Does a critical mass exist? A comparative analysis of women's legislative representation since 1950
Donley T. Studlar
Department of Political Science, West Virginia University, USA
Search for more papers by this authorIan McAllister
Research School of Social Sciences, Australian National University, Australia
Search for more papers by this authorDonley T. Studlar
Department of Political Science, West Virginia University, USA
Search for more papers by this authorIan McAllister
Research School of Social Sciences, Australian National University, Australia
Search for more papers by this authorAbstract
Abstract. It has often been argued theoretically that a ‘critical mass,’ ranging from 10 to 35 per cent women, is needed before major changes in legislative institutions, behaviour, policy priorities and policy voting occurs. This paper examines one of the less-explored dimensions of the critical mass concept: Is there a process by which women reaching a critical mass of the legislature accelerates the election of further women? Using data from the Inter-Parliamentary Union and International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance, we analyze this question for 20 industrialized democracies over a period of half a century, longer than any other relevant research. Descriptive results indicate that gains in women's representation have been incremental rather than a critical mass accelerating the election of women to legislatures. In a multivariate analysis of the percentage of women in the lower house of the legislature, the critical mass is tested against established explanations of women's gains in seats: institutional rules, egalitarian political culture, political parties and economic development. Of two measures of the critical mass theory, one has no impact and the second results in only a small increase in women's gains. Far from being clearly demonstrated, critical mass theories need empirical testing.
Referenc
- Berkman, M.B. & O'Connor, R.E. (1994). Do women legislators matter? Female legislators and state abortion policy. in M. Goggin (ed.) , Understanding the new politics of abortion. Newbury Park , CA : Sage.
- Bratton, K.A. (2001). The fifteen percent threshold: Obstacle or illusion? Unpublished paper, Louisiana State University.
- Bratton, K.A. & Ray, L.P. (2001). Descriptive representation and policy outcomes: Evidence from municipal day care coverage. American Journal of Political Science 45.
- Bystydzienski, J.M. (1995). Women in electoral politics: Lessons from Norway. Westport , CT : Praeger.
- Broughton, S. & Palmieri, S. (1999).Gendered contributions to parliamentary debates: The case of euthanasia. Australian Journal of Political Science 34: 29–45.
- Caul, M.L. (2001). Political parties and the adoption of candidate gender quotas: A cross-national analysis. Journal of Politics 63: (forthcoming.
- Clark, J. (1998). Women at the national level: An update on roll call voting behavior. in S. Thomas & C. Wilcox (eds) , Women and elective office. New York : Oxford University Press.
- Considine, M. & Deutchman, I.E. (1996).Instituting gender: State legislators in Australia and the United States. Women and Politics 16:(4) 1–19.
- Costain, A.N. (1992). Inviting women's rebellion: A political process model of the women's movement. Baltimore , MD : Johns Hopkins Press.
- Dahlerup, D. (1988).From a small to large minority: Women in Scandinavian politics. Scandinavian Political Studies 11: 275–297.
10.1111/j.1467-9477.1988.tb00372.x Google Scholar
- Darcy, R., Welch, S. & Clark, J. (1994). Women, elections and representation. 2nd edn. Lincoln , NB : University of Nebraska Press.
- Davis, R.H. (1996). Culture, contagion or critical mass: The political recruitment of women in Denmark, Germany, Norway, and the United Kingdom. Paper presented at the American Political Science Association conference, San Francisco , CA .
- Davis, R.H. (1997). Women and power in parliamentary democracies. Lincoln , NB : University of Nebraska Press.
- Dolan, K. et. al. (1998). Are all women state legislators alike? in S. Thomas & C. Wilcox (eds) , Women and elective office. New York : Oxford University Press.
- Gelb, J. (1989). Feminism and politics. Berkeley , CA : University of California Press.
- Grey, S. (2001). Does size matter? Critical mass and New Zealand's women MPs. Paper presented at the Political Studies Association conference, Manchester , April 10–12.
- Htun, M.N. & Jones, M.P. (2001). Engendering the right to participate in decisionmaking: Electoral quotas and women's leadership in Latin America. in N. Craske & M. Molyneux (eds) , Gender, rights and justice in Latin America. New York : Macmillan.
- International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance. (1997a). Voter turnout from 1945 to 1997. Stockholm : International IDEA.
- International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance. (1997b). The International IDEA handbook of electoral system design. Stockholm : International IDEA.
- Inter-Parliamentary Union (IPU). (1997). Democracy still in the making. Series Reports and Documents, No. 28. Geneva : Inter-Parliamentary Union.
- Inter-Parliamentary Union (IPU). (2000). Women in national parliaments. http://www.ipu.org
- Jacquette, J.S. (1997).Women in power: From tokenism to critical mass. Foreign Policy 108: 23–37.
- Kanter, R.M. (1977a). Men and women of the corporation. New York : Basic Books.
- Kanter, R.M. (1977b).Some effects of proportions on group life: Skewed sex ratios and responses to token women. American Journal of Sociology 82: 965–990.
- Kathlene, L. (1994).Power and influence in state legislative policymaking: The interaction of gender and position in committee hearing debates. American Political Science Review 88: 560–576.
- Kathlene, L. (1998). In a different voice: Women and the policy process. in S. Thomas & C. Wilcox (eds) , Women and elective office. New York : Oxford University Press.
- Kittilson, M.C. (2001). Change from the inside out: Women in the party leadership in Western Europe, 1975–1997. Paper presented at Western Political Science Association conference, Las Vegas , NV .
- Lovenduski, J. (1997).Gender politics: A breakthrough for women Parliamentary Affairs 50: 708–719.
- McAllister, I. & Studlar, D.T. (1992).Gender and representation among legislative candidates in Australia. Comparative Political Studies 25: 388–411.
- Matland, R.E. (1993).Institutional variables affecting female representation in national legislatures: The case of Norway. Journal of Politics 55: 737–755.
- Matland, R.E. (1998).Women's representation in national legislatives: Developed and developing democracies. Legislative Studies Quarterly 23: 109–125.
- Malland, R.E. & Sludlar, D.T. (1996).The conlagion of women candidates in single-member district and proportional representation electoral systems: Canada and Norway. Journal of Politics 58: 707–733.
- Norrander, B. & Wilcox, C. (1998). The geography of gender power. in S. Thomas & C. Wilcox (eds) , Women and elective office. New York : Oxford University Press.
- Norris, P. (1987). Politics and sexual equality. Boulder , CO : Lynne Rienner.
- Norris, P. (1993). Conclusions: Comparing legislative recruitment. in J. Lovenduski & P. Norris (eds) , Gender and party politics. Beverly Hills , CA : Sage.
- Norris, P. (1996).Women politicians: Transforming Weslminster Parliamentary Affairs 49: 89–102.
- Norris, P. (2001). Women's power at the ballot box. in International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assislance, Voter turnout from 1945 to 2000: A global report on political participation. Stockholm : International IDEA.
- Norris, P. & Franklin, M. (1997).Social representation. European Journal of Political Research 32: 185–210.
- Norris, P. & Inglehart, R. (2000). Cultural barriers to women's leadership: A worldwide comparison. Paper presented at the International Political Science Association conference, Quebec City .
- Overby, L.M., Tatalovich, R. & Studlar, D.T. (1998).Party and free votes in Canada: Abortion in the House of Commons. Party Politics 4:(3) 481–492.
- Pattie, C., Johnston, R. & Stuart, M. (1998). Voting without party? in P. Cowley (ed.) , Conscience and parliament. London : Frank Cass.
- Randall, V. (1987). Women and politics. 2nd edn. Chicago , IL : University of Chicago Press.
10.1007/978-1-349-18836-9 Google Scholar
- Reingold, B. (1992).Concepts of representation among female and male state legislators. Legislative Studies Quarterly 27: 509–537.
- Reingold, B. (2000). Representing women: Sex, gender, and legislative behavior in Arizona and California. Chapel Hill , NC : University of North Carolina Press.
- Reynolds, A. (1999).Women in the legislatives and executives of the world. World Politics 51: 547–572.
- Rule, W. (1981).Why women don't run: The critical factors in women's legislative recruilmenl. Western Political Quarterly 34: 60–77.
- Rule, W. (1987).Electoral systems, contextual factors, and women's opportunities for election to parliament in twenly-three democracies. Western Political Quarterly 40: 477–498.
- St Germain, M.A. (1989).Does their difference make a difference? The impact of women on public policy in the Arizona legislature. Social Science Quarterly 70: 956–968.
- Sawer, M. (2002). Representation of women: Meaning and make-believe. Parliamentary Affairs 27: (forthcoming).
- Schroedel, J.R. & Amazumdar, N. (1998). Into the twenty-first century: Will women break the political glass ceiling? in S. Thomas & C. Wilcox (eds) , Women and elective office. New York : Oxford University Press.
- Siaroff, A. (2000).Women's representation in legislatures and cabinets in industrial democracies. International Political Science Review 21: 197–216.
- Skjeie, H. (1991).The rhetoric of difference: On women's inclusion into political elites. Politics and Society 19: 233–263.
- Staudt, K. (1996). Women in politics: Mexico in global perspective. in V.E. Rodriguez (ed.) , Women's participation in Mexican political life. Boulder , CO : Westview Press.
- Stevenson, L.S. (1999). Gender politics in the Mexican democratization process. in J. Dominquez & A. Poire (eds) , Towards Mexico's democratization. New York : Routledge.
- Studlar, D.T. & Matland, R.E. (1998).Gender and the electoral opportunity structure in the Canadian provinces. Political Research Quarterly 51: 117–140.
- Swers, M. (1999). Placing women's issues on the national agenda: An analysis of gender differences in women's issue bill sponsorship for the 103rd and 104th Congress. Paper presented at the American Political Science Association conference, Atlanta , GA .
- Thomas, S. (1989).Voting patterns in the California assembly: The role of gender. Women and Politics 9: 43–53.
- Thomas, S. (1991).The impact of women on state legislative policies. Journal of Politics 53: 958–976.
- Thomas, S. (1994). How women legislate. New York : Oxford University Press.
- Thomas, S. & Welch, S. (1991).The impact of gender on activities and priorities of state legislators. Western Political Quarterly 44: 445–456.
- S. Thomas & C. Wilcox (eds). (1998). Women and elective office. New York : Oxford University Press.
- Tremblay, M. & Pelletier, R. (2000).More feminists or more women? Descriptive and substantive representations of women in the 1997 Canadian federal election. International Political Science Review 21: 381–406.
- Trimble, L. (1998). Who's represented? Gender and diversity in the Alberta legislature. in M. Tremblay & C. Andrew (eds) , Women and political representation in Canada. Ottawa : University of Ottawa Press.
- Wangnerud, L. (2000).Testing the politics of presence: Women's representation in the Swedish Riksdag. Scandinavian Political Studies 23: 67–91.
- Wattenberg, M. (1998). The decline of party mobilization. Paper presented at the Elections, Parties, and Public Opinion conference of the Political Studies Association, Manchester , 11–13 September.
- Welch, S. (1985).Are women more liberal than men in the US Congress Legislative Studies Quarterly 10: 125–134.
- Weldon, S.L. (1999). Explaining cross-national variation in government responsiveness to violence against women: Women's movements and political institutions in democratic policymaking. Unpublished PhD thesis, University of Pittsburgh.
- Whicker, M. & Jewell, M. (1998). The feminization of leadership in state legislatures. in S. Thomas & C. Wilcox (eds) , Women and elective office. New York : Oxford University Press.
- Whip, R. (1991).Representing women: Australian female parliamentarians on the horns of a dilemma. Women and Politics 11: 1–22.
- Young, L. (1997). Fulfilling the mandate of difference: Women in the Canadian House of Commons. in J. Ascot & L. Trimble (eds.) , In the presence of women. Toronto : Harcourt Brace Canada.