Fewer Costs, More Votes? United Kingdom Innovations in Election Administration 2000–2007 and the Effect on Voter Turnout
Abstract
There is a rich political science literature on the relationship between election administration and voter turnout but it is largely based on studies of U.S. elections. Innovations with election administration by the United Kingdom’s New Labour government allow researchers to see whether U.S. findings travel. These short-term experiments and permanent reforms have been criticized for encouraging electoral fraud and undermining confidence in the democratic process (Wilks-Heeg, 2009); being led by motivations of party statecraft (James, 2010a); or being a false substitute for real democratic reform (Hay and Stoker, 2009: 226). There is much to these claims, and drawing lessons from the pilots is difficult because of poor experimental design. However, the innovations suggest that election administration can affect U.K. turnout. The effects of all-postal and individual registration appear to be particularly significant. Election administration is therefore an overlooked variable in non-U.S. literatures on electoral participation and is worthy of further investigation by researchers and policymakers.
Get full access to this article
View all available purchase options and get full access to this article.
References
Ali A.Percival G.1993Race and Representation: Ethnic Minorities and the 1992 ElectionsLondonCommission for Racial Equality. Ali, A. and Percival, G. (1993) Race and Representation: Ethnic Minorities and the 1992 Elections (London: Commission for Racial Equality).
Alvarez R. MichaelHall Thad E.Hyde Susan D.2008. “Introduction,”M. AlvarezT. E. HallS. D. HydeElection FraudWashington D.C.Brookings Press. Alvarez, R. Michael, Hall, Thad E., and Hyde, Susan D. (2008) “Introduction,” in M. Alvarez, T. E. Hall, and S. D. Hyde (eds) Election Fraud (Washington D.C.: Brookings Press).
Barreto Matt A.Pump Barry2007. “Closing the Polls: How Switching to All Vote-by-Mail Elections Affects Public Confidence and Turnout,”American Political Science Association Annual ConferenceChicagoIllinois. Barreto, Matt A. and Pump, Barry (2007) “Closing the Polls: How Switching to All Vote-by-Mail Elections Affects Public Confidence and Turnout,” American Political Science Association Annual Conference, Chicago, Illinois.
Birch SarahWatt Bob2004. “Remote Electronic Voting: Free Fair and Secret?”Political Quarterly75160-72. Birch, Sarah and Watt, Bob (2004) “Remote Electronic Voting: Free Fair and Secret?” Political Quarterly 75(1): 60–72.
Clarke Harold D.Sanders DavidStewart Marianne C.Whiteley Paul2004Political Choice in BritainOxford and New YorkOxford University Press. Clarke, Harold D., Sanders, David, Stewart, Marianne C., and Whiteley, Paul (2004) Political Choice in Britain (Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press).
Committee on Standards in Public Life1998Fifth Report of the Committee on Standards in Public Life: The Funding of Political Parties in the United KingdomLondon. Committee on Standards in Public Life (1998) Fifth Report of the Committee on Standards in Public Life: The Funding of Political Parties in the United Kingdom (London).
—2007Eleventh Report of the Committee on Standards in Public Life: Review of the Electoral CommissionLondonHMSOCM 7006January2007. — (2007) Eleventh Report of the Committee on Standards in Public Life: Review of the Electoral Commission (London: HMSO), CM 7006, January 2007.
Council of Europe2008Opinion of the Bureau of the Assembly Prepared by the Committee of the Honouring of Obligations and Commitments by Member States of the Council of Europe (Monitoring Committee)StrasbourgCouncil of Europe. Council of Europe (2008) Opinion of the Bureau of the Assembly Prepared by the Committee of the Honouring of Obligations and Commitments by Member States of the Council of Europe (Monitoring Committee) (Strasbourg: Council of Europe).
Crewe IvorFox A.Alt James E.Crouch C.1977. “Non-Voting in British General Elections, 1966–October 1974,”C. CrouchBritish Political Sociology Yearbook, Vol III: Political ParticipationLondonCroom Helm. Crewe, Ivor, Fox, A., Alt, James E., and Crouch, C. (1977) “Non-Voting in British General Elections, 1966–October 1974,” in C. Crouch (ed) British Political Sociology Yearbook, Vol III: Political Participation (London: Croom Helm).
Curtice JohnySeyd Ben2003. “Is There a Crisis of Political Participation?”A ParkJ. CurticeK. ThomsonL. JarvisC. BromleyBritish Social Attitudes, the 20th Report: Continuity and Change over Two DecadesLondonSage. Curtice, John and Seyd, Ben (2003) “Is There a Crisis of Political Participation?” in A. Park, J. Curtice, K. Thomson, L. Jarvis, and C. Bromley (eds) British Social Attitudes, the 20th Report: Continuity and Change over Two Decades (London: Sage).
Cutts DavidFieldhouse EdwardPurdam KingsleySteel DavidTranmer Mark2007. “Voter Turnout in British South Asian Communities at the 2001 General Election,”British Journal of Politics and International Relations93396-412. Cutts, David, Fieldhouse, Edward, Purdam, Kingsley, Steel, David, and Tranmer, Mark (2007) “Voter Turnout in British South Asian Communities at the 2001 General Election,” British Journal of Politics and International Relations 9(3): 396–412.
Department of Constitutional Affairs2004The Government's Response to the Electoral Commission's Report: Delivering Democracy? The Future of Postal VotingLondonDCA. Department of Constitutional Affairs (2004) The Government's Response to the Electoral Commission's Report: Delivering Democracy? The Future of Postal Voting (London: DCA).
Electoral Commission2002Modernising Elections: A Strategic Evaluation of the 2002 Electoral Pilot SchemesLondonElectoral Commission. Electoral Commission (2002) Modernising Elections: A Strategic Evaluation of the 2002 Electoral Pilot Schemes (London: Electoral Commission).
—2003a. The Electoral Fraud (Northern Ireland) Act 2002An Assessment of Its First Year in OperationLondonElectoral CommissionDecember2003. — (2003a) The Electoral Fraud (Northern Ireland) Act 2002:An Assessment of Its First Year in Operation (London: Electoral Commission), December 2003.
—2003bPilot Scheme Evaluation South Somerset District Council—1 May 2003 Part ALondonElectoral Commission. — (2003b) Pilot Scheme Evaluation South Somerset District Council—1 May 2003 Part A (London: Electoral Commission).
—2003cPilot Scheme Evaluation St Albans City and District Council—1 May 2003LondonElectoral Commission. — (2003c) Pilot Scheme Evaluation St Albans City and District Council—1 May 2003 (London: Electoral Commission).
—2003dPilot Scheme Evaluation: Chorley Borough Council—1 May 2003 Part ALondonElectoral Commission. — (2003d) Pilot Scheme Evaluation: Chorley Borough Council—1 May 2003 Part A (London: Electoral Commission).
—2003ePilot Scheme Evaluation: Shrewsbury & Atcham Borough Council—1 May 2003 Part ALondonElectoral Commission. — (2003e) Pilot Scheme Evaluation: Shrewsbury & Atcham Borough Council—1 May 2003 Part A (London: Electoral Commission).
—2003fPilot Scheme Evaluation: South Tyneside Metropolitan Borough Council—1 May 2003LondonElectoral Commission. — (2003f) Pilot Scheme Evaluation: South Tyneside Metropolitan Borough Council—1 May 2003 (London: Electoral Commission).
—2003gThe Shape of Elections to Come: A strategic evaluation of the 2003 electoral pilot schemesLondonElectoral Commission. — (2003g) The Shape of Elections to Come: A strategic evaluation of the 2003 electoral pilot schemes (London: Electoral Commission).
—2004aThe 2004 European Parliamentary Elections in the United KingdomLondonElectoral CommissionDecember2004. — (2004a) The 2004 European Parliamentary Elections in the United Kingdom (London: Electoral Commission), December 2004.
—2004bDelivering Democracy? The Future of Postal VotingLondonElectoral CommissionAugust2004. — (2004b) Delivering Democracy? The Future of Postal Voting (London: Electoral Commission), August 2004.
—2005aElectoral Registration in Northern Ireland Summary of Research Update—August2005LondonElectoral Commission. — (2005a) Electoral Registration in Northern Ireland Summary of Research Update—August 2005 (London: Electoral Commission).
—2005bUnderstanding Electoral Registration: The Extent and Nature of Non-Registration in BritainLondonElectoral Commission. — (2005b) Understanding Electoral Registration: The Extent and Nature of Non-Registration in Britain (London: Electoral Commission).
—2006May 2006 Electoral Pilot SchemesLondonElectoral CommissionAugust2006. — (2006) May 2006 Electoral Pilot Schemes (London: Electoral Commission), August 2006.
—2007a. Advance VotingMay 2007 Electoral Pilot SchemesLondonElectoral CommissionAugust2007. — (2007a) Advance Voting: May 2007 Electoral Pilot Schemes (London: Electoral Commission), August 2007.
—2007bElectronic Counting: May 2007 Electoral Pilot SchemesLondonElectoral CommissionAugust2007. — (2007b) Electronic Counting: May 2007 Electoral Pilot Schemes (London: Electoral Commission), August 2007.
—2007cElectronic Voting: May 2007 Electoral Pilot SchemesLondonElectoral CommissionAugust2007. — (2007c) Electronic Voting: May 2007 Electoral Pilot Schemes (London: Electoral Commission), August 2007.
Fieldhouse EdwardCutts David2007Electoral Participation of South Asian Communities in England WalesYorkJoseph Rowntree Foundation. Fieldhouse, Edward and Cutts, David (2007) Electoral Participation of South Asian Communities in England and Wales. (York: Joseph Rowntree Foundation).
—2008. “Diversity, Density and Turnout: The Effect of Neighbourhood Ethno-Religious Composition on Voter Turnout in Britain,”Political Geography27530-548. — (2008) “Diversity, Density and Turnout: The Effect of Neighbourhood Ethno-Religious Composition on Voter Turnout in Britain,” Political Geography 27: 530–548.
Garcia Patricia A.Stein Robert M.Ward Daniel S.1993. Registration and the Cost of VotingEarly Voting in TexasNew Orleans, LASouthwestern Social Science Association. Garcia, Patricia A, Stein, Robert M., and Ward, Daniel S. (1993) Registration and the Cost of Voting: Early Voting in Texas (New Orleans, LA: Southwestern Social Science Association).
Harris Joseph P.1934Election Administration in the United StatesMenasha, WisconsinGeorge Banta Publishing Company. Harris, Joseph P. (1934) Election Administration in the United States (Menasha, Wisconsin: George Banta Publishing Company).
Hay Colin2007Why We Hate PoliticsCambridgePolity Press. Hay, Colin (2007) Why We Hate Politics (Cambridge: Polity Press).
Hay ColinStoker Gerry2009. “Revitalising Politics: Have We Lost the Plot?”Representation453225-236. Hay, Colin and Stoker, Gerry (2009) “Revitalising Politics: Have We Lost the Plot?” Representation 45(3): 225–236.
Heath AnthonyTaylor Bridget1999. “New Sources of Abstention?”G. EvansP. NorrisCritical Elections: British Parties and Voters in Long-Term PerspectiveLondonSage. Heath, Anthony and Taylor, Bridget (1999) “New Sources of Abstention?” in G. Evans and P. Norris (eds) Critical Elections: British Parties and Voters in Long-Term Perspective (London: Sage).
Henry Susan2003. “Can Remote Internet Voting Increase Turnout?””ASlib Proceedings554193-202. Henry, Susan (2003) “Can Remote Internet Voting Increase Turnout?” ASlib Proceedings 55(4): 193–202.
Highton Benjamin1997. “Easy Registration and Voter Turnout,””Journal of Politics59565-575. Highton, Benjamin (1997) “Easy Registration and Voter Turnout,” Journal of Politics 59: 565–575.
Howarth George1999Final Report of the Working Party on Electoral ProceduresLondonHome Office. Howarth, George (1999) Final Report of the Working Party on Electoral Procedures (London: Home Office).
Inglehart Ronald1990Culture Shift in Advanced Industrial SocietyPrinceton, NJPrinceton University Press. Inglehart, Ronald (1990) Culture Shift in Advanced Industrial Society (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press).
James Toby Samuel2010a. “Electoral Modernisation or Elite Statecraft: Electoral Administration in the United Kingdom. 1997–2007,””British Politics52179-201. James, Toby Samuel (2010a) “Electoral Modernisation or Elite Statecraft: Electoral Administration in the United Kingdom. 1997–2007,” British Politics 5(2): 179–201.
—2010b. “Researching Electoral Administration in America: Insights from the ‘Post-Florida’ Era,””Political Studies Review83357-367. — (2010b) “Researching Electoral Administration in America: Insights from the ‘Post-Florida’ Era,” Political Studies Review 8(3): 357–367.
—2010c. “Electoral Administration and Voter Turnout: Towards an International Public Policy Continuum,””Representation464369-389. — (2010c) “Electoral Administration and Voter Turnout: Towards an International Public Policy Continuum,” Representation 46(4):369–389.
Kelley Stanley Jr.Ayres Richard E.Bowen William G.1967. “Registration and Voting: Putting First Things First,””American Political Science Review612359-379. Kelley Jr., Stanley, Ayres, Richard E., and Bowen, William G. (1967) “Registration and Voting: Putting First Things First,” American Political Science Review 61(2): 359–379.
Kiewiet D. RoderickHall Thad E.Alvarez R. MichaelKatz Jonathan N.2008. “Fraud or Failure? What Incident Reports Reveal About Election Anomalies and Irregularities,””R. M. AlvarezT. E. HallS. D. HydeElection Fraud: Detecting and deterring electoral manipulationWashington D.C.Brookings Press. Kiewiet, D. Roderick, Hall, Thad E., Alvarez, R. Michael, and Katz, Jonathan N. (2008) “Fraud or Failure? What Incident Reports Reveal About Election Anomalies and Irregularities,” in R. M. Alvarez, T. E. Hall, and S. D. Hyde (eds) Election Fraud: Detecting and deterring electoral manipulation (Washington D.C.: Brookings Press).
Lardy Heather2001. “Democracy by Default: The Representation of the People Act 2000,””Modern Law Review64163-81. Lardy, Heather (2001) “Democracy by Default: The Representation of the People Act 2000,” Modern Law Review 64(1): 63–81.
Linton MartinSouthcott Mary1998Making Votes Count: The Case for Electoral ReformLondonProfile. Linton, Martin and Southcott, Mary (1998) Making Votes Count: The Case for Electoral Reform (London: Profile).
Luechinger SimonRosinger MyraStutzer Alois2007. “The Impact of Postal Voting on Participation: Evidence for Switzerland,””Swiss Political Science Review132167-202. Luechinger, Simon, Rosinger, Myra, and Stutzer, Alois (2007) “The Impact of Postal Voting on Participation: Evidence for Switzerland,” Swiss Political Science Review 13(2): 167–202.
Magleby David B.1987. “Participation in Mail Ballot Elections,””Western Political Quarterly41179-91. Magleby, David B. (1987) “Participation in Mail Ballot Elections,” Western Political Quarterly 41(1): 79–91.
Mawrey Richard B.2004Report To The High Court Of Justice In The Matter Of The Representation Of The People Act 1983 And In The Matter Of A Local Government Election For The Bordesley Green Ward Of The Birmingham City Council Held On 10th June 2004Report M/309/044thApril2005. Mawrey, Richard B. (2004) Report To The High Court Of Justice In The Matter Of The Representation Of The People Act 1983 And In The Matter Of A Local Government Election For The Bordesley Green Ward Of The Birmingham City Council Held On 10th June 2004, Report M/309/04, 4th April 2005.
Miller William Lockley1988. Irrelevant Election?The quality of local democracy in BritainOxfordOxford University Press. Miller, William Lockley (1988) Irrelevant Election?: The quality of local democracy in Britain (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
Ministry of Justice2008The Governance of Britain: Election Day Weekend VotingLondonMinistry of JusticeConsultation Paper CP 13/08. Ministry of Justice (2008) The Governance of Britain: Election Day Weekend Voting (London: Ministry of Justice), Consultation Paper CP 13/08.
—2010Election Day: Weekend Voting Consultation: Summary of ResponsesLondonMinistry of JusticeMarch2010. — (2010) Election Day: Weekend Voting Consultation: Summary of Responses (London: Ministry of Justice), March 2010.
MORI2003Public Opinion and the 2003 Electoral Pilot SchemesLondonElectoral CommissionMORI (2003) Public Opinion and the 2003 Electoral Pilot Schemes (London: Electoral Commission),
Pattie CharlesJohnston Ron2001. “A Low Turnout Landslide: Abstention at the British General Election of 1997,””Political Studies492286-305. Pattie, Charles and Johnston, Ron (2001) “A Low Turnout Landslide: Abstention at the British General Election of 1997,” Political Studies 49(2): 286–305.
Pattie CharlesSeyd PatrickWhiteley Paul2003. “Civic Attitudes and Engagement in Modern Britain,””Parliamentary Affairs56616-633. Pattie, Charles, Seyd, Patrick, and Whiteley, Paul (2003) “Civic Attitudes and Engagement in Modern Britain,” Parliamentary Affairs 56: 616–633.
Piveny Frances FoxCloward Richard A.1989Why Americans Don't VoteNew YorkPantheon Books. Piven, Frances Fox and Cloward, Richard A. (1989) Why Americans Don't Vote (New York: Pantheon Books).
—2000Why Americans Still Don't Vote: And Why Politicians Want It that WayNew YorkBeacon Press. — (2000) Why Americans Still Don't Vote: And Why Politicians Want It that Way (New York: Beacon Press).
Price-Waterhouse Coopers2006The Electoral Commission in Northern Ireland: Component of Change in the 2005 CanvassBelfastPricewaterhouse-Coopers. Price-Waterhouse Coopers (2006) The Electoral Commission in Northern Ireland: Component of Change in the 2005 Canvass (Belfast: Pricewaterhouse-Coopers).
Rollings ColinThrasher Michael1997Local Elections in BritainLondon and New YorkRoutledge. Rollings, Colin and Thrasher, Michael (1997) Local Elections in Britain (London and New York: Routledge).
—2000An Evaluation of the May 2000 Local Electoral PilotsLondonLocal Government AssociationReport 14. — (2000) An Evaluation of the May 2000 Local Electoral Pilots (London: Local Government Association), Report 14.
—2005The 2005 General Election: Analysis of the ResultsLondonElectoral Commission. — (2005) The 2005 General Election: Analysis of the Results (London: Electoral Commission).
—2006British Electoral FactsLondonTotal Politics. — (2006) British Electoral Facts (London: Total Politics).
—. “The Turnout ‘Gap’ and the Costs of Voting—a Comparison of Participation at the 2001 General and 2002 Local Elections in England,””Public Choice1313–4333-344. — “The Turnout ‘Gap’ and the Costs of Voting—a Comparison of Participation at the 2001 General and 2002 Local Elections in England,” Public Choice 131(3–4): 333–344.
Rallings ColinTemple MichaelThrasher Michael1994Community Identity and Participation in Local DemocracyLondonCommission for Local Democracy. Rallings, Colin, Temple, Michael, and Thrasher, Michael (1994) Community Identity and Participation in Local Democracy (London: Commission for Local Democracy).
Richardson Lilliard E.Neeley Grant W.1996. “The Impact of Early Voting on Turnout: The 1994 Elections in Tennessee,””State and Local Government Review283173-179. Richardson, Lilliard E. and Neeley, Grant W. (1996) “The Impact of Early Voting on Turnout: The 1994 Elections in Tennessee,” State and Local Government Review 28(3): 173–179.
Russell AndrewFieldhouse EdwardPurdam KingsleyKalra Virinder2002Voter Engagement and Young PeopleLondonElectoral CommissionJuly2002. Russell, Andrew, Fieldhouse, Edward, Purdam, Kingsley, and Kalra, Virinder (2002) Voter Engagement and Young People (London: Electoral Commission), July 2002.
Saggar Shamit1998The General Election 1997: Ethnic Minorities and Electoral PoliticsLondonCommission for Racial Equality. Saggar, Shamit (1998) The General Election 1997: Ethnic Minorities and Electoral Politics (London: Commission for Racial Equality).
Southwell Priscilla L.2004. “Five Years Later: A Re-Assessment of Oregon's Vote by Mail Electoral Process, ””Political Science and Politics37189-93. Southwell, Priscilla L. (2004) “Five Years Later: A Re-Assessment of Oregon's Vote by Mail Electoral Process, ” Political Science and Politics 37(1): 89–93.
Southwell Priscilla L.Burchett Justin I.2000. “The Effect of All-Mail Elections on Voter Turnout, ””American Politics Quarterly28172-79. Southwell, Priscilla L. and Burchett, Justin I. (2000) “The Effect of All-Mail Elections on Voter Turnout, ” American Politics Quarterly 28(1): 72–79.
Stein Robert M.Garcia-Monet Patricia A.1997. “Voting Early but Not Often,””Social Science Quarterly78657-671. Stein, Robert M. and Garcia-Monet, Patricia A. (1997) “Voting Early but Not Often,” Social Science Quarterly 78: 657–671.
Stewart John2006. “Contemporary Issues: A banana republic? The investigation into electoral fraud by the Birmingham Election Court, ””Parliamentary Affairs594665. Stewart, John (2006) “Contemporary Issues: A banana republic? The investigation into electoral fraud by the Birmingham Election Court, ” Parliamentary Affairs 59(4): 665.
Swaddle KevinHeath Anthony1989. “Official and Reported Turnout in the British General Election of 1987,””British Journal of Political Science194537-551. Swaddle, Kevin and Heath, Anthony (1989) “Official and Reported Turnout in the British General Election of 1987,” British Journal of Political Science 19(4): 537–551.
Taylor Alan1973. “Journey Time, Perceived Distance, and Electoral Turnout: Victoria Ward, Swansea,”Area5159-62. Taylor, Alan (1973) “Journey Time, Perceived Distance, and Electoral Turnout: Victoria Ward, Swansea,” Area 5(1): 59–62.
Tongue Jon2009. “Revitalising Politics: Engaging Young People,””Representation453237-246. Tongue, Jon (2009) “Revitalising Politics: Engaging Young People,” Representation 45(3): 237–246.
Wilks-Heeg Stuart2008Purity of Elections in the UK: Causes for ConcernYorkJoseph Rowntree Reform Trust. Wilks-Heeg, Stuart (2008) Purity of Elections in the UK: Causes for Concern (York: Joseph Rowntree Reform Trust).
—2009. “Treating Voters as an Afterthought? The Legacies of a Decade of Electoral Modernisation in the United Kingdom,””Political Quarterly801101-110. — (2009) “Treating Voters as an Afterthought? The Legacies of a Decade of Electoral Modernisation in the United Kingdom,” Political Quarterly 80(1): 101–110.
Wolfinger Raymond E.Highton BenjaminMullin Megan2005. “How Postregistration Laws Affect the Turnout of Citizens Registered to Vote,””State Politics & Policy Quarterly511-23. Wolfinger, Raymond E., Highton, Benjamin and Mullin, Megan (2005) “How Postregistration Laws Affect the Turnout of Citizens Registered to Vote,” State Politics & Policy Quarterly 5(1): 1–23.
Wolfinger Raymond E.Rosenstone Steven J.1980Who Votes?New Haven, CTYale University Press. Wolfinger, Raymond E. and Rosenstone, Steven J. (1980) Who Votes? (New Haven, CT: Yale University Press).
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
Election Law Journal
Volume 10 • Issue Number 1 • March 2011
Pages: 37 - 52
Copyright
Copyright 2011, Mary Ann Liebert, Inc.
History
Published online: 14 March 2011
Published in print: March 2011
Topics
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Citations
Export Citation
Export citation
Select the format you want to export the citations of this publication.
View Options
Get Access
Access content
To read the fulltext, please use one of the options below to sign in or purchase access.⚠ Society Access
If you are a member of a society that has access to this content please log in via your society website and then return to this publication.