Genocide, Politicide, and the Prospects of Democratization since 1900
Abstract
Why do some autocracies democratize? A country’s violent past has received little attention. We argue that genocide and politicide undermine democratization by binding the elites’ supporters more tightly to the governing power, while cementing in-group/out-group animosities, and helping preserve the elites’ status quo position within the state. We test this argument on a new dataset of government atrocity and democratization since 1900. These novel data allow us to capture many important instances of atrocity missed by others, and thus take a longer look at democratization and violence throughout history. We find that episodes of genocide and politicide are associated with a lower likelihood of democratization in both the short and long run. These effects are larger and more consistent than other common explanations for democratization. They also differ from the effects of non-genocidal civil war violence.
Get full access to this article
View all access and purchase options for this article.
References
Abadie A., Diamond A., Hainmueller J. 2010. “Synthetic control methods for comparative case studies: Estimating the effect of California’s tobacco control program.” Journal of the American statistical Association 105(490): 493–505.
Albertus M., Menaldo V. 2018. Authoritarianism and the Elite Origins of Democracy. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press.
Angrist J., Pischke J. 2009. Mostly Harmless Econometrics: An Empiricist’s Companion Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Balcells L. 2017. Rivalry and Revenge: The Politics of Violence during Civil War. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Bellamy A. 2015. “When States Go Bad: The Termination of State Perpetrated Mass Killing.” Journal of Peace Research 52:565–76.
Besley T., Reynal-Querol M. 2014. “The Legacy of Historical Conflict: Evidence from Africa.” American Political Science Review 108:319–36.
Boehling R. 1996. A Question of Priorities: Democratic Reforms and Economic Recovery in Postwar Germany. New York: Berghahn Books.
Bohnke J., Zurcher C. 2013. “Aid, Minds and Hearts: The Impact of Aid in Conflict Zones.” Conflict Management and Peace Science 30:411–32.
Boix C. 2011. “Democracy, Development, and the International System.” American Political Science Review 105:809–28.
Boix C., Miller M., Rosato S. 2013. “A complete data set of political regimes, 1800–2007.” Comparative Political Studies. 46 (12):1523–54.
Bolt J., van Zanden J. 2014. “The Maddison Project: Collaborative Research on Historical National Accounts.” Economic History Review 67(3), 627–651.
Braun R. 2016. “Religious Minorities and Resistance to Genocide: The Collective Rescue of Jews in the Netherlands during the Holocaust.” American Political Science Review 110:127–47.
Cederman L., Wimmer A., Min B. 2010. “Why Do Ethnic Groups Rebel?” World Politics 62 (1): 870119.
Charnysh V., Finkel E. 2017. “The Death Camp Eldorado: Political and Economic Effects of Mass Violence.” American Political Science Review 111:801–18.
Chenoweth E., Stephan M. 2011. Why Civil Resistance Works: The Strategic Logic of Nonviolent Conflict. New York: Columbia University Press.
Clark W., Golder M., Golder S. 2017. “An Exit, Voice and Loyalty Model of Politics.” British Journal of Political Science 47:719–48.
Cohen D. 2013. “Explaining Rape during Civil War: Cross-national Evidence 1980-2009.” American Political Science Review 107:461–77.
Collier P. 2003. Breaking the Conflict Trap: Civil War and Development Policy. New York: World Bank.
Coppedge Michael, Gerring John, Knutsen Carl Henrik, Lindberg Staffan I., ing Svend-Erik Skaan-, Teorell Jan, Altman David, Bernhard Michael, Steven Fish M., Cornell Agnes, Dahlum Sirianne, Gjerløw Haakon, Glynn Adam, Hicken Allen, Krusell Joshua, Anna Lührmann, Marquardt Kyle L., McMann Kelly, Mechkova Valeriya, Medzihorsky Juraj, Olin Moa, ton Pamela Pax-, Pemstein Daniel, Pernes Josefine, von Römer Johannes, Seim Brigitte, Sigman Rachel, Staton Jeffrey, Stepanova Natalia, Aksel Sundström, Tzelgov Eitan, Wang Yi-ting, Wig Tore, Wilson Steven, Ziblatt Daniel. 2019. V-Dem [Country-Year/Country-Date] Dataset v9. Accessed December 20, 2019. https://www.v-dem.net/en/data/data-version-9/
DeMeritt J. 2015. “Delegating Death: Military Intervention and Government Killing.” Journal of Conflict Resolution 59:428–54.
Donno D. 2013. “Elections and Democratization in Authoritarian Regimes.” American Journal of Political Science 57:703–16.
Dryzek J. 1996. “Political Inclusion and the Dynamics of Democratization.” American Political Science Review 90:475–87.
Encrnación O. 2001. “Spain after Franco: Lessons in Democratization.” World Policy Journal 18:35–44.
Esteban J., Morelli M., Rohner D. 2015. “Strategic Mass Killings.” Journal of Political Economy 123 (5): 1087–132.
Fletcher L., Weinstein H., Rowen J. 2009. “Context, Timing, and the Dynamics of Transitional Justice.” Human Rights Quarterly 31:163–220.
Freeman M. 1991. “The Theory and Prevention of Genocide.” Holocaust and Genocide Studies 6:185–99.
Gleditsch K., Ward M. 2006. “Diffusion and the International Context of Democratization.” International Organization 60:911–33.
Goldsmith L. 2012. “Alawites for Assad.” Foreign Affairs. Accessed February 1, 2019. https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/middle-east/2012-04-16/alawites-assad.
Gunitsky S. 2014. “From Shocks to Waves: Hegemonic Transitions and Democratization in the Twentieth Century.” International Organization 68:561–97.
Haggard S., Kaufman R. 1995. The Political Economy of Democratic Transitions. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Haggard S., Kaufman R. 2012. “Inequality and Regime Change: Democratic Transitions and the Stability of Democratic Rule.” American Political Science Review 106:495–516.
Haklai O. 2000. “A Minority Rule over a Hostile Majority.” Nationalism and Ethnic Politics 6 (3): 19–50.
Harff B. 2003. “No Lessons Learned from the Holocaust? Assessing Risks of Genocide and Political Mass Murder since 1955.” American Political Science Review 97:57–73.
Harkness K. 2016. “The Ethnic Army and the State: Explaining Coup Traps and the Difficulties of Democratization in Africa.” Journal of Conflict Resolution 60:587–616.
Hoddie M., Smith J. 2009. “Forms of Civil War Violence and Their Consequences for Future Public Health.” International Studies Quarterly 53:175–202.
Houle C. 2009. “Inequality and Democracy: Why In-equality Harms Consolidation but Does Not Affect Democratization.” World Politics 61:589–622.
Huber E., Rueschemeyer D., Stephens J. 1993. “The Impact of Economic Development on Democracy.” Journal of Economic Perspectives 7:71–86.
Iacus S., King G., Porro G. 2012. “Causal inference without balance checking: Coarsened exact matching.” Political analysis 20(1):1–24.
Kalyvas S. 2006. The Logic of Violence in Civil War. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press.
Kalyvas S., Kocher M. 2007. “How Free is Free Riding in Civil Wars? Violence, Insurgency, and the Collective Action Problem.” World Politics 59:177–216.
Kim N. 2018. “Revolutionary Leaders and Mass Killing.” Journal of Conflict Resolution 62:289–317.
Kim N., Uzonyi G. 2020. “Government Mass Killing and Post-conflict Domestic Trials.” Studies in Conflict & Terrorism 43(5): 396–413.
Kiwuwa D. 2005. “Democratization and Ethnic politics: Rwanda’s Electoral Legacy.” Ethnopolitics 4 (4): 447–64.
Koren O. 2017. “Means to an End: Pro-government Militias as a Predictive Indicator of Strategic Mass Killing.” Conflict Management and Peace Science 34:461–84.
Krain M. 1997. “State-sponsored Mass Murder: The Onset and Severity of Genocides and Politicides.” Journal of Conflict Resolution 41:331–60.
Krain M. 2005. “International Intervention and the Severity of Genocides and Politicides.” International Studies Quarterly 49:363–87.
Krcmaric D. 2018. “Should I Stay or Should I Go? Leaders, Exile, and the Dilemmas of International Justice.” American Journal of Political Science 62:486–98.
Lefevre R. 2013. Ashes of Hama. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press.
Levitsky S., Way L. 2013. “The Durability of Revolutionary Regimes.” Journal of Democracy 24:5–17.
Lipset S. 1959. “Some Social Requisites of Democracy.” American Political Science Review 53:69–105.
Lupu N., Peisakhin L. 2017. “The Legacy of Political Violence across Generations.” American Journal of Political Science 61:836–51.
Lyall J. 2009. “Does Indiscriminate Violence Incite Insurgent Attacks? Evidence from Chechnya.” Journal of Conflict Resolution 53:331–62.
Lyons T. 2016. “From Victorious Rebels to Strong Authoritarian Parties.” Democratization 23 (5): 1026–41.
Mann M. 2005. The Dark Side of Democracy: Explaining Ethnic Cleansing. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press.
Marshall M., Gurr T., Harff B. 2017. PITF-State Failure Problem Set: Internal Wars and Failures of Governance, 1955-2016. Vienna, VA: Societal-Systems Research Inc.
Marshall M., Gurr T., Jaggers K. 2019. “Polity IV Project: Political Regime Characteristics and Transitions, 1800-2018.” Dataset Users' Manual. Center for Systemic Peace. http://www.systemicpeace.org/inscr/p4manualv2018.pdf.
McDonough P., Barnes S., López Pina A. 1984. “Authority and Association: Spanish Democracy in Comparative Perspective.” Journal of Politics 46:652–88.
McDoom O. 2014. “Antisocial Capital: A Profile of Rwandan Genocide Perpetrators’ Social Networks.” Journal of Conflict Resolution 58:865–93.
McKoy M., Miller M. 2012. “The Patron’s Dilemma: The Dynamics of Foreign-supported Democratization.” Journal of Conflict Resolution 56:904–32.
Midlarsky M. 2005. The Killing Trap. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
Miller M. 2012. “Economic Development, Violent Leader Removal, and Democratization.” American Journal of Political Science 56:1002–20.
Owsiak A. 2013. “Democratization and International Border Agreements.” Journal of Politics 75:717–29.
Przeworski A., Alvarez M., Cheibub J., Limongi F. 2000. Democracy and Development: Political Institutions and Well-being in the World, 1950–1990. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
Riedl R. B., Slater D., Wong J., Ziblatt D. 2020. “Authoritarian-led Democratization.” Annual Review of Political Science 23:315–32.
Rozenas A., Schutte S., Zhukov Y. 2017. “The Political Legacy of Violence: The Long-term Impact of Stalin’s Repression in Ukraine.” Journal of Politics 79:1147–61.
Rummel R. J. 1997. Death by Government. London, UK: Transaction Publishers.
Sambanis N., Shayo M. 2013. “Social Identification and Ethnic Conflict.” American Political Science Review 107:294–325.
Sarkees M. 2000. “The Correlates of War Data on War: An Update to 1997.” Conflict Management and Peace Science 18:123–44.
Semelin J. 2007. Purify and Destroy: The Political Uses of Massacre and Genocide. New York: Columbia University Press.
Serneels P., Verpoorten M. 2015. “The Impact of Armed Conflict on Economic Performance: Evidence from Rwanda.” Journal of Conflict Resolution 59:555–92.
Silva-Leadner S. 2008. “On the Danger and Necessity of Democratisation: Trade-offs between Short-term Stability and Long-term Peace in Post-genocide Rwanda.” Third World Quarterly 29 (8): 1601–20.
Skaaning S., Gerring J., Bartusevičius H. 2015. “A Lexical Index of Electoral Democracy.” Comparative Political Studies 48:1491–525.
Stanton J. 2013. “Terrorism in the Context of Civil War.” Journal of Politics 75:1009–22.
Staub E. 1989. The Roots of Evil: The Origins of Genocide and Other Group Violence. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press.
Thomson Susan. 2018. Rwanda: From Genocide to Precarious Peace. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
Tilly C. 2007. Democracy. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press.
Ulfelder J., Valentino B. 2008. “Assessing Risks of State-sponsored Mass Killing.” Working Paper. Accessed February 2, 2019. SSRN: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1703426.
United States Department of State. 2019. “Democracy.” Accessed February 1, 2019. https://www.state.gov/j/drl/democ/.
Uzonyi G., Asal V. 2020. “Discrimination, Genocide and Politicide.” Political Research Quarterly 73 (2): 352–65.
Uzonyi G., Demir B. 2020. “Excluded Ethnic Groups, Conflict Contagion, and the Onset of Genocide and Politicide during Civil War.” International Studies Quarterly 64 (4): 857–66.
Uzonyi G., Hanania R. 2017. “Government-sponsored Mass Killing and Civil War Reoccurence.” International Studies Quarterly 61:677–89.
Valentino B. 2004. Final Solutions. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
Van der Maat E. 2020. “Genocidal Consolidation: Final Solutions to Elite Rivalry.” International Organization 74:773–809.
Walter B. 2004. “Does Conflict Beget Conflict? Explaining Recurring Civil War.” Journal of Peace Research 41:371–88.
Ward M., Greenhill B., Bakke K. 2010. “The Perils of Policy by P-value: Predicting Civil Conflicts.” Journal of Peace Research 47 (4): 363–75.
Wayman F., Tago A. 2010. “Explaining the Onset of Mass Killing, 1949-97.” Journal of Peace Research 47:3–13.
Wood E. 2003. Insurgent Collective Action and Civil War in El Salvador. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Young C. 2006. “The Heart of the African Conflict Zone: Democratization, Ethnicity, Civil Conflict, and the Great Lakes Crisis.” Annual Review of Political Science 9:301–28.
Zabad Ibrahim. 2017. Middle Eastern Minorities: The Impact of the Arab Spring. New York: Routledge.
Supplementary Material
Supplemental Material
Please find the following supplemental material visualised and available to download via Figshare in the display box below. Where there are more than one item, you can scroll through each tab to see each separate item.
Please note all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is here associated with
