Challenges to established parties: The effects of party system features on the electoral fortunes of anti-political-establishment parties
Corresponding Author
Arim Abedi
Department of Political Science, University of British Columbia, Canada
Correspondence to: Arim Abedi, Department of Political Science, University of British Columbia, C472-1866 Main Mall, Vancouver BC, Canada V6T 1Z1. [email protected]Search for more papers by this authorCorresponding Author
Arim Abedi
Department of Political Science, University of British Columbia, Canada
Correspondence to: Arim Abedi, Department of Political Science, University of British Columbia, C472-1866 Main Mall, Vancouver BC, Canada V6T 1Z1. [email protected]Search for more papers by this authorAbstract
Abstract. The rise of parties that challenge the political establishment has recently sparked the interest of political scientists. Scholars have identified several factors that lie behind the success of such anti-political-establishment parties. Most empirical studies, however, have concentrated their attention either on the importance of electoral system features or on the effects of socioeconomic conditions. This article focuses instead on the role that party system factors play in the electoral success of these parties. Using three data sets from studies conducted in three different time periods it tests two seemingly contradictory hypotheses. On the one hand, the claim that where the established parties have converged toward centrist positions and thus fail to present voters with an identity that is noticeably different from their established competitors, the electorate will be more susceptible to the markedly different policies put forward by anti-political-establishment parties. On the other hand, there is the argument that these parties profit more from increasing polarization and the subsequent enlargement of the political space than from a convergence toward the median. The results of the analyses show that anti-political-establishment parties generally profit from a close positioning of the establishment parties on the left-right scale. However, there is no consistent support for the notion that party system polarization by itself is associated with an increase in the support for parties that challenge the political establishment.
REFERENCES
- N.A. Addinall (ed.) 1995. French political parties: A documentary guide Cardiff : University of Wales Press.
- Andeweg, R.B. & Irwin, G.A. (1993). Dutch government and politics. Houndmills : Macmillan.
10.1007/978-1-349-22931-4 Google Scholar
- Andren, N. (1964). Government and politics in the Nordic countries: Denmark, Finland, Iceland, Norway, Sweden. Stockholm : Almqvist & Wiksell.
- Arnason, R. (1980). Political parties and defence: The case of Iceland 1945–1980. Kingston : Centre for International Relations, Queen's University.
- Arter, D. (1987). Politics and policy-making in Finland. New York : St Martin's Press.
- Arter, D. (1999). Scandinavian politics today. Manchester : Manchester University Press.
- Autengruber, P. (1997). Kleinparteien in Österreich 1945–1966. Innsbruck : Studien Verlag.
- D. Azoulay (ed.) 1999. Canadian political parties Toronto : Irwin Publishing.
- A.S. Banks & T.C. Muller (eds.) 1999. Political handbook of the world: 1999 Binghampton : CSA Publications.
- P. Barberis J. McHugh & M. Tyldesley (eds.) 2000. Encyclopedia of British and Irish political organizations: Parties, groups and movements of the twentieth century London : Pinter.
- Bartolini, S. & Mair, P. (1990). Identity, competition, and electoral availability: The stabilisation of European electorates 1885–1985. Cambridge : Cambridge University Press.
- Berglund, S. & Lindström, U. (1978). The Scandinavian party system(s):A comparative study. Lund : Studentlitteratur.
- Betz, H.-G. (1994). Radical right-wing populism in Western Europe. New York : St Martin's Press.
10.1007/978-1-349-23547-6 Google Scholar
- H.-G. Betz & S. Immerfall (eds.) (1998). The new politics of the right: Neo-populist parties and movements in established democracies. New York : St Martin's Press.
- Beyme, K.V. (1985). Political Parties In Western Democracies. E. Martin (trans.). Aldershot : Gower Publishing.
- Bomberg, E. (1998). Green parties and politics in the European Union. London : Routledge.
- Braunthal, G. (1996). Parties and politics in modern Germany. Boulder : Westview Press.
- D. Broughton & M. Donovan (eds.) 1999. Changing party systems in Western Europe London : Pinter.
- Budge, I. & Robertson, D. (1987). Do parties differ, and how? Comparative discriminant and factor analyses. In I. Budge D. Robertson & D. Hearl (eds.), Ideology, strategy and party change: Spatial analyses of post-war election programmes in 19 democracies. Cambridge : Cambridge University Press(pp. 387–416).
10.1017/CBO9780511558771 Google Scholar
- Campbell, C. & Christian, W. (1996). Parties, leaders, and ideologies in Canada. Toronto : McGraw-Hill Ryerson.
- D.O. Carrigan (ed.) 1968. Canadian party platforms 1867–1968 Toronto : Copp Clark Publishing.
- Carty, R.K. (1981). Party and parish pump: Electoral politics in Ireland. Waterloo : Wilfried Laurier Press.
- Carty, R.K., Cross, W. & Young, L. (2000). Rebuilding Canadian party politics. Vancouver : University of British Columbia Press.
- Castles, EG. & Mair, P. (1984). Left-right political scales: Some ‘expert’ judgements. European Journal of Political Research 12: 73–88.
- A. Cole (ed.) 1990. French political parties in transition Aldershot : Dartmouth Publishing.
- Crepaz, M.M.L. (1990). The impact of party polarization and postmaterialism on voter turnout: A comparative study of 16 industrial democracies. European Journal of Political Research 18: 183–205.
- Daalder, H. & Irwin, G.A. (1989). Politics in the Netherlands: How much change?. London : Frank Cass.
- H. Daalder & P. Mair (eds) 1983. Western European party systems: Continuity and change London : Sage.
- Dachs, H. et. al. (1997). Handbuch des Politischen Systems Österreichs: Die Zweite Republik. 3rd edn. Vienna : Manzsche Verlags- und Universitatsbuchhandlung.
- R.J. Dalton & M. Kuechler (eds.) 1990. Challenging the political order: New social and political movements in Western democracies Oxford : Oxford University Press.
- A.J. Day & H.W. Degenhardt (eds) (1984). Political parties of the world. 2nd edn. Burnt Mill : Longman.
- Declair, E.G. (1999). Politics on the fringe: The people, policies and organization of the French National Front. Durham : Duke University Press.
- G.E. Delury (ed.) (1983). World encyclopedia of political systems and parties, Vols. 1 & 2. New York : Facts on File Publications.
- L. Winter & H. Tursan (eds.) 1998. Regionalist parties in Western Europe London : Routledge.
10.4324/9780203169391 Google Scholar
- Dodd, L.C. (1976). Coalitions in parliamentary government. Princeton : Princeton University Press.
- Downs, A. (1957). An economic theory of democracy. New York : HarperCollins.
- Duverger, M. (1959). Political parties: Their organization and activity in the modern state. 2nd rev. edn. B. North & R. North (trans.). London : Methuen & Co.
- R. East (ed.) (1990). Communist and Marxist parties of the world. 2nd edn. Chicago : St James Press.
- G.E. Edwards (ed.) 1998. German political parties: A documentary guide Cardiff : University of Wales Press.
- Elder, N, Thomas, A.H. & Arter, D. (1988). The consensual democracies? The government and politics of the Scandinavian states. Rev. edn. Oxford : Basil Blackwell.
- Elgie, R. & Griggs, S. (2000). French politics: Debates and controversies. London : Routledge.
- Farneti, P. (1985). The Italian party system (1945–1980). London : Pinter.
- Fisher, J. (1996). British political parties. London : Prentice Hall.
10.1007/978-1-349-15024-3 Google Scholar
- Fitzmaurice, J. (1981). Politics in Denmark. New York : St Martin's Press.
- Fitzmaurice, J. (1996). The politics of Belgium: A unique federalism. London : Hurst & Co.
- Frears, J. (1991). Parties and voters in France. New York : St Martin's Press.
- Gallagher, M. (1985). Political parties in the Republic of Ireland. Manchester : Manchester University Press.
- Garner, R. & Kelly, R. (1998). British political parties today. 2nd edn. Manchester : Manchester University Press.
- Gladish, K. (1991). Governing from the centre: Politics and policy-making in the Netherlands. London : Hurst & Co.
- S. Gundle & S. Parker (eds) 1996. The new Italian Republic: From the fall of the Berlin Wall to Berlusoni London : Routledge.
- Hadenius, S. (1997). Swedish politics during the 20th century: Conflict and consensus. 4th edn. Stockholm : Svenska Institutet.
- Hainsworth, P. (1992a). Introduction: The cutting edge: The extreme right in post-war Western Europe and the USA. In P. Hainsworth (ed.), The extreme right in Europe and the USA. New York : St Martin's Press, (pp. 1–28).
- P. Hainsworth (ed.) (1992b). The extreme right in Europe and the USA. New York : St Martin's Press.
- P. Hainsworth (ed.) 2000. The politics of the extreme right: From the margins to the mainstream London : Pinter.
- D. Hanley (ed.) 1994. Christian democracy in Europe: A comparative perspective London : Pinter.
- Harmel, R. & Robertson, J.D. (1985). Formation and success of new parties: A cross-national analysis. International Political Science Review 6: 501–523.
10.1177/019251218500600408 Google Scholar
- Hazan, R.Y. (1997). Centre parties: Polarization and competition in European parliamentary democracies. London : Pinter.
- G. Hermet J.T. Hottinger & D.-L. Seller (eds) 1998. Les partis politique en Europe de l'Ouest Paris : Economica.
- Huber, J. & Inglehart, R. (1995). Expert interpretations of party space and party locations in 42 societies. Party Politics 1: 73–111.
- Ieraci, G. (1992). Centre parties and anti-system oppositions in polarised systems. West European Politics 15: 17–34.
10.1080/01402389208424904 Google Scholar
- Ignazi, P. (1992). The silent counter-revolution: Hypotheses on the emergence of extreme right-wing parties in Europe. European Journal of Political Research 22: 3–34.
- Ignazi, P. (1996). The crisis of parties and the rise of new political parties. Party Politics 2: 549–566.
- Ignazi, P. (1997). New challenges: Postmaterialism and the extreme right. In M. Rhodes P. Heywood & V. Wright (eds.), Developments in West European politics. New York : St Martin's Press, (pp. 300–319).
10.1007/978-1-349-25341-8_17 Google Scholar
- Inglehart, R. (1977). The silent revolution: Changing values and political styles among Western publics. Princeton : Princeton University Press.
- Inglehart, R. (1997). Modernization and postmodernization: Cultural, economic, and political change in 43 societies. Princeton : Princeton University Press.
- Jackman, R.W. & Volpert, K. (1996). Conditions favouring parties of the extreme right in Western Europe. British Journal of Political Science 26: 501–521.
- F. Jacobs (ed.) 1989. Western European political parties: A comprehensive guide The High : Longman.
- Jaensch, D. & Mathieson, D.S. (1998). A plague on both your houses: Minor parties in Australia. St Leonard's : Allen & Unwin.
- Keman, H. (1994). The search for the centre: Pivot parties in West European party systems. West European Politics 17: 124–148.
10.1080/01402389408425046 Google Scholar
- Keman, H. (1997). Centre-space politics: Party behaviour in multi-party systems. In H. Keman (ed.), The politics of problem-solving in postwar democracies. New York : St Martin's Press, (pp. 85–112).
10.1007/978-1-349-25223-7_5 Google Scholar
- E.J. Kirchner (ed.) 1988. Liberal parties in Western Europe Cambridge : Cambridge University Press.
10.1017/CBO9780511521843 Google Scholar
- Kitschelt, H. (1988). Left-libertarian parties: Explaining innovation in competitive party systems. World Politics 40: 194–234.
- Kitschelt, H. (1989). The logics of party formation: Ecological politics in Belgium and West Germany. Ithaca : Cornell University Press.
10.7591/9781501745959 Google Scholar
- Kitschelt, H. & McGann, A.J. (1995). The radical right in Western Europe: A comparative analysis. Ann Arbor , MI : University of Michigan Press.
- Kitschelt, H. & Hellemans, S. (1990). Beyond the European left: Ideology and political action in the Belgian ecology parties. Durham : Duke University Press.
- Knigge, P. (1998). The ecological correlates of right-wing extremism in Western Europe. European Journal of Political Research 34: 249–279.
- Knutsen, O. (1998). Expert judgements of the left-right location of political parties: A comparative longitudinal study. West European Politics 21: 63–94.
10.1080/01402389808425245 Google Scholar
- Koff, S.Z. & Koff, S.P. (2000). Italy: From the First to the Second Republic. London : Routledge.
- Laponce, J.A. (1981). Left and right: The topography of political perceptions. Toronto : University of Toronto Press.
- V. Lauber (ed.) 1996. Contemporary Austrian politics Boulder , CO : Westview Press.
- S. Levine (ed.) (1999). The New Zealand politics source book. 3rd edn. Palmerston North : Dunmore Press.
- Lijphart, A. (1994). Electoral systems and party systems: A study of twenty-seven democracies 1945–1990. Oxford : Oxford University Press.
10.1093/acprof:oso/9780198273479.001.0001 Google Scholar
- Mackie, T.T. (1995). Parties and elections. In J. Hayward & E.G. Page (eds.), Governing the New Europe. Cambridge : Polity Press, (pp. 166–195).
- Mackie, T.T. & Rose, R. (1991). The international almanac of electoral history. 3rd edn. London : Macmillan.
10.1007/978-1-349-09851-4 Google Scholar
- Mackie, T.T. & Rose, R. (1997). A decade of election results: Updating the international almanac. University of Strathclyde : Centre for the Study of Public Policy.
- Mair, P. (1987). The changing Irish party system: Organisation, ideology and electoral competition. London : Pinter.
- Mair, P. (1995). Political parties, popular legitimacy and public privilege. West European Politics 18: 40–57.
10.1080/01402389508425090 Google Scholar
- Mair, P. (1997). Party system change: Approaches and interpretations. Oxford : Clarendon Press.
- Mair, P. & Castles, F.G. (1997). Reflections: Revisiting expert judgements. European Journal of Political Research 31: 150–157.
- V.E. McHale (ed.) (1983). Political parties of Europe, Vols. 1 & 2. Westport , CT : Greenwood Press.
- Miller, K.E. (1968). Government and politics in Denmark. Boston , MA : Houghton Mifflin Company.
- R. Miller (ed.) 1997. New Zealand politics in transition Auckland : Oxford University Press.
- Milne, R.S. (1966). Political parties in New Zealand. Oxford : Clarendon Press.
- Mudde, C. (1996). The paradox of the anti-party party: Insights from the extreme right. Party Politics 2: 265–276.
- Mudde, C. (2000). The ideology of the extreme right. Manchester : Manchester University Press.
- Mulgan, R. (1998). Politics in New Zealand. 2nd edn. Auckland : Auckland University Press.
- W.C. Müiller & K. Strøm (eds.) 2000. Coalition governments in Western Europe Oxford : Oxford University Press.
- F. Muller-Rommel (ed.) 1989. New politics in Western Europe: The rise and success of green parties and alternative lists Boulder , CO : Westview Press.
- F. Muller-Rommel & G. Pridham (eds.) 1991. Small parties in Western Europe: Comparative and national perspectives London : Sage.
- J. Mylly & R.M. Berry (eds.) 1984. Political parties in Finland: Essays in history and politics Turku : Department of Political Science, University of Turku.
- Newell, J.L. (2000). Parties and democracy in Italy. Aldershot : Ashgate Publishing.
- Nousiainen, J. (1971). The Finnish political system. J.H. Hodgson (trans.). Cambridge , MA : Harvard University Press.
10.4159/harvard.9780674429239 Google Scholar
- Olzog, G. & Liese, H.-J. (1996). Die politischen Parteien in Deutschland: Geschichte, Programmatik, Organisation, Personen, Finanzierung. 24th edn. Munich : Günter Olzog Verlag.
- C. Ó Maoláin (ed.) 1987. The radical right: A world directory Burnt Mill : Longman.
- O'Neill, M. (1997). Green parties and political change in contemporary Europe: New politics, old predicaments. Aldershot : Ashgate.
- S. Padgett (ed.) 1993. Parties and party systems in the new Germany Aldershot : Dartmouth Publishing.
- Partridge, H. (1998). Italian politics today. Manchester : Manchester University Press.
- G. Pasquino & P. McCarthy (eds.) 1993. The end of post-war politics in Italy: The landmark 1992 elections Boulder , CO : Westview Press.
- P. Pennings & J.-E. Lane (eds.) 1998. Comparing party system change London : Routledge.
- Petersson, O. (1994). The government and politics of the Nordic countries. F.G. Perry, (trans.). Stockholm : C E Fritzes AB.
- Powell, G.B. (1982). Contemporary democracies: Participation, stability, and violence. Cambridge , MA : Harvard University Press.
10.4159/9780674042353 Google Scholar
- Powell, G.B. (1986). Extremist parties and political turmoil: Two puzzles. American Journal of Political Science 30: 357–378.
- D. Richardson & C. Rootes (eds.) 1995. The green challenge: The development of green parties in Europe London : Routledge.
- Sani, G. & Sartori, G. (1983). Polarization, fragmentation and competition in Western democracies. In H. Daalder & P. Mair (eds.), Western European party systems: Continuity and change. London : Sage Publications, (pp. 307–340).
- Sartori, G. (1976). Parties and party systems: A framework for analysis. Cambridge : Cambridge University Press.
- Schedler, A. (1996). Anti-political-establishment parties. Party Politics 2: 291–312.
- A. Selden (ed.) 1990. UK political parties since 1945 New York : Philip Allan.
- Siaroff, A. (2000). Comparative European party systems: An analysis of parliamentary elections since 1945. New York : Garland Publishing.
- Sigelman, L. & Nam Yough, S. (1978). Left-right polarization in national party systems: A cross-national analysis. Comparative Political Studies 11: 355–379.
- Smith, G. (1987). Party and protest: The two faces of opposition in Western Europe. In E. Kolinsky (ed.), Opposition in Western Europe. New York : St Martin's Press, (pp. 52–76).
- Smith, G. (1989). Core persistence: Change and the ‘people's party’. West European Politics 12: 157–168.
- G. Smith & P. Mair (eds.) (1989). Understanding party system change in Western Europe. West European Politics 12 (Special Issue).
- Starr, G., Richmond, K. & Maddox, G. (1978). Political parties in Australia. Richmond : Heinemann Educational Australia.
- Stevens, A. (1996). The government and politics of France. 2nd edn. Houndmills : Macmillan.
- K. Strøm & L. Svåsand (eds.) 1997. Challenges to political parties: The case of Norway Ann Arbor , MI : Michigan University Press.
10.3998/mpub.14380 Google Scholar
- Sully, M.A. (1981). Political parties and elections in Austria. London : Hurst & Co.
- Taggart, P.A. (1996). The new populism and the new politics: New protest parties in Sweden in a comparative perspective. New York : St Martin's Press.
10.1007/978-1-349-13920-0 Google Scholar
- H.G. Thorburn (ed.) (1991). Party politics in Canada. 6th edn. Scarborough : Prentice-Hall Canada.
- Valen, H. & Katz, D. (1965). Political parties in Norway: A community study. Oslo : Universitetsforlaget.
- Verkade, W. (1965). Democratic parties in the Low Countries and Germany: Origins and historical developments. Leiden : Leiden University Press.
- M. Waller & M. Fennema (eds.) (1988). Communist parties in Western Europe: Decline or adaption?. Oxford : Basil Blackwell.
- J. Warhurst (ed.) (1997). Keeping the bastards honest: The Australian democrats' first twenty years. St Leonards : Allen & Unwin.
- Webb, P. (2000). The modern British party system. London : Sage.
- F. Wende (ed.) 1981. Lexikon zur Geschichte der Parteien in Europa Stuttgart : Alfred Kroner Verlag.
- Willey, J. (1998). Institutional arrangements and the success of new parties in old democracies. Political Studies 46: 651–668.
- Woldendorp, J., Keman, H. & Budge, I. (1998). Party government in 20 democracies: An update (1990–1995). European Journal of Political Research 33: 125–164.
- S.B. Wolinetz (ed.) 1988. Parties and party systems in liberal democracies London : Routledge.
- D. Woodward A. Parkin & J. Summers (eds.) (1997). Government, politics, power and policy in Australia. 6th edn. South Melbourne : Addison Wesley Longman.
- Zillacus, K.O.K. (2001). ‘New polities’ in Finland: The greens and the left wing in the 1990s. West European Politics 24: 27–54.