Anti-party sentiment - Conceptual thoughts and empirical evidence: Explorations into a minefield
THOMAS POGUNTKE,
Corresponding Author
THOMAS POGUNTKE
University of Mannheim, Germany
Address for correspondence: Thomas Poguntke, Faculty of Social Sciences, University of Mannheim Seminargebaude, A 5, D-68131 Mannheim, Germany Phone: 0621-292-2029; Fax: 0621-292-5315, E-mail: [email protected]Search for more papers by this author
THOMAS POGUNTKE,
Corresponding Author
THOMAS POGUNTKE
University of Mannheim, Germany
Address for correspondence: Thomas Poguntke, Faculty of Social Sciences, University of Mannheim Seminargebaude, A 5, D-68131 Mannheim, Germany Phone: 0621-292-2029; Fax: 0621-292-5315, E-mail: [email protected]Search for more papers by this authorAbstract
The literature about ‘crisis of party’ or ‘decline of party’ abounds, but most studies in this genre refer to underlying social changes when trying to explain these phenomena. Normative reservations about political parties have thus far been widely neglected in this debate. This article argues that more attention should be given to the interaction between elite theorizing about, and mass orientations towards, political parties. Even though direct survey evidence on popular attitudes towards political parties is largely unavailable, these attitudes can be indirectly measured using several attitudinal and behavioural indicators. Based on a survey of longitudinal data for 13 Western democracies, this article shows that signs of anti-party sentiment have become more visible as we have moved into the 1980s; but that sweeping generalizations are unfounded.
References
- Armingeon, K. (1994). Gründe und Folgen geringer Wahlbeteiligung, Kölner Zeitschrift für Soziologie und Sozialpsychologie 46 (1): 43–64.
- Arnim, H.H. von (1993a). Staat ohne Diener. Was schert die Politiker das Wohl des Volkes? München : Kindler.
- Arnim, H.H. von (1993b). 1st die Kritik an den politischen Parteien berechtigt?, Aus Politik und Zeitgeschichte 43 (11): 14–23.
- Bardi, L. (1996). Anti-party sentiment and party system change in Italy, European Journal of Political Research 29 (3)this issue.
- Bartolini, S. (1983). The membership of class parties: The social democratic experience, 1889–1978, pp. 177–220 in H. Daalder & P. Mair (eds.), Western European party systems: Continuity and change. Beverly Hills and London : Sage.
- Berger, S. (1979). Politics and antipolitics in Western Europe in the seventies, Daedalus 108: 27–50.
- Bermbach, U. (1978). On civic initiative groups, pp. 227–242 in M. Kaase & K. Beyme (eds.), Elections and parties. London and Beverly Hills : Sage.
- Betz, H.-G. (1991). Radikal rechtspopulistische Parteien in Westeuropa, Aus Politik und Zeitgeschichte 41 (44): 3–14.
- Betz, H.-G. (1992). Wahlenthaltung und Wählerprotest im westeuropäischen Vergleich, Aus Politik und Zeitgeschichte 42 (19): 31–41.
- Daalder, H. (1992). A crisis of party?, Scandinavian Political Studies 15 (4): 269–287.
10.1111/j.1467-9477.1992.tb00022.x Google Scholar
- Dittrich, K. & Johansen, L.N. (1983). Voting turnout in Europe, 1945–1978: Myths and Realities, pp. 95–114 in H. Daalder & P. Mair (eds.), Western European party systems: Continuity and change. Beverly Hills and London : Sage.
- Ehrhart, C. & Sandschneider, E. (1994). Politikverdrossenheit: Kritische Anmerkungen zur Empirie, Wahrnehmung und Interpretation abnehmender Partizipation, Zeitschrift für Parlamentsfragen 25 (3): 441–458.
- Eilfort, M. (1994). Die Nichtwahler: Wahlenthaltung als Form des Wahlverhaltens Paderborn : Schöningh.
- Europäisches Parlament (1994), Europawahl 1994. Ergebnisse und gewählte Mitglieder. mimeo .
- Falter, J.W. & Schumann, S. (1993). Nichtwahl und Protestwahl: Zwei Seiten einer Medaille, Aus Politik und Zeitgeschichte 43 (11): 36–49.
- Falter, J.W. & Schumann, S. (1994). Der Nichtwähler: das unbekannte Wesen, pp. 161–213 in H.-D. Klingemann & M. Kaase (eds.), Wahlen und Wähler: Analysen aus Anlaβ der Bundestagswahl 1990. Opladen : Westdeutscher Verlag.
- Gabriel, O.W. (1992). Politische Einstellungen und politische Kultur, pp. 95–131 In: O.W. Gabriel (ed.), Die EG-Staaten im Vergleich. Bonn : Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung.
- P. Haungs & E. Jesse (1987). Parteien in der Krise? Cologne : Verlag Wissenschaft und Politik.
- Harmel, R. & Svasand, L. (1989). From protest to party: Progress on the Right. Paper prepared for delivery at the Annual Meeting of the American Political Science Association, The Washington Hilton , 31 August to 3 September.
- Hennis, W. (1980). Demokratisierung, pp. 104–113 in M. Greiffenhagen (ed.), Kampf um Wörter? Politische Begriffe im Meinungsstreit. München : Hanser.
- Hildebrandt, K. & Dalton, R.J. (1978). Political change or sunshine politics?, pp. 69–96 in M. Kaase & K. Beyme (eds.), Elections and parties. [German Political Studies, Vol. 3]. London and Beverly Hills : Sage.
- Ignazi, P. (1992). The silent counter-revolution: Hypotheses on the emergence of extreme right-wing parties in Europe, pp. 3–34 in P. Ignazi & C. Ysmal (eds.), Extreme right-wing parties in Europe, Special Issue of the European Journal of Political Research 22(1).
- P. Ignazi & C Ysmal, eds. (1992). Extreme Right-wing Parties in Europe, special Issue of the European Journal of Political Research 22(1).
- Immerfall, S. (1993). German party sociology in the nineties: On the state of a discipline in times of turmoil, European Journal of Political Research 23: 465–482.
- Inglehart, R. (1977). The silent revolution: Changing values and political styles among Western publics. Princeton : Princeton University Press.
- Inglehart, R. (1990). Culture shift in advanced industrial society. Princeton : Princeton University Press.
10.1515/9780691186740 Google Scholar
- Katz, R.S. (1990). Party as linkage: A vestigial function?, pp. 143–161 In: D. Sainsbury (ed.), Party strategies and party-voter linkages, Special Issue of the European Journal for Political Research 18(1).
- R.S. Katz & P. Mair, eds. (1992). Party organizations: A data handbook. London : Sage.
- Katz, R.S. & Mair, P. (1995). Changing models of party organization and party democracy: The emergence of the cartel party, Party Politics 1 (1): 5–28.
- Katz, R.S., Mair, P. et al. (1992). The membership of political parties in European democracies, 1960–1990, European Journal of Political Research 22 (3): 329–345.
- Kielmansegg, P. Graf (1985). Die Quadratur des Zirkels: Überlegungen zum Charakter der repräsentativen Demokratie, pp. 9–41 in U. Matz (ed.), Aktuelle Herausforderungen der repräsentativen Demokratie. Sonderheft der Zeitschrift für Politik (Köln).
- Kirchheimer, O. (1965). Der Wandel des westeuropäischen Parteiensystems, Potitische Viertel-jahresschrift 6 (1): 20–41.
- R. Koole & P. Mair eds. (1992). Political data yearbook 1992, Special Issue of the European Journal of Political Research 22 (4).
- Koole, R. & Mair, P. eds. (1993). Political data yearbook 1993, Special Issue of the European Journal of Political Research 24(4).
- Küchler, M. (1982). Staats-, Parteien- oder Politikverdrossenheit?, pp. 39–54 in J. Raschke (ed.), Bürger und Parteien. Opladen : Westdeutscher Verlag.
10.1007/978-3-322-83694-6_3 Google Scholar
- Lawson, K. (1988). When linkage fails, pp. 13–38 in K. Lawson & P.H. Merkl (eds.), When parties fail: Emerging alternative oganizations. Princeton , NJ : Princeton University Press.
- K. Lawson & P.H. Merkl, eds. (1988). When parties fail: Emerging alternative organizations. Princeton , NJ : Princeton University Press.
10.1515/9781400859498 Google Scholar
- Mackie, T. & Rose, R. (1991). The international almanac of electoral history, 3rd. ed. London : Macmillan.
10.1007/978-1-349-09851-4 Google Scholar
- Mair, P. (1984). Party politics in contemporary Europe: A challenge to party?, West European Politics 7 (4): 170–184.
10.1080/01402388408424502 Google Scholar
- Mair, P. (1989). Continuity, change and the vulnerability of party, West European Politics 12 (4): 169–187.
10.1080/01402388908424770 Google Scholar
- Michels, R. (1989). Soziologie des Parteiwesens, 4th ed. Stuttgart : Kröner.
- Neumann, S. (1956). Towards a comparative study of political parties, pp. 395–421 in S. Neumann (ed.), Modern political parties. Chicago : University of Chicago Press.
- Pedersen, M. (1988). The defeat of all parties: The Danish Folketing election, 1973, pp. 257–281 in K. Lawson & P.H. Merkl (eds.), When parties fail: Emerging alternative organizations. Princeton , NJ : Princeton University Press.
- Panebianco, A. (1988). Political parties: Organization and power. Cambridge : Cambridge University Press.
- Poguntke, T. (1987). Grön-alternative Parteien: Eine neue Farbe in westlichen Parteiensystemen, Zeitschrift für Parlamentsfragen 18 (3): 368–382.
- Poguntke, T. (1989). The ‘new politics dimension’ in European Green Parties, pp. 175–194 in F. Muller-Rommel (ed.), New politics in Western Europe: The rise and success of Green Parties and alternative lists. Boulder and London : Westview.
- Poguntke, T. (1994). Parties in a legalistic culture: the case of Germany, pp. 185–215 in R.S. Katz & P. Mair (eds.), How parties organize: Adaptation and change in party organizations in Western democracies. London : Sage.
10.4135/9781446250570.n8 Google Scholar
- Poguntke, T. & Scarrow, S. (1996). The politics of anti-party sentiment: Introduction, European Journal of Political Research 29(3)this issue.
- Rattinger, H. (1993). Abkehr von Parteien? Dimensionen der Parteienverdrossenheit, Aus Politik und Zeitgeschichte 43 (11): 24–35.
- Reif, K. (1984). National electoral cycles and European elections 1979 and 1984, Electoral Studies 3 (3): 244–255.
- Reiter, H.L. (1993). The rise of the ‘new agenda’ and the decline of partisanship, West European Politics 16 (2): 89–104.
10.1080/01402389308424962 Google Scholar
- Reiter, H.L. (1989). Party decline in the West: A sceptic's view, Journal of Theoretical Politics 1 (3): 325–348.
10.1177/0951692889001003004 Google Scholar
- Rokkan, S. (1965). Numerical democracy and corporate pluralism, pp. 34–69 in R.A. Dahl (ed.), Political oppositions in Western democracies. New Haven and London : Yale University Press.
- Scarrow, S.E. (1966). Politicians against parties: Anti-party arguments as weapons for change in Germany, European Journal of Political Research 29(3).
- Schmitt, H. & Holmberg, S. (1995). Political parties in decline?, pp. 95–133 in H.-D. Klinge-mann & D. Fuchs (eds.), Citizens and the State, Vol. 1 of the ‘Beliefs in Government’ Series. Oxford : Oxford University Press.
- Streeck, W. & Schmitter, P.C. (1985). Private interest government: Beyond market and state. Beverly Hills and London : Sage.
- Taggart, P. (1992). Green parties and populist parties and the establishment of new politics in Sweden. Paper prepared for delivery at the 1992 Annual Meeting of the American Political Science Association, Chicago , 3–6 September.
- Topf, R. (1995). Electoral participation, in H.-D. Klingemann & D. Fuchs (eds.), Citizens and the State, Vol. 1 of the ‘Beliefs in Government’ Series. Oxford : Oxford University Press.
- Westle, B. (1989). Einstellungen zu den politischen Parteien und der Demokratie in der Bundesrepublik Deutschland, pp. 223–240 in R. Wildenmann (ed.), Volksparteien: Ratlose Riesern Eine Studie unter Mitarbeit von Werner Kaltefleiter, Manfred Küchler, Alf Mintzel, KarlHeinz Naßmacher, Hans-Martin Pawlowski, Thomas Poguntke, Gordon Smith, Ulrich Wid-maier. Baden-Baden : Nomos.
- Westle, B. (1990). Zur Akzeptanz der politischen Parteien und der Demokratie in der Bundesrepublik Deutschland, pp. 253–295 in M. Kaase & H.-D. Klingemann (eds.), Wahlen und Wähler: Analysen aus Anlaß der Bundestagswahl 1987. Opladen : Westdeutscher Verlag.
10.1007/978-3-322-96181-5_9 Google Scholar
- Wiesendahl, E. (1992). Volksparteien im Abstieg, Aus Politik und Zeitgeschichte 42(34–35): 3–14.
- Wildenmann, R Ed. (1989). Volksparteien: Ratlose Riesenl. Eine Studie unter Mitarbeit von Werner Kaltefleiter, Manfred Küchler, Alf Mintzel, Karl-Heinz Naßmacher, Hans-Martin Pawlowski, Thomas Poguntke, Gordon Smith, Ulrich Widmaier. Baden-Baden : Nomos.
