Melanin, afrocentricity, and pseudoscience
Bernard R. Ortiz De Montellano
Anthropology Department, Wayne State University, Detroit, Michigan 48228
Search for more papers by this authorBernard R. Ortiz De Montellano
Anthropology Department, Wayne State University, Detroit, Michigan 48228
Search for more papers by this authorAbstract
A component of the Afrocentric movement has incorporated a theory that black people, including ancient Egyptians, have superior mental, physical, and paranormal powers because they have more melanin both in their skin and in their brains. By extension it is also claimed that black people have more melatonin and β-MSH in their systems and that these compounds also contribute to the superiority of people of color over whites. In this paper, these claims are detailed and refuted. A review of the genetics and biochemistry of human pigmentation shows that all humans have similar amounts of neuromelanin (brain melanin), and that its concentration is absolutely independent of skin color; that adult humans do not synthesize β-MSH; and that human melatonin has no clearly demonstrable physiological function and no relationship to skin color. “Melanists” also distort human evolution by claiming that European whites are descendants of negroid albinos. The main problems posed by this ideological movement are that it will increase the already rampant scientific illiteracy in this country, it will contribute to further widening the gap between the races, and, most importantly, it is being introduced into the public school curriculum under the guise of multicultural education. © 1993 Wiley-Liss, Inc.
Literature Cited
- Adams HH (1987) Lecture 1st melanin conference. San Francisco, Sept. 16–18, 1987. On “ African-American World View.” Detroit: WDTR, September 25, 1990.
- Adams HH (1988) Lecture 2nd melanin conference. New York, 1988. On “ African American world View.” Detroit: WDTR, October 2, 1988.
- Adams HH (1990) African and African-American contributions in science. Baseline essay. Portland, OR: Multnomah County School District.
- Adeloye A and Felson B (1974): Incidence of normal pineal gland calcification in skull roentgenograms of black and white Americans. Am. J. Roentgenology Radiat. Nucl. Med. 122: 503–507.
- Anonymous (1983) Dreams led Barr to pursue melanin. Brain/Mind Bull. 8 (12/13): 7.
- Asante MK (1980) Afrocentricity. The theory of social change. Buffalo: Amulefi Publishing Co.
- Bachofen JJ (1861) Das mutterrecht. Basel: Benno Schwabe.
- Barden H (1969): The histochemical relationship of neuromelanin and lipofuscin. J. Neuropathol. Exp. Neurol. 24: 419–441.
- Barnes C (1988) Melanin: the Chemical key to Black Greatness. Houston: C. B. Publishers.
- Barnes C (1991) Interview on “ What's going on.” Detroit: WDTR, February 28.
- Barr FE (1983): Melanin: The organizing molecule. Med. Hypotheses 11: 1–139.
- Basu PK, Manon IA, Parsed SD, and Wiltshire JD (1989) Binding of chlorpromazine to cultured retinal pigment, epithelial cells. Lens Eye Toxicity Res. 6: 229–240.
- Ben-Jochannan Y (1971) Africa. Mother of “Western Civilization.” New York: Alkebu-lan Books.
- Bernal M (1987) Black Athena. Volume 1. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.
- Bernal M (1991) Black Athena. Volume 2. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.
- Bernal M (1992) Letter to editor. Newsweek, March 9: 5.
- Berry AC, Berry RJ, and Ucko PJ (1967) Genetical change in ancient Egypt. Man 2: 551–568.
- Bloomfield GA, Scott AP, Lowry PJ, Gickas JJH, and Rees LH (1974): A reappraisal of human β-MSH. Nature 252: 492–493.
- Browder AT (1989) From the Browder File. Washington DC: Institute for Karmic Guidance.
- Brown JD and Doe RP (1978) Pituitary pigmentary hormones. JAMA 240: 1273–1278.
- Cann RL, Stoneking M, and Wilson AC (1987) Mitochondrial DNA and human evolution. Nature 325: 31–36.
- Churchward A (1913) The signs and Symbols of Primordial Man. London: G. Allen & Unwin.
- Churchward A (1921) The origin and Evolution of the Human race. London: G. Allen & Unwin.
- Coleman JE (1992) Did Egypt shape the glory that was Greece? Archeology 45 (2): 49–52, 77–81.
- Creel D, Garber SR, King RA, and Witkop CJ (1980) Auditory brainstem anomalies in human albino. Science 209: 1253–1255.
- Daramola GF, and Olowu AO (1972) Physiological and radiological implications of a low incidence of pineal calcification in Nigeria. Neuroendocrinology 9: 41–57.
- Diop CA (1974) The African Origin of Civilization. Myth or Reality? Translated by M Cook. Westport, CT
- Diop CA (1981) Origin of ancient Egyptians. In G Mokhtar (ed.): General History of Africa II. Ancient Civilizations of africa. Berkeley: University of California (UNESCO), pp. 27–51.
- Douglass WC (n. d.) Who Murdered Africa? Clayton, GA: Wm. C. Douglass.
- Dubinen NP (1975) Race and Contemporary genetics. In L Kuper (ed.): Race, Science, and Society. Paris: UNESCO Press, pp. 68–94.
- Eberle AN (1988) The Melanotropins. Chemistry, Physiology and Mechanisms of Action. New York: Karger.
- Ebling FJP and Foster DL (1989) Pineal Melatonin rhythms and their timing of puberty in mammals. Experientia 45: 946–952.
- Emiru VP (1971): Response to mydriatics in the African. Br. J. Ophthalmol. 55: 538–543.
- Engels F (1972 [1884]) The origin of the Family, Private Property and the State. New York: International Publishers.
- Fagan BM (1991) In the Beginning an introduction to Archeologyxs. Seventh edition. New York: Harper Collins.
- Filatovs J, McGinness J, and Correy P (1976): Thermal and electronic contributions to switching in melanins. Biopolymers 15: 2309–2312.
- Finch CS (1990) The African Background to Medical Science. London: Karnak House.
- Garber SR, Furner CW, Creel D and Witkop CJ (1982): Auditory system abnormalities in human albinos. Ear Hear. 3: 207–210.
- Gibbons A (1992) Mitochondrial Eve: Wounded but not dead yet. Science 257: 873–875.
- Graham DG (1979) On the origin and significance of neuromelanin. Arch. Pathol. Lab. Med. 103: 359–362.
- Griaule M and Dieterlen G (1950) Un systeme soudanais de Sirius. J. Soc. Africanistes 20: 273–294.
10.3406/jafr.1950.2611 Google Scholar
- Griaule M and Dieterlen G (1965) Le Renard Pale. Volume 1, fascicule 1: Le Mythe Cosmogonique: La Creation du Monde. Paris: Travaux et Memoires de l'Institut d'Ethnologie.
- Hale BD et al. (1980) Iris pigmentation and fractionated reaction and reflex time. Biol. Psychol. 10: 57–67.
- Hassan FA (1988) The predynastic of Egypt. J. World Prehist. 2: 135–185.
- Hastings MH, Vance G, and Maywood E (1989) Phylogeny and function of the pineal. Experientia 45: 903–908.
- Hearing VJ and Tsukamoto K (1991): Enzymatic control of pigmentation in mammals. FASEB J. 5: 2902–2909.
- Hedges SB, Kumar S, Tamura K, and Stoneking M (1992) Human origins and analysis of mitochondrial DNA sequences. Science 225: 737–739.
- Hines T (1988) Pseudoscience and the paranormal. Buffalo: Prometheus Books.
- James GGM (1988 [1954]) Stolen Legacy. San Francisco: Julian Richardson Associates.
- Kastin AJ, Kuzemchak B, Tompkins RG, Schally AV, and Miller MC (1976): Melanin in the rat brain. Brain Res. Bull. 1: 567–572.
- Kastin AJ, Kuzemchak B, Schally AV, and Eggert MW (1979): Rat brain melanin at different ages and after various treatments. Brain Res. Bull. 4: 793–797.
- Keita SOY (1990) Studies of ancient crania from northern Africa. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 83: 35–48.
- Kelly DH (1991) Egyptians and Ethiopians: Color, race, and racism. The Classical Outlook, Spring: 77–82.
- King R (1990) African Origin of Biological Psychiatry. Germantown, TN: Seymour Smith.
- King R (1991a) “ African-American World View.” Detroit: WDTR, June 4.
- King R (1991b) Lecture 5th melanin conference. Los Angeles, April 19–21, 1991. On “ African-American world View.” Detroit: WDTR, April 30.
- Klag MJ, Whelton PK, Curesh AB, Grim CE, and Kuller LH (1991) The association of skin color with blood pressure in U. S. Blacks with low socioeconomic status. JAMA 255: 599–602.
- Klein DC (1984) Melatonin and puberty. Science 224: 6.
- Kollias N, Sayres RM, Zeise L, and Chokodel MR (1988): Photoprotection by melanin. J. Photochem. Photobiol. 19: 135–150.
- Kunjufu J (1989) “ African American World View.” Detroit: WDTR, May 9.
- Landers DM, Obermeier GE, and Patterson AH (1976) Iris pigmentation and reactive motor performance. J. Motor Behav. 8: 171–179.
- Latter BDH (1980) Genetic differences within and between populations of the major human subgroups. Am. Naturalist 116: 220–237.
- Levine MM (1992) The use and abuse of Black Athena. Am. Hist. Rev. 97 (2): 440–464.
- Lewontin RC (1972) The apportionment of human diversity. Hum. Genet. 6: 381–398.
- Lindquist NG (1973): Accumulation of drugs on melanin. Acta Radiol. [Suppl.] (Stockh.) 325: 1–92.
- Livingston FB (1969)xs Polygenic models for the evolution of human skin color differences. Hum. Biol. 8: 480–493.
- Lowry ME (1984) Phonon-electron coupling as a possible transducing mechanism in bioelectronic processes involving neuromelanin. J. Theor. Biol. 111: 201–204.
- Lowry PJ (1988) The Melanotropic Peptides. An introduction. In ME Hadley (ed.): The melanotropic peptides. Volume 1. Boca Raton: CRC Press, pp. 1–2.
- MacPherson P, and Matheson MS (1979) Comparison of calcification of pineal, habenular commisure, and choroid plexus on plainfilms and computed tomography. Neuroradiology 18: 67–72.
- Maine H (1861) Ancient law. London: J. Murray.
- Mann DM and Yates PO (1974) Lipoprotein pigments—their relationship to ageing in the human nervous system. Brain 97: 489–498.
- Marsden CD (1961) Pigmentation in the nucleus substantiae nigrae of mammals. J. Anat. 95: 256–261.
- Marsden CD (1983) Neuromelanin and Parkinson's disease. J. Neural Trans. [Suppl.] 19: 121–141.
- Massey G (1907) Ancient Egypt: The Light of the World. Two volumes. London: T. Fisher Unwin.
- McGinness J, Corry P, and Proctor P (1974): Amorphous semiconductors switching in melanins. Science 183: 853–855.
- Montgomery B (1989) Readings from “ black dot black seed” by Richard King. Detroit: WDTR, April 18.
- Mugandi SG and Poltera AA (1976): Pineal calcification (PGC) in Ugandans. Br. J. Radiol. 49: 594–599.
- Nobles W (1989) Lecture. On “ African-American World View.” Detroit: WDTR, June 27.
- Nordlund JJ and Lerner AB (1977): The effect of oral melatonin on skin color and on the release of pituitary hormones. J. Clin. Endocrinol. Metab. 45: 768–774.
- O'Connor D (1971) Ancient Egypt and black Africa-early contacts. Expedition 14 (1): 2–9.
- Ortiz de Montellano BR (1991) Multicultural pseudoscience. Spreading scientific illiteracy among minorities. Skeptical Inquirer 16 (Fall): 46–50.
- Ortiz de Montellano BR (1992) Avoiding egyptocentric pseudoscience: Colleges must help set standards for schools. Chronicle of Higher Education (March 25): B1.
- Pasteur AA and Toldson IL (1982) Roots of soul. New York: Anchor Doubleday.
- Perry WJ (1923) The children of the sun: A Study in the Early History of Civilization. New York: E. P. Dutton & Co.
- Perry WJ (1937) The Growth of civilization. Second edition. Hammondsworth, Middlesex: Penguin Books.
- Pfeiffer CC and Mailloux RJ (1989): Hypertension: Heavy metal useful cations and melanin as a possible repositor. Med. Hypotheses 25: 125–130.
- Potts AM (1976) The affinity of melanin for inorganic ions. Exp. Eye Res. 22: 487–491.
- Prota G (1980) Recent advances in the chemistry of melanogenesis in mammals. J. Invest. Dermatol. 75: 122–127.
- Quevedo WC, Fitzpatrick TB, Szabo G, and Limbow K (1987) Biology of melanocytes. In TB Fitzpatrick, HZ Eisen, K Wolff, IM Friedberg, and KF Austen (eds.): Dermatology in general medicine. Third edition. New York: McGraw Hill, pp. 224–251.
- Ralph MR (1989) The rhyth maker. Pinpointing the master clock in mammals. The Sciences (Nov./Dec.).
- Riley RA (1988) Radicals in melanin biochemistry. Ann. NY Acad. Sci. 551: 111–119.
- Relkin R (1983) The human Pineal. In R Relkin (ed.): The pineal Gland. New York: Elsevier, pp. 273–301.
- Robins AH (1991) Biological Perspectives on Human Pigmentation. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
10.1017/CBO9780511600463 Google Scholar
- Rodgers AD and Curzon G (1975): Melanin formation by human brain in vitro. J. Neurochem. 24: 1123–1129.
- Rothman MA (1988) Physicist's Guide to Skepticism. Buffalo: Prometheus Books.
- Sizonenko PC, Lang U, and Aubert ML (1982) Neuroendocrinology of puberty. Role of melatonin in man. Ann. Endocrinol 43 (6): 453–464.
- Smith GE (1923) The ancient egyptians and the Origins of Civilization. Second edition. New York: Harper & Bros.
- Snowden FM (1970) Blacks in antiquity. Ethiopians in Greco-Roman Experience. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
- Snowden FM (1989) Bernal's ‘blacks,’ Herodotus, and other classical evidence. Arethusa Special Issue (Fall): 83–93.
- Snowden FM (1992) Whither afrocentrism? Descant (Georgetown University) Winter: 8–9.
- Stern C (1970): Model estimates of the number of gene pairs involved in pigmentation variability of the negro American. Hum. Hered. 20: 165–168.
- Stewart N (1988) Lecture 2nd annual melanin conference. On “ African-American World View.” Detroit: WDTR, February 12, 1991.
- Strecker RB (n. d.) The strecker Memorandum. Eagle Rock, CA: The Strecker Group.
- Tapp E and Huxley M (1971) The weight and degree of calcification of the pineal gland. J. Pathol. 105: 34–39.
- Tapp E and Huxley M (1972) The histological appearance of the human pineal gland from puberty to old age. J. Pathol. 108: 137–144.
- Tedford WH, Hill WR, and Hensley L (1978) Human eye color and reaction time. Percept. Mot. Skills 47: 503–506.
- Temple RG (1976) The Sirius Mystery. London: Sidwick and Jackson.
- Tepperman J (1980) Metabolic and Endocrine Physiology. Fourth edition. Chicago: Year Book Medical Publishers.
- Thorne AG and Wolpoff MH (1992) The Multiregional evolution of humans. Sci. Am. April: 76–83.
- Touitou Y, Fevre-Muntagne M, Proust J, Klinger E, and Nakache JP (1985): Age-and sex-associated modification of plasma melatonin concentrations in man. Relationship to pathology, malignant or not, and autopsy findings. Acta Endocrinol. 108: 135–144.
- Touitou Y, Bogden A, Claustrot B, and Touitou C (1987) Drugs affecting melatonin in man. In GP Trentini, C De Gaetani, and P Pevet (eds.): Fundamentals and clinics in Pineal Research. New York: Raven Press, pp. 349–356.
- Trigger BG (1978) Nubian, negro, black, nilotic? In Africa in Antiquity. The Arts of Ancient Nubia and Sudan. Volume. 1. Brooklyn: Brooklyn Museum, pp. 27–35.
- van Beek WEA (1991): Dogon restudies. A field evaluation of the work of Marcel Griaule. Curr. Anthropol. 12: 139–167.
- Van Sertima I (1976) They came before columbus. New York: Random House.
- I Van Sertima (ed) (1985a) African Presence in Early Asia. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction.
- I Van Sertima (ed) (1985b) African presence in Early Europe. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction.
- Vercoutter J (1978) The Peopling of Ancient Egypt. In The peopling of ancient egypt and the Deciphering of the Meroitic script. Paris: UNESCO, pp. 15–36.
- Waldhauser F and Waldhauser M (1988) Melatonin. In A Miles, DRS Philbrick, and C Thompson (eds.): Melatonin Clinical Perspectives. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 174–189.
- Waldhauser F, Lynch HR, and Wurtman RJ (1984) Melatonin in human body fluids: Clinical significance. In RJ Reiter (ed.): The Pineal Gland. New York: Raven Press, pp. 345–369.
- Weiss ML and Mann AE (1985) Human Evolution and Prehistory. Fourth edition. Boston: Little, Brown and Co.
- Welsh MG (1985) Pineal calcification: Structural and functional aspects. Pineal Res. Rev. 3: 41–68.
- Welsing FC (1987) Lecture 1st melanin conference, San Francisco, September 16–17, 1987. On “ African-American world view.” Detroit: WDTR, September 5 and 12, 1989.
- Welsing FC (1991a) The Isis Papers. Chicago: Third World Press.
- Welsing FC (1991b) “ African-American World View.” Detroit: WDTR, July 2.
- Welsing FC (1991c) “ African-American World View.” Detroit: WDTR, June 25.
- Williams C (1974) The Destruction of Black Civilization. Great Issues of Race from 4500 B. C. To 2000 A. D. Chicago: Third World Press. Williams JM, Schultz AJ, Geiser U, Carlson KD, Kini AM, Wang HH, Kwok W-K, Whangbo M-H and Schirber JE (1991) Organic superconductors—new benchmarks. Science 252: 1501–1504.
- Williams S (1991) Fantastic Archaeology. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
- Worthy M (1974) Eye color, sex and race: keys to human and Animal Behaviors. Anderson, SC: Droke House/Hallux.
- Wurtman RJ, Axelrod J, and Barcho JD (1964) Age and enzyme activity in the human pineal. J. Clin. Endocrinol. Metabol. 24: 299–301.
- Wurtman RJ, Waldhausen F, and Lieberman HR (1983) The secretion and effects of melatonin in humans. In J Axelrod, F Franchini, and GP Velo (eds.): The Pineal Gland and Its Endocrine Role. New York: Plenum Press, pp. 551–573.
10.1007/978-1-4757-1451-7_29 Google Scholar
- Young PA (1992) Was Nefertiti black? Archeology 45 (2 Sept./Oct.): 2.
- Yurco FY (1989) Were the ancient Egyptians black or white? Bibl. Archeol. Rev. 15 (5): 24–29, 58.
- Yurco FY (1990) Letter to Erich Martel, November 19.