Why Should We Abolish Daylight Saving Time?
Abstract
Local and national governments around the world are currently considering the elimination of the annual switch to and from Daylight Saving Time (DST). As an international organization of scientists dedicated to studying circadian and other biological rhythms, the Society for Research on Biological Rhythms (SRBR) engaged experts in the field to write a Position Paper on the consequences of choosing to live on DST or Standard Time (ST). The authors take the position that, based on comparisons of large populations living in DST or ST or on western versus eastern edges of time zones, the advantages of permanent ST outweigh switching to DST annually or permanently. Four peer reviewers provided expert critiques of the initial submission, and the SRBR Executive Board approved the revised manuscript as a Position Paper to help educate the public in their evaluation of current legislative actions to end DST.
Less than 200 years ago, humans organized their daily routines by the sun clock (set by the rotation of Earth), which was in synchrony with their body clock (set by our individual biological clock). Now, most of us live in cities, work mostly in buildings, use electric light at night, and organize our daily lives by a social clock (set by human societies) that is rarely in synch with the sun clock or the body clock. These new conditions challenge our health and can cause safety problems; these challenges become even worse under Daylight Saving Time (DST). In this article, we describe how the 3 clocks came to drift apart and how that can create problems.
Why is light important for our health?
Living creatures have a body clock that creates daily rhythms. This body clock organizes our biology, such as when we eat and sleep, when we can run fastest, and when our brain works at its best (Young, 2000). The body clock must be made to match our 24-h environment. In a “natural day,” the light of the sun and darkness at night are the main signals that adjust the timing of our body clock. This is true even within cities, where we experience less outdoor light during the day and more electric light during the night. Electric light can also adjust body clocks to match 24-h days, but natural daylight is usually 100 to 1000 times brighter than indoor light (Wright et al., 2013) and therefore more effective. We must recognize the important role of light in shaping our daily behavior and the important role of our body clock in maintaining our health and well-being.
Why is the natural day important?
The earth rotates toward the east. That is why the sun seems to travel from the east in the morning via its highest point near midday toward the west where it sets in the evening. Although we live according to the same clock time within a time zone (which we will call the social clock), our body clocks still receive the timing signal from the sun defined by its east-west path (sun clock). It takes the sun 4 min to cross each longitude from east to west. Longitudes are imaginary lines that run between the North and the South Pole and cut the earth into 360 even “apple slices.” The zero line has been defined to go through Greenwich east of London in England. This means that the sun rises and sets 4 min later every longitude line as it “travels” to the west, taking 1 h across the 15 longitude lines that are generally 1 time zone. Since country or state lines do not exactly match longitude lines, the time zone of a specific place may not be the same as expected by the longitude lines. Some countries (like China) have combined neighboring time zones to make their time zones bigger, so that the sun needs even longer than 1 h to cross the time zone. We live according to the same social clock time within a time zone, but as long as we still can see the natural day (through windows or on our way to or from work or school), our body clocks still follow more or less the time of the sun clock defined by the sun’s east-west path. Body clocks are later relative to the social clock in winter, when nights are longer with earlier sunsets and later sunrises (Hadlow et al., 2014; Hadlow et al., 2018; Hashizaki et al., 2018; Kantermann et al., 2007), and body clocks are earlier at the eastern edge of a time zone and become gradually later toward the western edge (Borisenkov, 2011; Hadlow et al., 2018; Randler, 2008; Roenneberg et al., 2007). Several studies found that the further west people live within a time zone, the more health problems they may experience and the shorter they live on average (Borisenkov, 2011; Gu et al., 2017; VoPham et al., 2018). The best explanation for these findings is that the difference between our social clock—set by humans—and our body clock—set by the sun—increases toward the western edges of time zones. Thus, when 2 people wake up at 0700 h for work, the body clock of the person in the eastern edge may be set to 0700 h, but that of the person on the western edge may be set to 0600 h, and the difference between the 2 clocks leads to health and safety problems.
What is DST?
Many decades ago, politicians introduced DST. DST commonly lasts from spring to autumn and changes the social clock so that we simply start the social day 1 h earlier relative to the sun clock. DST was thought to save energy because people would use less electric light in the evenings (Kotchen and Grant, 2011; Mirza and Bergland, 2011). Although this turned out not to be true (Aries and Newsham, 2008), DST is still kept to allow people to start work earlier by social clock time in summer. However, DST disrupts the relationship between the social and sun clocks. For example, New York’s social clock closely matches the sun clock in winter during Standard Time: when the social clock says it is noon, it is very close to midday, the sun’s highest point in the sky. During DST, however, New York’s social clock shows noon when it is only 1100 h by the sun clock. People who have to get up at 0600 h by the sun clock in winter have to get up at 0500 h by the sun clock under DST, despite the social clock showing 0600 h. Essentially, they have to go to work in 1 time zone further to the east. This means that people in Chicago have to work during the office hours of New York, and people in Berlin have the office hours of St. Petersburg. Instead of seeing DST as working according to one time zone to the east, one can also think of it as people’s body clocks being pushed further west within their time zone (or social clock). Since the body clock follows the sun clock, these changes can affect our health.
How Does DST Affect Our Health?
There are good sides to DST, such as coming home earlier (by the sun clock) from school or work and having more hours of daylight during our free time after work. But DST also creates problems, which can be either short-term (acute) or long-term (chronic). The first days after the sudden switch to DST in spring cause acute effects including shorter sleep duration (Barnes and Wagner, 2009; Harrison, 2013), worse performance (Gaski and Sagarin, 2011), and worse health; heart attacks are, for example, higher during that time compared with other weeks (Janszky and Ljung, 2008; Manfredini et al., 2018), and there may be more traffic accidents (Carey and Sarma, 2017; Coren, 1996a, 1996b; Hicks et al., 1983; Lahti et al., 2010). The chronic effects may last throughout the months of DST because in many people, social clocks and body clocks remain set to different times, as explained in the previous section; the body clock does not adjust to DST social clock time even over months (Hadlow et al., 2014).
The chronic effects of DST have not been studied directly, but we know that DST increases the time difference between the social clock and the body clock (Borisenkov et al., 2017). More and more studies show that time differences between the social clock and the body clock challenge our health (Koopman et al., 2017; Mota et al., 2017; Parsons et al., 2015; Roenneberg et al., 2012; Rutters et al., 2014; Wong et al., 2015), are associated with decreased life expectancy (Borisenkov, 2011), shorten sleep (Borisenkov et al., 2017; Wittmann et al., 2006), cause mental (Foster et al., 2013; Levandovski et al., 2011) and cognitive problems (Díaz-Morales and Escribano, 2015; Haraszti et al., 2014), and contribute to the many sleep disturbances in our societies that are estimated to cost approximately 2% of the gross domestic product (Hafner et al., 2017). If we established DST throughout the year, the chronic effects would become more severe not only because we have to go to work an hour earlier for an additional 5 months every year but also because body clocks are usually later in winter than in summer with reference to the sun clock (Kantermann et al., 2007). The combination of DST and winter would therefore make the differences between body clocks and the social clock even worse and would negatively affect our health even more.
What should we do? What do scientists recommend?
The choice of DST is political and therefore can be changed. If we want to improve human health, we should not fight against our body clock, and therefore, we should abandon DST and return to Standard Time (which is when the sun clock time most closely matches the social clock time) throughout the year. This solution would fix both the acute and the chronic problems of DST. We therefore strongly support removing DST changes or removing permanent DST and having governing organizations choose permanent Standard Time for the health and safety of their citizens.
Conflict Of Interest Statement
The authors have no potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.
ORCID iD
Debra J. Skene https://orcid.org/0000-0001-8202-6180
References
Aries MB, Newsham GR (2008) Effect of daylight saving time on lighting energy use: a literature review. Energy Policy 36:1858-1866.
Barnes CM, Wagner DT (2009) Changing to daylight saving time cuts into sleep and increases workplace injuries. J Appl Psychol 94:1305.
Borisenkov MF (2011) Latitude of residence and position in time zone are predictors of cancer incidence, cancer mortality, and life expectancy at birth. Chronobiol Int 28:155-162.
Borisenkov MF, Tserne TA, Panev AS, Kuznetsova ES, Petrova NB, Timonin VD, Kolomeichuk SN, Vinogradova IA, Kovyazina MS, Khokhlov NA, et al. (2017) Seven-year survey of sleep timing in Russian children and adolescents: chronic 1-h forward transition of social clock is associated with increased social jetlag and winter pattern of mood seasonality. Biol Rhythm Res 3–12.
Carey RN, Sarma KM (2017) Impact of daylight saving time on road traffic collision risk: a systematic review. BMJ Open 7:e014319.
Coren S (1996a) Accidental death and the shift to daylight savings time. Percept Mot Skills 83:921-922.
Coren S (1996b) Daylight savings time and traffic accidents. N Engl J Med 334:924-925.
Díaz-Morales JF, Escribano C (2015) Social jetlag, academic achievement and cognitive performance: understanding gender/sex differences. Chronobiol Int 32:822-831.
Foster RG, Peirson SN, Wulff K, Winnebeck E, Vetter C, Roenneberg T (2013) Sleep and circadian rhythm disruption in social jetlag and mental illness. Prog Mol Biol Transl Sci 119:325-346.
Gaski JF, Sagarin J (2011) Detrimental effects of daylight-saving time on SAT scores. J Neurosci Psychol Econ 4:44.
Gu F, Xu S, Devesa SS, Zhang F, Klerman EB, Graubard BI, Caporaso NE (2017) Longitude position in a time zone and cancer risk in the United States. Cancer Epidemiol Biomarkers Prev 26:1306-1311.
Hadlow N, Brown S, Wardrop R, Conradie J, Henley D (2018) Where in the world? Latitude, longitude and season contribute to the complex co-ordinates determining cortisol levels. Clin Endocrinol 89:299-307.
Hadlow NC, Brown S, Wardrop R, Henley D (2014) The effects of season, daylight saving and time of sunrise on serum cortisol in a large population. Chronobiol Int 31:243-251.
Hafner M, Stepanek M, Taylor J, Troxel WM, Van Stolk C (2017) Why Sleep Matters: The Economic Costs of Insufficient Sleep. Santa Monica, CA: RAND.
Haraszti RÁ, Ella K, Gyöngyösi N, Roenneberg T, Káldi K (2014) Social jetlag negatively correlates with academic performance in undergraduates. Chronobiol Int 31:603-612.
Harrison Y (2013) The impact of daylight saving time on sleep and related behaviours. Sleep Med Rev 17:285-292.
Hashizaki M, Nakajima H, Shiga T, Tsutsumi M, Kume K (2018) A longitudinal large-scale objective sleep data analysis revealed a seasonal sleep variation in the Japanese population. Chronobiol Int 35:933-945.
Hicks RA, Lindseth K, Hawkins J (1983) Daylight saving-time changes increase traffic accidents. Percept Mot Skills 56:64-66.
Janszky I, Ljung R (2008) Shifts to and from daylight saving time and incidence of myocardial infarction. N Engl J Med 359:1966-1968.
Kantermann T, Juda M, Merrow M, Roenneberg T (2007) The human circadian clock’s seasonal adjustment is disrupted by daylight saving time. Curr Biol 17:1996-2000.
Koopman AD, Rauh SP, van‘t Riet E, Groeneveld L, Van Der Heijden AA, Elders PJ, Dekker JM, Nijpels G, Beulens JW, Rutters F (2017) The association between social jetlag, the metabolic syndrome, and type 2 diabetes mellitus in the general population: the new Hoorn study. J Biol Rhythms 32:359-368.
Kotchen MJ, Grant LE (2011) Does daylight saving time save energy? Evidence from a natural experiment in Indiana. Rev Econ Stat 93:1172–1185.
Lahti T, Nysten E, Haukka J, Sulander P, Partonen T (2010) Daylight Saving Time transitions and road traffic accidents. J Environ Public Health. 2010:657167.
Levandovski R, Dantas G, Fernandes LC, Caumo W, Torres I, Roenneberg T, Hidalgo MPL, Allebrandt KV (2011) Depression scores associate with chronotype and social jetlag in a rural population. Chronobiol Int 28:771-778.
Manfredini R, Fabbian F, De Giorgi A, Zucchi B, Cappadona R, Signani F, Katsiki N, Mikhailidis DP (2018) Daylight saving time and myocardial infarction: should we be worried? A review of the evidence. Eur Rev Med Pharmacol Sci 22:750-755.
Mirza FM, Bergland O (2011) The impact of daylight saving time on electricity consumption: evidence from southern Norway and Sweden. Energy Policy 39:3558-3571.
Mota MC, Silva CM, Balieiro LCT, Fahmy WM, Crispim CA (2017) Social jetlag and metabolic control in non-communicable chronic diseases: a study addressing different obesity statuses. Sci Rep 7:6358.
Parsons MJ, Moffitt TE, Gregory AM, Goldman-Mellor S, Nolan PM, Poulton R, Caspi A (2015) Social jetlag, obesity and metabolic disorder: investigation in a cohort study. Int J Obes 39:842.
Randler C (2008) Differences in sleep and circadian preference between Eastern and Western German adolescents. Chronobiol Int 25:565-575.
Roenneberg T, Allebrandt KV, Merrow M, Vetter C (2012) Social jetlag and obesity. Curr Biol 22:939–943.
Roenneberg T, Kumar CJ, Merrow M (2007) The human circadian clock entrains to sun time. Curr Biol 17:R44-R45.
Rutters F, Lemmens SG, Adam TC, Bremmer MA, Elders PJ, Nijpels G, Dekker JM (2014) Is social jetlag associated with an adverse endocrine, behavioral, and cardiovascular risk profile? J Biol Rhythms 29:377-383.
VoPham T, Weaver MD, Vetter C, Hart JE, Tamimi RM, Laden F, Bertrand KA (2018) Circadian misalignment and hepatocellular carcinoma incidence in the United States. Cancer Epidemiol Prev Biomarkers 27:719-727.
Wittmann M, Dinich J, Merrow M, Roenneberg T (2006) Social jetlag: misalignment of biological and social time. Chronobiol Int 23:497-509.
Wong PM, Hasler BP, Kamarck TW, Muldoon MF, Manuck SB (2015) Social jetlag, chronotype, and cardiometabolic risk. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 100:4612-4620.
Wright KP Jr, McHill AW, Birks BR, Griffin BR, Rusterholz T, Chinoy ED (2013) Entrainment of the human circadian clock to the natural light-dark cycle. Curr Biol 23:1554-1558.
Young MW (2000) The tick-tock of the biological clock. Sci Am 282:64-71.
Cite article
Cite article
Cite article
OR
Download to reference manager
If you have citation software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice
Information, rights and permissions
Information
Published In
Article first published online: June 6, 2019
Issue published: June 2019
Keywords
PubMed: 31170882
Authors
Metrics and citations
Metrics
Journals metrics
This article was published in Journal of Biological Rhythms.
VIEW ALL JOURNAL METRICSArticle usage*
Total views and downloads: 44558
*Article usage tracking started in December 2016
Articles citing this one
Receive email alerts when this article is cited
Web of Science: 46 view articles Opens in new tab
Crossref: 54
-
The development and application of a localised metric for estimating d...
-
Daylight saving time and mortality—proceed with caution
-
The Effects of Daylight Saving Time Adjustments on Investor Informatio...
-
Circadian immunity from bench to bedside: a practical guide
-
All cause and cause specific mortality associated with transition to d...
-
Permanent standard time is the optimal choice for health and safety: a...
-
Spatiotemporal light exposure modeling for environmental circadian mis...
-
Does daylight saving time lead to more myocardial infarctions?
-
Potential Effects of Permanent Daylight Savings Time on Daylight Expos...
-
Implications of Sleep Health Policy: Daylight Saving and School Start ...
-
The science and politics of time change
-
Solar clock and school start time effects on adolescents' chronotype a...
-
Debunking myths about daylight saving time: ten things everyone should...
-
Causes, Consequences, and Treatments of Sleep and Circadian Disruption...
-
Sample size bias in the empirical assessment of the acute risks associ...
-
It is time to abolish the clock change and adopt permanent standard ti...
-
Daylight Saving Time: Neurological and Neuropsychological Implications
-
Chronobiology: Is daylight saving time a deer-saving time?
-
A Data-Informed Perspective on Public Preferences for Retaining or Abo...
-
The history and role of the Assembly of National Sleep S...
-
Taking to “heart” the proposed legislation for permanent daylight savi...
-
Driving simulator performance worsens after the Spring transition to D...
-
Longitudinal Location Influences Preference for Daylight Saving Time
-
How Did You Sleep Tonight? The Relevance of Sleep Quality and Sleep–Wa...
-
Human chronotype: Comparison of questionnaires and wrist-worn actigrap...
-
A chronobiological evaluation of the risks of canceling daylight savin...
-
Sleep in Critical Illness: Future Directions
-
Predicting the Effects of Permanent Daylight Savings Time on Light Exp...
-
Weekly and seasonal variation in the circadian melatonin rhythm in hum...
-
Daylight savings time transitions and risk of out-of-hospital cardiac ...
-
Daylight Saving Time preferences in Norway: Do individual chronotype a...
-
Sociospatial Factors Explaining Daylight Saving Preferences in Austral...
-
Daylight Saving Time
-
Highlights of the ERS Lung Science Conference and Sleep and Breathing ...
-
Effect of Daylight Saving Time clock shifts on white-tailed deer-vehic...
-
Translating sleep health science and insights to public health policy ...
-
Weekly and seasonal variation in the circadian melatonin rhythm in hum...
-
Frontiers in Chronobiology: Endogenous Clocks at the Core of Signaling...
-
Disrupted circadian rhythms and mental health
-
Sleep Disruption and Investor Processing of Earnings News: Evidence fr...
-
Chronotype assessment via a large scale socio-demographic survey favou...
-
Daylight saving time: an American Academy of Sleep Medicine position s...
-
Scandinavian bed and rise times in the Age of Enlightenment and in the...
-
Sleep Health: An Opportunity for Public Health to Address Health Equit...
-
Traffic accident increase attributed to Daylight Saving Time doubled a...
-
Response to Martín-Olalla
-
Perspective: Daylight Saving Time—An Advocacy for a Balanced View and ...
-
The Role of Daylight for Humans: Gaps in Current Knowledge
-
Daylight Saving Time Transitions: Impact on Total Mortality
-
A Chronobiological Evaluation of the Acute Effects of Daylight Saving ...
-
Evening chronotype, late weekend sleep times and social jetlag as poss...
-
The long term impact of Daylight Saving Time regulations in daily life...
-
Engaging Scientists in Policy Discourse
-
Sleep Timing in Late Autumn and Late Spring Associates With Light Expo...
Figures and tables
Figures & Media
Tables
View Options
View options
PDF/ePub
View PDF/ePubGet access
Access options
If you have access to journal content via a personal subscription, university, library, employer or society, select from the options below:
loading institutional access options
SRBR members can access this journal content using society membership credentials.
SRBR members can access this journal content using society membership credentials.
Alternatively, view purchase options below:
Purchase 24 hour online access to view and download content.
Access journal content via a DeepDyve subscription or find out more about this option.
