Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

Explore news, videos, and much more based on what your friends are reading and watching. Publish your own activity and retain full control.

To get started, first

YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    Canada Politics

    Justin Trudeau to run for Liberal leadership but is he all splash and no substance?

    Liberal MP Justin Trudeau has told Montreal's La Presse that he will run for the leadership of the federal Liberal …He's taking the plunge.

    Sources for La Presse are reporting that Justin Trudeau will be seeking the leadership of the Federal Liberals.  According to the French-language Montreal newspaper, Trudeau will make the official announcement in his home riding of Papineau on Tuesday.

    While many in the media are already crowning Justin as the King of the Liberals, political analyst Warren Kinsella says that's not what is best for the party.

    "He would be the front-runner," Kinsella told Yahoo! Canada News in an email exchange.

    "But a lot of us Liberals don't want or need a coronation. We need a competitive race with lots of great, viable candidates and ideas. Justin needs that, too."

    Kinsella, who was a Jean Chretien staffer, adds that Trudeau has the sizzle but needs the steak.

    "He needs to talk about ideas and policies. He has the charisma thing nailed. Now he needs to tell us what he thinks."

    [ Related: Justin Trudeau to announce run for Liberal leadership ]

    Former Liberal MP Dan McTeague, who was in caucus with Trudeau, believes that Trudeau won't have any trouble showing Canadians his 'steak.'

    "He's smart, young and intelligent and will have time to hone the skills to start his bid for PM. Liberal supporters who sat out the last election or drifted to the NDP in the last election will now have a serious rethink," McTeague, who now now operates Tomorrowsgaspricetoday.com told Yahoo!.

    "The future is bright for the Liberal Party, but it will take work and a fresh approach to re-engage Canadians, especially the new generation, where Justin has a considerable advantage."

    Not everyone, however, believes in Trudeau's abilities.

    Jim Ross, who was a senior Conservative government staffer on the immigration committee when Trudeau was the Liberal immigration critic, told Yahoo! Canada News that the son of Pierre is unimpressive.

    "He's a lightweight who didn't know his stuff," Ross said.

    "He was the least knowledgeable of any of the opposition critics who I dealt with."

    [ Photos: Justin Trudeau through the years ]

    We also spoke to Abacus Data pollster David Coletto who says Canadians aren't necessarily looking for a professor to be prime minister.

    "I think it is a misconception to say that Canadians are looking for a leader who has deep policy knowledge.  They want someone who they can trust, who is authentic, and who shares their values," he said.

    "Michael Ignatieff and Stephane Dion were likely the most academically accomplished Canadian political leaders in a generation and they were unable to connect with Canadians.  The world of Twitter, Facebook and 30 second sound bites is not conducive to a deep thinker who cannot explain his or her positions in less than 140 characters. "

    And what does his research predict will happen if Trudeau wins the leadership?

    "We asked Canadians how they would vote if Trudeau was Liberal leader.  Under a Trudeau leader scenario, the Liberals were statistically tied with the Conservatives and he would have taken 25 per cent of the NDP's vote," Coletto told Yahoo! in an email.

    "Trudeau would throw a wrench into the NDP's plans to consolidate the anti-Conservative vote while giving the Conservatives and the BQ some breathing room due to vote splitting in Ontario and Quebec."

    Whether he's just another pretty face or not, thanks to Trudeau, Canada's political landscape has just become a lot more interesting.

    [ Related: Is the Stephen Harper 'brand' broken? ]

     

    456 comments

    • BAM BAM  •  8 hours ago
      Fiberals, liarbles, still the same old tax and spend tax and spend
      when will these old croanies get the hint. Canada says your done!!!!
      No more liberals period. They have destroyed our country fiscally and have killed families with all the taxes over the years that they continuosly pile on and pile on. Who cares about his charisma...its all the same old thing with prettier packaging..
      I dont believe for one minute that he would win no way..all his dads policies are the reason our oil prices are so high, no refineries built, tax payers are paying billions in relabelling everything to accomadate quebecs french. And the list goes on and on..and my caps are on so that i can vent on how slimey and ungood this party would be for canada..they are done!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!liars, liars, liars, wrap it up in any packing you want. The same old lies and scandels.....is this what canada needs????i think not.......
    • The Truth  •  22 hours ago
      Will Justin Trudeau, come out of the closest (if he wins) and become the first openly Gay Leader of a Country? We all know, his marriage is a Sham!
    • Paulo88ca  •  20 hours ago
      Justin Trudeau is all flash and no bang. Yes he is young and charismatic, but is that what Canada needs. I say no, if you look south of the border at Mr. Obama you would see what a ineffective but charasmatic leader has gotten them. Would he affect the political landscape in Canada, yes but would only affect the NDP as the majority of thier MP's come from Quebec, and that is where I see the majority of his appeal would be from.
    • markvend1  •  23 hours ago
      Where is the splash?
    • Rachel  •  1 day 16 hours ago
      Nick - I could HAVE (not of) used anyone I chose and I did. My comparison was quite correct.
    • Bog  •  1 day 17 hours ago
      The idea of someone named Trudeau running for leader of the federal Liberals is enough to make all of them Libs all giddy. Just remember folks we are talking about Justin here not Pierre. Though I am not sure if this guy would be any better but I do know he could not be much worse.
    • Ricardo  •  1 day 0 hours ago
      Trudeau and Mulcair can fight over the scraps allowing PM Harper to reap rewards of being re-elected.
    • loki_sloe  •  1 day 22 hours ago
      It would be easy to crown Trudeau and sink the Libs again. Get a membership and vote him in. Problem is you aren't so sure he will NOT be the next PM.
    • Steve  •  1 day 9 hours ago
      I thought all politicians were splash with no substance.
    • MJ  •  1 day 6 hours ago
      The liberals are in big trouble, big!. Their policies are lame, and they are not to be trusted.
      Federally they are dismal, Provincially in ONT they are a disaster. If they soon don't smarten up, they'll be out and gone...... That's what you get for being the biggest LIARS and cheats around.
    • jojo  •  1 day 3 hours ago
      He is all splash -has never worked at any thing much--lots of money and loves his hair. PM of Canada--don't think so !
    • Malcolm McColl  •  1 day 22 hours ago
      Haven't seen enough to judge his smarts.
    • Montrealer  •  1 day 15 hours ago
      Charisma is one thing, wisdom and strength of character is another.
    • Klew  •  2 days 7 hours ago
      To me he is just another candidate. I don't care what his name is and I will not laud or hang him on it. Let's see first if he wins and then look at him on his merits or lack thereof. Quite frankly after looking I can't find much on anything that gives me a clear idea about what his policies or platform may be. I'll reserve judgement until I can make an informed personal decision on wether he is suitable to run not only his party but also this country.
    • 2centsworth  •  2 days 3 hours ago
      Riding his last name to Ottawa. All aboard the zero substance train.
    • Larry  •  1 day 9 hours ago
      Priveleged little nit wit, not a care in the world riding along on his daddy's coat tails, How could any sane Canadian expect this guy to run an economy and a country. The biggest thing he ever did on his own was to organize a dart game down at the pub. But he will have a following of students and gays and those who won't work for a living.Surely the libs.can find someone fresh and new without trying to get anymore out of the Trudeau name.
    • David  •  2 days 8 hours ago
      I look forward to seeing the coronation that the CBC puts out for Justin Trudeau if this becomes official. If you thought their breathless accolades about Jack Layton was over the top, it will pale in comparison to when Justin makes this official.
    • xx  •  2 days 2 hours ago
      I worked with him in Whistler after university. We were both snowboard instructors at he time. We dated. He was crazy- he lived in his own world and was not grounded in reality. He got fired from Intrawest. He poses a true danger for Canada as he trades on his daddy's name and influence. NO SUBSTANCE!
    • Dietrich  •  1 day 14 hours ago
      The Liberals have learned nothing from the past. Justin...you have to be kidding!
    • Stan Hicks  •  12 hours ago
      mommy,mommy,is Mick Jagger gonna be my new daddy,please
    Search

    Blog Authors / Profiles