Skip to main content
William DiMichele

    William DiMichele

    Although conceptual whole-plants are occasionally reconstructed, disarticulation means that palaeobotanical taxonomy remains primarily the preserve of fragmented organ-species, each bearing a Linnaean binomial. Thus, a "natural" taxon... more
    Although conceptual whole-plants are occasionally reconstructed, disarticulation means that palaeobotanical taxonomy remains primarily the preserve of fragmented organ-species, each bearing a Linnaean binomial. Thus, a "natural" taxon that would in any neobotanical classification bear a single valid binomial (any other epithets automatically being deemed synonyms) typically is a chimera, consisting of several binomials that are not only valid but also arguably essential, each representing a different organ of the original plant. The situation is further complicated by the fact that each organ can also carry multiple valid binomials that refer to contrasting preservation states, most commonly either adpression or permineralisation. Thus, a fossil plant is obliged to carry the heavy burden of not one but two or more parallel taxonomies. The two opposing logical approaches to clarifying this complex situation are (1) to coin additional formal names for organ-species that are found in multiple modes of preservation but at present are named in only one mode, or (2) to attempt to gradually rationalise parallel preservational taxonomies through detailed character comparison, giving priority to whichever preservational mode typically offers a stronger suite of morphological characters and therefore the greater probability of approaching the biological reality necessary for meaningful evolutionary and ecological interpretation. We illustrate our preference for Option 2 using Palaeozoic rhizomorphic lycopsid genera in general and our antagonism to the recently erected permineralisation stem-genus "Dimicheleodendron" in particular.
    In our recent description of a new genus of lycopsids from the Carboniferous (Pennsylvanian), Synchysidendron DiMichele & Bateman (1992), we neglected to designate the type of the generic name. Under Art. 37.1 of the... more
    In our recent description of a new genus of lycopsids from the Carboniferous (Pennsylvanian), Synchysidendron DiMichele & Bateman (1992), we neglected to designate the type of the generic name. Under Art. 37.1 of the botanical Code, on or after 1 Jan 1958, the name of a new taxon is not validly published unless the (holo) type is indicated. Without valid publication of the generic name, our species names were also not validly published under Art. 43.1.
    DiMichele, W.A. and Phillips, T.L., 1988. Paleoecology of the Middle Pennsylvanian-age Herrin Coal swamp (Illinois) near a contemporaneous river system, the Walshville paleochannel. Rev. Palaeobot. Palynol., 56: 151-176. Coal-ball peats... more
    DiMichele, W.A. and Phillips, T.L., 1988. Paleoecology of the Middle Pennsylvanian-age Herrin Coal swamp (Illinois) near a contemporaneous river system, the Walshville paleochannel. Rev. Palaeobot. Palynol., 56: 151-176. Coal-ball peats were sampled quantitatively in seven profiles from the Old Ben Coal Company No.24 Mine in southern Illinois. The coal and the coal-ball peats are thicker in this near-channel area than
    Breathtaking in scope, this is the first survey of the entire ecological history of life on land—from the earliest traces of terrestrial organisms over 400 million years ago to the beginning of human agriculture. By providing myriad... more
    Breathtaking in scope, this is the first survey of the entire ecological history of life on land—from the earliest traces of terrestrial organisms over 400 million years ago to the beginning of human agriculture. By providing myriad insights into the unique ecological information contained in the fossil record, it establishes a new and ambitious basis for the study of evolutionary paleoecology of land ecosystems. A joint undertaking of the Evolution of Terrestrial Ecosystems Consortium at the National Museum of Natural History, ...
    ABSTRACT—In 1904, Clarence Luther Herrick described a lycopsid flora (including three new species of Lepidodendron) from “fire clay” of Pennsylvanian age being mined for brick manufacturing east of Socorro. Herrick’s description of the... more
    ABSTRACT—In 1904, Clarence Luther Herrick described a lycopsid flora (including three new species of Lepidodendron) from “fire clay” of Pennsylvanian age being mined for brick manufacturing east of Socorro. Herrick’s description of the locality was vague, and it has not been revisited in nearly a century. In 2002 we relocated Herrick’s locality. The “fire clay” is a refractory gray to black shale in the lower part of the Middle Pennsylvanian (Atokan) Sandia Formation that can be followed on strike through a series of fault blocks for more than 2 km. The Sandia Formation at the lycopsid locality contains basal troughcrossbedded quartzose sandstone and quartzite-pebble conglomerate about 4 m thick, filling channels scoured into Proterozoic granite. These coarse clastics are sharply overlain by ~2.5 m of gray and yellow, fine-grained, massive to thinly laminated sandstone, which has lycopsid bark concentrated near the top. This in turn is overlain by the “fire clay” interval, ~4 m of g...
    In our recent description of a new genus of lycopsids from the Carboniferous (Pennsylvanian), Synchysidendron DiMichele & Bateman (1992), we neglected to designate the type of the generic name. Under Art. 37.1 of the... more
    In our recent description of a new genus of lycopsids from the Carboniferous (Pennsylvanian), Synchysidendron DiMichele & Bateman (1992), we neglected to designate the type of the generic name. Under Art. 37.1 of the botanical Code, on or after 1 Jan 1958, the name of a new taxon is not validly published unless the (holo) type is indicated. Without valid publication of the generic name, our species names were also not validly published under Art. 43.1.
    DSpace. ...
    Premise of research. Extant Isoetes species, which all develop small pseudoherbaceous habits, are the only living remnants of the once diverse clade of rhizomorphic lycopsids, which included trees that grew to towering heights of 50 m.... more
    Premise of research. Extant Isoetes species, which all develop small pseudoherbaceous habits, are the only living remnants of the once diverse clade of rhizomorphic lycopsids, which included trees that grew to towering heights of 50 m. Although the rhizomorphic lycopsids evolved a range of diverse body plans in the Pa-leozoic, it is thought that the evolution of the small pseudoherbaceous habit, with small rooting systems similar to modern Isoetes species, was a late event in the clade's history, occurring in the Mesozoic. Here we describe small fossilized rooting systems from the early Permian Abo Formation of New Mexico, increasing our knowledge of the diversity of small Paleozoic rhizomorphic rooting systems. Methodology. Ten fossilized rooting systems are described from a slab collected from the early Permian Abo Formation of New Mexico. Pivotal results. Here we report 10 rooting systems interpreted as those of rhizomorphic lycopsids due to the presence on each of a large number of isotomously branched rootlets radiating from a central rhizomorph and two associated microphyll leaf impressions. Because of the fossils' tiny size (the largest rhizomorph is only 1.5 cm in diameter, and the largest rooting system, including rootlets, is only 6 cm in diameter), we interpret these fossils either as juvenile plants or as adult morphologies with a small rooting system. Given the paucity of mature rhizomorphic lycopsids in the Abo Formation and the limited fossil record of juvenile rhizomorphic lycopsids from any geological period, we predict that these are most likely to be adult plants with small rooting systems. Conclusions. The small size of the specimens described here increases our knowledge of the diversity of small rhizomorphic rooting systems in the Paleozoic before the radiation of the modern Isoetes growth habit during the Mesozoic.
    Fossil floras have been recovered from a unique deposit of early Permian age in North-Central Texas. The site, Kola Switch, preserves three distinct floras in different lithofacies, in a succession from a single outcrop. The sedimentary... more
    Fossil floras have been recovered from a unique deposit of early Permian age in North-Central Texas. The site, Kola Switch, preserves three distinct floras in different lithofacies, in a succession from a single outcrop. The sedimentary environment appears to be a floodplain channel fill of primarily siltstones and claystones. The lowermost flora, preserved in a kaolinitic siltstone, indicates active water flow. It is dominated by plants typical of well-drained substrates, dominated by Sphenopteris germanica, and contains no wetland elements. The middle flora is from a finely laminated carbonaceous claystone and is dominated by marattialean tree ferns, with no elements from habitats typical of seasonal moisture availability. It contains no roots and appears to have formed as a floating peat mat. The upper flora is a mixed assemblage of wetland taxa and those typical of well-drained soil environments or a seasonal rainfall regime. Unlike the two lower floras, it has a relatively even distribution of dominance and is the most diverse of the three assemblages. Palynofloras also were recovered from each of these beds. The palynofloras, although varying between and even within the beds, indicate a common background species pool during the time interval sampled, suggesting that these distinct floras reflect local changes in microhabitat conditions under a constant climatic background. The palynoflora from each bed has characteristics in common with the macroflora of that bed, but also distinct differences. Together, the macroflora and microflora provide an unusually broad picture of this site through time. Kola Switch compares favorably with the recently described flora from the nearby Sanzenbacher Ranch site of approximately the same age and also with floras of Rotliegend age from Central Europe.
    The Carboniferous, the time of Earth’s penultimate icehouse and widespread coal formation, was dominated by extinct lineages of early-diverging vascular plants. Studies of nearest living relatives of key Carboniferous plants suggest that... more
    The Carboniferous, the time of Earth’s penultimate icehouse and widespread coal formation,
    was dominated by extinct lineages of early-diverging vascular plants. Studies of nearest living
    relatives of key Carboniferous plants suggest that their physiologies and growth forms differed
    substantially from most types of modern vegetation, particularly forests. It remains a matter of
    debate precisely how differently and to what degree these long-extinct plants influenced the
    environment. Integrating biophysical analysis of stomatal and vascular conductivity with
    geochemical analysis of fossilized tissues and process-based ecosystem-scale modeling yields a
    dynamic and unique perspective on these paleoforests. This integrated approach indicates that
    key Carboniferous plants were capable of growth and transpiration rates that approach values
    found in extant crown-group angiosperms, differing greatly from comparatively modest rates
    found in their closest living relatives. Ecosystem modeling suggests that divergent stomatal
    conductance, leaf sizes and stem life span between dominant cladeswouldhave shifted the balance
    of soil–atmosphere water fluxes, and thus surface runoff flux, during repeated, climate-driven,
    vegetation turnovers. This synthesis highlights the importance of ‘whole plant’ physiological
    reconstruction of extinct plants and the potential of vascular plants to have influenced the Earth
    system hundreds of millions of years ago through vegetation–climate feedbacks
    Research Interests:
    —We document the first record of Annularia cf. spinulosa from the red-bed facies of the lower Permian Abo Formation in New Mexico. The record is in the Cañon de Espinoso Member of the Abo Formation northeast of Socorro and is associated... more
    —We document the first record of Annularia cf. spinulosa from the red-bed facies of the lower Permian Abo Formation in New Mexico. The record is in the Cañon de Espinoso Member of the Abo Formation northeast of Socorro and is associated with a low diversity tetrapod footprint assemblage dominated by Dromopus and a low diversity paleofloral assemblage dominated by Supaia. Calamitaleans are generally rare in the Abo Formation, which is unusual for floras of this age, even in western Pangea. The discovery of Annularia cf. spinulosa indicates that these plants likely were represented by small numbers and were widely dispersed within the Abo landscape, which was dominated throughout its known extent by walchian conifers and Supaia.
    Research Interests:
    —Late Middle through Late Pennsylvanian fossil plant assemblages, and the strata from which they were collected, are described from Socorro County, New Mexico, U.S.A. The flora is diverse and consists of a mixture of taxa generally... more
    —Late Middle through Late Pennsylvanian fossil plant assemblages, and the strata from which they were collected, are described from Socorro County, New Mexico, U.S.A. The flora is diverse and consists of a mixture of taxa generally considered typical of both wetland and seasonally dry habitats. The overall climate likely varied in synchrony with glacial-interglacial cycles, the effects of which were felt across the tropics. However, in the absence of coals and other such indicators of humid climates, it is likely that the climate norms fell between subhumid and arid in this part of the western Pangean continent, which was at the time nearly equatorial. The flora includes the following major taxa: Arborescent lycopsids, Sigillaria, Bergeria, and Asolanus; Calamitalean axes and foliage attributable to Annularia and Asterophyllites; Sphenophyllalean sphenopsids; Marattialean fern foliage mostly unidentifiable but some attributable to either Polymorphopteris or Lobatopteris; a variety of small ferns; medullosan pteridosperms of the genera Alethopteris, Barthelopteris, Charliea; and forms of uncertain affinity, Taeniopteris and Sphenopteris germanica. The flora also contains a variety of reproductive organs, including many types of seeds. Most of the floral elements can be found across tropical Pangea from present-day western North America into the central regions of the supercontinent in present-day Europe. Nearly all of the assemblages are of allochthonous origin, with some rare and notable exceptions, and were deposited in coastal plain to nearshore environments. Thus, most of the plant remains are fragmentary, and many identifications are tentative. Total biodiversity is difficult to estimate due to the vagaries of preservation and disarticulation of the plants, but a rough approximation is somewhere between 50 and 60 species, depending on how determinations are made and on the number of unique but fragmentary specimens that could not be identified with confidence.
    Research Interests:
    — This volume documents the results of 20+ years of field, laboratory and museum research on the Pennsylvanian-Permian rocks and fossils of Socorro County, New Mexico. The articles in this volume report studies of the... more
    — This volume documents the results of 20+ years of field, laboratory and museum research on the Pennsylvanian-Permian rocks and fossils of Socorro County, New Mexico. The articles in this volume report studies of the Pennsylvanian-Permian strata east of Socorro (Joyita Hills-Cerros de Amado-Carthage area), in the Los Pinos Mountains (Sepultura Canyon area), in the Little San Pascual Mountains and at Bell Hill in the Southern San Mateo Mountains. Lithostratigraphy, sedimentary petrography, microfacies analysis and sedimentological interpretation as well as diverse paleontological studies (fossil plants, calcareous microfossils, conodonts, fossil insects, tetrapod footprints, coprolites and fossil fishes) are presented. The entire Pennsylvanian-Permian stratigraphic section in Socorro County is about 2 km thick. The Pennsylvanian strata are a complex succession of sedimentary rocks of marine and nonmarine origin deposited during the Middle-Late Pennsylvanian. These are synorogenic deposits of the ancestral Rocky Mountain (ARM) orogeny and associated marine carbonates of shallow seaways along the western periphery of equatorial Pangea. They are overlain by another complex succession of clastic and carbonate strata of Permian age, the oldest of which were deposited during the final phase of the ARM orogeny. Fossils (primarily the fusulinids and conodonts) provide the age control for the Pennsylvanian-Permian strata of Socorro County. They also are a significant part of the data used to interpret local and regional paleoenvironments and depositional systems. In addition, many of the fossils play a broader role in the understanding of late Paleozoic biotic and evolutionary events.
    Research Interests:
    —A reassessment of the taxonomic relationships of North American gigantopterids is presented in light of an examination of large populations of specimens housed in the US National Museum of Natural History. Variations in venation and... more
    —A reassessment of the taxonomic relationships of North American gigantopterids is presented in light of an examination of large populations of specimens housed in the US National Museum of Natural History. Variations in venation and subtle aspects of leaf shape facilitate refined understanding of the relationships and diversity of the North American gigantopterid species leading to an improved understanding of the taxonomic and biogeographic relationships of this group, which are found most abundantly in western equatorial Pangea and Cathaysia. Current literature suggests that there are eight North American genera, however, this study has revealed a morphological overlap of several previously defined genera, leading to the conclusion that Gigantopteridium encompasses the species previously treated as Cathaysiopteris yochelsonii as well as a new species, Gigantopteridium utebaturianum. The transfer of C. yochelsonii to Gigantopteridium yochelsonii suggests that Cathaysiopteris may represent a genus endemic to Cathaysia, limiting the biogeographical connection between the regions to Zeilleropteris, Gigantopteridium, Euparyphoselis, and Gigantonoclea.
    Research Interests:
    DiMichele, William A., Spencer G. Lucas, Cindy V. Looy, Hans Kerp, and Dan S. Chaney. Plant Fossils from the Pennsylvanian–Permian Transition in Western Pangea, Abo Pass, New Mexico. Smithsonian Contributions to Paleobiology, number 99,... more
    DiMichele, William A., Spencer G. Lucas, Cindy V. Looy, Hans Kerp, and Dan S. Chaney. Plant Fossils from the Pennsylvanian–Permian Transition in Western Pangea, Abo Pass, New Mexico. Smithsonian Contributions to Paleobiology, number 99, viii + 40 pages, 21 figures, 1 table, 2017. — Plant fossils are described from five stratigraphic levels spanning the Pennsylvanian–
    Permian boundary in Abo Canyon, New Mexico. Charles B. Read collected the fossils in 1940 and 1941; Read’s
    field notes cannot be located. A combination of Read’s bed numbering pattern, his notes in the collections, and collection
    taxonomic composition permits them to be placed in an oldest to youngest sequence. The youngest fossils, from the Abo
    Formation of early Permian age, anchor the collection stratigraphically. A collection labeled “Base of Red Magdalena” is most
    likely equivalent to the modern Bursum Formation, thus immediately below the Abo. The three remaining collections are from
    the Upper Pennsylvanian portion of the Atrasado Formation. All collections are dominated or codominated by plants typical
    of environments with seasonal moisture stress and record increasing moisture limitation through time. Conifers, Sphenopteris
    germanica, and mixoneurid odontopterids are common to abundant in pre–Abo Formation collections. These same collections
    also contain wet-substrate taxa, particularly calamitaleans and marattialean tree ferns, with arborescent lycopsids in the oldest
    collection. The middle three collections contain the remains of microconchids/spirorbids, snails, ostracods, and conchostracans
    closely associated with the plant remains, indicating brackish to marine salinities at the burial sites of the organics. The Abo
    Pass collections document Pennsylvanian–Permian floristic changes in the western Pangean equatorial belt, an important point
    of comparison to better studied floras from this same interval in central Pangea (eastern United States and Europe). Most of the
    plants in the western equatorial assemblages are the same as those of similar age from west central to central Pangea (Euramerica),
    indicating a widespread tropical biogeographic province at this time, but within which there were several distinct biomes.
    Research Interests:
    Earth’s last icehouse, 300 million years ago, is considered the longest-lived and most acute of the past half-billion years, characterized by expansive continental ice sheets1,2 and possibly tropical low-elevation glaciation3. This... more
    Earth’s last icehouse, 300 million years ago, is considered the
    longest-lived and most acute of the past half-billion years,
    characterized by expansive continental ice sheets1,2 and possibly
    tropical low-elevation glaciation3. This atypical climate has
    long been attributed to anomalous radiative forcing promoted
    by a 3% lower incident solar luminosity4 and sustained low
    atmospheric pCO2 (300 ppm)5. Climate models6, however,
    indicate aCO2 sensitivity of ice-sheet distribution and sea-level
    response that questions this long-standing climate paradigm
    by revealing major discrepancy between hypothesized ice
    distribution, pCO2 ,andgeologic records of glacioeustasy2,6.Here
    we present a high-resolution record of atmospheric pCO2 for
    16 million years of the late Palaeozoic, developed using soil
    carbonate-based and fossil leaf-based proxies, that resolves
    the climate conundrum. Palaeo-fluctuations on the 105-yr scale
    occur within the CO2 range predicted for anthropogenic change
    and co-vary with substantial change in sea level and ice volume.
    We further document coincidence between pCO2 changes and
    repeated restructuring of Euramerican tropical forests that,
    in conjunction with modelled vegetation shifts, indicate a
    more dynamic carbon sequestration history than previously
    considered7,8 and a major role for terrestrial vegetation–CO2
    feedbacks in driving eccentricity-scale climate cycles of the late
    Palaeozoic icehouse.
    Research Interests:
    —A macrofloral assemblage dominated by elements of the Euramerican dryland biome is described from the Brazil Formation in Clay County, Indiana (Illinois Basin). Fossils were recovered from a thin heterolithic unit between a... more
    —A macrofloral assemblage dominated by elements of the Euramerican dryland biome is described from the Brazil Formation in Clay County, Indiana (Illinois Basin). Fossils were recovered from a thin heterolithic unit between a shallow-marine bed and the paleosol beneath the Minshall Coal, a Middle Pennsylvanian succession deposited near the Atokan-Desmoinesian and Bolsovian-Asturian boundaries. Sedimentological indicators imply accumulation under a seasonal climate, including interbedded siltstone and sandstone deposited during flashfloods, intraclasts eroded from local sources, and charcoal produced by wildfires. The macrofloral assemblage is consistent with a dryland setting, being dominated by large, coriaceous gymnosperm leaves with mesic to xeric traits, including Cordaites spp. indet., Lesleya sp. indet., and Taeniopteris sp. cf. T. multinervia. Sphenopsids and ferns typical of the wetland biome are rare. In contrast , the microfloral assemblage is dominated by fern spores, with lesser lycopsid spores and cordaitalean pollen. The succession indicates that the dryland biome predominated during late regression, prior to the onset of perhumid conditions that resulted in peat accumulation at late lowstand. However, the abundance of palynomorphs from wetland vegetation implies gradual fragmentation of the prevailing dryland flora and replacement by the wetland biome in the transition to glacial maximum. The taphonomic and paleobiogeographic context confirms that floras adapted to seasonal moisture deficit periodically dispersed into tropical lowlands, rather than being transported from 'extrabasinal' or 'upland' environments. The precocious occurrence of Taeniopteris, more typical of Late Pennsylvanian and Permian floras, may be the earliest record of the fossil-genus, and exemplifies the association of derived plant taxa with dryland habitats. The predominance of broad-leaved gymnosperms with mesic to xeric characters suggests that dryland communities contained more slow-growing and long-lived plants than contemporaneous wetland floras.
    Research Interests:
    —Taxonomic analysis is provided for a Middle Pennsylvanian macrofloral assemblage collected from clastic wetland deposits in Clay County, Indiana, on the eastern margin of the Illinois Basin. Adpressed plant fossils were recovered from... more
    —Taxonomic analysis is provided for a Middle Pennsylvanian macrofloral assemblage collected from clastic wetland deposits in Clay County, Indiana, on the eastern margin of the Illinois Basin. Adpressed plant fossils were recovered from four distinct beds in the lowermost Staunton Formation, positioned above the Minshall Coal (uppermost Brazil Formation), part of a succession deposited near the Atokan-Desmoinesian boundary. The assemblage of 22 fossil-taxa is dominated by pteridosperms (including Neuropteris flexuosa, Macroneuropteris scheuchzeri, Alethopteris densinervosa, Neuropteris ovata, Eusphenopteris neuropteroides, and Neuropteris missouriensis) with lesser cordaitaleans (Cordaites spp. indet.) and sphenopsids (particularly Sphenophyllum cuneifo-lium). Lycopsids are uncommon, and ferns are rare. In contrast, the microfloral assemblage from the Minshall Coal and overlying clastic units is dominated by lycopsid and tree fern spores. Comparisons with established biozonation schemes yield different ages depending on the regional biostratigraphic framework used: (1) latest Bolsovian (Radiizonates difformis Biozone, American microfloras); (2) latest Bolsovian or earliest Asturian ('Neuropteris' rarinervis Biozone, Appalachian Basin macrofloras); or (3) earliest Asturian (Linopteris obliqua Biozone, European macrofloras). The placement and correlation of the Bolsovian-Asturian and Atokan-Desmoinesian boundaries, which have traditionally been equated by palynology, are evaluated in the context of this discordance. Several revised stratigraphic scenarios are proposed for this interval in the Illinois Basin, which is being increasingly recognized as a time of significant environmental change throughout Euramerica. Homotaxial comparisons with European macro-floral assemblages indicate that, of the 18 biological taxa recorded, between 14 and 17 (78–94%) also are common in coeval wetland deposits in Europe. The similarities exemplify the spatial conservatism and low diversity of wetland plant communities over vast areas of tropical Euramerica, a manifestation of the intrinsically stressful conditions that characterize such habitats, and indicates that neither the Laurentian Shield nor the Appalachian-Variscan Mountains were an insurmountable barrier to plant dispersal during the Middle Pennsylvanian.
    Research Interests:
    Abstract—The only known coal bed in the Late Pennsylvanian Bursum Formation crops out in Carrizo Arroyo, Valencia County, New Mexico. Biozonation using fossils of conodonts, insects and plants suggests a latest Pennsylvanian age. The coal... more
    Abstract—The only known coal bed in the Late Pennsylvanian Bursum Formation crops out in Carrizo Arroyo, Valencia County, New Mexico. Biozonation using fossils of conodonts, insects and plants suggests a latest Pennsylvanian age. The coal was first reported by Darton in 1928, and palynofloras have been previously obtained from strata below and above it. Associated megaflora was noted but not illustrated. Here, we re-describe the coal-bearing interval in detail, describe and illustrate a palynoflora from the coal and some elements of the megaflora from above and below it. The peat body from which the coal is derived appears to have formed in an abandoned channel, possibly an oxbow lake or estuary. It is high in mineral matter and inertinite macerals. It may have formed during a widespread episode of Late Pennsylvanian tropical humid equability. This humid episode was relatively less intense in western Pangea than in central Pangea, where it led to thicker and more widespread peat formation. Long-term preservation of the peat body was likely facilitated by regional syndepositional tectonism.
    Research Interests:
    A well preserved plant assemblage at the Colwell Creek Pond locality of Leonardian (Kungurian) age provides an opportunity to evaluate taphonomic conditions in a dryland alluvial setting. A narrow channel body incised to 5 m depth through... more
    A well preserved plant assemblage at the Colwell Creek Pond locality of Leonardian (Kungurian) age provides an opportunity to evaluate taphonomic conditions in a dryland alluvial setting. A narrow channel body incised to 5 m depth through red paleo-Vertisols contains 2 m of varicolored laminated mudstone with graded layers and plant material. X-ray diffraction analysis of individual laminae indicates the presence of chlorite, illite, kaolinite, and mixed-layer clay, with hematite in red and gray layers and goethite in yellow-brown laminae. No carbonate was identified, and the total organic carbon content is minimal. The fine sediment accumulated in a shallow abandoned channel from suspension and gentle underflows, probably linked to seasonal inflow, and analysis of lamina thickness suggests that standing water may have persisted for up to a few millennia. The preservation of lamination is attributed to a lack of bioturbation, possibly linked to a paucity of subsurface oxygen, low productivity, elevated salinity, rapid deposition, or a combination of these factors; minimal bioturbation may also reflect the limited use of freshwater ecospace during the Early Permian. Clay-rich paleo-Vertisols complete the fill, with drab root traces that indicate growth of vegetation in a strongly seasonal setting. Abundant plant material in the laminated beds includes branches of walchian conifers, the possible cycadophyte Taeniopteris spp., and the comioid, possible peltasperm, Auritifolia waggoneri. They were derived from an adjacent riparian zone and preserved as 3D goethite petrifactions. Much of the foliage shows evidence of arthropod herbivory. Although a humid climatic episode cannot be ruled out, the exceptional abundance and preservation of the plants probably reflects the persistence of an oxbow lake on a relatively arid alluvial plain, where riparian plants experienced periodic moisture stress but had access to groundwater nearly year round. Rapid burial in standing water, the lack of bioturbation in the laminated sediments, and early biomineralization probably explain the exceptional preservation of the plant remains.
    Research Interests:
    Most of the morphological studies of late Desmoinesian age (late Westphalian D) coal-ball plants in the Euramerican floral province have utilized specimens from the Herrin (No. 6) Coal at the Sahara Coal Company Mine No. 6 in southern... more
    Most of the morphological studies of late Desmoinesian age (late
    Westphalian D) coal-ball plants in the Euramerican floral province have
    utilized specimens from the Herrin (No. 6) Coal at the Sahara Coal
    Company Mine No. 6 in southern Illinois. The compiled coal-ball flora of 59
    genera and 68 identified speciesis the largest known for a single mine in the
    Pennsylvanian. Quantitative analysis of coal-swamp vegetation from peat
    profiles from two sites with 12 to l5 coal-ball zones, 526 coal balls, and
    31,555 cm2 surface area of peels (biomass determinations) indicate that the
    seam is dominated by lycopods with 63 to 65 percent of the volume; ferns
    and pteridosperms are subdominants with l5 to 17 percent and 15 to 16
    percent, respectively. Sphenopsids contributed 4 percent with cordaites
    < 0.2 percent. The organ composition of the peat profiles is 35 to 47
    percent for roots, 27 to 42 percent for stems, l7 to l8 percent foliage, and 6
    to 9 percent fructifications. Lycopods and ferns are the major contributors
    of roots and fructifications; lycopod stems and pteridosperm foliage are the
    most abundant for those organs. On a seam basis the peat is largely
    composed of these genera: Lepidophloios (29 to 49 percent), Lepidodendron
    (13 to 27 percent), Psaronius (15 to 16 percent), and Medullosa (13 to 14
    percent). The most complete vertical section of coal-ball zones indicates an
    oscillating series of swamp environments between strongly dominated
    Lepidophloios forests with low diversity and diverse forests with Lepidodendron
    or rarely Sigillaria, a lower story of Psaronius and/ or Medullosa, and a
    ground story of small plants. Changes in vegetation occur in relationship to
    the five clastic partings in the seam. Sigillaria-Paralycopodites assemblages
    with the maximum fusain content for the profile occur between the most
    prominent pair of gray shale bands. Indications of two floods intervened by
    an extreme dry period are compared to the "blue band." Lepidophloios
    (prolonged standing water and net rising water table) and Sigillaria (driest
    habitat conditions) assemblages are the extremes in polar ordination of
    communities. Lepidodendron-M-edullosaa ssemblages ar variously intermediate
    in habitats and are diverse. Psaronius probably exhibits the broadest
    ecological amplitude. Dominance diversity curves of representative assemblages
    are illustrated. The paleoecology of the two sites differs significantly
    in thickness and number of coal-ball zones, relative abundances of aerial and
    root composition, and percent volume of Lepidophloios and Lepidodendron scleroticum.
    Beta-diversity values for the two sites are 2.4 to 3.1. The field
    relations of coal-ball zones, clastic bands, major fusain and pyrite occurrences and the continuity and preservational qualities of the vegetation are
    consistent with independent coal -ball formation from the bottom most coal -
    ball zone upward in a recurrent series of permineralizing episodes.
    Research Interests:
    Fossils found in cores from wells in the Midland Basin of West Texas include several kinds of terrestrial plants and a variety of marine animal remains. Depositional settings ranged from basin slope to deep-water basin floor, hence the... more
    Fossils found in cores from wells in the Midland Basin of West Texas include several kinds of terrestrial plants and a variety of marine animal remains. Depositional settings ranged from basin slope to deep-water basin floor, hence the presence of land plants was unexpected. The fossil plant assemblage is depauperate, dominated by Germaropteris martinsii, a Permian-age peltasperm. Other specimens include the peltasperm Supaia, Sphenopteris germanica, axes of uncertain affinity, and incertae sedis remains presumed to be terrestrial plants. Fossil plants are found predominantly in fine-grained, siliceous mudrocks between coarser-grained calcareous floatstones and wackestones/packstones interpreted as debrites and turbidites, suggesting that the plants were carried from land by surface currents before sinking to the basin floor and being buried by slowly accumulating hemipelagic sediment. Specimens were examined from drillcores in 14 wells spanning an interval from the lower Wolfcamp through the lower Leonard. This record of G. martinsii in lower Permian Wolfcamp rocks is among the earliest occurrences of these plants, which have been found most abundantly in upper Permian strata of Western Europe.
    Research Interests:
    Six late Atokan (early Asturian) floras from seasonally dry environments are described and quantitatively analyzed from adpressions and palynomorphs. Collections are from the eastern margin of the Illinois Basin, USA, in an 80 km N-S... more
    Six late Atokan (early Asturian) floras from seasonally dry environments are described and quantitatively analyzed from adpressions and palynomorphs. Collections are from the eastern margin of the Illinois Basin, USA, in an 80 km N-S transect. Plant fossils occur in sedimentary rocks below the underclay (paleosol) of the Minshall-Buffaloville Coal Member (thus, not “roof-shale” assemblages), uppermost Brazil Formation. Growth of floras under seasonal dryness is indicated by outcrop and lithological features that suggest deposition in flashy discharge streams, including intraformational conglomerates, plant fossils that cross bedding planes indicating rapid, episodic burial, and local rhythmically laminated sediments. Common charcoal clasts are consistent with seasonal climate. Cordaitalean foliage dominates the macroflora, accompanied by the dryland elements Lesleya sp., Taeniopteris sp. cf. T. multinervia, and Sphenopteridium sp. Two unusual forms of foliage are presumed to be rare or novel dryland species. Small numbers of wetland/periwetland taxa include calamitaleans, Linopteris neuropteroides, Karinopteris/Eusphenopteris sp., marattialean fern foliage, Senftenbergia plumosa, cf. Zeilleria avoldensis and Sphenopteris sp. The palynoflora is dominated by marattialean tree ferns, wetland plants with broad dispersal capacities and environmental tolerances. Subdominant elements also have strong wetland affinities: arborescent lycopsids, calamitaleans, small ferns.  Cordaitalean pollen is relatively uncommon.  Palynoflora-macroflora mismatches may reflect primary ecology, palynomorph reworking, or both.  The occurrence of these floras near the Atokan-Desmoinesian (~Bolsovian-Asturian) boundary coincides with an array of physical and geochemical data that indicate change from weak rainfall seasonality to marked seasonality at all phases of glacial-interglacial cycles reflected prominently in the stratigraphic record from the localities studied.
    Research Interests:
    Saltational evolution, a much abused term, is here narrowly defined as a genetic modification that is expressed as a profound phenotypic change across a single generation and results in a potentially independent evolutionary lineage... more
    Saltational evolution, a much abused term, is here narrowly defined as a genetic
    modification that is expressed as a profound phenotypic change across a single generation
    and results in a potentially independent evolutionary lineage (prospecies: 'hopeful
    monster' of Richard Goldschmidt). Dichotomous saltation is driven by mutation
    within a single ancestral lineage, and can result not only in instantaneous speciation
    but also in the simultaneous origin of a supraspecific taxon. Reticulate saltation is
    driven by allopolyploidy and thus incorporates genes of fwo ancestral lineages; it
    results in speciation only. Several exceptionally rapid but multigenerational evolutionary
    mechanisms are collectively termed parasaltational. Saltational evolutionary mechanisms
    probably generated many vascular plant species and most higher taxa.
    Hypotheses of saltation can be falsified using cladograms, which also provide an
    essential context for interpretations of evolutionary process as well as pattern - here
    illustrated using studies of evolutionary developmental change in architectures of
    fossil lycopsids and living angiosperms.
    The neoGoldschmidtian synthesis advocated here accepts Goldschmidt's concept
    of speciation across a single generation but rejects his preferred causal mechanism
    of large-scale mutations and his requirement for competitively high levels of fitness
    in the monsters. Rather, we postulate that vast numbers of hopeful monsters are continuously
    generated by mutation of key homoeotic genes that control ontogeny via
    morphogens ('D-genes' of Wallace Arthur). The fitness of hopeful monsters is inevitably
    too low to survive competition-mediated selection - their establishment requires
    temporary release from selection in unoccupied niches. The prospecies can then be
    honed to competitive fitness by gradual reintroduction to neodarwinian selection.
    When viewed backward through geological time, niches become less well-defined
    and more often vacant, causing a corresponding increase in the probability of successful
    establishment of hopeful monsters. Hence, saltation was most important among
    the earliest land plants, explaining the Siluro-Devonian origins of all class-level taxa.
    Although D-genes are similar at the molecular level across the biotic kingdoms, their
    phenotypic expression differs between higher plants and higher animals; this reflects
    highly contrasting modes of growth, notably the Iocalization of plant growth in
    numerous meristems and consequent continuous, largely iterative development. More
    importantly, the sessile life-style of plants renders competition indirect and environmentally
    mediated; thus, vectorial selection is a far less profound cause of evolution
    in plants than in animals. Plants enjoy much greater latitude for nonlethal experimentation
    in form by saltation. Future advances in the study of evolutionary mechanisms
    will require cladograms that use phenotypically expressed genes as characters, rather
    than static morphology or cryptic base pairs, thereby allowing reciprocal illumination
    between phenotype and genotype.
    Research Interests:
    Roof facies of widespread, Pennsylvanian Period, economically important coals in the Eastern Interior Coal Basin (Illinois Basin) commonly exhibit evidence of extensive and cataclysmic tidal sedimentation during rapid marine‐flooding... more
    Roof facies of widespread, Pennsylvanian Period, economically important coals in the
    Eastern Interior Coal Basin (Illinois Basin) commonly exhibit evidence of extensive
    and cataclysmic tidal sedimentation during rapid marine‐flooding events. Upright
    Trees and smaller plants were covered and entombed by swiftly deposited, thin‐bedded
    and laminated mud and sand. This facies has historically been interpreted as fluvialstyle
    cross bedding. Detailed examination clearly shows that these facies consist of
    inclined heterolith stratifications (IHS). Entire forests of upright trunks have been
    documented
    in the roof strata of surface and underground coal mines. Detailed sedimentological
    analyses of mine‐roof facies indicate a pervasive and significant tidal
    influence. In some cases, daily and semi‐monthly tidal periods have been preserved
    within laminated facies (‘tidal rhythmites’). Based upon modern analogues, the tidal
    facies are indicative of hypertidal conditions. The hyper‐dynamic tidal regime resulted
    in rapid sediment accumulation, particularly along pre‐existing drainages within the
    ancient coastal swamp. Stratigraphic successions indicate a recurring pattern of very
    rapid change from widespread coal‐swamp conditions to tidally‐influenced deposition.
    The repetition of these stratigraphic phenomena throughout the Pennsylvanian
    Period suggests significant external controls on sea‐level, probably related to Gondwanan
    deglaciations and resultant large‐scale meltwater pulses. Despite the rapid changes of
    sea‐level rise, the hypertidal depositional dynamics resulted in conditions whereby
    inundated coastal forests were buried by tidally influenced sedimentation.
    Research Interests:
    Understanding how ecological communities are organized and how they change through time is critical to predicting the effects of climate change 1. Recent work documenting the co-occurrence structure of modern communities found that most... more
    Understanding how ecological communities are organized and how they change through time is critical to predicting the effects of climate change 1. Recent work documenting the co-occurrence structure of modern communities found that most significant species pairs co-occur less frequently than would be expected by chance 2,3. However, little is known about how co-occurrence structure changes through time. Here we evaluate changes in plant and animal community organization over geological time by quantifying the co-occurrence structure of 359,896 unique taxon pairs in 80 assemblages spanning the past 300 million years. Co-occurrences of most taxon pairs were statistically random, but a significant fraction were spatially aggregated or segregated. Aggregated pairs dominated from the Carboniferous period (307 million years ago) to the early Holocene epoch (11,700 years before present), when there was a pronounced shift to more segregated pairs, a trend that continues in modern assemblages. The shift began during the Holocene and coincided with increasing human population size 4,5 and the spread of agriculture in North America 6,7. Before the shift, an average of 64% of significant pairs were aggregated; after the shift, the average dropped to 37%. The organization of modern and late Holocene plant and animal assemblages differs fundamentally from that of assemblages over the past 300 million years that predate the large-scale impacts of humans. Our results suggest that the rules governing the assembly of communities have recently been changed by human activity.
    Research Interests:
    Organic carbon burial plays a critical role in Earth systems, influencing atmospheric O 2 and CO 2 concentrations and, thereby, climate. The Carboniferous Period of the Paleozoic is so named for massive, widespread coal deposits. A widely... more
    Organic carbon burial plays a critical role in Earth systems, influencing atmospheric O 2 and CO 2 concentrations and, thereby, climate. The Carboniferous Period of the Paleozoic is so named for massive, widespread coal deposits. A widely accepted explanation for this peak in coal production is a temporal lag between the evolution of abundant lignin production in woody plants and the subsequent evolution of lignin-degrading Agaricomycetes fungi, resulting in a period when vast amounts of lignin-rich plant material accumulated. Here, we reject this evolutionary lag hypothesis, based on assessment of phylogenomic, geochemical, paleontological, and strati-graphic evidence. Lignin-degrading Agaricomycetes may have been present before the Carboniferous, and lignin degradation was likely never restricted to them and their class II peroxidases, because lignin modification is known to occur via other enzymatic mechanisms in other fungal and bacterial lineages. Furthermore, a large proportion of Carboniferous coal horizons are dominated by unlignified lycopsid periderm with equivalent coal accumulation rates continuing through several transitions between floral dominance by lignin-poor lycopsids and lignin-rich tree ferns and seed plants. Thus, biochemical composition had little relevance to coal accumulation. Throughout the fossil record, evidence of decay is pervasive in all organic matter exposed subaerially during deposi-tion, and high coal accumulation rates have continued to the present wherever environmental conditions permit. Rather than a consequence of a temporal decoupling of evolutionary innovations between fungi and plants, Paleozoic coal abundance was likely the result of a unique combination of everwet tropical conditions and extensive depositional systems during the assembly of Pangea. lignin | carbon cycle | wood rot | fungi | lignin degradation
    Research Interests:
    This volume presents eight articles on the Pennsylvanian-Permian geology and paleontology of the Robledo Mountains in Doña Ana County, southern New Mexico. The reported research resulted from a federally- funded study of the trace fossils... more
    This volume presents eight articles on the Pennsylvanian-Permian geology and paleontology of the
    Robledo Mountains in Doña Ana County, southern New Mexico. The reported research resulted from a federally-
    funded study of the trace fossils in and around the Prehistoric Trackways National Monument (PTNM). We
    divide the overview by the main topics addressed—stratigraphy, sedimentology, paleobotany, micropaleontology,
    biostratigraphy and ichnology―and draw attention to the most significant research results. These indicate that the
    identification of glacio-eustatically driven sedimentary cyclicity in the Robledos Lower Permian strata, paralleling
    that seen in mid-continent and Appalachian basin cyclothems of Pennsylvanian age, is problematic. There may
    be some kind of allocyclic signature in the Robledo sections, but autocyclic drivers clearly were important forces
    in the local Early Permian sedimentary history. The red-bed fossil assemblages in the PTNM were early fit into
    a rather simple model of intertidal flat depositional environments, but studies here indicate much greater depositional
    complexity, and identify what are likely a mosaic of local paleonenvironments and taphonomic settings in
    which the trace fossils and red-bed plant assemblages accumulated. The Early Permian geological record indicates
    episodically increasing seasonality and climatic dryness around the equatorial regions of central and western
    Pangea, a trend that began in the late Middle Pennsylvanian. During this period of warming, terrestrial floras
    became increasingly heterogeneous spatially, and the Robledo paleofloras fit that pattern. Precise and extensive
    age data for the Hueco Group section based on non-fusulinid and fusulinid foraminiferans indicate that the base
    of the Leonardian (Artinskian) is very close to the base of the Robledo Mountains Formation. This means the
    upper part of the local Hueco section is Leonardian, not Wolfcampian as long supposed.
    Research Interests:
    The cauline and leaf cushion morphology of five species of anatomically preserved Lepidodendron are described from Lower and Middle Pennsylvanian coals of Euramerica. These species are Lepidodendron vasculare Binney, L. scleroticum... more
    The cauline and leaf cushion morphology of five species of anatomically preserved Lepidodendron are described from Lower and Middle Pennsylvanian coals of Euramerica. These species are Lepidodendron vasculare Binney, L. scleroticum Pannel, L. dicentricum C. Felix emend. DIMichele, L. serratum C. Felix emend. Leisman & Rivers, and L. phillipsii sp. nov. Lepidodendron brevifolium Williamson and Lepidodendron hickii Watson have morphologies distinct from other species of Lepidodendron and from each other. Their inclusion within the generic concept of Lepidodendron has been the major factor in the problems regarding separation of anatomically preserved Lepidodendron and Lepidophloios.
        The species of Lepidodendron comprise three distinct morphological groups with different patterns of reproduction and evolution. Lepidodendron vasculare, L. scleroticum, and L. phillipsii are similar anatomically. All were 8-20 m tall and bore deciduous lateral branches on excurrent trunks. Cones of the Achlamydocarpon varius-type were produced subterminally on the deciduous branches conferring plants with the capacity for low-level but sustained reproduction. Lepidodendron dicentricum trees were 10-15 m tall with synchronously determinate crowns. Achlamydocarpon varius-type cones were produced in large numbers near branch tips late in determinate growth - the trees were possibly monocarpic. Lepidodendron serratum was herbaceous and produced Achlamydocarpon takhtajanii-type cones. All species have non-coronate steles, ranging from haplostelic to siphonostelic in the large stems, a three zoned cortex with varying degrees of "dictyoxylon' development in the thick outer zone, and, except for L. serratum, a distinctly bifacial periderm with phelloderm consisting of alternating bands of thick and thin-walled cells and a homogeneous phellem.
        The morphological similarities of Lepidodendron vascalare, L. scleroticum and L. phillipsll suggest a close evolutionary relationship. Lepidodendron vasculare occurred in many different types of coal-swamp environments from the Westphalian A to the early Westphalian D. In the early Westphalian D, L. scleroticum and L. phillipsli first appeared in the same swamp floras as L. vasculare. This was followed by segregation of each species to a distinctive swamp depositional setting and flora, with little or no further cooccurrence. Lepidodendron dicentricum may have evolved from populations of L. vasculare, or a morphologically similar species, in the Westphalian B; L. dicentricum occurred in coal swamps up to the late Westphalian D. More morphological variability is displayed by L. dicentricum than by other species of coal-swamp lycopod trees, and each morpho-type is confined to a distinct type of coal-swamp environment. Lepidodendron serratum displays little morphological variability throughout its range in coal swamps, from the Westphalian A to the Westphalian D. Its evolutionary relationship to other species of Lepidodendron is not clear.
        Coal swamp environments may have been evolutionary refugia for Lepidodendron and Lepidophloios. Their inherent morphological conservatism, plus their highly specialized reproductive biologies, made these lycopods extremely well adapted to the aquatic conditions of the swamp. Major speciation probably occurred in extra-coal swamp environments, particularly in the case of Lepidodendron.
    Research Interests:
    The anatomy and morphology of the stem of Lepidodendron dicentricum C. Felix are re-evaluated and re-interpreted on the basis of specimens from eight coals in the United States. These coals extend stratigraphically from the Buffaloville... more
    The anatomy and morphology of the stem of Lepidodendron dicentricum C. Felix are re-evaluated and re-interpreted on the
    basis of specimens from eight coals in the United States. These coals extend stratigraphically from the Buffaloville (Indiana) equivalent coal, Cherokee Group of Iowa to the Baker Coal Member, Lisman Formation of western Kentucky. The species has not been reported previously from coals other than the Fleming Coal Member of Kansas, due primarily to the peculiar characteristics of the type specimens from that coal. The most apparent and superficial difference between these specimens and specimens from other coals isthe lack of secretory cells in tissues of Fleming Coal Member specimens; secretory cells are abundant in specimens from most other coals. In Fleming Coal Member specimens varying percentages of parenchyma cells internal to the elongate metaxylem tracheids have
    secondary wall thickenings; this zone is re-interpreted as a pith rather than the inner zone of a two zoned protostele. Parichnos is
    shown not to connect to the lateral groove beneath the leaf scar on the cushion surface as originally described. Large specimens of
    L. dicentricum have anatomy that corresponds to that of Lepidodendron schizostelicum Arnold, also described originally from the Fleming Coal Member. L, schizostelicum is placed in synonymy with t. dicentricum.
      Several important characteristics of Lepidodendron dicentricum sepatate it from other species of Lepidodendron. Pith and primary
    xylem are sharply delimited; in large specimens the primary xylem is divided into discrete units by longitudinal columns of
    parenchyma that are continuous with broad wood rays; leaf traces are ensheathed by inner cortical cells throughout their length in the middle cortex; the outer cortex consists of homogeneous thinner-walled cells rather than alternating areas of thick and thin-walled cells; the periderm originated from a bifacial cambium, which produced histologically distinct phellem and phelloderm; there are conspicuous zones of secondary, tangential cell expansion between the leaf bases that correspond to interareas seen in compressions. Protostelic lateral branches, which may be cone peduncles, are borne subterminally on siphonostelic branches that usually lack wood. The
    distribution of L. dicentricum correlates closely with that of Achlamydocarpon varius, which may represent the fructification of the plant. The habit of L. dicentricum is incompletely known; it did branch by anisotomous dichotomies at irregular intervals and of different angles. It appears to have been of greater height and more highly branched than Lepidophloios. An emended diagnosis of Lepidodendron dicentricum is given.
    Research Interests:
    Abstract—Early Permian (Wolfcampian), fossiliferous terrestrial red beds of the Abo Formation crop out in a north-to-south band through central New Mexico. Abo strata were deposited in entirely terrestrial settings and only in southern... more
    Abstract—Early Permian (Wolfcampian), fossiliferous terrestrial red beds of the Abo Formation crop out in a
    north-to-south band through central New Mexico. Abo strata were deposited in entirely terrestrial settings and
    only in southern portions of the state do they intertongue with marine rocks of the Hueco Group. Here we focus
    on fossil floras from one of the areas where this close spatio-temporal intercalation of marine rocks and terrestrial
    red beds has been recognized, the Prehistoric Trackways National Monument located in the Robledo Mountains
    in Doña Ana County, south-central New Mexico. These strata are assigned to the Robledo Mountains Formation
    and are part of the upper Hueco Group. They are laterally equivalent to the upper part of the Abo Formation
    identified elsewhere in the state.
    The floras of the Robledo Mountains Formation red beds are compositionally similar to those found in the
    Abo Formation. They are dominated by walchian conifers most similar to Walchia piniformis, a form taxon
    that may represent a number of distinct biological species. Isolated occurrences of other taxa include the
    peltasperm Supaia thinnfeldioides, the possible peltasperm Gigantopteridium sp., the cycadophyte Taeniopteris
    and callipterid peltasperms. The monotony of these Early Permian red-bed floras over a very large area is
    noteworthy and perplexing. Other facies from strata within this same time interval, elsewhere in the region,
    preserve either strikingly different floras or floras of considerably higher diversity. The red-bed floras do not
    appear to reflect a persistent preservational bias, but suggest that large areas were covered by low diversity
    forests of conifers. The proximity of the red-bed facies to marine conditions bordering the Hueco seaway does
    not seem to have had any discernible effect on their composition.
    Research Interests:
    Abstract—Among the Early Permian deposits in Prehistoric Trackways National Monument, Robledo Mountains, is a limestone-filled paleochannel in the Community Pit Formation, discovered by Jerry MacDonald. The paleochannel, which is ~ 140 m... more
    Abstract—Among the Early Permian deposits in Prehistoric Trackways National Monument, Robledo Mountains,
    is a limestone-filled paleochannel in the Community Pit Formation, discovered by Jerry MacDonald. The paleochannel,
    which is ~ 140 m wide and 5-6 m maximum depth, contains a complex fill sequence, indicating a seasonally
    dry climate, and two distinct fossil plant assemblages. The base of the channel is a limestone conglomerate that
    contains permineralized logs and charcoal attributable to indeterminate walchian conifers. The middle channel
    fill consists of multiple lenses of lime mudstone with a sparse brackish-to-marine water invertebrate fauna and a
    macroflora consisting largely of an undescribed voltzian conifer and the callipterid Lodevia oxydata; the deposit
    also contains in situ fossil roots, indicating at least sporadic plant colonization of the micritic muds. The upper
    portion of the channel fill is a micritic, gypsiferous lime mudstone that lacks macrofossils.
    The significance of this deposit, despite its low diversity, lies in the great caution it presents regarding
    interpretations of evolutionary patterns based on direct reading of the terrestrial fossil record. This is indicated by
    the spatio-temporal occurrences of the two rare elements that make up the mid-channel flora. The voltzian conifer
    is the earliest member of this evolutionary lineage yet described, extending the known range by approximately 25
    million years from the previously known occurrence, which itself extended the range approximately 10 million
    years. Similarly, the geographic range of Lodevia oxydata at the Late Pennsylvanian-Early Permian transition, is
    extended nearly 2500 km, from its previously most westerly known occurrence in West Virginia, USA. Together
    with the only other report from the Rotliegendes of Poland, it gives this species a total known range, based on
    these three widely separated and localized occurrences, of approximately 9000 km on today’s earth. Clearly,
    prior to the latest Permian, when such conifers were abundant, the voltzians were significant tropical landscape
    elements somewhere, but have been incorporated into the fossil record rarely and thus their early history remains
    largely unknown. For the callipterid, temporal continuity throughout its known range cannot be established, so it
    cannot be determined if the plant occupied the full range at any given time, or only portions thereof. Nonetheless,
    the geographic sparseness of its appearances, in light of the high density of plant remains from the sites where
    it does occur, indicate that its fossil record also is highly incomplete. Such patterns of occurrence, if used in
    conjunction with indicators of climate and environment, serve to support inferences about where and under what
    conditions these plants lived and the kinds of taphonomic factors that influenced their preservation.
    The Pennsylvanian–Permian transition has been inferred to be a time of significant glaciation in the Southern Hemisphere, the effects of which were manifested throughout the world. In the equatorial regions of Pangea, the response of... more
    The Pennsylvanian–Permian transition has been inferred to be a time of significant glaciation in the Southern
    Hemisphere, the effects of which were manifested throughout the world. In the equatorial regions of Pangea,
    the response of terrestrial ecosystems was highly variable geographically, reflecting the interactions of polar
    ice and geographic patterns on atmospheric circulation. In general, however, there was a drying trend throughout
    most of the western and central equatorial belt. In western Pangea, the climate proved to be considerably more
    seasonally dry andwith much lower mean annual rainfall than in areas in the more central and easterly portions
    of the supercontinent. Here we describe lower Permian (upper Asselian) fossil plant assemblages from the
    Community Pit Formation in Prehistoric Trackways National Monument near Las Cruces, south-central New
    Mexico, U.S.A. The fossils occur in sediments within a 140-m-wide channel that was incised into indurated marine
    carbonates. The channel filling can be divided into three phases. A basal channel, limestone conglomerate
    facies contains allochthonous trunks ofwalchian conifers. A middle channel fill is composed of micritic limestone
    beds containing a brackish-to-marine fauna with carbon, oxygen and strontium isotopic composition that
    provide independent support for salinity inferences. The middle limestone also contains a (par)autochthonous
    adpressed megaflora co-dominated by voltzian conifers and the callipterid Lodevia oxydata. The upper portions
    of the channel are filledwith muddy, gypsiferous limestone that lacks plant fossils. This is the geologically oldest
    occurrence of voltzian conifers. It also is the westernmost occurrence of L. oxydata, a rare callipterid known only
    fromthe Pennsylvanian–Permian transition in Poland, the Appalachian Basin and NewMexico. The presence of in
    situ fine roots within these channel-fill limestone beds and the taphonomic constraints on the incorporation of
    aerial plant remains into a lime mudstone indicate that the channel sediments were periodically colonized by
    plants, which suggests that these species were tolerant of salinity, making these plants one of, if not the earliest
    unambiguous mangroves.
    Research Interests:
    Natural molds of 165 stems were found in life position in a 1 m-thick sandstone bed, lower Permian (Wolfcampian), Sangre de Cristo Formation, northern New Mexico. The sandstone represents a single flood event of a river sourced in the... more
    Natural molds of 165 stems were found in life position in a 1 m-thick sandstone bed, lower Permian
    (Wolfcampian), Sangre de Cristo Formation, northern New Mexico. The sandstone represents a single flood
    event of a river sourced in the Ancestral RockyMountains. Most of the flood-buried plants survived and resumed
    growth. The stem affinities are uncertain, but they resemble coniferophytic gymnosperms, possibly
    dicranophylls. Stem diameters (N = 135) vary from 1 to 21 cm, with three strongly overlapping size classes.
    Modern forest studies predict a monotonically decreasing number (inverse square law) of individuals per size
    class as diameter increases. This is not seen for fossil stems ≤6 cm diameter, reflecting biases against preservation,
    exposure, and observation of smaller individuals. Stems ≥6 cm diameter obey the predicted inverse square
    lawof diameter distribution. Height estimates calculated from diameter-to-height relationships of modern gymnosperms
    yielded heights varying from ~0.9 m to N8 m, mean of ~3 m. Mean stand density is approximately 2
    stems/m2 (20,000 stems/hectare) for all stems N1 cm diameter. For stems N7.5 cm or N10 cm diameter, density
    is approximately 0.24 stems/m2 (2400 stems/hectare) and 0.14 stems/m2 (1400 stems/hectare). Stem spatial
    distribution is random (Poisson). Mean all-stem nearest-neighbor distance (NND) averages 36 cm. Mean NND
    between stems N7.5 cm and N10 cm diameter is approximately 1.02 m and 1.36 m. NND increases in approximate
    isometry with stem diameter, indicating conformation to the same spatial packing rules found in extant
    forests and other fossil forests of varying ages. Nearest-neighbor distance distribution passes statistical testing
    for normality, but with positive skew, as often seen in extant NND distributions. The size-frequency distribution
    of the stems is similar to those of Jurassic, early Tertiary, and extantwoodlands; the early Permian woodland distribution
    line has the same slope, but differs in that the overall size range increases over time (Cope's rule). The
    early Permian woodland is self-thinning; its volume versus density relationship shows a self-thinning exponent
    between −1.25 and −1.5, within the range seen in some extant plant stands (−1.21 to −1.7).
    Research Interests:
    Carboniferous coal-forming swamps are an excellent system in which to evaluate the effects of regional to global climatic changes on ecosystem structure and dynamics. Stressful physical conditions restrict the access of most species,... more
    Carboniferous coal-forming swamps are an excellent system in which to evaluate the
    effects of regional to global climatic changes on ecosystem structure and dynamics.
    Stressful physical conditions restrict the access of most species, creating semiclosed
    conditions in which the signal-to-noise ratio should be high. We examine patterns of
    change in coal-swamp systems during the Pennsylvanian at three levels: landscapes,
    habitats within landscapes, and species within habitats. The timing and extent of turnover
    at these three levels suggest a hierarchial organization, in the sense that patterns at one
    level emerge from interactions among elements at a lower level, and can have subsequent
    reciprocal effects on the dynamics at that lower level.
    Changes in the species composition of coals, and in the dominance-diversity structure
    they define, occur continuously throughout the Pennsylvanian. However, there are distinct
    breakpoints that allow us to recognize five basic organizational themes. Bach of these
    breakpoints corresponds to an independently inferred change in regional or global climate.
    Examination of species-level turnover patterns reveals highest values at the landscapelevel
    breakpoints, suggesting at rust that climate change may be affecting species turnover,
    which then scales upward directly into landscape changes. Estimation of the
    relationship between species turnover and habitat patterns, however, suggests an intermediate
    level of organization. Species turnover throughout the Westphalian occurs mostly
    within habitats and on strongly ecomorphic themes; species of the same or closely related
    and morphologically similar genera tend to replicate each other through time. It is the
    proportion of habitats that changes at the landscape-breakpoint boundaries, and habitats
    contain the ecomorphic elements that give the landscape its apparent dominance-diversity
    structure.
    At the Westphalian-Stephanian boundary, high levels of extinction eliminated sufficient
    numbers of species that Westphalian ecomorphic patterns were destroyed and a new set of species-habitat dynamics was established. In combination with replacement patterns
    during the Westphalian, the extinction suggests that biotic interactions among species
    assist in creating a "fabric" or multiniche system that helps constrain the ecomorphic nature
    of species replacements, whether such replacements occur through evolution within or
    migration into the system. Loss or decline of a species creates a vacant niche, whose limits
    are partially defined by the remaining biota. Major disruption of this system by extrinsically
    induced extinction permits the system to reestablish the interaction fabric based on
    the biologies of the new suite of species.
    Research Interests:
    The cauline and leaf cushion morphology of Lepidophloios trees from lower and middle Pennsylvanian, American coal swamps are described and compared with other Carboniferous specimens. More than one hundred specimens were anatomically... more
    The cauline and leaf cushion morphology of Lepidophloios trees from lower and middle Pennsylvanian, American coal swamps
    are described and compared with other Carboniferous specimens. More than one hundred specimens were anatomically studied from twenty-six localities in ten coals extending stratigraphically from the Magoffin Member, Breathitt Formation, Pottsville Group in the Appalachian Coal Province to the "Baker" Coal Member, Lisman Formation in the upper Desmoinesian Series of the midcominent Interior Coal Provinces. With few exceptions the stems are referable to one species along this entire stratigraphic range. The two previously described American species of Lepidophloios, L. kansanus (C. FELIX) EGGERT and L. pachydermatikos ANDREW & MURDY are placed in synonymy with Lepidophloios hallii (EVERS) comb. nov. which was originally described as a species of Lepidodendron. An emended diagnosis of Lepidophloios hallii is given and two taxa based on partially preserved specimens without leaf cushions are transferred from Lepidodendron to Lepidophloios as L. wilsonii (ANDREWS & BAXTER) comb. nov. and L. johnsonii (ARNOLD) comb. nov. on the basis of their cauline anatomy.
              The mature tree of Lepidophloios hallii attained a height of 10-20 m. A reconstruction of the crown suggests upright, compact, infrequent isotomous branching consistent with the lack of secondary supportive tissues in the branches. Most of the crown support was derived from the thick outer cortex. Cones were borne laterally in the upper crown and / or terminally on ultimate divisions of the crown. Specimens attributed to Lepidophloios kansanus are from the main trunk and lower part of the crown; those described as Lepidophloios pachydermatikos represent the middle and upper crown. There is no secondary xylem and very little periderm in these crown branches. Transitions between the two have been established and provide further documentation of positional differences in the tree of pith zonation, stelar dimensions, presence or absence of secondary growth and lateral branches, and depth of periderm initiation. Periderm development in Lepidophloios hallii originated from a bifacial phellogen. The size and degree of imbrication of leaf cushions are related to total size of the primary body and position on the cauline systems, hence to vegetative determinate growth. There is no evidence of continued leaf cushion expansion concomitant with secondary development of the stem. Leaf cushion morphology and their cuticles are very similar to those of Lepidophloios laricinus STERNBERG which is based on compressions and impressions.
              The most similar anatomically preserved European species to Lepidophloios hallii are L. harcoztrtii (WITHAM) SEWARD & HILL
    and L. fuliginosus (WiLLIAMSON) SEWARD. All of these Upper Carboniferous species differ anatomically and morphologically
    from the European Lepidophloios Wuenchianus (CARRUTHERS) SEWARD & HILL and L. scottii GORDON, primar ily from the Lower Carboniferous, and from the American L. johnsonii from the lower Pennsylvanian. These two groups of species, L. harcourtii and L. wuenchianus, overlap stratigraphically in the Namurian and Westphalian A. The L. w uenchiantts group is not known from coal swamp environments. The L. harcourtii group constitutes a major vegetationa! component of Euramerican coal swamps, with L. hallii stratigraphicall y complementing L. harcourtii and L. fuliginosus prior to and during the middle Pennsylvanian (Desmoinsian Series or U.S.G.S. interval C).
    Research Interests:
    As vegetation evolved during the Palaeozoic Era, terrestrial landscapes were substantially transformed, especially during the 120 million year interval from the Devonian through the Carboniferous. Early Palaeozoic river systems were of... more
    As vegetation evolved during the Palaeozoic Era, terrestrial landscapes were substantially transformed,
    especially during the 120 million year interval from the Devonian through the Carboniferous. Early
    Palaeozoic river systems were of sheet-braided style – broad, shallow, sandbed rivers with non-cohesive
    and readily eroded banks. Under the influence of evolving roots and trees that stabilised banks and added
    large woody debris to channels, a range of new fluvial planform and architectural styles came to
    prominence, including channelled- and island-braided systems, meandering and anabranching systems,
    and stable muddy floodplains. River systems co-evolved with plants and animals, generating new
    ecospace that we infer would have promoted biological evolution. By the end of the Carboniferous, most
    landforms characteristic of modern fluvial systems were in existence.
    Research Interests:
    In this essay we examine the fossil record of land plants, focusing on the late Paleozoic. We explore the nature of this record in terms of what is preserved, where, why and with what biases. And as a consequence, how it can be used to... more
    In this essay we examine the fossil record of land plants, focusing on the late Paleozoic. We explore the nature of this record in terms of what is preserved, where, why and with what biases. And as a consequence, how it can be used to answer questions posed at various spatial and temporal scales, what cautions we must consider when interpreting it, and what surprises it may hold. Generally speaking, the record of terrestrial plants is rich and reveals clear directional trends in phenotypic complexity, biodiversity, and ecosystem organization. It also has reasonably well understood taphonomic biases. It must be used with considerable caution, however, when researching time and location of evolutionary innovations and the development of ecological structure and interactions.
    Research Interests:
    Fossil plants have been collected and described from strata near the Pennsylvanian-Permian boundary in three areas of San Juan County, Utah. Collections made near Indian Creek east of Canyonlands National Park comprise mainly tree fern... more
    Fossil plants have been collected and described from strata near the Pennsylvanian-Permian boundary in three
    areas of San Juan County, Utah. Collections made near Indian Creek east of Canyonlands National Park comprise
    mainly tree fern foliage and sphenopsids from one stratigraphic level, and large logs of conifers with rare conifer
    foliage from a higher level. A site on Lime Ridge west of Bluff, Utah, yielded abundant large branches of walchian
    conifers together with calamitaleans and cordaitalean foliage. Sites in Valley of the Gods State Park, west of Lime
    Ridge, produced mainly stems, with variable occurrences of foliage. Most of the stems are calamitalean or the
    large tree fern Caulopteris, but a single medullosan pteridosperm specimen also was found, as were several small
    fragments of the lycopsid Sigillaria. Tree fern foliage, Pecopteris, rare neuropterid foliage, and fragments of leafbearing
    conifer branches also were identified. Thus, our collections contain a mixture of plants adapted to seasonally
    dry conditions (conifers and possibly cordaitaleans) and those requiring wet substrates (calamitaleans, tree
    ferns, lycopsids and pteridosperms). Red beds, dune sands, loess, and gypsum indicate aridity, on average, but with
    intervals of more humid conditions. The combination implies an arid eolian depositional system traversed at times
    by streams sourced on the Uncompahgre highland.

    And 116 more