Can Stereotype Threat Explain the Gender Gap in Mathematics Performance and Achievement?
Abstract
Men and women score similarly in most areas of mathematics, but a gap favoring men is consistently found at the high end of performance. One explanation for this gap, stereotype threat, was first proposed by Spencer, Steele, and Quinn (1999) and has received much attention. We discuss merits and shortcomings of this study and review replication attempts. Only 55% of the articles with experimental designs that could have replicated the original results did so. But half of these were confounded by statistical adjustment of preexisting mathematics exam scores. Of the unconfounded experiments, only 30% replicated the original. A meta-analysis of these effects confirmed that only the group of studies with adjusted mathematics scores displayed the stereotype threat effect. We conclude that although stereotype threat may affect some women, the existing state of knowledge does not support the current level of enthusiasm for this as a mechanism underlying the gender gap in mathematics. We argue there are many reasons to close this gap, and that too much weight on the stereotype explanation may hamper research and implementation of effective interventions.
Get full access to this article
View all access and purchase options for this article.
References
Baron-Cohen S., Knickmeyer R. C., & Belmonte M. K. (2005). Sex differences in the brain: Implications for explaining autism. Science, 310, 819–823.
Benbow C. P., & Stanley J. C. (1980). Sex differences in mathematical ability: Fact or artifact? Science, 210, 1262–1264.
Benbow C. P., & Stanley J. C. (1983). Sex differences in mathematical reasoning ability: More facts. Science, 222, 1029–1031.
Brown R. P., & Josephs R. A. (1999). A burden of proof: Stereotype relevance and gender differences in math performance. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 76, 246–257.
Brown University News Service. (2000). Women perform better in math when tested without men, study says [Press release]. Retrieved from http://brown.edu/Administration/News_Bureau/2000-01/00-023.html
Carey B. (2011, November). Fraud case seen as a red flag for psychology research. New York Times, A3.
Casey M. B., Nuttall R., & Benbow C. P. (1995). The influence of spatial ability on gender differences in mathematics college entrance test-scores across diverse samples. Developmental Psychology, 31, 697–705.
Ceci S. J., & Williams W. M. (2007). Why aren't more women in science? Top researchers debate the evidence. Washington, DC: APA.
Ceci S. J., & Williams W. M. (2010). The mathematics of sex: How biology and society conspire to limit talented women and girls. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
Ceci S. J., Williams W. M., & Barnett S. M. (2009). Women's underrepresentation in science: Sociocultural and biological considerations. Psychological Bulletin, 135, 218–261.
Chapman J. P., & Miller G. A. (2001). Misunderstanding analysis of covariance. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 110, 40–48.
Chrisler J. C., & McCreary D. R. (2010). Handbook of gender research in psychology. New York, NY: Springer.
Davies P. G., Spencer S. J., Quinn D. M., & Gerhardstein R. (2002). Consuming images: How television commercials that elicit stereotype threat can restrain women academically and professionally. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 28, 1615–1628.
Derks B., Inzlicht M., & Kang S. (2008). The neuroscience of stigma and stereotype threat. Group Processes and Intergroup Relations, 11, 163–181.
Erbé B. (2008, July). To the contrary. Public Broadcasting Service (PBS). Retrieved from http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qVlyJi5hwhA
Eriksson K., & Lindholm T. (2007). Making gender matter: The role of gender-based expectancies and gender identification on women's and men's math performance in Sweden. Scandinavian Journal of Psychology, 48, 329–338.
Farrell W. (2005). Why men earn more: The startling truth behind the pay gap—And what women can do about it. New York, NY: AMACOM.
Ferriman K., Lubinski D., & Benbow C. P. (2009). Work preferences, life values, and personal views of top math/science graduate students and the profoundly gifted: Developmental changes and sex differences during emerging adulthood and parenthood. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 97, 517–532.
Fine C. (2010). Delusions of gender: The real science behind sex differences. London, England: Icon Books Ltd.
Forbes C. E., & Schmader T. (2010). Retraining attitudes and stereotypes to affect motivation and cognitive capacity under stereotype threat. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 99, 740–754.
Fryer R. G., & Levitt S. D. (2010). An empirical analysis of the gender gap in mathematics. American Economic Journal-applied Economics, 2, 210–240.
Geary D. C. (1996). Sexual selection and sex differences in mathematical abilities. Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 19, 229–247.
Geary D. C. (2010). Male, female: The evolution of human sex differences (2nd ed.). Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.
Gonzales P. M., Blanton H., & Williams K. J. (2002). The effects of stereotype threat and double-minority status on the test performance of Latino women. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 28, 659–670.
Good C., Aronson J., & Harder J. A. (2008). Problems in the pipeline: Stereotype threat and women's achievement in high-level math courses. Journal of Applied Developmental Psychology, 29, 17–28.
Goodall A. (2010). Sister's winning formula. Times Higher Education, 1967, 34–39.
Grand J. A., Ryan A. M., Schmitt N., & Hmurovic J. (2011). How far does stereotype threat reach? The potential detriment of face validity in cognitive ability testing. Human Performance, 24, 1–28.
Grimm L. R., Markman A. B., Maddox W. T., & Baldwin G. C. (2009). Stereotype threat reinterpreted as a regulatory mismatch. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 96, 288–304.
Halpern D. F. (2000). Sex differences in cognitive abilities (3rd ed.). Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum.
Halpern D. F., Benbow C. P., Geary D. C., Gur R. C., Hyde J. S., & Gernsbacher M. A. (2007). The science of sex differences in science and mathematics. Psychological Science, 8, 1–51.
Hedges L. V., & Nowell A. (1995). Sex differences in mental scores, variability, and numbers of high-scoring individuals. Science, 269, 41–45.
Hines M. (2010). Sex-related variation in human behavior and the brain. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 14, 448–456.
Hyde J. S. (2005). The gender similarities hypothesis. American Psychologist, 60, 581–592.
Hyde J. S., & Mertz J. E. (2009). Gender, culture, and mathematics performance. Proceedings of the National Academy of Science USA, 106, 8801–8807.
Hyde J. S., Fennema E., & Lamon S. J. (1990). Gender differences in mathematics performance: A meta-analysis. Psychological Bulletin, 107, 139–155.
Inzlicht M., & Ben-Zeev T. (2000). A threatening intellectual environment: Why females are susceptible to experiencing problem-solving deficits in the presence of males. Psychological Science, 11, 365–371.
Johns M., Schmader T., & Martens A. (2005). Knowing is half the battle. Psychological Science, 16, 175–179.
Johnson E. S. (1984). Sex differences in problem solving. Journal of Educational Psychology, 76, 1359–1371.
Josephs R. A., Newman M. L., Brown R. P., & Beer J. M. (2003). Status, testosterone, and human intellectual performance: Stereotype threat as status concern. Psychological Science, 14, 158–163.
Keller J. (2002). Blatant stereotype threat and women's math performance: Self-handicapping as a strategic means to cope with obtrusive negative performance expectations. Sex Roles, 47, 193–198.
Keller J. (2007). Stereotype threat in classroom settings: The interactive effect of domain identification, task difficulty and stereotype threat on female students' maths performance. British Journal of Educational Psychology, 77, 323–338.
Keller J., & Dauenheimer D. (2003). Stereotype threat in the classroom: Dejection mediates the disrupting threat effect on women's math performance. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 29, 371–381.
Kit K. A., Tuokka H. A., & Mateer C. A. (2008). A review of the stereotype threat literature and its application in a neurological population. Neuropsychology Review, 18, 132–148.
Krendl A. C., Richeson J. A., Kelley W. M., & Heatherton T. F. (2008). The negative consequences of threat: A functional magnetic resonance imaging investigation of the neural mechanisms underlying women's underperformance in math. Psychological Science, 19, 168–175.
Lawrence J. S., & Charbonneau J. (2009). The link between basing self-worth on academics and student performance depends on domain identification and academic setting. Learning and Individual Differences, 19, 615–620.
Lesko A. C., & Corpus J. H. (2006). Discounting the difficult: How high math-identified women respond to stereotype threat. Sex Roles, 54, 113–125.
Lindberg S. M., Hyde J. S., Petersen J. L., & Linn M. C. (2010). New trends in gender and mathematics performance: A meta-analysis. Psychological Bulletin, 136, 1123–1135.
Lubinski D., Benbow C. P., & Sanders C. E. (1993). Reconceptualizing gender differences in achievement among the gifted. In Heller K. A., Monks F. J., & Passow A. H., International handbook of research and development of giftedness and talent (pp. 693–707). London, England: Pergamon Press.
Martens A., Johns M., Greenberg J., & Schimel J. (2006). Combating stereotype threat: The effect of self-affirmation on women's intellectual performance. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 42, 236–243.
Marx D. M., & Roman J. S. (2002). Female role models: Protecting women's math test performance. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 28, 1183–1193.
McIntyre R. B., Paulson R. M., & Lord C. G. (2003). Alleviating women's mathematics stereotype threat through salience of group achievements. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 39, 83–90.
Muzzatti B., & Agnoli F. (2007). Gender and mathematics: Attitudes and stereotype threat susceptibility in Italian children. Developmental Psychology, 43, 747–759.
Myers D. G. (2008). Social psychology (9th ed.). New York, NY: McGraw-Hill Companies.
Nguyen H. H. D., & Ryan A. M. (2008). Does stereotype threat affect test performance of minorities and women? A meta-analysis of experimental evidence. Journal of Applied Psychology, 93, 1314–1334.
O'Brien L. T., & Crandall C. S. (2003). Stereotype threat and arousal: Effects on women's math performance. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 29, 782–789.
Osborne J. W. (2007). Linking stereotype threat and anxiety. Educational Psychology, 27, 135–154.
Penner A. M. (2003). International gender-by-item difficulty interactions in mathematics and science achievement tests. Journal of Educational Psychology, 95, 650–655.
Sackett P. R., Hardison C. M., & Cullen M. J. (2004a). On interpreting stereotype threat as accounting for African American-White differences on cognitive tests. American Psychologist, 59, 7–13.
Sackett P. R., Hardison C. M., & Cullen M. J. (2004b). On the value of correcting mischaracterizations of stereotype threat. American Psychologist, 59, 48–49.
Schmader T. (2002). Gender identification moderates stereotype threat effects on women's math performance. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 38, 194–201.
Schmader T., & Johns M. (2003). Converging evidence that stereotype threat reduces working memory capacity. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 85, 440–452.
Smith J. L. (2004). Understanding the process of stereotype threat: A review of mediational variables and new performance goal directions. Educational Psychology Review, 16, 177–206.
Smith L. G. E., & Postmes T. (2011). Shaping stereotypical behaviour through the discussion of social stereotypes. British Journal Of Social Psychology, 50, 74–98.
Spencer S. J., Steele C. M., & Quinn D. M. (1999). Stereotype threat and women's math performance. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 35, 4–28.
Steele C. M., & Aronson J. (1995). Stereotype threat and the intellectual test performance of African Americans. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 69, 797–811.
Steele C. M., & Aronson J. A. (2004). Stereotype threat does not live by Steele and Aronson (1995) alone. American Psychologist, 59, 47–48.
Stewart T. L., Latu I. M., Kawakami K., & Myers A. C. (2010). Consider the situation: Reducing automatic stereotyping through situational attribution training. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 46, 221–225.
Strand S., Deary I. J., & Smith P. (2006). Sex differences in cognitive abilities test scores: A UK national picture. British Journal of Educational Psychology, 76, 463–480.
Viechtbauer W. (2010). Conducting meta-analyses in R with the metafor package. Journal of Statistical Software, 36, 1–48.
Wai J., Cacchio M., Putallaz M., & Makel M. C. (2010). Sex differences in the right tail of cognitive abilities: A 30 year examination. Intelligence, 38, 412–423.
Wheeler S. C., & Petty R. E. (2001). The effects of stereotype activation on behavior: A review of possible mechanisms. Psychological Bulletin, 127, 797–826.
Wicherts J. M., Dolan C. V., & Hessen D. J. (2005). Stereotype threat and group differences in test performance: A question of measurement invariance. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 89, 696–716.
Wraga M., Helt M., Jacobs E., & Sullivan K. (2008). Neural basis of stereotype-induced shifts in women's mental rotation performance. Scan, 2, 12–19.
Yeager D. S., & Walton G. M. (2011). Social-psychological interventions in education: They're not magic. Review of Educational Research, 81, 267–301.
Cite article
Cite article
Cite article
OR
Download to reference manager
If you have citation software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice
Information, rights and permissions
Information
Published In
Article first published online: March 1, 2012
Issue published: March 2012
Keywords
Authors
Metrics and citations
Metrics
Journals metrics
This article was published in Review of General Psychology.
VIEW ALL JOURNAL METRICSArticle usage*
Total views and downloads: 2852
*Article usage tracking started in December 2016
Altmetric
See the impact this article is making through the number of times it’s been read, and the Altmetric Score.
Learn more about the Altmetric Scores
Articles citing this one
Receive email alerts when this article is cited
Web of Science: 0
Crossref: 110
-
A National Study Exploring Factors Promoting Adolescent College Readin...
-
Adding Up Peer Beliefs: Experimental and Field Evidence on the Effect ...
-
A Systematic Review of the Consequences of Stigma and Stereotype Threa...
-
What does gender has to do with math? Complex questions require comple...
-
Mind the gender gap: The social neuroscience of belonging
-
Does Stereotype Threat Contribute to the Political Knowledge Gender Ga...
-
Explaining the gender gap in negotiation performance: Social network t...
-
Teaching Media Psychology
-
Expressing the self or achieving security through academic choices: Im...
-
Gender Similarities in the Mathematical Performance of Early School-Ag...
-
The sexual brain, genes, and cognition: A machine‐predicted brain sex ...
-
The uniformity of stereotype threat: Analyzing the moderating effects ...
-
Mathematics–gender stereotype endorsement influences mathematics anxie...
-
Stereotype Threat Theory in Organizational Research: Constructive Anal...
-
Gender stereotypes: implicit threat to performance or boost for motiva...
-
Stereotype threat, gender and mathematics attainment: A conceptual rep...
-
What race and gender stand for: using Markov blankets to identify cons...
-
Gender differences in mathematics achievement: A secondary analysis of...
-
Investigating the importance of girls’ mathematical identity within Un...
-
Teaching Media Psychology
-
Interventionen gegen Stereotype Threat: Ein Überblick
-
Ist Wissen wirklich die halbe Miete? Überprüfung der Effektivität eine...
-
Development of children’s math attitudes: Gender differences, key soci...
-
Does expressive writing or an instructional intervention reduce the im...
-
Genre et cursus scientifiques : un état des lieux
-
The effects of activating a “baby brain” stereotype on pregnant women’...
-
The Impact of Naturalistic Age Stereotype Activation
-
Stereotype Threat in High School Classrooms: How It Links to Teacher M...
-
References
-
Mediational effect of prior preparation on performance differences of ...
-
Men, women and STEM: Why the differences and what should be done?
-
Shifting Minds: A Quantitative Reappraisal of Cognitive-Intervention R...
-
Teaching Media Psychology
-
Emotionsregulation im Kontext von Stereotype Threat: Die Reduzierung d...
-
Women on the edge of a breakthrough? A stereotype threat theory of wom...
-
A Cultural Psychological Model of Cross-National Variation in Gender G...
-
Collaborative Learning in Sociology Research Methods Courses: Does Rac...
-
The applied implications of age-based stereotype threat for older adul...
-
Explaining the gender gaps in mathematics achievement and attitudes: T...
-
Affirmation and Majority Students: Does Affirmation Impair Academic Pe...
-
The influence of gender on the choice of education: the mediating effe...
-
Tribalism in War and Peace: The Nature and Evolution of Ideological Ep...
-
The effect of first high school science teacher's gender and gender ma...
-
Ideological Blinders in the Study of Sex Differences in Participation ...
-
Warum Mädchen schlechter rechnen und Jungen schlechter lesen – Wenn Ge...
-
Emotionsregulation im Kontext von Stereotype Threat: Die Reduzierung d...
-
Sex Differences in Intelligence
-
The independent contributions of gender stereotypes and gender identif...
-
Exposure to half-dressed women and economic behavior
-
The distinct effect of multiple sources of stereotype threat
-
Stereotype threat may not impact women's inhibitory control or mathema...
-
Heterosis in COMT Val158Met Polymorphism Contributes to Sex-Difference...
-
The reality and evolutionary significance of human psychological sex d...
-
Cumulative Science via Bayesian Posterior Passing
-
Mathematics and Emotions: The Case of Math Anxiety
-
Grit
-
Gender Stereotypes in a Children's Television Program: Effects on Girl...
-
Education or Indoctrination? The Accuracy of Introductory Psychology T...
-
Pre-Service Teachers’ Views of the Child—Reproducing or Challenging Ge...
-
Does weight stigma reduce working memory? Evidence of stereotype threa...
-
Comparisons of content and scientific quality indicators across peer-r...
-
The influence of gender stereotype threat on mathematics test scores o...
-
Stereotype threat among students with disabilities: the importance of ...
-
Parental Occupation and the Gender Math Gap: Examining the Social Repr...
-
Stereotype Threat and Educational Tracking: A Field Experiment in Chin...
-
Undressed for Success? The Effects of Half-Naked Women on Economic Beh...
-
Biology and the Gender Gap in Educational Performance: The Role of Pre...
-
Embodied Harm: A Phenomenological Engagement with Stereotype Threat
-
Implicit Bias, Stereotype Threat, and Political Correctness in Philoso...
-
The effect of stereotype threat on older people’s clinical cognitive o...
-
Gender Gap in Mathematics and Physics in Chinese Middle Schools: A Cas...
-
Exploring the gender gap in the conceptual survey of electricity and m...
-
Do Gender Roles and Norms Affect Performance in Maths? The Impact of A...
-
An Examination of Age-Based Stereotype Threat About Cognitive Decline...
-
An Open Letter to Our Students: Doing Interdisciplinary Moral Psycholo...
-
Validating the proposed structure of the relationships among test anxi...
-
Expert performance of men and women: A cross-cultural study in the che...
-
Stereotype Threat and Gender: Math Performance in Chinese College Stud...
-
Do performance avoidance goals moderate the effect of different types ...
-
Rethinking Explicit Expectations: Connecting Placebos, Social Cognitio...
-
Math Question Type and Stereotype Threat: Evidence from Educational Se...
-
Social Work Students and Faculty: Testing the Convergence of Perspecti...
-
Stereotype manipulation effects on math and spatial test performance: ...
-
Twenty Years of Stereotype Threat Research: A Review of Psychological ...
-
Stereotype Threat
-
Can Incarceration Really Strip People of Racial Privilege?
-
'Membership Has Its Privileges': Status Incentives and Categorical Ine...
-
The Influence of Chronic and Situational Social Status on Stereotype S...
-
Gender differences in a technology-based numeracy intervention in a de...
-
What a Loaded Generalization: Generics and Social Cognition
-
Gender and Social-Cognitive Development
-
The Impact of Symbolic and Non-Symbolic Quantity on Spatial Learning
-
Does stereotype threat influence performance of girls in stereotyped d...
-
Mathematics for All? The Case for and Against National Testing
-
Myths about Learning
-
Sex differences in academic achievement are not related to political, ...
-
Trends in GRE scores and graduate enrollments by gender and ethnicity
-
Recommendations for sex/gender neuroimaging research: key principles a...
-
A Replication Attempt of Stereotype Susceptibility ()
-
The new science of cognitive sex differences
-
Gender-, race-, and income-based stereotype threat: the effects of mul...
-
Is There Neurosexism in Functional Neuroimaging Investigations of Sex ...
-
Concepts and implications of altruism bias and pathological altruism
-
Beyond Performance: A Motivational Experiences Model of Stereotype Thr...
-
A lesson not to be learned? Understanding stereotype threat does not p...
-
Exploring the Moderating Role of Context on the Mathematics Performanc...
-
Sex Differences in Mathematics and Reading Achievement Are Inversely R...
-
Stereotyped: Investigating Gender in Introductory Science Courses
-
Test anxiety and performance-avoidance goals explain gender difference...
-
Gender Differences in the Demand and Effects of Relative Performance F...
Figures and tables
Figures & Media
Tables
View Options
Get access
Access options
If you have access to journal content via a personal subscription, university, library, employer or society, select from the options below:
loading institutional access options
Alternatively, view purchase options below:
Purchase 24 hour online access to view and download content.
Access journal content via a DeepDyve subscription or find out more about this option.
