Ethical convergence, divergence or communitas? An examination of public relations and journalism codes of ethics
Section snippets
Conflicting metaphors in society
A quick look at the dominant metaphors that guide our understanding of the relationship between journalism and public relations suggest a complex but one-sided view. Gandy (1982) called public relations’ generated materials “information subsidies” and warned journalists about relying too heavily on materials that were created by governments, businesses and consultants. For journalists to perform their role in society, they had to minimize their reliance on public relations provided content. In
Understanding professionalism through industry associations' codes of ethics
The field of public relations and journalism both strive for societal recognition as professions and professionalization has occurred through industry-driven associations. For instance, in public relations there are over 70 national and international public relations associations serving practitioners with education, training, and networking opportunities (Yang & Taylor, 2014). In journalism, there are nearly 250 associations across the world that advocate for members and also provide
Sample
The study examined a matched sample of codes of ethics from national public relations and journalism associations. Such a sample allows for both national level analysis of codes of ethics and the opportunity to identify global trends.
The researchers first identified a sample of national public relations associations, and then visited each organization's website to download the codes of ethics for further analysis. In terms of public relations associations, World Report from ICCO, PR Links from
Results
Overall, codes of ethics were collected from a total of 66 national journalism (n = 33) and public relations (n = 33) associations (See Table 1 for details). This sample included countries from six regions (i.e., Asia, Africa, Europe, North America, Oceania, and South America) and countries with various political and economic backgrounds. These countries share the commonality that they all have established national public relations and journalism associations and each association has identified a
Discussion
The answers to the three research questions point to two inter-related conclusions about the convergence/divergence between the two professions that facilitate the foundational information and relationships in a fully functioning society. The first finding suggests that there are both divergence and convergence in the two professions’ values and perceptions of ethical conducts. The divergence is most clear in how each field sees its contribution to an organizational-centric or societal good.
Conclusion
Metaphors matter. The common metaphor of public relations and journalism is the conflict/tango whereby public relations and journalism have divergent roles in society (Carlson, 2009, Gans, 1979). Countries with divergent public relations and journalism codes of ethics characterize this conflict metaphor. But not all countries are alike. Codes of ethics that focus on the broader, societal interests rather than the distinction between the two professions indicate communitas or a convergence of
References (65)
- et al.
How public relations works: theoretical roots and public relations perspectives
Public Relations Review
(2007) - et al.
Toward a dialogic theory of public relations
Public Relations Review
(2002) The civility of social capital: public relations in the public sphere, civil society, and democracy
Public Relations Review
(2013)- et al.
Dropping the ball on media inquiries: the role of deadlines in media catching
Public Relations Review
(2011) Enforcement dilemma: voluntary nature of public relations codes
Public Relations Review
(1993)- et al.
Relationship-building by Chinese ENGOs' websites: education, not activation
Public Relations Review
(2010) - et al.
The relationship between the professionalization of public relations, societal social capital and democracy: evidence from a cross-national study
Public Relations Review
(2013) - et al.
Review social media newsrooms in public relations: A conceptual framework and corporate practices in three countries
Public Relations Review
(2014) - et al.
What factors influence control over work in the journalism/public relations dynamic? An application of theory from the sociology of occupations
Mass Communication & Society
(2007) New perspectives of public relations in Europe
Fourth-rate estate: an anatomy of Fleet Street (No. 285)
Public relations, professionalism, and the public interest
Journal of Business Ethics
Codes of ethics: texts in practice
Professional Ethics: A Multidisciplinary Journal
The extent of ethics
Communitas/corporatas tensions in organizational rhetoric: finding a balance in sports public relations
Journal of Public Relations Research
Professionalisation and public relations: an ethical mismatch
Ethical Space: The International Journal of Communication Ethics
Principles and influence in codes of ethics: a centering resonance analysis comparing pre and post-Sarbanes-Oxley codes of ethics
Journal of Business Ethics
Dueling, dancing, or dominating? Journalists and their sources
Sociology Compass
The professional bond—public relations education and the practice
It's not just PR: public relations in society
Studying complex discursive systems: centering resonance analysis of communication
Human Communication Research
Reevaluating public relations information subsidies: market-driven journalism and agenda-building theory and practice
Journal of Public Relations Research
Ethics in public relations: theory and practice
Online journalism and civic cosmopolitanism: professional vs. participatory ideals
Journalism Studies
Evolving standards in public relations: a historical examination of PRSA's codes of ethics
Journal of Mass Media Ethics
From enforcement to education: the development of PRSA's member code of ethics 2000
Journal of Mass Media Ethics
What's the harm in moonlighting? A qualitative survey on the role conflicts of freelance journalists with secondary employment in the field of PR
Media Culture Society
Beyond agenda setting: information subsidies and public policy
Deciding what's news
Public journalism: a reply to critics
Journalism
The theory of communicative action (vol. 2)
Cited by (24)
-
The change process to agile public relations
2021, Public Relations ReviewCitation Excerpt :Agile methods usually specify such roles. The regulatory rules must also consider the norms and values of the public relations profession, such as the codes of ethics in public relations (Yang et al., 2016). Giddens distinguishes between two types of resources, which are to be regarded as “‘levers’ of social change” (1984, p. 260): Allocative resources refer to the ability to control the material properties of the environment (including raw materials, techniques and technologies), while authoritative resources include the ability to shape and transform the organization of relationships between people in society (Giddens, 1984; Röttger, 2005).
-
Tornado warning: Understanding the National Weather Service's communication strategies
2020, Public Relations ReviewCitation Excerpt :The fully functioning society is a normative theory that has been used in limited empirical research (e.g., Logan, 2018; Waymer et al., 2012). More typically, scholars have employed the theory as a foundation without direct empirical validation (Johnston & Lane, 2019; Klyueva, 2016; Yang et al., 2016). Given the literature reviewed, we ask the following questions:
-
Embracing a network perspective in the network society: The dawn of a new paradigm in strategic public relations
2019, Public Relations ReviewCitation Excerpt :To begin, a researcher must identify a set of nodes and the types of ties that connect those nodes within a phenomenon of interest. In the public relations literature, network studies have identified nodes like NGOs, IGOs, private firms (Saffer, 2016, 2019; Sommerfeldt, 2013; Taylor & Doerfel, 2005), departments within organizations (Sommerfeldt & Taylor, 2011), words in texts (Schultz et al., 2012; Yang et al., 2016), social media users (Himelboim et al., 2014; Saffer, Yang, Morehouse, & Qu, 2019; Yang & Saffer, 2018), and even citations in scholarly journal articles (Ki, Pasadeos, & Ertem-Eray, 2019; Morehouse & Saffer, 2018; Pasadeos, Berger, & Renfro, 2010). Researchers have examined how these nodes are connected by looking at their communicative relationships, interactions, co-occurrences in a corpus, following/follower relations, to name a few.
-
Ritualistic sacrifice in crisis communication: A case for eliminating scapegoating from the crisis/apologia lexicon
2018, Public Relations Review -
The Flint water crisis: An analysis of public relations as a mediator between human and corporate persons
2018, Public Relations ReviewCitation Excerpt :FFST emphasizes the capacity of public relations activities to improve the human experience as well as foster productive relationships between the organizations and individuals that constitute society (Heath, 2006, 2011). Scholars have employed FFST to explicate the societal implications of public relations practice and to illuminate public relations’ ethical purposes (Boyd & Waymer, 2011; Heath, 2011; Taylor, 2011; Waymer, Cannon & Curry, 2012; Yang, Taylor, & Saffer, 2016). Describing the role of public relations in society using FFST, Heath (2006) wrote:
-
The European right to be forgotten: A challenge to the United States Constitution's First Amendment and to professional public relations ethics
2017, Public Relations ReviewCitation Excerpt :For example, the public relations industry successfully argued regulation for video news releases could have a chilling effect on open communication and work against providing the public with vital, interesting information from myriad points of view and sources (PRSA, 2005). It has been asserted that journalists and public relation professionals perform vital roles in a fully functioning society by virtue of providing information to citizens and assisting relationship formation across social, economic, and political sectors (Yang, Taylor & Saffer, 2016). In light of this vital role, professional communicators are urged to reject the right to be forgotten for its effrontery on the marketplace of ideas.