Abstract
Brands work more on the perceptual identity than the real identity as it spotlights the position of the brands in customers’ minds. Positioning is an unbeatable weapon in marketer’s arsenal for establishing perceptual identity. After deciding the positioning strategy, companies spend millions on marketing communications without considering that whether this huge budget has helped in achieving the desired position in customers’ perceptions or not. So, measuring the effectiveness of brand positioning strategies is more important to achieve the coherence among the efforts than merely designing and communicating these strategies. The present study aims to examine this coherence by measuring the effectiveness of the brand positioning strategies of three Indian car brands. For this, the desired, communicated and perceived positioning strategies are taken. The triangulation research methodology (secondary data of these car brands, content analysis of the advertisements and survey research of consumers’ opinions) is adopted. Findings of this study reveal that car brands go for multiple positioning strategies rather than single positioning strategy. It is also observed that full congruence is not visible in any car brand that signifies that the positioning efforts are not clearly communicated through advertisements. This study has relevance in marketing as it may serve as a basis for assessing the operationalization of positioning strategies in general. This study also makes the managers available with the description of basic building blocks for the implementation of positioning strategies in automobile industry.
Similar content being viewed by others
Data availability statement
All data generated or analysed during this study are included in this published article.
References
Websites
Aaker DA, Joachimsthaler E (2000) The brand relationship spectrum: the key to the brand architecture challenge. Calif Manage Rev 42(4):8–23
Aaker DA, Shansby J (1982) Positioning your product. Bus Horiz 25:56–62
Adiguzel S (2020) Market and brand positioning and sustainability strategies in international marketing. Int J Sci Res Manag 8(9):9–24
Alden DL, Steenkamp JBEM, Batra R (1999) Brand positioning through advertising in Asia, North America, and Europe: the role of global consumer culture. J Mark 63:75–87
Arnott DC (1992) Bases of financial services positioning in the personal pension, life assurance and personal equity plan sectors. Ph.D. Thesis, Manchester Business School, University of Manchester, UK
Azmat M, Lakhani AS (2015) Impact of brand positioning strategies in consumer standpoint (A consumer’s perception). J Mark Consum Res 14:109–116
Batra R, Myers JG, Aaker DA (1996) Advertising management. Prentice-Hall, Upper Saddle River
Berry LL (1982) Retail positioning strategies for the 1980’s. Bus Horiz 25(6):45–50
Blankson C (2004) Positioning strategies and incidence of congruence of two UK store card brands. J Prod Brand Manage 13(5):315–328
Blankson C, Kalafatis SP (2004) The development and validation of a scale measuring consumer/customer-derived generic typology of positioning strategies. J Mark Manag 20:5–43
Blankson C, Kalafatis SP (2007) Positioning strategies of international and multicultural-oriented service brands. J Serv Mark 21(6):435–450
Blankson C, Kalafatis SP, Coffie S, Tsogas MH (2014) Comparison of media types and congruence in positioning of service brands. J Prod Brand Manag 23(3):162–179
Burton J, Easingwood CJ (2006) A positioning typology of consumers’ perceptions of the benefits offered by successful service brands. J Retail Consum Serv 13(5):301–316
Chew C (2005) Strategic marketing planning and positioning in voluntary nonprofit organizations: Empirical findings and implications for British charitable organizations. Aston Business School research paper. Aston University, Birmingham
Childers TL, Pride WM, Ferrell OC (1980) A reassessment of the effects of appeals on response to mail surveys. J Mark Res 17:365–370
Chowdhury PP (2013) Key strategies and issues of positioning: a review of past studies. Am Acad Schol Res J 5(1):55–66
Coffie S (2018) Positioning strategies for branding services in an emerging economy. J Strateg Mark 28(4):1–15
Coffie S, Darmoe J (2016) Branding in the base of the pyramid: Bases for country and organisations in Ghana. In: Riley FD, Singh J, Blankson C (eds) The Routledge companion to contemporary brand management. Routledge, Abingdon, pp 378–390
Crawford CM (1985) A new positioning typology. J Prod Innov Manag 2(4):243–253
de Chernatony L (1994) Developing a more effective brand positioning. J Brand Manag 1(6):373–379
de Chernatony L, Cottam S (2009) Interacting contributions of different departments to brand success. J Bus Res 62(3):297–304
Dibb S, Simkin L (1993) The strength of branding and positioning in services. Int J Serv Ind Manag 4(1):25–35
DiMingo E (1988) The fine art of positioning. J Bus Strateg 9(2):34–38
Diwan SP, Bodla BS (2011) Development of empirically based customer-derived positioning typology in automobile industry. J Strateg Mark 19(6):531–550
Dovel GP (1990) Stake it out: positioning success, step by step. Bus Mark (July) 5:43–51
Doyle P (1994) Marketing management and strategy, as quoted in Percy, L., Rossiter, J.R. and Elliott, R. 2001 Positioning Strategy. Strateg Advert Manag:107–127
Eckstein H (1998) Congruence theory explained. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, Lanham
Falkala AM, Keranen F (2014) Brand positioning strategies for industrial firms providing customer solutions. J Bus Ind Mark 29(3):253–264
Fay M, Currier G (1994) The rise and fall of the copy point: the changing information content of print advertisements from 1953–1988. Eur J Mark 28(10):10–31
Fayvishenko D (2018) Formation of brand positioning strategy. Balt J Econ Stud 4(2):245–248
Fry LW, Smith DA (1987) Congruence, contingency and theory building. Acad Manag Rev 12(1):117–132
Fuchs C, Diamantopoulos A (2010) Evaluating the effectiveness of brand positioning strategies from a consumer perspective. Eur J Mark 44(11/12):173–178
Fuchs C, Diamantopoulos A (2012) Customer perceived positioning effectiveness: conceptualization, operationalization and implications for new product managers. J Prod Innov Manag 29(2):229–244
Ganesh J, Oakenfull G (1999) International product positioning: an illustration using perceptual mapping techniques. J Glob Mark 13(2):85–110
Griffiths-Hemans J, Grover R (2006) Setting the stage for creative new products: investigating the idea fruition process. J Acad Mark Sci 34(1):27–39
Gwin and Gwin (2003) Product attributes model: a tool for evaluating brand positioning. J Mark Theory Pract 11(2):30–42
Hartmann P, Ibanaz V, Sainz F (2005) Green branding effects on attitude: functional versus emotional positioning strategies. Mark Intell Plan 23(1):9–29
Hawes JM, Crittender VJ, Crittender WF (1987) The effect of personalisation, source and offer on mail survey response rate and speed. ABER 18(2):54–63
Hooley GJ, Saunders J (1993) Competitive positioning: the key to market success. Prentice-Hall, London
Hooley GJ, Broderick A, Moller K (1998) Competitive positioning and the resource-based view of the firm. J Strateg Mark 6(2):97–115
Hooley GJ, Saunders J, Piercy NF (2004) Marketing strategy and competitive positioning, 3rd edn. FT Prentice Hall, London
Hooley GJ, Piercy NF, Nicoulaud B (2012) Marketing strategy and competitive positioning, 6th edn. Pearson Education Limited, Harlow
Hornik J (1982) Impact of pre-call request form and gender interaction on response to a mail survey. J Mark Res 19:144–151
Houston FS, Hanieski JF (1976) Pooled marketing and positioning. J Advert 5(1):38–39
Huo E (2018) The importance of brand positioning in marketing strategy. Mod Mark 12:59
Hsu TS, Feldt LS (1969) The effect of limitations on the number of criterion scores on the significance level of the F-test. Am Educ Res J 6:515–527
Janiszewska K, Insch A (2012) The strategic importance of brand positioning in the place brand concept: elements, structure and application capabilities. J Int Stud 5(1):9–19
Johar JS, Sirgy MJ (1989) Positioning models in marketing: toward a normative-integrated model. J Bus Psychol 3(4):475–485
Kalafatis SP, Tsogas M, Blankson C (2000) Positioning strategies in business markets. J Bus Ind Mark 15(2):416–437
Keller KL (2003) Strategic brand management, 2nd edn. Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs
Keller KL, Lehmann DR (2006) Brands and branding: research findings and future priorities. Mark Sci 25(6):740–759
Kennedy PF, McGarvey MG (2008) Animal-companion depictions in women’s magazine advertising. J Bus Res 61(5):424–430
Knox S (2004) Positioning and branding your organization. J Prod Brand Manag 13(2):105–115
Kotler P (2003) Marketing management, 11th edn. Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs
Kotler P, Andreasen A (1991) Strategic marketing for nonprofit organizations, as quoted in Hibbert, S. A. 1995. The market positioning of British medical charities. Eur J Mark 29(10):6–26
Kotler P, Keller KL, Ang SH, Tan CT, Leong SM (2018) Marketing management: an Asian perspective. Pearson, London
Lautman MR (1993) The abcs of positioning. Mark Res 5(1):12–18
Lee JL, Kim Y, Won J (2018) Sports brand positioning: Positioning congruence and consumer perceptions towards brands. Int J Sports Mark Spons 19(4):450–471
Malhotra NK, Dash S (2009) Marketing research: an applied orientation. Pearson Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River
Myers MB (2004) Implications of pricing strategy-venture strategy congruence: an application using optimal models in an international context. J Bus Res 57(6):591–600
Nadler DA, Tushman ML (1980) A congruence model for organizational assessment. In: Lawler EE, Nadler DA, Cammann CC (eds) Organizational assessment. Wiley, New York
Park CW, Jaworski BJ, MacLnnis DJ (1986) Strategic brand concept-Image management. J Mark 50:135–145
Piercy NF (2005) Market-Led strategic change: a guide to transforming the process of going to market. Elsevier Butterworth Heinemann, London
Porter ME (1996) What is strategy? Harvard Bus Rev. November/December:61–78
Ray ML (1992) Advertising and communication management. Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliff
Ries A, Trout J (1986) Positioning: the battle for your mind. McGraw-Hill, New York
Rigger W (1995) Positioning in theory and practice: Towards a research agenda. In: 24th EMAC conference proceedings, 1 ESSEC, France. May 16–19, pp 991–1009
Rossiter JR, Percy L (1997) Advertising communications and promotion management, 2nd edn. The McGraw-Hill Companies, New York
Saqib N (2020) Positioning—a literature review. PSU Res Rev. https://doi.org/10.1108/PRR-06-2019-0016
Schiffman LG, Kanuk LL (2007) Consumer behavior, 9th edn. Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River
Seggev E (1982) Testing persuasion by strategic positioning. J Advert Res 22(1):37–42
Sengupta S (1999) Brand positioning strategies for competitive advantage. Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, New Delhi
Shan W (2018) Brand positioning error and countermeasures. Cooper Econ Technol 19:92–94
Smith RE, Lusch RF (1976) How advertising can position a brand. J Advert Res 16(1):37–43
Stukalina Y (2019) Strategic brand positioning in a modern academia. In: The European proceedings of social & behavioural sciences, pp 21–29
Trout J (2012) Positioning myopia. Mark News Mag Mar 15:34
Urde M, Koch C (2014) Market and brand-oriented schools of positioning. J Prod Brand Manag 23(7):478–490
Dictionary W (2004) The Merriam Webster dictionary. New ed. Merriam-Webster, Springfield
Young GJ, Meterko MM, Mohr D, Shwartz M, Lin H (2009) Congruence in the assessment of service quality between employees and customers: a study of a public health care delivery system. J Bus Res 22(11):257–268
Zineldin M (1996) Bank strategic positioning and some determinants of bank selection. Int J Bank Mark 14(6):12–22
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflicts of interest
The author declares none.
Supplementary Information
Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Diwan, S.P., Bodla, B.S. Measuring brand positioning effectiveness of car brands using triangular approach. SN Bus Econ 2, 39 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1007/s43546-022-00211-8
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s43546-022-00211-8