Firing Blanks? An Analysis of Discursive Struggle in HRM
Abstract
ABSTRACT We revisit Karen Legge's (2001) critique of HRM in which she argues that the attempt of modernist/positivist HRM research to show that HRM improves organizational performance is a ‘spent round’. We note that despite spirited challenges by Legge and others, the discourse of HRM is becoming increasingly dominant. Accordingly, we use discourse analysis to examine why this might be the case. Specifically, we analyse the texts produced in the engagement between Karen Legge and David Guest to show how modernist/positivist texts like those of Guest have been successful in constructing an identity for HRM and embedding it in the broader academic discourse concerning the employment relationship, while critical researchers like Legge face a number of difficulties in producing ‘counter-texts’.
REFERENCES
- Addison, J. and Belfield, C. (2001). ‘Updating the determinants of firm performance: estimation using the 1998 UK Workplace Employee Relations Survey. British Journal of Industrial Relations, 39, 3, 341–66.
- Alvesson, M. and Deetz, S. (2000). Doing Critical Management Research. London: Sage.
- Alvesson, M. and Kärreman, D. (2000). ‘Varieties of discourse: on the study of organizations through discourse analysis. Human Relations, 53, 9, 1125–49.
- ACU (Association of Commonwealth Universities) (1990). Commonwealth Universities Yearbook. London: ACU.
- ACU (Association of Commonwealth Universities) (1995). Commonwealth Universities Yearbook. London: ACU.
- ACU (Association of Commonwealth Universities) (2000). Commonwealth Universities Yearbook. London: ACU.
- Astley, W. G. and Sachdeva, P. S. (1984). ‘Structural sources of intraorganizational power: a theoretical synthesis. Academy of Management Review, 9, 1, 104–13.
- Barry, D. E. and Elmes, M. (1997). ‘Strategy retold: toward a narrative view of strategic discourse. Academy of Management Review, 22, 2, 429–52.
- Blyton, P. and Turnbull, P. (1998). The Dynamics of Employee Relations, 2nd edn. London: Macmillan.
10.1007/978-1-349-14314-6 Google Scholar
- Boal, K. B., Hunt, J. G. and Jaros, S. J. (2003). ‘ Order is free: on the ontological status of organizations’. In Westwood, R. and Clegg, S. (Eds), Debating Organization: Point-Counterpoint in Organization Studies. Oxford: Blackwell.
- Boje, D. M. (1991). ‘The storytelling organization: a study of story performance in an office-supply firm. Administrative Science Quarterly, 36, 1, 106–26.
10.2307/2393432 Google Scholar
- Bourdieu, P. (1993). Sociology in Question. London: Sage.
- Burrell, G. and Morgan, G. (1979). Sociological Paradigms and Organizational Analysis. London: Heinemann.
- Callon, M. (1986). ‘ Some elements of a sociology of translation: domestication of the scallops and the fisherman of St. Briene Bay’. In Law, J. (Ed.), Power, Action and Belief: A Sociology of Knowledge. London: Routledge, 1986.
- Chalaby, J. K. (1996). ‘Beyond the prison-house of language: discourse as a sociological concept. British Journal of Sociology, 47, 4, 684–98.
- Clegg, S. R. and Hardy, C. (1996). ‘ Introduction’. In Clegg, S. R., Hardy, C. and Nord, W. R. (Eds), Handbook of Organization Studies. London: Sage.
- Cobb, S. (1993). ‘ Empowerment and mediation: a narrative perspective. Negotiation Journal, July, 245–61.
- Cobb, S. and Rifkin, J. (1991). ‘Neutrality as a discursive practice: the construction and transformation of narratives in community mediation. Studies in Law, Politics, and Society, 11, 69–91.
- Collinson, D. (1988). ‘Engineering humor: masculinity, joking and conflict in shop-floor relations. Organization Studies, 9, 181–99.
- Czarniawska, B. (2003). ‘ Social constructionism and organization studies’. In Westwood, R. and Clegg, S. (Eds), Debating Organization: Point-Counterpoint in Organization Studies. Oxford: Blackwell.
- Davis, M. (1986). ‘ “That's classic!” The phenomenology and rhetoric of successful social theories. Philosophy of the Social Sciences, 16, 285–301.
- Deetz, S. (1992). Democracy in an Age of Corporate Colonization: Developments in Communication and the Politics of Everyday Life. Albany, NY: State University of New York.
- Donaldson, L. (2003). ‘ Position statement for positivism’. In Westwood, R. and Clegg, S. (Eds), Debating Organization: Point-Counterpoint in Organization Studies. Oxford: Blackwell.
- Fairclough, N. (1992). Discourse and Social Change. Cambridge: Polity Press.
- Fairclough, N. (1995). Critical Discourse Analysis: The Critical Study of Language. London: Longman.
- Foucault, M. (1980). Power/Knowledge: Selected Interviews and Other Writings 1972–1977. Brighton: Harvester Press.
- Foucault, M. (1982). ‘ The subject and power’. In Dreyfus, H. L. and Rabinow, P. (Eds), Michel Foucault: Beyond Structuralism and Hermeneutics. Brighton: Harvester Press.
- Fournier, V. and Gray, C. (2000). ‘At the critical moment: conditions and prospects for critical management studies. Human Relations, 53, 1, 7–32.
- Gephart, R., Frayne, C. A., Boje, D., White, J. and Lawless, M. (2000). ‘Genres at Journal of Management Inquiry: breaking frames and changing fields. Journal of Management Inquiry, 9, 3, 246–55.
- Gergen, K. J. (1994). Realities and Relationships: Soundings in Social Construction. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
- Gergen, K. J. (2001a). ‘ Self narration in social life’. In Wetherell, M., Taylor, S. and Yates, S. J. (Eds), Discourse Theory and Practice: A Reader. London: Sage.
- Gergen, K. J. (2001b). Social Construction in Context. London: Sage.
10.4135/9781446219645 Google Scholar
- Grant, D. and Oswick, C. (Eds) (1996). Metaphor and Organizations. London: Sage.
- Grant, D., Keenoy, T and Oswick, C. (1998). ‘ Introduction: organizational discourse: of diversity, dichotomy and multi-disciplinarity’. In Keenoy, T., Grant, D. and Oswick, C. (Eds), Discourse and Organization. London: Sage.
10.4135/9781446280270 Google Scholar
- Guest, D. (1987). ‘Human resource management and industrial relations. Journal of Management Studies, 24, 5, 503–21.
- Guest, D. (1989). ‘ Human resource management: its implications for industrial relations and trade unions’. In Storey, J. (Ed.), New Perspectives on Human Resource Management. London: Routledge.
- Guest, D. (1990). ‘Human resource management and the American dream. Journal of Management Studies, 27, 4, 377–97.
- Guest, D. (1995). ‘ Human resource management, trade unions and industrial relations’. In Storey, J. (Ed.), Human Resource Management: A Critical Text. London: Routledge.
- Guest, D. (1997). ‘Human resource management and performance: a review and research agenda. The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 8, 3, 263–76.
10.1080/095851997341630 Google Scholar
- Guest, D. (1999). ‘Human resource management – the workers’ verdict. Human Resource Management Journal, 9, 3, 5–25.
10.1111/j.1748-8583.1999.tb00200.x Google Scholar
- Guest, D. (2001). ‘Human resource management: when research confronts reality. International Journal of Human Resource Management, 12, 7, 1092–106.
- Guest, D. (2002). ‘Human resource management, corporate performance and employee well-being: building the worker in to HRM. Journal of Industrial Relations, 44, 3, 335–58.
10.1111/1472-9296.00053 Google Scholar
- Hall, S. (2001). ‘ Foucault: power, knowledge and discourse’. In Wetherell, M., Taylor, S. and Yates, S. J. (Eds), Discourse Theory and Practice: A Reader. London: Sage, 72–81.
- Hardy, C. and Clegg, S. (1997). ‘Relativity without relativism: reflexivity in post-paradigm organization studies. British Journal of Management, 8, S5–S17.
10.1111/1467-8551.8.s1.2 Google Scholar
- Hardy, C. and Phillips, N. (1998). ‘Strategies of engagement: lessons from the critical examination of collaboration and conflict in an interorganizational domain. Organization Science, 9, 2, 217–30.
- Hardy, C. and Phillips, N. (1999). ‘No joking matter: discursive struggle in the Canadian refugee system. Organization Studies, 20, 1, 1–24.
- Hardy, C. and Phillips, N. (forthcoming). ‘ Discourse and power’. In Grant, D., Hardy, C., Oswick, C., Phillips, N. and Putnam, L. (Eds), Handbook of Organizational Discourse. London: Sage.
- Hassard, J. and Kelemen, M. (2002). ‘Production and consumption in organisational knowledge: the case of the “paradigms debate” . Organization, 9, 2, 331–55.
- Hatch, M. J. (1997). ‘Irony and the social construction of contradiction in the humor of a management team. Organization Studies, 8, 3, 275–88.
- Huselid, M. A. (1995). ‘The impact of human resource management practices on turnover, productivity, and corporate financial performance. Academy of Management Journal, 38, 635–72.
- Jameson, D. A. (2001). ‘Narrative discourse and management action. Journal of Business Communication, 38, 4, 476–511.
10.1177/002194360103800404 Google Scholar
- Keenoy, T. (1997). ‘Review article: HRMism and the languages of re-presentation. Journal of Management Studies, 34, 5, 825–41.
10.1111/1467-6486.00073 Google Scholar
- Keenoy, T. (1999). ‘HRM as hologram: a polemic. Journal of Management Studies, 36, 1, 1–23.
- Keenoy, T. and Anthony, P. D. (1992). ‘ HRM: metaphor, meaning and morality’. In Blyton, P. and Turnbull, P. (Eds), Reassessing HRM. London: Sage.
- Keenoy, T., Oswick, C. and Grant, D. (1997). ‘Organizational discourses: text and context. Organization, 4, 2, 147–57.
- Kieser, A. (1997). ‘Rhetoric and myth in management fashion. Organization, 4, 49–74.
- Kitchell, A., Hannan, E. and Kempton, W. (2000). ‘Identity through stories: story structure and function in two environmental groups. Human Organization, 59, 1, 96–105.
- Kuhn, T. (1997). ‘The discourse of issues management: a genre of organizational communication. Communication Quarterly, 45, 3, 188–210.
10.1080/01463379709370060 Google Scholar
- Legge, K. (1978). Power, Innovation and Problem-Solving in Personnel Management. London: McGraw-Hill.
- Legge, K. (1989). ‘ Human resource management: a critical analysis’. In Storey, J. (Ed.), New Perspectives on Human Resource Management. London: Routledge.
- Legge, K. (1995a). ‘ HRM: rhetoric, reality and hidden agendas’. In Storey, J. (Ed.), Human Resource Management: A Critical Text. London: Routledge.
10.1007/978-1-349-24156-9 Google Scholar
- Legge, K. (1995b). Human Resource Management: Rhetorics and Realities. London: Macmillan.
10.1007/978-1-349-24156-9 Google Scholar
- Legge, K. (1998). ‘ The morality of HRM’. In Mabey, C., Skinner, D. and Clark, T. (Eds), Experiencing Human Resource Management. London: Sage.
- Legge, K. (2001). ‘ Silver bullet or spent round? Assessing the meaning of the “high commitment management”/performance relationship’. In Storey, J. (Ed.), HRM – A Critical Text, 2nd edn. London: Thompson Learning.
- Livesey, S. M. (2002). ‘Global warming wars: rhetorical and discourse analytic approaches to ExxonMobil's corporate public discourse. Journal of Business Communication, 39, 1, 117–48.
10.1177/002194360203900106 Google Scholar
- Mumby, D. (1993). Narrative and Social Control: Critical Perspectives. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
10.4135/9781483345277 Google Scholar
- Mumby, D. K. and Clair, R. P. (1997). ‘ Organizational discourse’. In van Dijk, T. A. (Ed.), Discourse as Structure and Process. London: Sage.
- Noon, M. and Blyton, P. (1997). The Realities of Work. London: Macmillan.
10.1007/978-1-349-25689-1 Google Scholar
- O'Connor, E. (2002). ‘Storied business: typology, intertextuality, and traffic in entrepreneurial narrative. Journal of Business Communication, 39, 1, 36–54.
10.1177/002194360203900103 Google Scholar
- Orlikoswki, W. J. and Yates, J. (1994). ‘Genre reporting: the structuring of communicative practices in organizations. Administrative Science Quarterly, 39, 541–74.
- Oswick, C., Keenoy, T. and Grant, D. (2002). ‘Metaphor and analogical reasoning in organization theory: beyond orthodoxy. Academy of Management Review, 27, 2, 294–303.
- Ott, B. and Walter, C. (2000). ‘Intertexuality: interpretive practice and textual strategy. Critical Studies in Media Communication, 17, 4, 429–43.
- Parker, I. (1992). Discourse Dynamics. London: Routledge.
- Pettigrew, A. M. (1973). The Politics of Organizational Decision Making. London: Tavistock.
- Phillips, N. and Hardy, C. (1997). ‘Managing multiple identities: discourse, legitimacy and resources in the UK refugee system. Organization, 4, 2, 159–86.
- Phillips, N. and Hardy, C. (2002). Discourse Analysis: Investigating Processes of Social Construction. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
10.4135/9781412983921 Google Scholar
- Ramsay, H., Scholarios, D. and Harley, B. (2000). ‘Employees and high performance work systems: testing inside the black box. British Journal of Industrial Relations, 38, 501–31.
- Ricoeur, P. (1981). Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences: Essays on Language, Action and Interpretation. New York: Cambridge University Press.
10.1017/CBO9781316534984 Google Scholar
- Ricoeur, P. (1986). From Text to Action: Essays in Hermeneutics II. Evanston, IL: Northwestern University Press.
- Roche, W. (2001). ‘The individualization of Irish industrial relations?. British Journal of Industrial Relations, 39, 2, 183–206.
- Storey, J. (1987). ‘ Developments in the management of human resources: an interim report. Warwick Papers in Industrial Relations, 17, Industrial Relations Research Unit, The University of Warwick.
- Storey, J. (1992). Developments in the Management of Human Resources. Oxford: Blackwell.
- Taylor, J. R. and Van Every, E. J. (1993). The Vulnerable Fortress: Bureaucratic Organization in the Information Age. Toronto: University of Toronto.
- Taylor, J. R., Cooren, F., Giroux, N. and Robichaud, D. (1996). ‘The communicational basis of organization: between the conversation and the text. Communication Theory, 6, 1, 1–39.
- Thompson, P. (forthcoming). ‘ Brands, boundaries and bandwagons: a critical reflection on critical management studies’. In Fleetwood, S. and Ackroyd, S. (Eds), Critical Realism in Action in Organisation and Management Studies. London: Routledge.
- Thompson, P. and McHugh, D. (2002). Work Organisations, 3rd edn. London: Palgrave.
10.1007/978-1-4039-0765-3 Google Scholar
- Watson, T. J. (1995). ‘Rhetoric, discourse and argument in organizational sense making: a reflexive tale. Organization Studies, 16, 5, 805–21.
- Willmott, H. (1993). ‘Strength is ignorance, slavery is freedom: managing culture in modern organizations. Journal of Management Studies, 30, 4, 515–52.
- Witten, M. (1993). ‘ Narrative and the culture of obedience at the workplace’. In Mumby, D. (Ed.), Narrative and Social Control: Critical Perspectives. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
10.4135/9781483345277.n5 Google Scholar
- Wood, L. A. and Kroger, R. O. (2000). Doing Discourse Analysis: Methods for Studying Action in Talk and Text. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
10.4135/9781452233291 Google Scholar
- Wood, S. (1999). ‘Human resource management and performance. International Journal of Management Reviews, 1, 367–413.
10.1111/1468-2370.00020 Google Scholar
- Wood, S. and De Menezes, L. (1998). ‘High commitment management in the UK: evidence from the Workplace Industrial Relations Survey and Employers’ Manpower and Skills Practices Survey. Human Relations, 51, 485–515.
- Yates, J. and Orlikowski, W. (1992). ‘Genres of organizational communication: a structurational approach to studying communication and media. Academy of Management Review, 17, 2, 299–326.
- Yates, J. and Orlikowski, W. (2002). ‘Genre systems: structuring interaction through communication norms. Journal of Business Communication, 39, 1, 13–35.
10.1177/002194360203900102 Google Scholar
