The Wayback Machine - https://web.archive.org/web/20040815023253/http://www.brethren.org:80/genbd/witness/ConscientiousObjection/COinfo.htm
Brethren Witness Home

Peace and Justice
Link to Faith Expeditions
Care for Creation
Just for Youth
Global Food Crisis Fund
Global Womens Project
Death Row Support Project
Brethren Witness
Peace and Justice

Conscientious Objection

Conscientious objection: a sincere conviction, motivated by conscience, that forbids someone from taking part in organized killing.

Boy wearing Peace Shirt
Are you a C.O.?
It depends on whether you would find it unconscionable—or against your deepest held beliefs—to engage in activities designed to take a human life. If that's you, it is your legal right not to have to fight in war. You're not off the hook—you'll still need to do alternative service. That means spending time doing other kinds of service in the national interest through an agency such as Brethren Volunteer Service. And some C.O.'s actually go into the military, but are assigned noncombatant roles such as in the medical corps. Others think this is being supportive of the war effort.

Still others refuse to go along with the whole process—they don't register for the draft or cooperate in any way with the Selective Service system. These persons sometimes face fines or imprisonment, or at least the denial of federal student loans or government jobs. Yet they feel this is the step their faith requires.

So, what about you? Would you go if called? Would you fight to kill? Would you support others while they did?

Just because you don't believe in killing doesn't mean you're a coward or don't care about your neighbor. Many peacemakers have put themselves on the line by going unarmed into dangerous places to work for peace: living with refugees to protect them from the military; accompanying church leaders to help them find safety; working in war zones to help people survive while their world is falling apart; protesting at military training camps or at missile silos. It takes a certain courage to do these things without the protection of the latest weaponry or the support of vast military forces.

Ted Studebaker
One Man's Witness
Ted Studebaker was a Brethren conscientious objector during the Vietnam War. Yet he chose to go to Vietnam through Brethren Volunteer Service. He said, "Give me a shovel instead of a gun. If I die, I want to die trying to build something rather than tearing something down." Die he did, on April 25, 1971, killed by North Vietnamese soldiers in the village where he had worked for several years helping people improve their lives amidst a brutal war.

Was his life a waste? Was his death a tragedy? Of course it would have been better had he lived. Yet his mother said, "If Ted had known what was to happen, I'm sure he would have gone right ahead. In one way, his death is an even greater witness than had he lived." His wife of only a few weeks said, "I'm sure all of you share my grief, but grieve more for those who do not understand what he did."

Ted was a Christian who was trying to follow the teachings of Jesus as best he knew how. What about you? How does your life reflect Jesus' teachings about loving our enemies and doing good to those who would harm us?

Documenting your C.O. Beliefs
While the government doesn't officially recognize C.O.'s until there's an actual draft, young men faced with registration for the draft can express their peace convictions by writing "I am a conscientious objector to war" above their name on the registration form and photocopying the form. Send a copy to the Brethren Witness/Washington Office where a file will be opened in the person's name, into which other peace-related information provided by the person can be placed. It is a good idea to keep a photocopy for yourself and possibly one at your church as well. It would also be helpful to fill out the form "What Do I Believe About War?", and send a copy to the Brethren Witness/Washington Office office. This is a good thing to do in any event, but especially important if you have already filled out the Selective Service form without noting your beliefs about conscientious objection, or if, being a female, you did not need to fill out that form.

It's also a good idea for young women to find ways to document their beliefs, as they may be subject to a future military draft. Young men and women who do this demonstrate their on-going commitment to conscientious objection, which will help establish a conscientious objector claim should the need arise.

Some young men refuse to register, choosing to not cooperate with the Selective Service system. The Church of the Brethren supports open non-cooperation, and has a fund to help reimburse college students for loans and grants denied due to their non-registration. Non-registrants can also be denied employment by the government. The government has legal grounds for prosecuting non-registrants, which can mean fines and imprisonment. There is little evidence of active prosecution in recent years, however.

What if I've Already Signed Up?!
Men and women who decide they are conscientious objectors after they have already enlisted in the military can receive counsel on how to be discharged from the military from the Center on Conscience and War (202-483-2220; nisbco@nisbco.org).

The Bible says:
"You have heard that is was said, 'An eye for an eye and a tooth for a tooth.' But I say to you, do not resist one who is evil. But if anyone strikes you on the right cheek, turn to him the other one as well (Matthew 5:38,39)." "If you love those who love you, what credit is that to you? For even sinners love those who love them (Luke 6:32)."

What to Do
Take the Pledge. It's a clear statement of your intention not to take human life. Work for a world without war—a world where all people live a decent life, where children are healthy and happy, where nations redirect their resources away from military spending and toward human well-being, where the peace of Christ is proclaimed and lived. Read The Peace Book to find out more. Make the little choices each day that tend toward a life of peace—in your home, school, workplace, athletic field...wherever. It's here that you take the first steps toward a more peaceful world.

Link to What Do I Believe About War? ...Questions for the Conscientious Objector


Link to Conscientious Objection Information Home Page
Link to Peace and Justice Home Page | Link to Witness/Washington Office Home Page
Link to General Board Home Page | Link to Church of the Brethren Home Page


© 2001, 2002 Church of the Brethren. All rights reserved.
Please e-mail the web administrator with your questions and comments