Who selects the party leader?
Abstract
We study the degree of formal influence that rank-and-file members have on the selection of party leaders in the five English-speaking Westminster countries: Australia, Canada, Ireland, New Zealand and the United Kingdom. We find that in recent years there has been a general, though not universal, trend towards granting party members greater influence in the choice of their leader. We observe that the decision to broaden the selectorate has been made by most parties in the UK, Canada and Ireland, while parties in Australia and New Zealand have generally resisted reform. We set out a series of four hypotheses explaining the decisions made by parties in the first three countries. We show that this organizational reform is adopted by parties in opposition, in the aftermath of an electoral setback and by new parties. We also find a strong contagion effect within party systems. Finally, we offer an explanation for why the Australian and New Zealand cases have resulted in less change.
Get full access to this article
View all access and purchase options for this article.
Notes
References
Abramson Paul, Inglehart Ronald (1995) Value Change in Global Perspective. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press.
Alderman Keith (1998) ‘The Conservative Party Leadership Election of 1997’, Parliamentary Affairs 51: 1–16.
Alderman Keith (1999) ‘Revision of Leadership Selection Procedures in the Conservative Party’, Parliamentary Affairs 52: 260–74.
Alderman R. K., Carter Neil (1993) ‘The Labour Party Leadership and Deputy Leadership Elections of 1992’, Parliamentary Affairs 46: 49–65.
Archer Keith, Whitehorn Alan (1997) Political Activists: the NDP in Convention. Toronto: Oxford University Press.
Bille Lars (1997) ‘Leadership Change and Party Change: the Case of the Danish Social Democratic Party 1960–95’, Party Politics 3: 379–90.
Brennock Mark (2004) ‘PDs to Adopt New System of Electing Leader’, Irish Times, 27 February.
Butler David, Ranney Austin (eds) (1994) Referendums Around the World: the Growing use of Direct Democracy. London: Macmillan.
Carty R. Kenneth (2004) ‘Parties as Franchise Systems: the Stratarchical Organizational Imperative’, Party Politics 10: 5–24.
Carty R. Kenneth, Blake Donald (1999) ‘The Adoption of Membership Votes for Choosing Party Leaders: The Experience of Canadian Parties’, Party Politics 5: 211–24.
Carty R. Kenneth, Cross William, Young Lisa (2000) Rebuilding Canadian Party Politics. Vancouver: UBC Press.
Cheadle Bruce (2002) ‘Tory Leadership Question Given Fresh Urgency by PM’s Resignation Date’, The Canadian Press, 22 August.
Collins Stephen (2004) ‘PDs Give Party Membership New Role in Choosing Leader’, Sunday Times, 29 February.
Cornellier Manon (1996) ‘Mal de Bloc’, Le Devoir, A1, 21 November.
Courtney John (1995) Do Conventions Matter? Montreal: McGill-Queen’s University Press.
Cross William (1996) ‘Direct Election of Provincial Party Leaders in Canada, 1985–1995: The End of the Leadership Convention?’ Canadian Journal of Political Science 29: 295–315.
Cross William (2004) Political Parties. Vancouver: UBC Press.
Cross William, Crysler John (2009) ‘Grassroots Participation in Party Leadership Selection: Examining the British and Canadian Cases’,in DeBardeleben Joan, Pammett Jon (eds) Participation and the Good Citizen, pp. 173–93. Basingstoke: Palgrave.
Curry Bill, Alberts Sheldon (2003) ‘How the Deal Went Down’, National Post, A5, 2 June.
Dalton Russell (2004) Democratic Challenges, Democratic Choices: The Erosion of Political Support in Advanced Industrial Democracies. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Dalton Russell, Wattenberg Martin (2001) Parties Without Partisans: Political Change in Advanced Industrial Democracies. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Denham Andrew, Dorey Peter (2006) ‘The “Caretaker” Cleans Up: The Liberal Democrat Leadership Election of 2006’, Parliamentary Affairs 60: 26–45.
Denham Andrew, O’Hara Kieron (2007) ‘Cameron’s Mandate: Democracy, Legitimacy and Conservative Leadership’, Parliamentary Affairs 60: 409–23.
Deschouwer Kris (1992) ‘Survival of the Fittest: Measuring and Explaining Adaptation and Change in Political Parties’. Paper presented at the joint sessions of the European Consortium on Political Research (Limerick Ireland) (as cited in Harmel and Janda, 1994).
Drucker Henry (1987) ‘Intra-Party Democracy in Action: the Election of Leader and Deputy Leader by the Labour Party in 1983’, Parliamentary Affairs 37: 283–300.
Economou Nick, Ghazarian Zareh (2008) ‘Vale and the Australian Democrats: Organizational Failure and Electoral Decline’. Paper presented at the annual meetings of the Australian Political Science Association, Brisbane, 6–9 July.
Fitzgerald Peter, Kennedy Fiachra, Lyons Pat (2004) ‘The Irish Labour Party Leadership Election, 2002: a Survey of Members’, British Election and Parties Review 14: 230–44.
Flanagan Tom (1995) Waiting for the Wave: the Reform Party and Preston Manning. Toronto: Stoddard.
Frantzich Stephen E. (1989) Political Parties in the Technological Age. New York: Longman.
Gallagher Michael, Marsh Michael (eds) (2002) How Ireland Voted 2002: the Full Story of Ireland’s General Election. Houndmills: Palgrave Macmillan.
Gauja Anika (2009) ‘Internal Party Democracy and Policy Formulation: Rationales, Trends and Relevance’. Paper presented at the joint sessions of the European Consortium on Political Research in Lisbon, Portugal.
Gauja Anika (2005) ‘The Pitfalls of Participatory Democracy: a Study of the Australian Democrats’ GST’, Australian Journal of Political Science 40: 71–85.
Gauja Anika (2004) ‘The Internal Organization of the Australian Democrats: Lessons for Participatory Parties.’ Paper presented at the annual meetings of the Australian Political Science Association, Adelaide, 29 September to 1 October.
Harmel Robert (2002) ‘Party Organizational Change: Competing Explanations?’ in Luther Richard, Muller-Rommel Ferdinand (eds) Political Parties in the New Europe: Political and Analytical Challenges, pp. 119–42. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Harmel Robert, Janda Kenneth (1994) ‘An Integrated Theory of Party Goals and Party Change’, Journal of Theoretical Politics 6: 259–87.
Heidar Knut, Koole Ruud (2000) ‘Parliamentary Party Groups Compared’,in Heidar, Koole (eds) Parliamentary Party Groups in European Democracies: Political Parties Behind Closed Doors, pp. 248–70. London: Routledge.
Heppell Timothy (2008) Choosing the Tory Leader: Conservative Party Elections from Heath to Cameron. London: Tauris Academic Studies.
Ignazzi Piero, Farrell David, Rommele Andrea (2005) ‘The Prevalence of “Linkage by Reward” in Contemporary Parties’,in Rommeleet al. (eds) Political Parties and Political Systems: the Concept of Linkage Revisited, pp. 17–35. Westport, CT: Praeger.
Johnson William (1996) ‘Bouchard Still Pulls the Strings of his Ottawa Party’, Kitchener Waterloo Record, A6, 17 January.
Katz Richard S. (2001) ‘The Problem of Candidate Selection and Models of Party Democracy’, Party Politics 7: 277–96.
Katz Richard S., Mair Peter (1995) ‘Changing Models of Party Organization and Party Democracy: the Emergence of the Cartel Party’, Party Politics 1: 5–28.
Katz Richard S., Mair Peter (1993) ‘The Evolution of Party Organizations in Europe: the Three Faces of Party Organization’, American Review of Politics 14: 593–617.
Kenig Ofer (2009a) ‘Classifying Party Leaders’ Selection Methods in Parliamentary Demcoracies’, Journal of Elections, Public Opinion and Parties 19: 433–47.
Kenig Ofer (2009b) ‘Democratization of Party Leadership Selection: Do Wider Selectorates Produce More Competitive Contests’, Electoral Studies 28: 240–7.
King Anthony (1994) ‘Chief Executives in Western Europe’,in Budge Ian, McKay D. (eds) Developing Democracies. London: Sage.
Kirchheimer Otto (1966) Political Parties and Political Development. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Latouche Daniel (1992) ‘Universal Democracy and Effective Leadership: Lessons from the Parti Quebecois Experience’,in Carty R. Kenneth, et al. (eds) Leaders and Parties in Canadian Politics: Experiences of the Provinces. Toronto: Harcourt, Brace, Jovanovich.
Leduc Larry (2001) ‘Democratizing Party Leadership Selection’, Party Politics 7: 323–41.
Lyons Pat (2003) ‘Irish Labour Party Background Notes’, unpublished.
Mair Peter (1994) ‘Party Organizations: From Civil Society to the State’,in Katz Richard, Mair Peter (eds) How Parties Organize: Change and Adaptation in Party Organizations in Western Democracies. London: Sage.
Mair Peter, Biezen Ingrid van (2001) ‘Party Membership in Twenty European Democracies, 1980–2000’, Party Politics 7: 5–21.
Marsh Michael (1993a) ‘Introduction: Selecting the Party Leader’, European Journal of Political Research 24: 229–31.
Marsh Michael (1993b) ‘Selecting Party Leaders in the Republic of Ireland’, European Journal of Political Research 24: 295–316.
McAllister Ian (1996) ‘Leaders’,in LeDuc Lawrence, et al. (eds) Comparing Democracies: Elections and Voting in Global Perspective. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
McSweeney Dean (1999) ‘Changing the Rules Changed the Game: Selecting Conservative Leaders’, Party Politics 4: 471–83.
Michels Robert (1962) Political Parties: a Sociological Study of the Oligarchical Tendencies of Modern Democracy. New York: Free Press (original edition 1911).
Nevitte Neil (1996) The Decline of Deference: Canadian Value Change in Cross National Perspective. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Norton Philip (1998) ‘Electing the Leader: the Conservative Leadership Contest 1997’, Politics Review 7: 10–14.
Norton Philip (2000) ‘The United Kingdom: Exerting Influence from Within’,in Heidar Knut, Koole Ruud (eds) Parliamentary Party Groups in European Democracies: Political Parties Behind Closed Doors, pp. 39–56. London: Routledge.
O’Malley Eoin (2007) ‘The Power of Prime Ministers: Results of an Expert Survey’, International Political Science Review 28: 7–27.
Panebianco Angelo (1988) Political Parties: Organization and Power. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Poguntke Thomas, Webb Paul (eds) (2005) The Presidentialization of Politics: A Comparative Study of Modern Democracies. New York: Oxford University Press.
Punnett R. M. (1992) Selecting the Party Leader: Britain in Comparative Perspective. New York: Harvester Wheatsheaf.
Quinn Thomas (2004) ‘Electing the Leader: the British Labour Party’s Electoral College’, British Journal of Politics and International Relations 6: 333–52.
Quinn Thomas (2005) ‘Leasehold or Freehold? Leader-Eviction Rules in the British Conservative and Labour Parties’, Political Studies 53: 793–815.
Rafter Kevin (2003) ‘Leadership Changes in Fine Gael and the Labour Party, 2002’, Irish Political Studies 18: 108–19.
Rahat Gideon, Hazan Reuven (2001) ‘Candidate Selection Methods: an Analytical Framework’, Party Politics 7: 297–322.
Russell Meg (2005) Building New Labour: the Politics of Party Organization. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Scarrow Susan (1999) ‘Parties and the Expansion of Direct Democracy. Who Benefits?’ Party Politics 5: 341–62.
Scarrow Susan, Webb Paul, Farrell David (2001) ‘From Social Integration to Electoral Contestation: The Changing Distribution of Power within Political Parties’,in Dalton Russell J., Wattenberg Martin P. (eds) Parties without Partisans: Political Change in Advanced Industrial Democracies, pp. 129–51. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Seyd Patrick (1999) ‘New Parties/New Politics? a Case Study of the British Labour Party’, Party Politics 5: 383–405.
Sheahan Fionnan (2003) ‘Harney Warns Leadership Pretenders’, Irish Examiner, 12 April.
Stark J. P. (1996) Choosing a Leader: Party Leadership Contests in Britain from Macmillan to Blair. Basingstoke: Macmillan.
Stewart David, Kenneth Carty R. (2002) ‘Leadership Politics as Party Building: the Conservatives in 1998’,in Cross William (ed.) Political Parties, Representation and Electoral Democracy in Canada, pp. 55–67. Don Mills: Oxford University Press.
Warhurst John (ed.) (1997) Keeping the Bastards Honest: the Australian Democrats First Twenty Years. St. Leonard’s: Allen and Unwin).
Wauters Bram (2010) ‘Explaining Participation in Intra-Party Elections: Evidence from Belgian Political Parties’, Party Politics 16: 237–59.
Weller Patrick (1985) First Among Equals: Prime Ministers in Westminster Systems. Sydney: George Allen and Unwin.
Wilson Frank (1980) ‘Sources of Party Transformation: the Case of France’,in Merkl Peter H. (ed.) Western European Party Systems: Trends and Prospects, pp. 526–51. New York: Free Press.
Young Lisa, Cross William (2002) ‘The Rise of Plebiscitary Democracy in Canadian Political Parties’, Party Politics 8: 673–99.
Cite article
Cite article
Cite article
OR
Download to reference manager
If you have citation software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice
Information, rights and permissions
Information
Published In
Article first published online: January 26, 2011
Issue published: March 2012
Keywords
Authors
Metrics and citations
Metrics
Article usage*
Total views and downloads: 3879
*Article usage tracking started in December 2016
Altmetric
See the impact this article is making through the number of times it’s been read, and the Altmetric Score.
Learn more about the Altmetric Scores
Articles citing this one
Receive email alerts when this article is cited
Web of Science: 114 view articles Opens in new tab
Crossref: 121
-
Try, Try Again? Are Unsuccessful Leadership Contestants Sore Losers?
-
Primarily about primaries
-
United in division: explaining attitudes towards Muslims in Canada and...
-
Choosing among the chosen? Electoral lists and party primaries in Euro...
-
What’s on a Party Member’s Mind? Voting Motives in Competitive Party L...
-
Great minds think alike? Ideological congruence between party members ...
-
How active are right-wing party members? Portuguese right-wing delegat...
-
Personalization at different levels: Intra-party competition and prefe...
-
Inclusive candidate selection and corruption: evidence from Spanish re...
-
Are Citizens More Politically Engaged when Candidate Selection is Demo...
-
Who rules the deliberative party? Examining the Agora case in Belgium
-
Power struggles in the German Christian Democrats. The dynamics of thr...
-
The Social Democratic Party of Germany (SPD) and Immigration Policies:...
-
Between love and hate: party members and the new forms of participatio...
-
Accruing career capital: How party leaders with more political experie...
-
Sour Grapes? Party Donors and Canadian Leadership Primaries
-
Selecting Sunak: Conservative MPs’ Nomination Preferences in the (Seco...
-
Locating power in party leader selection
-
Parliamentary Women Opposition Leaders: A Comparative Assessment Acros...
-
Political Parties and the Trials of Democracy
-
Fame and factions: A process-tracing analysis of the 2019 leadership s...
-
Leadership election reform in the British Labour party: democratisatio...
-
Lost but not blown away. How do losers of party leadership contests re...
-
After defeat: how governing parties respond to electoral loss
-
Erdogan against Turkey։ Stalemate of “Patriot-F-35-S-400” triangle
-
Country or party? Variations in party membership around the globe
-
Elección presidencial a tres vueltas: efectos de las primarias abierta...
-
United we stand, divided we fall? The effects of parties’ Brexit rheto...
-
The Face of the Party: Party Leadership Selection, and the Role of Fam...
-
Member Influence and Involvement in Civil Society Organizations: A Res...
-
Intra-party decision-making in contemporary Europe: improving represen...
-
The Politics of Loyalty: Understanding Voters’ Attitudes after Primary...
-
Introduction
-
The Effect of Exogenous Shocks on the Administration of Online Voting:...
-
Strategic Nominee Selection in Tournament Solutions
-
Does It Pay Off? The Effects of Party Leadership Elections on Parties’...
-
Internal democracy in populist right parties: the process of party pol...
-
Are digital parties more democratic than traditional parties? Evaluati...
-
Membership vote for party leadership changes: Electoral effects and th...
-
Selecting Starmer: The Nomination Preferences of Labour Parliamentaria...
-
Behavioral Consequences of Open Candidate Recruitment
-
Personalization of parliamentary behaviour: Conceptualization and empi...
-
Waiting for the green light: tracing candidate selection by the French...
-
Decline, adaptation and relevance: political parties and their researc...
-
Selecting party leaders, reform processes and methods: Examining the A...
-
The Conservative Party Leadership Transition from Theresa May to Boris...
-
Conflicts and Coronations: Analysing Leader Selection in European Poli...
-
Patterns in Leader Selection: Where Does Power Lie?
-
The Rule of the Valberedning? Party Leader Selection in Sweden
-
Theoretical-Conceptual Framework
-
Birth, Life and End of Collective Leadership
-
Party dynamics and leadership longevity: experience from Western Balka...
-
Do regional party primaries affect the ideological cohesion of politic...
-
Party organization and intra-party democracy in Italy
-
Membership and members’ participation in new digital parties: Bring ba...
-
Leadership succession in different types of organizations: What busine...
-
Why Parties Narrow Their Representative Profile: Evidence from Six Eur...
-
The Limits of Cartelization: Can Parties Cope with Vulnerability?
-
Analysis of political parties ideologies influencing public policy for...
-
More than opinion expression: Secondary effects of intraparty referend...
-
Judicial decision-making within political parties: A political approac...
-
Party institutionalization as multilevel concept: base- versus elite-l...
-
New Parties and Democracy in Slovenia
-
Whose primaries? Grassroots’ views on candidate selection procedures
-
Untangling the gender gap: nomination and representativeness in Turkis...
-
Candidate selection methods and electoral performance in comparative p...
-
A Oligarquia Desvendada: Organização e Estrutura dos Partidos Político...
-
The influence of legislators’ endorsements in party leadership electio...
-
Intraparty democracy in Central and Eastern Europe...
-
Tales of the unexpected: The selection of British party leaders since ...
-
The meanings of party membership. A comparison of three parties
-
When Europeanisation meets organisation: enhancing the rights of party...
-
Leader and Party: Still an Oxymoron?
-
The Presidential Primaries and Polarization of Mainstream Party Politi...
-
The Iron Law of Oligarchy and New Ways of Selecting Candidates
-
From May’s Laws to May’s legacy...
-
Choosing party leaders: Anglophone democracies, British parties and th...
-
Social Movements within Organisations: Occupy Parties in Italy and Tur...
-
Who Leads the Party? On Membership Size, Selectorates and Party Oligar...
-
Challenges of political participation and intra-party democracy: Bitte...
-
Do stateless-nationalist-regionalist-parties differ from other party t...
-
From cartel party to traditional membership organisation: the organisa...
-
Managed intra-party democracy...
-
Which members? Using cross-national surveys to study party membership
-
Raising a big tent: Internal party composition and leadership selector...
-
The Labour Party leadership election, 2014
-
Agency, institutional stretch and structural adjustment...
-
Candidate Selection in Canada...
-
Candidate Selection in a Multilevel State: The Case of Spain
-
The Pendulum Swings: Experiences from the LDP on Democratizing Party L...
-
Considering the Appropriateness of State Regulation of Intra-Party Dem...
-
Looking for the party? The effects of partisan change on issue attenti...
-
(Re‐)join the party! The effects of direct democracy on party membersh...
-
Selecting the leader, Italian style
-
Comparing the Dynamics of Party Leadership Survival in Britain and Aus...
-
Intra-party democracy, political performance and the survival of party...
-
Personal leaders and party change: Italy in comparative perspective
-
Objective and Subjective Party Leadership Selection: Regulations, Acti...
-
Leadership Elections: What is at Stake for Parties? A Comparison of th...
-
Rising to the Top: Gender, Political Performance, and Party Leadership...
-
Politicizing Bodies: Hegemonic Masculinity, Heteronormativity, and Rac...
-
New forms of political participation. Changing demands or changing opp...
-
The Politics of Party Policy: From Members to Legislators ...
-
PARTY PRIMARIES: TOWARDS A DEFINITION AND TYPOLOGY
-
Turnout Rates in Closed Party Leadership Primaries: Flash and Fade Out...
-
The Influence of Legislators' Endorsements in Party Leadership Electio...
-
Objective and Subjective Party Leadership Selection: Regulations, Acti...
-
The Selection of Party Leaders in Poland: Democratisation of Rules and...
-
Gendered Candidate Selection and the Representation of Women in Northe...
-
Democratising Party Leadership Selection in Belgium: Motivations and D...
-
The discreet charm of political parties
-
No man can serve two masters...
-
Power and the (il)legitimacy of political parties...
-
Presidentialism and Primaries
-
Linkage in Multi-level Party Organizations: The Role(s) of Norwegian R...
-
From coronations to close encounters: Party leadership selection in Br...
-
‘Zippin’ up My Boots, Goin’ Back to My Roots': Radical Left Parties in...
-
New Challenges of Intra-Party Democracy: Grassroots Activists, Instant...
-
New Adventures in Membership: Primary Elections and the Italian Case
-
Broadening the Appeal and Opening Up the Party: A Comparison of the Br...
-
Going, going, . . . gone? The decline of party membership in contempor...
Figures and tables
Figures & Media
Tables
View Options
Get access
Access options
If you have access to journal content via a personal subscription, university, library, employer or society, select from the options below:
loading institutional access options
Alternatively, view purchase options below:
Purchase 24 hour online access to view and download content.
Access journal content via a DeepDyve subscription or find out more about this option.
