YouTube launches country-specific homepage for Pakistan

Naveed Ahmed | 8 years ago | Reply First of all it has not been really an easy task to know what is the YouTube URL to the country-specific homepage launched by Google. I have not found a consensus on this issue in the different newspapers of Pakistan as well as the relevant blog post on the Google Asia Pacific blog. To clarify my point, some newspapers say the URL could be youtube.pk while others say it could be youtube.com.pk, while still others maintain it would be youtube.com/pk and not to ignore, there is also voice for another URL youtubePK.com. So in this regards, neither has PTA clarified what the URL to the newly launched version of YouTube was, on its website or in its petitions to the Supreme Court? For me, if I could get the answer to this foremost question, I would like to know how would Google co-ordinate with the Pakistani Government for controlling content appearing on its customized domain? Will it open an office in Pakistan and make arrangements for a prior Agreement with the Pakistani Government as to what type of content should be made available on this country-specific domain? After this I would also like to know, if YouTube would benefit from the rich Pakistani media content, what would the Pakistanis gain? Would YouTube / Google offer the YouTube Partnership program / content monetization in Pakistani version of YouTube after benefitting itself from the rich Pakistani content and viewership.

Md. Tahir Shah | 8 years ago | Reply I agree with PTA on this. If Google wishes to operate in Pakistan, it has to respect local laws. You can't play cowboy as if its Wild Wild West. We don't need another East India Company.

Parvez | 8 years ago | Reply @Sara: Excuse me, then you have not explored YouTube properly. For example, there are Khan Academy's more than 4,000 videos teaching every subject under the sun - admittedly for those who can understand basic English. The 'How to' / 'How things work' and training videos are useful for all, because practical video demonstrations minimise the need of understanding the language. If our poor self-learned plumbers, car mechanics, electricians, masons, carpenters, painters, tailors, etc etc, could be taught using these videos, they could give super quality outputs, and be more productive. I could go on and on. Unfortunately, most of our teachers (particularly in small towns) do not know (or at least cannot teach) the modern methods of doing things. I am an engineer with decades of experience, but even today, when confronted with something new that I want to understand, I go to YouTube. The TED talk videos are also hugely inspiring. I know YouTube is accessible even today, but unless it is the legal way it cannot be accessed by EVERYONE, and also cannot be used in schools and training institutions etc.

Sara | 8 years ago | Reply Youtube is over rated. Local rip offs and facebook aleady post similar content anyways pakistanis need to watch. Plus it is aceessible from cell phones anyways to access international stuff so unbaning does not really help that much. Even new chrome browser lets you access youtube without proxy.

Steve Foerster | 8 years ago | Reply @zainulabadin: But, but if you live in a free country you get to make the choice for yourself. Only if you live in an unfree country do politicians make that choice for you. There is a famous saying, "Error alone needs the support of government. Truth can stand by itself."

Parvez | 8 years ago | Reply @zainulabadin: Sometimes, we do not listen to someone because we think differently. It does not mean there is an issue of respect. And my dear in this case dont forget that we are the onew losing out in a big way! There is an immense amount of udeful stuff in YouTube. It is a video library, all the world's largest libraries of books contain objectionable/hateful stuff as well as useful stuff. When we go there we go for what we want to learn from, and ignore the rest. I say the same thing as you - for me my country stands first, if my country can get benefit from something, then I should be able to access it!

zainulabadin | 8 years ago | Reply for me my country stands first, if youtube doesn't respect my country, i am better off without it.

TeeAay | 8 years ago | Reply @GooglMan: Sorry. But who are you?

Syed M. Adil | 8 years ago | Reply @Ali S: Do you think PTA doesnt know about it? So innocent of you.

Parvez | 8 years ago | Reply Reason why it's the right time to raise your voice in favor of unblocking YouTube.

@GooglMan: | 8 years ago | Reply @GooglMan: Seriously something is burning

Kickass | 8 years ago | Reply @GooglMan: Have the moral courage to give your name. You are nothing but a cheap lowlife making such silly comment.Dignity is a strange word to the likes if you. You have trued to malign Google.

ali | 8 years ago | Reply @curious2 No, you're wrong. Google's approximate net worth is $50 billion whereas Pakistan's GDP (PPP) is $930 billion. Fact check before posting next time please.

Sammer | 8 years ago | Reply @Aslam: True, except that proxy services install those delicious little cookies into the user's computer, which then spy on him, tracking his every move. Direct access will at least minimize the scale and scope of this problem if not avoid it altogether.

Javairia | 8 years ago | Reply @curious2: I agree with your argument but for the record, Pakistan's GDP in 2014 was $246.88 billion, roughly around half Google's market capitalization. I understand that statistics about Pakistan's GDP vary greatly depending on whom you ask, but if it were 9 times smaller, it would be $55.55 billion, and certainly nobody will say it's that small.

Aslam | 8 years ago | Reply What matter youtube ban or open who want to visit youtube so they use the proxy and change ip address so there is no effect whether youtube will open or ban.

curious2 | 8 years ago | Reply @Soofiya Malik:

Wow…Google…blinked…first!

I don't think that is correct. YouTube has just added some regional content and hasn't changed it's policies - it's still remains officially banned in Pakistan. Pakistan has yet to jump through the various legal hoops required by YouTube in order to gain control over local content. You should note that Google market capitalization is about $500 Billion - that's about 9 times larger than the GDP of Pakistan - it's unlikely that Pakistan has enough leverage to coerce Google into doing anything.

Aliya | 8 years ago | Reply Thank You Raheel Sharif

Ali S | 8 years ago | Reply Thank God that YouTube has been unlocked for about 3-4 months now - but don't cheer too much or you might wake up the PTA

Techober | 8 years ago | Reply i don't think this is going to put any effect on the ban.

Hilmi | 8 years ago | Reply @Soofiya Malik: Nothing of the sort. Google.com.pk has been active for years now. They are just expanding their offerings as always. Unlike Pakistani businesses American tech companies are always looking to grow.

GooglMan | 8 years ago | Reply Dear All, we have not launced any localized version, As it is only shift from general to specific doman to have more relevant content available, We are dignified and are not going to remove any content on request of Pakistan Govt. We dont care and will not care,

Soofiya Malik | 8 years ago | Reply Wow...Google...blinked...first! Bravo PTA!