Routine Article
Was Hugo Chávez to Blame? Media Depictions of Polarisation in Venezuela, 1998–2013
First published: 15 January 2019
Abstract
This article explores how seven leading western newspapers covered the topic of polarisation in Venezuelan society during the Chávez era. It found that the media largely ignored the debate as to whether Hugo Chávez was the catalyst or consequence of polarisation. It virtually unanimously presented him as a divisive, polarising character destroying democracy, contrary to the lived experiences of many Venezuelans, while ignoring other possible explanations for the polarisation. It also found that there was a strong similarity in how the liberal and conservative, British and American press covered the issue, with virtually no differences in explanations or outlook, thus manufacturing consent for the elite view of the issue.
References
- Baldassarri, D. and Gelman, A. (2008) ‘Partisans without Constraint: Political Polarisation and Trends in American Public Opinion’. American Journal of Sociology 114(2): 408–446.
- Beeton, D., Johnston, J. and Main, A. (2015) ‘ Venezuela’ in Wikileaks, Wikileaks: The World According to the US Empire. Verso: London, 773–818.
- Bhatt, K. (2013) ‘The Hypocrisy of Human Rights Watch’. NACLA Report on the Americas 46(4): 55–58.
10.1080/10714839.2013.11721894 Google Scholar
- Boykoff, J. (2009) ‘Devil or Democrat? Hugo Chávez and the US Prestige Press’. New Political Science 31(1): 3–26.
10.1080/07393140802693832 Google Scholar
- Cannon, B. (2004) ‘Venezuela, April 2002: Coup or Popular Rebellion? The Myth of a United Venezuela’. Bulletin of Latin American Research 23(3): 285–302.
10.1111/j.0261-3050.2004.00109.x Google Scholar
- Cannon, B. (2008) ‘Class/Race Polarization in Venezuela and the Electoral Success of Hugo Chávez: A Break with the Past or the Song Remains the Same?’. Third World Quarterly 29(4): 731–748.
- Cannon, B. (2014) ‘As Clear as MUD: Characteristics, Objectives, and Strategies of the Opposition in Bolivarian Venezuela’. Latin American Politics and Society 56(4): 49–70.
- Cannon, B. and Brown, J. (2017) ‘Venezuela 2016: The Year of Living Dangerously’. Revista de Ciencia Política 37(2): 613–634.
- Carroll, R. (2013) Comandante: The Life and Legacy of Hugo Chávez. Cannongate: London.
- Chernomas, R. and Hudson, I. (2012) The Gatekeeper: 60 Years of Economics according to the New York Times. Paradigm: London.
- Chomsky, N. (2004) Hegemony or Survival: America's Quest for Global Dominance. Metropolitan: New York.
- Chomsky, N. (2011) Stability, a Code Word with the US. [WWW document]. URL https://chomsky.info/20110224/ [accessed 20 June 2018].
- Comisión Económica para América Latina y el Caribe (CEPAL) (2016a) Millennium Development Goals: Country Profiles: Venezuela (Bolivarian Republic of). [WWW document]. URL http://interwp.cepal.org/perfil_ODM/perfil_Pais.asp?Pais=VEN&Id_idioma=2 [accessed 20 June 2018].
- Comisión Económica para América Latina y el Caribe (CEPAL) (2016b) Venezuela (Bolivarian Republic of): National Economic Profile. [WWW document]. URL http://interwp.cepal.org/cepalstat/Perfil_Nacional_Economico.html?pais=VEN&idioma=english [accessed 20 June 2018].
- Corrales, J. (2005) ‘In Search of a Theory of Polarization: Lessons from Venezuela, 1999–2005’. European Review of Latin American and Caribbean Studies 79: 105–118.
10.18352/erlacs.9666 Google Scholar
- Corrales, J. and Penfold, M. (2011) Dragon in the Tropics: Hugo Chávez and the Political Economy of Revolution in Venezuela. Brookings Institution: Washington.
- Duno-Gottberg, L. (2004) ‘Mob Outrages: Reflections on the Media Construction of the Masses in Venezuela’. Journal of Latin American Cultural Studies 13(1): 115–135.
- Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean (ECLAC) (2000–2013) Social Panorama of Latin America. United Nations: Santiago.
- Ellner, S. (2003) ‘ Introduction’ in S. Ellner and D. Hellinger (eds.) Venezuelan Politics in the Chávez Era: Class, Polarization, and Conflict. Rienner: London, 7–26.
- Ellner, S. (2017) ‘Venezuela's Fragile Revolution’. Monthly Review 69(5): 1.
- Evans, J. (2003) ‘Have Americans’ Attitudes become more Polarized? – An Update'. Social Science Quarterly 84(1): 71–90.
- Golinger, E. (2007) The Chávez Code: Cracking Intervention in Venezuela. Pluto: London.
- Gott, R. (2011) Hugo Chávez and the Bolivarian Revolution. Verso: London.
- Gramsci, A. (1971) Selections from the Prison Notebooks. Lawrence and Wishart: London.
- Hellinger, D. (2011) ‘ Defying the Iron Law of Oligarchy I. How does “El Pueblo” Conceive Democracy?’ in D. Smidle and D. Hellinger (eds.) Venezuela's Bolivarian Democracy: Participation, Politics, and Culture under Chávez. Duke University Press: Durham, 28–57.
10.1215/9780822394310-002 Google Scholar
- Hellinger, D. (2012) ‘ Venezuela: Movements for Rent?’ in G. Prevost, C. Olivia Campos and H. Vanden (eds.) Social Movements and Leftist Governments in Latin America: Confrontation or Co-optation? Zed: London, 145–164.
- Herman, E. and Chomsky, N. (2002) Manufacturing Consent: The Political Economy of the Mass Media. Pantheon: New York.
- Hernandez, J. A. (2010) ‘Against the Comedy of Civil Society’. Journal of Latin American Cultural Studies 13(1): 137–145.
10.1080/13569320420001866532 Google Scholar
- Jones, B. (2008) Hugo! The Hugo Chávez Story from Mud Hut to Perpetual Revolutionary. Vintage: London.
- Latinobarometro, 2000 Latinobarometro Reports (1995–2013). [WWW document]. URL http://www.latinobarometro.org/ [accessed 20 June 2018].
- Lemoine, M. (2002) Venezuela's Press Power. [WWW document]. URL http://mondediplo.com/2002/08/10venezuela [accessed 20 June 2018].
- Lupien, P. (2013) ‘The Media in Venezuela and Bolivia: Attacking the “Bad Left” from Below’. Latin American Perspectives 40(3): 226–246.
- MacLeod, A. (2018) Bad News from Venezuela: Twenty Years of Fake News and Misreporting. Routledge: Abingdon.
10.4324/9781351038263 Google Scholar
- Marquez, P. (2003) ‘ The Hugo Chávez Phenomenon: What do “The People” Think?’ in S. Ellner and D. Hellinger (eds.) Venezuelan Politics in the Chávez Era: Class, Polarization, and Conflict. Rienner: London, 197–214.
- Roberts, K. (2003) ‘ Social Polarization and the Populist Resurgence in Venezuela’ in S. Ellner and D. Hellinger (eds.) Venezuelan Politics in the Chávez Era: Class, Polarization, and Conflict. Rienner: London, 55–72.
- Stiglitz, J. (2012) The Price of Inequality. Penguin: London.
- Westwood, S. et al. (2017) ‘The Tie that Divides: Cross-National Evidence of the Primacy of Partyism’. European Journal of Political Research 57(2): 333–354.
- Yougov (2017) How Left or Right-Wing are the UK's Newspapers? [WWW document]. URL https://yougov.co.uk/news/2017/03/07/how-left-or-right-wing-are-uks-newspapers/ [accessed 4 September].
- Young, K. (2008) ‘Colombia and Venezuela: Testing the Propaganda Model’. NACLA Report on the Americas 41(6): 50–52.
10.1080/10714839.2008.11725435 Google Scholar
- Young, K. (2013) ‘The Good, The Bad, and the Benevolent Interventionist: US Press and Intellectual Distortions of the Latin American Left’. Latin American Perspectives 40(3): 207–225.
Newspapers
- Daily Telegraph (2013a) ‘Hugo Chávez: President of Venezuela who embraced “21st century socialism” and raged at the United States’ (7 March), p. 37.
- Daily Telegraph (2013b) ‘Even Chávez's adoring fans fail to mask fear for future’ (7 March), p. 17.
- Guardian (2002) ‘Ousted Chávez Detained by Army’ (13 April), foreign pages, p. 14.
- Guardian (2013a) ‘Hugo Chávez: Poor boy from the plains who became leftwing figurehead’ (5 March), p. 5.
- Guardian (2013b) Obituary: ‘Hugo Chávez: President of Venezuela seen as a hero by the poor and a socialist dictator by opponents’ (7 March), p. 40.
- Independent (2013a) ‘Passing of Venezuelan President leaves tears – and a Nation divided’ (6 March), p. 2.
- Independent (2013b) ‘Castro and Ahmadinejad among leaders to gather for Venezuelan President Hugo Chávez's funeral’ (8 March), p. 16.
- Miami Herald (1998) ‘Doubts Persist Despite Chávez's 16-point lead’ (5 December), p. 23a.
- Miami Herald (2002) ‘Chávez's Return May Deepen Divisions’ (15 April), p. 11a.
- Miami Herald (2013) ‘Venezuela's Hugo Chávez and his Legacy of Plunder’ (5 March), p. 9a.
- New York Times (1998) ‘Renegade Officer Favored in Venezuelan Election Today’ (6 December), p. 3.
- New York Times (2002) ‘Venezuela Press Sidestepped Leader's Return’ (23 April), p. 13.
- New York Times (2013) ‘Chávez Transformed the Way Venezuelans View Themselves’ (7 March), p. 10.
- Times (1998) ‘Colonel Swaps Bullets for Ballots’ (4 December), overseas news, p. 1.
- Washington Post (1998) ‘Venezuela's Chávez Faces High Hurdles’ (7 December), p. 31.
- Washington Post (2013a) ‘Chávez Supporters Mourn Loss, Brace for Next Chapter’ (6 March), p. 11.
- Washington Post (2013b) ‘Polarization in Venezuela Intensifies after Disputed Election’ (19 April), p. 14.
- Washington Post (2013c) ‘Chávez's Chosen Successor Maduro Sounding More Chávez-like’ (10 March), p. 13.
- Washington Post (2013d) ‘After Hugo Chávez’ (7 March), editorial, p. 16.
- Washington Post (2013e) ‘A Marxist with a dash of Oprah’ (10 March), Outlook, p. 1.