoger, The American Enemy; CitationBehrends, von Klimo, and Poutrus, eds., Antiamerikanismus im 20. Jahrhundert (with articles on Eastern Europe developments); CitationPells, Not Like Us; CitationBarjot and Réveillard, eds., L'américanisation; CitationJudt and Lacorne, eds., With Us or Against Us; CitationMcPherson, ed., Anti-Americanism in Latin America and the Caribbean.

[10] CitationBührer, ‘Auf eigenem Weg’.

[11] CitationBuisscot and Reinhardt, eds., Creolization in the Americas; CitationMatsuda, Age of Creolization in the Pacific.

[12] CitationRodgers, Atlantic Crossings; CitationGreene, Atlantic History; CitationRausch, ed., Transatlantischer Kulturtransfer. For the circulation concept see CitationTournès, ‘La philanthropie américaine et l'Europe’.

[13] Short summary of the concept in CitationJoll, Gramsci, 88–104. Mention should be made here of the concept, used by some scholars, of the ‘self-Americanization’ of the Europeans, but it seems to me that it comes close to what Gramsci meant when he talked of the cultural hegemony of the bourgeoisie and its power over the working class. The theme of culture in international relations is also taken up by CitationGienow-Hecht and Schumacher, eds., Culture and International History.

[14] CitationDe Grazia, Irresistible Empire; CitationLundestad, ‘Empire’ by Integration; CitationSchmidt, ‘Civil Empire by Co-Optation’; CitationScott-Smith, Networks of Empire. This may also explain why the concept of ‘encounter’ (Begegnung), for a while also popular in a non-Western context, came under criticism because it underestimated the frequently very violent nature of the European/Western expansion into other societies. For an application of Begegnung in a European–American cultural context see CitationPlé, Wissenschaft und säkulare Mission; Joseph et al., eds, Close Encounters.

[15] CitationGans, Popular Culture and High Culture; CitationKroes, ed., High Brow Meets Low Brow.

[16] CitationBerghahn, America and the Intellectual Cold Wars in Europe.

[17] CitationSchildt, ‘Die USA als “Kulturnation”’.

[18] CitationSaunders, Cultural Cold War; CitationWilford, Mighty Wurlitzer. See also the studies cited in note 9; CitationArmstrong, ‘Cultural Cold War in Korea’; CitationHixson, Parting the Curtain; CitationCorbin, L'image de l'Europe; CitationRichmond, Cultural Exchange and the Cold War; CitationRichmond, Practicing Public Diplomacy; CitationCull, Cold War and the United States Information Agency; CitationGalle, RIAS Berlin; CitationCaute, Dancer Defects; CitationBelmonte, Selling America; CitationMastrogregori, ed., Citation Studi sul ‘Congress for Cultural Freedom’; Scott-Smith, The Politics of Apolitical Culture .

[19] CitationSchildt, Zwischen Abendland und Amerika; CitationGijswijt, European Integration and Atlantic Cooperation.

[20] CitationLagemann, ed., Philanthropic Foundations.

[21] CitationScott-Smith and Krabbendam, eds., Cultural Cold War in Western Europe.

[22] CitationLucas, Freedom's War.

[23] CitationGilman, Mandarins of the Future; CitationFleck, Transatlantische Bereicherungen.

[24] CitationWise, Arts and Minds.

[25] On visual arts: CitationLenz, ‘Refractions of Modernity’; CitationRuby, ‘Fascination, Ignorance and Rejection’; CitationCuriel et al., eds., Arte, Historia e Idenditad en America; CitationSandler, The Confusion Era. On literature: CitationBrockmann, German Literary Culture; on classical music: CitationMonod, Settling Scores; on science: CitationKrige, American Hegemony; on architecture and design: see note 53 below; on modern dance: see note 54 below.

[26] CitationVon Eschen, Satchmo; CitationGabbard, Hotter Than That.

[27] CitationPoiger, Jazz, Rock, and Rebels; CitationFenemore, Sex, Thugs and Rock ‘n’ Roll; CitationMinganti, ‘Jukebox Boys’; CitationTournès, New Orleans sur Seine; Condry, ‘Social Production of Difference’.

[28] CitationSchildt and Siegfried, eds., Between Marx and Coca-Cola.

[29] CitationStreet, British National Cinema; CitationKniesche and Brockmann, eds., Dancing on the Volcano.

[30] CitationFehrenbach, Cinema in Democratizing Germany; CitationGoldstein, Capturing the German Eye; CitationKuisel, ‘French Cinema and Hollywood’; CitationPetterson, ‘No More Song and Dance’; CitationSchwartz, It's So French!; CitationEllwood and Kroes, eds., Hollywood in Europe; CitationGundle, Between Hollywood and Moscow; CitationHirano, Mr. Smith Goes to Tokyo.

[31] CitationKniesche, ‘Germans to the Final Frontier’.

[32] CitationTatsumi, ‘Waiting for Godzilla’; CitationIvy, Discourses of the Vanishing.

[33] CitationPierenkemper, Unternehmensgeschichte.

[34] CitationEllwood, Rebuilding Europe.

[35] CitationAbelshauser, Wirtschaft in Westdeutschland.

[36] CitationMilward, Reconstruction of Western Europe.

[37] CitationSchröder, ed., Marshallplan und westdeutscher Wiederaufstieg; CitationMcKenzie, Remaking France.

[38] CitationGillingham, Coal, Steel, and the Rebirth of Europe; Wiesen, West German Industry; CitationKipping, Zwischen Kartellen und Konkurrenz; CitationEichengreen, European Economy.

[39] CitationNeebe, Weichenstellung für die Globalisierung.

[40] CitationWilliams, Tragedy of American Diplomacy.

[41] CitationBerghahn, Americanization of West German Industry.

[42] CitationBrose, Technology and Science; CitationKanigel, The One Best Way; CitationBonin et al., eds., Ford, 1903–2003.

[43] CitationNolan, Visions of Modernity; CitationFridenson, Histoire des usines Renault; CitationBillstein et al., Working for the Enemy; CitationTurner, General Motors and the Nazis; CitationGassert, Amerika im Dritten Reich.

[44] CitationKleinschmidt, ‘Kulturalistische Wende in der Unternehmensgeschichtsschreibung’.

[45] CitationKipping and Bjarnar, eds., Americanisation of European Business; CitationGourvish and Tiratsoo, eds., Missionaries and Managers; CitationMcKenna, World's Newest Profession; CitationDjelic, Exporting the American Model; CitationKipping and Engwall, eds., Management Consulting. CitationKudo, Kipping and Schröter, eds., German and Japanese Business; CitationSaito, ‘Americanization and Postwar Japanese Management’. However, there was some technology transfer from East to West, i.e., from occupied Germany to Western Europe and the US. See CitationJudt and Ciesla, eds., Technology Transfer out of Germany.

[46] CitationCohen, A Consumers' Republic; CitationStrasser, Satisfaction Guaranteed; CitationStrasser et al., eds., Getting and Spending; CitationRioux and Sirinelli, eds., La culture de masse; CitationBerghoff, ed., Konsumpolitik; CitationWalter, ed., Geschichte des Konsums; CitationWildt, ‘Plurality of Taste’; CitationCarter, How German Is She?; CitationSiegrist et al., eds., Europäische Konsumgeschichte; CitationCrew, ed., Consuming Germany.

[47] CitationOldenziel and Zachmann, eds., Cold War Kitchen; CitationCastillo, ‘Domesticating the Cold War’; CitationSchindelbeck, Marken, Moden und Kampagnen; CitationTiersten, Marianne in the Market; CitationVeszelits, Neckermanns; CitationKleinschmidt and Triebel, eds., Marketing; CitationWiesen, ‘Miracles for Sale’; CitationSwett et al., eds., Selling Modernity.

[48] CitationMarkovits, Offside; CitationSorkin, ed., Variations on a Theme Park; CitationKroes, If You've Seen One.

[49] CitationZeitlin and Herrigel, eds., Americanization and Its Limits; CitationAbelshauser, Dynamics of German Industry; CitationFehrenbach and Poiger, ‘Americanization Reconsidered’; CitationFehrenbach, ‘Persistent Myths of Americanization’.

[50] CitationEyal and Bockman, ‘Eastern Europe as a Laboratory for Economic Knowledge’.

[51] CitationKoch-Wegener, Apostle of the Free Market Economy, 221 ff.

[52] CitationGienow-Hecht, Sound Diplomacy.

[53] CitationZukowsky, ed., Chicago Architecture and Design; CitationGrewe, ed., From Manhattan to Mainhattan; CitationBognar, ‘Surface Above All?’

[54] CitationGarafola, Legacies of Twentieth-Century Dance.

[55] CitationKrohn, Intellectuals in Exile.

[56] CitationMaase, Grenzenloses Vergnügen, 274 f.

[57] CitationWelters and Cunningham, Twentieth-Century American Fashion; CitationWeinbaum et al., eds., Modern Girl; CitationHill, As Seen in Vogue; CitationTrue, ‘Expanding Markets and Marketing Gender’; CitationBrubach, ‘A Luxury For All’.

[58] CitationBerghahn, ‘Deutsche Industrie und amerikanische Geschäftswelt’.

[59] CitationSabel and Zeitlin, eds., World of Possibilities; CitationKleinschmidt, Der produktive Blick; CitationBergner, The New Superpowers.

[60] CitationTett, Fool's Gold.

[61] In a different way, CitationJessica Gienow-Hecht tried to move away from the United States as the centre of gravity in her Decentering America. Mention should finally also be made of the concept of a histoire croisée that CitationMichael Werner and Bénédicte Zimmermann at EHESS in Paris have put forward. Interested in processes of constant interaction and interrelation, they stress the fluidity of national categories and advocate a transnational history that is multi-perspectival – one that looks for the ‘crossings’ of dynamic and often contradictory developments beyond a bilateralism.

Log in via your institution

Log in to Taylor & Francis Online

PDF download + Online access

  • 48 hours access to article PDF & online version
  • Article PDF can be downloaded
  • Article PDF can be printed
USD 53.00 Add to cart

Issue Purchase

  • 30 days online access to complete issue
  • Article PDFs can be downloaded
  • Article PDFs can be printed
USD 455.00 Add to cart

* Local tax will be added as applicable

Related Research

People also read lists articles that other readers of this article have read.

Recommended articles lists articles that we recommend and is powered by our AI driven recommendation engine.

Cited by lists all citing articles based on Crossref citations.
Articles with the Crossref icon will open in a new tab.