‘When, Where, if, and but’: Qualifying GIS and the Effect of Streetlighting on Crime and Fear
Abstract
Geographical information systems (GIS) are increasingly used in England and Wales as a tool to monitor crime and aid community-safety planning. This is despite the widely known limitations of police-recorded data on crime victimisation, and concerns about the quality and specificity of available data on fear of crime. Meanwhile, improving streetlighting is a popular strategy both for improving community safety and for reducing fear of crime. In this paper we report on research carried out in Northumberland, northeast England, which aimed to identify locations most in need of new streetlighting. First, GIS crime hotspot maps and lighting coverage maps were analysed to identify potential areas to target. Qualitative rapid appraisal techniques were then used in these areas to explore local residents' perceptions and understandings of the relationships between streetlighting, victimisation, and fear of crime. The qualitative data were used to interpret the hotspot maps further, and to inform the location and type of streetlighting interventions. The research demonstrates that people's experiences of crime and fear, and their understandings of the relationships these have to streetlighting, are complex and reflective. At most, streetlighting was held to have a marginal and even then contradictory influence on the problems of crime and fear that people face. The implications are considered. We conclude that qualifying the outputs of GIS mapping was essential in this case, and has wide potential in critical policy research to promote more inclusive knowledge and more effective decisionmaking.
Get full access to this article
View all access and purchase options for this article.
References
Abbott J, Chambers R, Dunn C, Harris T, Merode E, Porter G, Townsend J, Weiner D, 1998, “Participatory GIS: Opportunity or oxymoron?” PLA Notes 33 27–34
Atkins S, Husain S, Storey A, 1991 The Influence of Street Lighting on Crime and the Fear of Crime Crime Prevention Unit Paper 29, Home Office, London
Audit Commission, 1999 Conducting Crime and Disorder Audits http://ww2.audit-commission.gov.uk/comsafe/3_0.html
Ballentyne S, Fraser P, 1998, “It's good to talk, but its not good enough: Active consultation as a key to safer communities”, in Secure Foundations: Key Issues in Crime Prevention, Crime Reduction and Community Safety Eds Ballentyne S, Pease K, McLaren V, Institute for Public Policy Research, 30–32 Southampton Street, London WC2E 7RA, pp 164–188
Brown S, 1995, “Crime and safety in whose ‘community’? Age, everyday life, and problems for youth policy” Youth and Policy 48 27–48
Chainey S, Ratcliffe J, 2005 GIS and Crime Mapping (John Wiley, Chichester, Sussex)
Chainey S, Reid S, Stuart N, 2002, “When is a hotspot a hotspot? A procedure for creating statistically robust hotspot maps of crime”, in Innovations in GIS 9 Eds Kidner D, Higgs G, White S (Taylor and Francis, London) pp 21–36
Chambers R, 2002, “Relaxed and participatory appraisal : Notes on practical approaches and methods”, http://www.ids.ac.uk/ids/particip/research/pra/pranotes02.pdf
Clarke R V (Ed.), 1992 Situational Crime Prevention: Successful Case Studies (Harrow and Heston, New York)
Craig WJ, Harris TM, Weiner D, 2002 Community Participation and GIS (Taylor and Francis, London)
Crime and Disorder Act, 1998 Public General Acts—Elizabeth II chapter 37 (The Stationery Office, London)
Curry MR, 1998 Digital Places: Living with Geographic Information Technologies (Routledge, London)
Dorling D, Fairbairn D, 1997 Mapping: Ways of Representing the World (Longman, Harlow, Essex)
Farrall S, 2004, “Revisiting crime surveys: Emotional responses without emotions?” International Journal of Social Research Methodology 7(2) 157–171
Farrall S, Bannister J, Ditton J, Gilchrist E, 1997, “Questioning the measurement of the ‘fear of crime’: Findings from a major methodological study” British Journal of Criminology 37 658–679
Farrington DP, Welsh BC, 2002 Effects of Improved Street Lighting on Crime: A Systematic Review Home Office Research Study 251, Research, Development and Statistics Directorate, Home Office, London
Fuller D, Kitchin R (Eds), 2004 Radical Theory, Critical Praxis: Making a Difference Beyond the Academy? ACME e-book series, http://www.praxis-express.org/rtcp/contents.html
Gilling D, 1997 Crime Prevention (UCL Press, London)
Herbert D, Davidson N, 1995, “Modifying the built environment: The impact of improved street lighting” Geoforum 25 339–350
Hollway W, Jefferson T, 1997, “The risk society in an age of anxiety: Situating fear of crime” British Journal of Sociology 48 255–266
Home Office, 1998 The Crime and Disorder Act: Guidance on Statutory Crime and Disorder Partnerships Communications Directorate, Home Office, London
Home Office, 2001 Crime Reduction Toolkit: Focus Areas Home Office, London http://www.crimereduction.gov.uk
Hough M, 1995 Anxiety About Crime: Findings from the 1994 British Crime Survey Research Findings number 25, Home Office Research and Statistics Department, Home Office, London
Kesby M, Kindon S, Pain R, 2005, “Participatory approaches and diagramming techniques”, in Methods in Human Geography Eds Flowerdew R, Martin M (Pearson Education, Harlow, Essex) pp 144–166
Kitchin RM, Hubbard PJ, 1999, “Editorial: Research action and ‘critical’ geographies” Area 31 195–198
Koskela H, 1997, “‘Bold walk and breakings’, women's spatial confidence versus fear of violence” Gender, Place and Culture 4 301–319
Koskela H, Pain R, 2000, “Revisiting fear and place: Women's fear of attack and the built environment” Geoforum 31 269–280
Kwan MP, 2002, “Is GIS for women? Reflections on the critical discourse in the 1990s” Gender, Place and Culture 9 271–279
Levine N, 1999 Crimestat: A Spatial Statistics Program for the Analysis of Crime Incident Locations (National Institute of Justice, Washington, DC)
Loader I, Girling E, Sparks R, 1998, “Narratives of decline: Youth, dis/order and community in an English ‘Middletown’” British Journal of Criminology 38 388–403
MacFarlane R, Turner K, Pain R, Gill S, 2001 Streetlighting, Crime Patterns and Fear of Crime Analysis Centre for Environmental and Spatial Analysis, University of Northumbria, Newcastle upon Tyne
Marlow A, Pitts J (Eds), 1998 Planning Safer Communities (Russell House, Lyme Regis, Dorset)
Matthews H, Limb M, Taylor M, 2000, “The ‘street as thirdspace’”, in Children's Geographies: Playing, Living, Learning Eds Holloway SL, Valentine G (Routledge, London) pp 63–79
Mason D, 2000 Building Safer Communities for Children: A Child-focused Analysis of the First Crime and Disorder Strategies 1999–2002 National Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children, 42 Curtain Road, London EC2A 3NH
Mirrlees-Black C, Allen J, 1998 Concern About Crime: Findings from the 1998 British Crime Survey Research Findings number 83, Research Development and Statistics Directorate, Home Office, London
MORI, 2002 Policing and Crime: Experience and Latest Research http://www.mori.com/police/experience.html
Nair G, Ditton J, Phillips S, 1993, “Environmental improvements and the fear of crime” British Journal of Criminology 33 555–561
Newburn T, Jones T, 2001 Consultation by Crime and Disorder Partnerships Home Office, London
Oc T, Tiesdell S, 1997 Safer City Centres: Reviving the Public Realm (Paul Chapman, London)
Pain R, 2000, “Place, social relations and the fear of crime: A review” Progress in Human Geography 24 365–388
Pain R, 2006, “Social geography: Seven deadly myths in policy research” Progress in Human Geography 30 250–259
Pain R, Townshend T, 2002, “A safer city centre for all? Meanings of ‘community safety’ in Newcastle upon Tyne” Geoforum 33 105–119
Painter K, 1991, “Streetlighting and crime: A response to recent Home Office research” The Lighting Journal 58 229–231
Painter K, 1992, “Different worlds: The spatial, temporal and social dimensions of female victimisation” in Crime, Policing and Place Eds Evans DJ, Fyfe NR, Herbert D T (Routledge, London) pp 164–195
Painter K, 1996, “The influence of street lighting improvements on crime, fear and pedestrian street use, after dark” Landscape and Urban Planning 35 193–201
Painter KA, Farrington D, 2001, “Evaluating situational crime prevention using a young people's survey” British Journal of Criminology 41 266–284
Pease K, 1999 Lighting and Crime (Institution of Lighting Engineers, Regent House, Regent Place, Rugby, Warwicks CV21 2PN
Pickles J, 1995 Ground Truth (Guilford Press, New York)
Ramsey M, Newton R, 1991 The Effect of Better Street Lighting on Crime and Fear: A Review Crime Prevention Unit Paper number 29, Home Office, London
Schuurman N, 2002, “Reconciling social constructivism and realism in GIS” ACME 1 73–90
Simmonds J, Dodd T, 2003 Crime in England and Wales 2002/3 Home Office, London
Smith S, 2001, “Doing qualitative research: From interpretation to action”, in Qualitative Methodologies for Geographers: Issues and Debates Eds Limb M, Dwyer C (Arnold, London) pp 23–40
Stanko EA, 1987, “Typical violence, normal precaution: Men, women and interpersonal violence in England, Wales, Scotland and the USA”, in Women, Violence and Social Control Eds Hanmer J, Maynard M (Macmillan, Basingstoke, Hants) pp 122–134
Tien JM, O'Donnell VF, Barnett A, Mirchandani PB, 1978 Street Lighting Projects National Institute of Law Enforcement and Criminal Justice, US Department of Justice, Washington, DC
Townshend T, 1997, “Safer city centres: The role of public lighting”, in Safer City Centres: Reviving the Public Realm Eds Oc T, Tiesdell S (Paul Chapman, London)
Vrij A, Winkel FW, 1991, “Characteristics of the built environment and fear of crime: A research note on interventions in unsafe locations” Deviant Behaviour 12 203–215
Walklate S, 1989 Victimology (Unwin Hyman, London)
Williams C, Dunn C, 2003, “GIS in participatory research: Assessing the impact of landmines on communities in north-west Cambodia” Transactions in GIS 7 393–410
Cite article
Cite article
Cite article
OR
Download to reference manager
If you have citation software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice
Information, rights and permissions
Information
Published In
Article first published: November 2006
Issue published: November 2006
Authors
Metrics and citations
Metrics
Journals metrics
This article was published in Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space.
VIEW ALL JOURNAL METRICSArticle usage*
Total views and downloads: 1351
*Article usage tracking started in December 2016
Altmetric
See the impact this article is making through the number of times it’s been read, and the Altmetric Score.
Learn more about the Altmetric Scores
Articles citing this one
Receive email alerts when this article is cited
Web of Science: 74 view articles Opens in new tab
Crossref: 74
-
Neighborhood crime reduction interventions and perceived livability: A...
-
Making visible the Chicagoland suburban healthcare landscape of latina...
-
Three Decades of GIS Application in Spatial Crime Analysis: Present Gl...
-
Children's independent mobility during dark hours: a scoping review
-
Understanding the position of urban spatial configuration on the feeli...
-
A scoping review of qualitative geographic information systems in stud...
-
Ambient lighting, use of outdoor spaces and perceptions of public safe...
-
Çevresel Faktörlerin İnsan Üzerindeki Etkisinin Duygusal Haritalama Yö...
-
Optimizing the Spatial Location of Street Lights in Belle Isle, Michig...
-
Digitizing and Visualizing Sketch Map Data: A Semi-Structured Approach...
-
Outdoor heat stress at preschools during an extreme summer in Gothenbu...
-
Shared spaces and “throwntogetherness” in later life: A qualitative GI...
-
Walking toward Metro Stations: the Contribution of Distance, Attitudes...
-
“Sometimes the whole map is red”: applying geographical assessment met...
-
Qualitative GIS to Relate Perceptions with Behaviors among Fishers on ...
-
Making sense of diodes and sodium: Vision, visuality and the everyday ...
-
New nighttime roadway lighting documentation applied to public safety ...
-
The Use of Geonarratives to Add Context to Fine Scale Geospatial Resea...
-
“Is there a bubble to burst?”-college students’ spatial perception of ...
-
Mapping ambient light at night using field observations and high-resol...
-
Illuminating austerity: Lighting poverty as an agent and signifier of ...
-
The impact of the built environment on the decision to walk for short ...
-
Co-designing Urban Living Solutions to Improve Older People’s Mobility...
-
A method of identifying dark-time crime locations for street lighting ...
-
Qualitative Forschung und Geographische Informationssysteme
-
An Investigation of the Influence of the Spatial Distribution of Neigh...
-
Knowing homes and writing worlds? Ethics of the ‘eco-’, ethics of the ...
-
A Safe and Comprehensive Route Finding Algorithm for Pedestrians Based...
-
Uso de los parques recreativos en Mérida, Yucatán
-
Elderly Victimization and Fear of Crime in Public Spaces
-
Mapping sex offender activity spaces relative to crime using time-geog...
-
Litter, gender and brand: The anticipation of incivilities and percept...
-
Walk-friendly suburbs for older adults? Exploring the enablers and bar...
-
Night as Fragmenting Frontier: Understanding the Night that Remains in...
-
Community through the eyes of children: blending child-centered resear...
-
‘I don’t think we’ll ever be finished with this’: Fear and safety in p...
-
Cartographic Constructs: A Case Study of Nantucket Island Oral Histori...
-
Investigating urban transformations: GIS, map-elicitation and the role...
-
A qualitative study on the role of the built environment for short wal...
-
Reduced street lighting at night and health: A rapid appraisal of publ...
-
Safety, surveillance and policing in the night-time economy: (Re)turni...
-
Visual traffic sweeps (VTS): A research method for mapping user activi...
-
Fear of crime and affective ambiguities in the night-time economy
-
Introduction: Geographies of the urban night
-
Critical Reflection Mapping as a Hybrid Methodology for Examining Soci...
-
Exploring youth socio-spatial perceptions of higher education landscap...
-
Combining participatory mapping with Q-methodology to map stakeholder ...
-
Streetlighting in England and Wales: New Technologies and Uncertainty ...
-
Sketch Maps and Qualitative GIS: Using Cartographies of Individual Spa...
-
Crime, fear of crime and mental health: synthesis of theory and system...
-
In broad daylight, we trust in God! Brightness, the salience of morali...
-
Fear of crime and the environment: systematic review of UK qualitative...
-
Towards Qualitative Geovisual Analytics: A Case Study Involving Places...
-
Qualitative GIS and the visualization of narrative activity space data
-
Individual factors influencing the assessment of the outdoor lighting ...
-
Geospatial video for field data collection
-
Geographic Information Technologies for cultural research: cultural ma...
-
Content clouds as exploratory qualitative data analysis
-
Urban 3D GIS Modeling of Terrorism Sniper Hazards
-
Crime reduction through simulation: An agent-based model of burglary
-
Biophysical and Human-Social Applications
-
Extending the Qualitative Capabilities of GIS: Computer-Aided Qualitat...
-
Notes on the Issues of “GIS and Society”: Critical GIS as ...
-
Thinking Outside the Box: Engaging Critical Geographic Information Sys...
-
Analyzing Accessibility Dimension of Urban Quality of Life: Where Urba...
-
Qualitative Geographic Information Systems
-
Qualitative Geographic Information Systems
-
Geo-Narrative: Extending Geographic Information Systems for Narrative ...
-
References
-
Making Space for Integrative Research and Teaching
-
Participatory GIS — a people's GIS?
-
The Biopolitical Justification for Geosurveillance
-
Doing Qualitative Research Using GIS: An Oxymoronic Endeavor?
-
Critical Issues in Participatory GIS: Deconstructions, Reconstructions...
Figures and tables
Figures & Media
Tables
View Options
Get access
Access options
If you have access to journal content via a personal subscription, university, library, employer or society, select from the options below:
loading institutional access options
Alternatively, view purchase options below:
Purchase 24 hour online access to view and download content.
Access journal content via a DeepDyve subscription or find out more about this option.
