A review of paradoxical performance effects: Choking under pressure in sports and mental tests
Corresponding Author
Roy F Baumeister
Case Western Reserve University, U.S.A.
Department of Psychology, Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, Ohio 44106, U.S.A.Search for more papers by this authorCorresponding Author
Roy F Baumeister
Case Western Reserve University, U.S.A.
Department of Psychology, Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, Ohio 44106, U.S.A.Search for more papers by this authorAbstract
Paradoxical performance effects (‘choking under pressure’) are defined as the occurrence of inferior performance despite striving and incentives for superior performance. Experimental demonstrations of these effects on tasks analogous to athletic performance and the theories that may explain them are reviewed. At present, attentional theories seem to offer the most complete explanation of the processes underlying paradoxical performance effects. In particular, choking may result from distraction or from the interference of self-focused attention with the execution of automatic responses. Experimental findings of paradoxical performance decrements are associated with four pressure variables: audience presence, competition, performance-contingent rewards and punishments, and ego relevance of the task. The mediating factors of task complexity, expectancies, and individual differences are discussed.
References
- Agnew, N. and Agnew, M. (1963). ‘Drive level effects on tasks of narrow and broad attention’, Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology, 15: 58–62.
- Bandura, A. (1977). ‘Self-efficacy: Toward a unifying theory of behavior change’, Psychological Review, 84: 191–215.
- Baumeister, R. F. (1982). ‘A self-presentational view of social phenomena,’ Psychological Bulletin, 91: 3–26.
- Baumeister, R. F. (1984). ‘Choking under pressure: Self-consciousness and paradoxical effects of incentives on skillful performance,’ Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 46: 610–620.
- Baumeister, R. F. (1985). ‘The championship choke,’ Psychology Today, 19 (4: April), 48–52.
- Baumeister, R. F., Hamilton, J. C. and Tice, D. M. (1985). ‘Public versus private expectancy of success: Confidence booster or performance pressure?’ Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 48: 1447–1457.
- Baumeister, R. F. and Steinhilber, A. (1984). ‘Paradoxical effects of supportive audiences on performance under pressure: The home field disadvantage in sports championships,’ Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 47: 85–93.
- Baumeister, R. F. and Tice, D. M. (1985). ‘Self-esteem and responses to success and failure: Subsequent performance and intrinsic motivation’, Journal of Personality, in press.
- Berkey, A. S. and Hoppe, R. A. (1972). ‘The combined effect of audience and anxiety on paired-associates learning,’ Psychonomic Science, 29: 351–353.
- Besch, N. F. (1959). ‘Paired-associates learning as a function of anxiety level and shock,’ Journal of Personality, 27: 116–124.
- Blank, T. O., Staff, I. and Shaver, P. (1976). ‘Social facilitation of word associations: Further questions,’ Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 34: 725–733.
- Bond, C. F. Jr., (1982). ‘Social facilitation: A self-presentational view,’ Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 42: 1042–1050.
- Bond, C. F. Jr., and Titus, L. J. (1983). ‘Social facilitation: A meta-analysis of 241 studies,’ Psychological Bulletin, 94: 265–292.
- Broadbent, D. E. (1971). Decision and Stress, Academic Press, New York.
- Brockner, J. (1979). ‘Self-esteem, self-consciousness, and task performance: Replications, extensions, and possible explanations,’ Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 37: 447–461.
- Broen, W. E. Jr., and Storms, L. H. (1961). ‘A reaction potential ceiling and response decrements in complex situations,’ Psychological Review, 68: 405–415.
- Bruning, J. L., Capage, J. E., Kozuh, G. F., Young, P. F. and Young, W. E. (1968). ‘Socially induced drive and range of cue utilization,’ Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 9: 242–244.
- Brunson, B. I. and Matthews, K. A. (1981). ‘The type A coronary-prone behavior pattern and reactions to uncontrollable stress: An analysis of performance strategies, affect and attributions during failure,’ Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 40: 906–918.
- Carver, C. S., Blaney, P. H. and Scheier, M. F. (1979). ‘Reassertion and giving up: The interactive roles of self-directed attention and outcome expectancy,’ Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 37: 1859–1870.
- Carver, C. S., Coleman, A. E. and Glass, D. C. (1976). ‘The coronary-prone behavior pattern and the suppression of fatigue on a treadmill test,’ Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 33: 460–466.
- Carver, C. S. and Scheier, M. F. (1978). ‘Self-focusing effects of dispositional self-consciousness, mirror presence, and audience presence,’ Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 36: 324–332.
- Carver, C. S. and Scheier, M. F. (1981a). Attention and Self-Regulation, Springer-Verlag, New York.
10.1007/978-1-4612-5887-2 Google Scholar
- Carver, C. S. and Scheier, M. F. (1981b). ‘The self-attention-induced feedback loop and social facilitation,’ Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 17: 545–568.
- Carver, C. S. and Scheier, M. F. (1982). ‘Outcome expectancy, locus of attribution for expectancy, and self-directed attention as determinants of evaluations and performance,’ Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 18: 184–200.
- Church, R. (1962). ‘The effects of competition on reaction time and palmar skin conductance,’ Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 65: 32–40.
- Cottrell, N. B., Rittle, R. H. and Wack, D. L. (1967). ‘The presence of an audience and list type (competitional or non-competitional) as joint determiners of performance in paired associate learning,’ Journal of Personality, 35: 425–434.
- Cottrell, N. B., Wack, D. L., Sekerak, G. J. and Rittle, R. H. (1968). ‘Social facilitation of dominant responses by the presence of an audience and the mere presence of others,’ Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 9: 245–250.
- Deci, E. L. and Porac, J. (1978). ‘ Cognitive evaluation theory and the study of human motivation.’ In: M. R. Lepper and D. Greene (Eds) The Hidden Costs of Reward, Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ.
- Deese, J., Lazarus, R. S. and Keenan, J. (1953). ‘Anxiety, anxiety reduction, and stress in learning,’ Journal of Experimental Psychology, 46: 55–60.
- Deffenbacher, J. L. (1978). ‘Worry, emotionally and task-generated interference in test anxlety: An empirical test of attentional theory,’ Journal of Educational Psychology, 70: 248–254.
- Doctor, R. M. and Altman, F. (1969). ‘Worry and emotionality as components of test anxiety: Replication and further data,’ Psychological Reports, 24: 563–568.
- Dunn, J. A. (1968). ‘Anxiety, stress, and the performance of complex intellectual tasks: A new look at an old question,’ Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 32: 669–673.
- Duval, S. and Wicklund, R. A. (1972). A Theory Of Objective Self Awareness, Academic Press, New York.
- Easterbrook, J. A. (1959). ‘The effect of emotion on cue utilization and the organization of behavior,’ Psychological Review, 66: 183–201.
- Eysenck, M. W. (1979). ‘Anxiety, learning, and memory: A reconceptualization,’ Journal of Research in Personality, 13: 363–385.
- Fenigstein, A., Scheier, M. F. and Buss, A. H. (1975). ‘Public and private self-consciousness: Assessment and theory,’ Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 43: 522–527.
- Forgas, J. P., Brennan, G., Howe, S., Kane, J. F. and Sweet, S. (1980). ‘Audience effects on squash players' performance,’ Journal of Social Psychology, 111: 41–47.
- Ganzer, V. J. (1968). ‘Effects of audience presence and test anxiety on learning and retention in a serial learning situation,’ Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 8: 194–199.
- Gastorf, J. W., Suls, J. and Sanders, G. S. (1980). ‘Type A coronary-prone behavior pattern and social facilitation.’ Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 38: 773–780.
- Geen, R. G. (1973). ‘Effects of being observed on short- and long-term recall,’ Journal of Experimental Psychology, 100: 395–398.
- Geen, R. G. (1974). ‘Effects of evaluation apprehension on memory over intervals of varying length,’ Journal of Experimental Psychology, 102: 908–910.
- Geen, R. G. (1980). ‘ The effects of being observed on performance.’ In: P. B. Paulus (Ed.) Psychology of Group Influence, Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ.
- Geen, R. G. and Gange, J. J. (1977). ‘Drive theory of social facilitation: 12 years of theory and research,’ Psychological Bulletin, 84: 1267–1288.
- Glucksberg, S. (1962). ‘The influence of strength of drive on functional fixedness and perceptual recognition,’ Journal of Experimental Psychology, 63: 36–41.
- Guerin, B. (1983). ‘Social facilitation and social monitoring: A test of three models,’ British Journal of Social Psychology, 22: 203–214.
- Guerin, B. and Innes, J. M. (1982). ‘Social Facilitation and social monitoring: A new look at Zajonc's mere presence hypothesis,’ British Journal of Social Psychology, 21: 7–18.
- Haddad, N. F., McCullers, J. C. and Moran, J. D. (1976). ‘Satiation and the detrimental effects of material rewards,’ Child Development, 47: 547–550.
- Henchy, T. and Glass, D. (1968). ‘Evaluation apprehension and the social facilitation of domnant and subordinate responses,’ Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 10: 446–454.
- Hull, J. G. and Levy, A. S. (1979). ‘The organizational functions of the self: An alternative to the Duval and Wicklund model of self-awareness,’ Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 37: 756–768.
- Innes, J. M. and Sambrooks, J. E. (1969). ‘Paired-associate learning as influenced by birth order and the presence of others’, Psychonomic Science, 16: 109–110.
- Innes, J. M. and Young, R. F. (1975). ‘The effect of presence of an audience, evaluation apprehension, and objective self-awareness on learning,’ Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 11: 35–42.
- Jenkins, C. D., Rosenman, R. H. and Friedman, M. (1967). ‘Development of an objective psychological test for the determination of the coronary-prone behavior pattern in employed men.’ Journal of Chronic Diseases, 20: 371–379.
- Jones, E. E. and Berglas, S. C. (1978). ‘Control of attributions about the self through self-handicapped strategies: The appeal of alcohol and the role of under achievement,’ Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 4: 200–206.
- Kahneman, D. (1973). Attention and Effort, Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ.
- Karniol, R. and Ross, M. (1977). ‘The effects of performance relevant and performance irrelevant rewards on children's intrinsic motivation,’ Child Development, 48: 482–487.
- Katchmar, L. T., Ross, S. and Andrews, T. G. (1958). ‘Effects of stress and anxiety on performance of a complex verbal-coding task,’ Journal of Experimental Psychology, 55: 559–564.
- Kimble, G. and Perlmuter, L. (1970). ‘The problem of volition,’ Psychological Review, 77: 361–384.
- Lacey, J. (1967). ‘ Semantic response patterning and stress: Some revisions of activation theory.’ In: M. H. Appley and R. Trumbell (Eds) Psychological Stress: Issues in Research, Appleton- Century-Crofts, New York.
- Laughlin, P. R. and Jaccard, J. J. (1975). ‘Social facilitation and observational learning of individual and cooperative pairs,’ Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 32: 873–879.
- Lepper, M. R. and Greene, D. (1978). ‘ Overjustification research and beyond.’ In: M. R. Lepper and D. Greene (Eds) The Hidden Costs of Reword, Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ.
- Liebling, B. A. and Shaver, P. (1973). ‘Evaluation, self-awareness, and task performance,’ Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 9: 297–306.
- Martens, R. (1969a). ‘Effect of an audience on learning and performance of a complex motor skill,’ Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 12: 252–260.
- Martens, R. (1969b). ‘Palmar sweating and the presence of an audience,’ Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 5: 371–314.
- Martens, R. and Landers, D. M. (1972). ‘Evaluation potential as a determinant of coaction effects,’ Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 8: 347–359.
- McFarlin, D. B., Baumeister, R. F. and Blascovich, J. (1984). ‘On knowing when to quit: Task failure, self-esteem, advice, and nonproductive persistence,’ Journal of Personality,. 52: 138–155.
- McGraw, K. O. and McCullers, J. C. (1974). ‘The distracting effects of material reward: An alternate explanation for the superior performance of rewarded groups in probability learning,’ Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 18: 149–158.
- McGraw, K. O. and McCullers, J. C. (1976). ‘ Monetary reward and water-jar task performance: Evidence of a detrimental effect of reward on problem solving’. Paper presented at Southeastern Psychological Association, New Orleans. Cited in: M. R. Lepper and D. Greene (Eds) (1978). The Hidden Costs of Reward, Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ.
- McNamara, H. J. and Fisch, R. I. (1964). ‘Effect of high and low motivation on two aspects of attention,’ Perceptual and Motor Skills, 19: 571–578.
- Meichenbaum, D. (1972). ‘Cognitive modification of test anxious college students,’ Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 39: 370–380.
- Miller, L. B. and Estes, B. W. (1961). ‘Monetary reward and motivation in discrimination learning,’ Journal of Experimental Psychology, 61: 501–504.
- Morris, L. W. and Liebert, R. M. (1969). ‘Effects of anxiety on timed and untimed intelligence tests,’ Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 33: 240–244.
- Nicholson, W. M. (1958). ‘The influence of anxiety upon learning: Interference or drive increments?’ Journal of Personality, 26: 303–319.
- Paivo, A. (1965). ‘ Personality and audience influence.’ In: B. Maher (Ed.), Progress in Experimental Personality Research, Vol. 2, Academic Press, New York.
- Paul, G. L. and Eriksen, C. W. (1964). ‘Effects of test anxiety on “real-life” examinations,’ Journal of Personality, 32: 480–494.
- Paulus, P. B., Annis, A. B. and Risner, H. T. (1978). ‘An analysis of the mirror-induced objective self-awareness effect,’ Bulletin of the Psychonomic Society, 12: 8–10.
- Paulus, P. B., Shannon, V. C., Wilson, D. L. and Boone, T. D. (1972). ‘The effects of operator presence on gymnastics performance in a field situation,’ Psychonomic Science, 29: 88–90.
- Perez, R. C. (1973). ‘The effect of experimentally-induced failure, self-esteem, and sex on cognitive differentiation,’ Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 81: 74–79.
- Quarter, J. and Marcus, A. (1971). ‘Drive level and audience effect: A test of Zajonc's theory,’ Journal of Social Psychology, 83: 99–105.
- Rajecki, D. W., Ickes, W., Corcoran, C. and Lenerz, K. (1977). ‘Social facilitation of human performance: Mere presence effects,’ Journal of Social Psychology, 102: 297–310.
- Rhodewalt, F. and Davison, J. (1983). ‘Reactance and the coronary-prone behavior pattern: The role of self-attribution in responses to reduced behavioral freedom,’ Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 44: 220–228.
- Rosenfield, D., Folger, R. and Adelman, H. F. (1980). ‘When rewards reflect competence: A qualification of the overjustification effect,’ Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 39: 368–376.
- Sanders, G. S. (1981). ‘Driven by distraction: An integrative review of social facilitation theory and research,’ Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 17: 227–251.
- Sanders, G. S. and Baron, R. S. (1975). ‘The motivating effects of distraction on task performance,’ Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 32: 956–963.
- Sanders, G. S., Baron, R. S. and Moore, D. L. (1978). ‘Distraction and social comparison as mediators of social facilitation effects,’ Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 14: 291–303.
- Sarason, I. G. (1956). ‘Effect of anxiety, motivational instructions and failure on senal learning,’ Journal of Experimental Psychology, 51: 253–260.
- Sarason, I. G. (1959). ‘Relationships of measures of anxiety and experimental instructions to word association test performance,’ Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 59: 37–42.
- Sarason, I. G. (1961). ‘The effects anxiety and threat on the solution of a difficult task,’ Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 62: 165–168.
- Sarason, I. G. (1972). ‘ Experimental approaches to tests anxiety: Attention and the uses of information.’ In: C. D. Spielberger (Ed.) Anxiety: Current Trends in Theory and Research, Vol. 2, Academic Press, New York.
10.1016/B978-0-12-657402-9.50010-7 Google Scholar
- Sarason, I. G. and Palola, E. G. (1960). ‘The relationship of test and general anxiety, difficulty of task, and experimental instructions to performance,’ Journal of Experimental Psychology, 59: 185–191.
- Sasfy, J. and Okun, M. (1974). ‘Form of evaluation and audience expertness as joint determinants of audience effects,’ Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 10: 461–467.
- Schalon, C. L. (1968). ‘Effect of self-esteem upon performance following failure stress,’ Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 32: 497.
- Scheier, M. S., Fenigstein, A. and Buss, A. H. (1974). ‘Self-awareness and physical aggression,’ Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 10: 264–273.
- Schlenker, B. R. (1980). Impression Management: The Self-Concept, Social Identity, and Interpersonal Relations, Brooks/Cole, Monterey, CA.
- Schlenker, B. R. and Leary, M. R. (1982). ‘Social anxiety and self-presentation: A conceptualization and model,’ Psychological Bulletin, 92: 641–669.
- Seta, J. J. (1982). ‘The impact of comparison processes on coactors' task performance,’ Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 42: 281–291.
- Seta, J. J. and Seta, C. E. (1983). ‘ The impact of personal equity processes on performance in a group setting.’ In: P. B. Paulus (Ed.) Basic Group Processes, Springer-Verlag, New York, pp. 121–147.
10.1007/978-1-4612-5578-9_6 Google Scholar
- Seta, J. J. and Hassan, R. K. (1980). ‘Awareness of prior success or failure: A critical factor in task performance,’ Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 39: 70–76.
- Seta, J. J., Paulus, P. B. and Risner, H. T. (1977). ‘The effects of group composition and evaluation on task performance,’ Bulletin of the Psychonomic Society, 9: 115–117.
- Shaw, M. (1958). ‘Some motivational factors in cooperation and competition,’ Journal of Personality, 26: 155–169.
- Shrauger, J. S. and Sorman, P. B. (1977). ‘Self-evaluations, initial success and failure, and improvement as detemnants of persistence,’ Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 45: 784–795.
- Silverman, I. (1964). ‘Self-esteem and differential responsiveness to success and failure,’ Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 69: 115–119.
- Spence, J. T. and Spence, K. W. (1966). ‘ The motivational components of manifest anxiety: Drive and drive stimuli.’ In: C. D. Spielberger (Ed.) Anxiety and Behavior, Academic Press, New York.
10.1016/B978-1-4832-3131-0.50017-2 Google Scholar
- Spielberger, C. D. and Smith, L. H. (1966). ‘Anxiety (drive), stress, and serial-position effects in serial-verbal learning,’ Journal of Experimental Psychology, 72: 589–595.
- Taylor, J. (1958). ‘The effects of anxiety level and psychological stress on verbal learning,’ Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 57: 55–60.
- Tecce, J. J. and Happ, S. (1964). ‘Effects of shock-arousal on a card-sorting test of color-word interference,’ Perceptual and Motor Skills, 19: 905–906.
- Terrell, G. Jr., Durkin, K. and Wiesley, M. (1959). ‘Social class and the nature of the incentive in discrimination learning,’ Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 59: 270–272.
- Tice, D. M., Buder, J. and Baumeister, R. F. (1985). ‘Development of self-consciousness: At what age does audience pressure disrupt performance?’ Adolescence, in press.
- Trope, Y. (1982). ‘Self-assessment and task performance,’ Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 18: 201–215.
- Vogel, W., Raymond, S. and Lazarus, R. S. (1959). ‘Intrinsic motivation and psychological stress,’ Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 58: 225–233.
- Weiner, B. (1966). ‘Role of success and failure in the learning of easy and complex tasks,’ Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 3: 339–344.
- Weiss, R. F. and Miller, F. G. (1971). ‘The drive theory of social facilitation,’ Psychological Review, 78: 44–57.
- Wicklund, R. A. (1979). ‘The influence of self-awareness on human behavior,’ American Scientist, 67: 187–193.
- Wicklund, R. A. and Duval, S. (1971). ‘Opinion change and performance facilitation as a result of objective self-awareness,’ Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 7: 319–342.
- Wine, J. (1971). ‘Test anxiety and direction of attention,’ Psychological Bulletin, 76: 92–104.
- Yerkes, R. M. and Dodson, J. D. (1908). ‘The relationship of strength of stimulus to rapidity of habit-formation,’ Journal of Comparative Neurology of Psychology, 18: 459–482.
- Zajonc, R. B. (1965). ‘Social facilitation,’ Science, 149: 269–274.
- Zajonc, R. B. (1980). Compresence. In: P. B. Paulus (Ed.) Psychology of Group Influence, Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ.
- Zimring, F. M. (1983). ‘Attending to feelings and cognitive performance,’ Journal of Research in Personality, 17: 288–299.