The position of the earliest-derived living molluscs, the Polyplacophora (chitons) and shell-less vermiform Aplacophora, remains highly contentious despite many morphological, developmental and molecular studies of extant organisms. These two groups are thought to represent either a basal molluscan grade or a clade (Aculifera) sister to the ‘higher’ molluscs (Conchifera). These incompatible hypotheses result in very different predictions about the earliest molluscs. A new cladistic analysis incorporating both Palaeozoic and extant molluscs is presented here. Our results support the monophyly of Aculifera and suggest that extant aplacophorans and polyplacophorans both derive from a disparate group of multivalved molluscs in two major clades. Reanalysis of the critical Ordovician taxon ‘Helminthochiton’ thraivensis shows that this animal lacks a true foot despite bearing polyplacophoran-like valves. Its position within our phylogenetic reconstruction indicates that many fossil ‘polyplacophorans’ in the order Palaeoloricata are likely to represent footless stem-group aplacophorans. ‘H.’ thraivensis and similar forms such as Acaenoplax may be morphological stepping stones between chitons and the shell-less aplacophorans. Our results imply that crown-group molluscan synapomorphies include serial repetition, the presence of a foot, a mineralized scleritome and a creeping rather than worm-like mode of life.

References

Adrain J.M . 1992 Machaeridian classification. Alcheringa. 16, 15–32. Crossref, ISI, Google Scholar
Brusca R.C& Brusca G.J Invertebrates. 2nd edn. 2003 Sunderland, MA:Sinauer Associates. Google Scholar
Butterfield N.J . 2006 Hooking some stem-group ‘worms’: fossil lophotrochozoans in the Burgess Shale. Bioessays. 28, 1161–1166.doi:10.1002/bies.20507. . Crossref, PubMed, ISI, Google Scholar
Caron J.-B, Scheltema A, Schander C& Rudkin D . 2006 A soft-bodied mollusc with radula from the Middle Cambrian Burgess Shale. Nature. 442, 159–162.doi:10.1038/nature04894. . Crossref, PubMed, ISI, Google Scholar
Cherns L . 2004 Early Palaeozoic diversification of chitons (Polyplacophora Mollusca) based on new data from the Silurian of Gotland, Sweden. Lethaia. 37, 445–456.doi:10.1080/00241160410002180. . Crossref, ISI, Google Scholar
Cohen B.L, Holmer L.E& Lüter C . 2003 The brachiopod fold: a neglected body plan hypothesis. Palaeontology. 46, 59–65.doi:10.1111/1475-4983.00287. . Crossref, ISI, Google Scholar
Conway Morris S& Caron J.-B . 2007 Halwaxiids and the early evolution of the lophotrochozoans. Science. 315, 1255–1258.doi:10.1126/science.1137187. . Crossref, PubMed, ISI, Google Scholar
Dell'Angelo B, Gallorini H& Taviani M . 2003 First Neogene record of an articulated polyplacophoran. J. Paleontol. 77, 1193–1194.doi:10.1666/0022-3360(2003)077<1193:FNROAA>2.0.CO;2. . Crossref, ISI, Google Scholar
Dzik, J. 1994 Machaeridia, chitons, and conchiferan molluscs of the Mojcza Limestone. In Ordovician carbonate platform of the Holy Cross Mountains (eds J. Dzik, E. Olempska, & A. Pisera). Palaeontol. Pol. 53, 213–252. Google Scholar
Fedonkin M.A& Waggoner B.M . 1997 The Late Precambrian fossil Kimberella is a mollusc-like bilaterian organism. Nature. 388, 868–871.doi:10.1038/42242. . Crossref, ISI, Google Scholar
Ghiselin M.T . 1988 The origin of molluscs in light of molecular evidence. Oxford Surv. Evol. Biol. 5, 66–95. Google Scholar
Giribet G, Okusu A, Lindgren A.R, Huff S.W, Schrödl M& Nishiguchi M.K . 2006 Evidence for a clade composed of molluscs with serially repeated structures: monoplacophorans are related to chitons. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA. 103, 7723–7728.doi:10.1073/pnas.0602578103. . Crossref, PubMed, ISI, Google Scholar
Haszprunar G The Mollusca: coelomate turbellarians or mesenchymate annelids?. In Origin and evolutionary radiation of the Mollusca & Taylor J.D . 1996pp. 3–28. Eds. Oxford, UK:Oxford University Press. Google Scholar
Haszprunar G . 2000 Is the Aplacophora monophyletic? A cladistic point of view. Am. Malacol. Bull. 15, 115–130. ISI, Google Scholar
Hoare R.D . 2000 Considerations on Paleozoic Polyplacophora including the description of Plasiochiton curiosus n. gen. and sp. Am. Malacol. Bull. 15, 131–137. ISI, Google Scholar
Holmer L.E, Skovsted C.B& Williams A . 2002 A stem group brachiopod from the Lower Cambrian: support for a Micrina (halkieriid) ancestry. Palaeontology. 45, 875–882.doi:10.1111/1475-4983.00265. . Crossref, ISI, Google Scholar
Lindberg D.R& Ghiselin M.T . 2003 Fact, theory and tradition in the study of molluscan origins. Proc. Calif. Acad. Sci. 54, 663–686. Google Scholar
Lindberg D.R& Ponder W An evolutionary tree for the Mollusca: branches or roots?. In Origin and evolutionary radiation of the Mollusca & Taylor J.D . 1996pp. 67–75. Eds. Oxford, UK:Oxford University Press. Google Scholar
Nielsen C, Haszprunar G, Ruthensteiner B& Wanninger A . 2007 Early development of the aplacophoran mollusc Chaetoderma. Acta Zool. 88, 231–247.doi:10.1111/j.1463-6395.2007.00270.x. . Crossref, ISI, Google Scholar
Okusu A, Schwabe E, Eernisse D.J& Giribet G . 2003 Towards a phylogeny of chitons (Mollusca Polyplacophora) based on combined analysis of five molecular loci. Org. Div. Evol. 4, 281–302.doi:10.1078/1439-6092-00085. . Crossref, ISI, Google Scholar
Passamaneck Y.J, Schander C& Halanych K.M . 2004 Investigation of molluscan phylogeny using large-subunit and small-subunit nuclear rRNA sequences. Mol. Phylogenet. Evol. 32, 25–38.doi:10.1016/j.ympev.2003.12.016. . Crossref, PubMed, ISI, Google Scholar
Reed F.R.C . 1911 A new fossil from Girvan. Geol. Mag. 8, 337–340. Crossref, Google Scholar
Rosenberg G, Tillier S, Tillier A, Kuncio G.S, Hanlon R.T, Masselot M& Williams C.J . 1997 Ribozomal RNA phylogeny of selected major clades in the Mollusca. J. Moll. Stud. 63, 301–309.doi:10.1093/mollus/63.3.301. . Crossref, ISI, Google Scholar
Salvini-Plawen L.v . 1980 A reconsideration of systematics in Mollusca. Malacologia. 19, 247–278. ISI, Google Scholar
Salvini-Plawen L.v Early evolution and the primitive groups. The mollusca. , Trueman E.R& Clarke M.R Evolution vol. 10 1985pp. 59–150. Eds. New York, NY:Academic Press. Crossref, Google Scholar
Salvini-Plawen L.v& Steiner G Synapomorphies and plesiomorphies in higher classification of Mollusca. Origin and evolutionary radiation of the mollusca & Taylor J.D . 1996pp. 29–51. Eds. Oxford, UK:Oxford University Press. Google Scholar
Scheltema A.H . 1993 Aplacophora as progenetic aculiferans and the coelomate origin of mollusks as the sister taxon of Sipuncula. Biol. Bull. 184, 57–78.doi:10.2307/1542380. . Crossref, PubMed, ISI, Google Scholar
Scheltema A.H Phylogenetic position of the Sipuncula, Mollusca and the progenetic Aplacophora. Origin and Evolutionary Radiation of the Mollusca & Taylor J.D . 1996pp. 53–58. Eds. Oxford, UK:Oxford University Press. Google Scholar
Scheltema A.H, Kerth K& Kuzirian A.M . 2003 Original molluscan radula: comparisons among Aplacophora, Polyplacophora, Gastropoda, and the Cambrian fossil Wiwaxia corrugata. J. Morph. 257, 219–245.doi:10.1002/jmor.10121. . Crossref, PubMed, ISI, Google Scholar
Sigwart J.D . 2007 The Irish fossil Polyplacophora. Ir. J. Earth Sci. 25, 27–38. Google Scholar
Sirenko B.I . 1997 The importance of the development of articulamentum for taxonomy of chitons (Mollusca Polyplacophora). Ruthenica. 7, 1–24. Google Scholar
Sirenko B.I . 2006 New outlook on the system of chitons (Mollusca: Polyplacophora). Venus. 65, 27–49. Google Scholar
Smith A.G& Hoare R.D . 1987 Paleozoic Polyplacophora: a checklist and bibliography. Occas. pap. Calif. Acad. Sci. 146, 1–71. Google Scholar
Sutton M.D, Briggs D.E, Siviter D.J& Siviter D.J . 2001 An exceptionally preserved vermiform mollusc from the Silurian of England. Nature. 410, 461–463.doi:10.1038/35068549. . Crossref, PubMed, ISI, Google Scholar
Sutton M.D, Briggs D.E, Siviter D.J& Siviter D.J . 2004 Computer reconstruction and analysis of the vermiform mollusc Acaenoplax hayae from the Herefordshire Lagerstätte (Silurian England), and implications for molluscan phylogeny. Palaeontology. 47, 293–318.doi:10.1111/j.0031-0239.2004.00374.x. . Crossref, ISI, Google Scholar
Swofford, D. W. 2002 PAUP^*: phylogenetic analysis using parsimony (^*and other methods), version 4. Sunderland, MA: Sinauer Associates. Google Scholar
Vendrasco M.J& Runnegar B.N . 2004 Late Cambrian and Early Ordovician stem group chitons (Mollusca: Polyplacophora) from Utah and Missouri. J. Paleontol. 78, 675–689.doi:10.1666/0022-3360(2004)078<0675:LCAEOS>2.0.CO;2. . Crossref, ISI, Google Scholar
Vendrasco M.J, Wood T.E& Runnegar B.N . 2004 Articulated Palaeozoic fossil with 17 plates greatly expands disparity of early chitons. Nature. 429, 288–291.doi:10.1038/nature02548. . Crossref, PubMed, ISI, Google Scholar
Vinther J& Nielsen C . 2005 The Early Cambrian Halkieria is a mollusc. Zool. Scripta. 34, 81–89.doi:10.1111/j.1463-6409.2005.00177.x. . Crossref, ISI, Google Scholar
Wills M A phylogeny of recent and fossil Crustacea derived from morphological characters. Arthropod relationships , Fortey R.A& Thomas R.H . 1997pp. 189–209. Eds. London, UK:Chapman & Hall. Google Scholar