The Wayback Machine - https://web.archive.org/web/20061220050409/http://theoscarsite.com/1958.htm

theoscarsite.com is a registered Associate of amazon.com®.
When ordering Oscar®-nominated films, please help support this site by using the links provided on our film pages.

Welcome to theoscarsite.com's yearly Oscars® pages

This page covers the Awards for 1958. If you wish, read my disclaimer.

Click here for information on the Awards Ceremony for this year's nominees.

Use this link to go to my listing of every film and every person ever nominated for an Award!

Use this link to see every film nominated for an Award this year and how it ranks in nominations and Awards!

"My God, have we fallen to this?" -- Spencer Tracy

Best Picture
   AUNTIE MAME - Warner Bros. Jack L. Warner, studio head
   CAT ON A HOT TIN ROOF - Avon, MGM. Produced by Lawrence Weingarten
   THE DEFIANT ONES - Kramer, UA. Produced by Stanley Kramer
GIGI (Won 9 Awards. Swept every nominated category) - Freed, MGM. Produced by Arthur Freed
   SEPARATE TABLES - Hecht-Hill-Lancaster, UA. Produced by Harold Hecht

Actor
   Tony Curtis in THE DEFIANT ONES
   Paul Newman in CAT ON A HOT TIN ROOF
David Niven in SEPARATE TABLES
   Sidney Poitier in THE DEFIANT ONES
   Spencer Tracy in THE OLD MAN AND THE SEA

Actress
Susan Hayward in I WANT TO LIVE!
   Deborah Kerr in SEPARATE TABLES
   Shirley MacLaine in SOME CAME RUNNING
   Rosalind Russell in AUNTIE MAME
   Elizabeth Taylor in CAT ON A HOT TIN ROOF

Supporting Actor
   Theodore Bikel in THE DEFIANT ONES
   Lee J. Cobb in THE BROTHERS KARAMAZOV
Burl Ives in THE BIG COUNTRY
   Arthur Kennedy in SOME CAME RUNNING
   Gig Young in TEACHER'S PET

Supporting Actress
   Peggy Cass in AUNTIE MAME
Wendy Hiller in SEPARATE TABLES
   Martha Hyer in SOME CAME RUNNING
   Maureen Stapleton in LONELYHEARTS
   Cara Williams in THE DEFIANT ONES

Director
   Richard Brooks for CAT ON A HOT TIN ROOF
   Stanley Kramer for THE DEFIANT ONES
Vincente Minnelli for GIGI
   Mark Robson for THE INN OF THE SIXTH HAPPINESS
   Robert Wise for I WANT TO LIVE!

Writing: Story and Screenplay - Written Directly for the Screen
Nedrick Young & Harold Jacob Smith - THE DEFIANT ONES Film originally credited "Nathan E. Douglas," a pseudonym used by Young.
   Paddy Chayefsky - THE GODDESS
   Melville Shavelson & Jack Rose - HOUSEBOAT
   James Edward Grant & William Bowers - THE SHEEPMAN
   Fay Kanin & Michael Kanin - TEACHER'S PET

Writing: Screenplay - Based on Material from Another Medium
   Richard Brooks & James Poe - CAT ON A HOT TIN ROOF
Alan Jay Lerner - GIGI
   Sir Alec Guinness - THE HORSE'S MOUTH
   Nelson Gidding & Don Mankiewicz - I WANT TO LIVE!
   Sir Terence Rattigan & John Gay - SEPARATE TABLES

Foreign Language Film
   HELDEN (ARMS AND THE MAN, West Germany)
   LA VENGANZA (Spain)
MON ONCLE (MY UNCLE, France)
   CESTA DUGA GODINU DANA (THE ROAD A YEAR LONG, Yugoslavia)
   I SOLITI IGNOTI (THE USUAL UNIDENTIFIED THIEVES, a.k.a. BIG DEAL ON MADONNA STREET, Italy)

Art Direction/Set Decoration (Black & White or Color)
   Malcolm Bert - Art Direction, George James Hopkins - Set Decoration AUNTIE MAME
   Cary Odell - Art Direction, Louis Diage - Set Decoration BELL, BOOK AND CANDLE
   Lyle Wheeler & John De Cuir - Art Direction, Walter M. Scott & Paul S. Fox - Set Decoration A CERTAIN SMILE
William A. Horning & Preston Ames - Art Direction, Henry Grace & Keogh Gleason - Set Decoration GIGI
   Hal Pereira & Henry Bumstead - Art Direction, Sam Comer & Frank McKelvy - Set Decoration VERTIGO

Cinematography (Color)
Rules changed back this year to two Awards for Cinematography: one for black & white and one for color.
   Harry Stradling - AUNTIE MAME
   William H. Daniels - CAT ON A HOT TIN ROOF
Joseph Ruttenberg - GIGI
   James Wong Howe - THE OLD MAN AND THE SEA
   Leon Shamroy - SOUTH PACIFIC

Cinematography (Black & White)
Rules changed back this year to two Awards for Cinematography: one for black & white and one for color.
Sam Leavitt - THE DEFIANT ONES
   Daniel L. Fapp - DESIRE UNDER THE ELMS
   Lionel Lindon - I WANT TO LIVE!
   Charles B. Lang - SEPARATE TABLES
   Joseph P. MacDonald - THE YOUNG LIONS

Costume Design (Black & White or Color)
   Jean Louis - BELL, BOOK AND CANDLE
   Ralph Jester, Edith Head & John Jensen - THE BUCCANEER
   Charles LeMaire & Mary Wills - A CERTAIN SMILE
Sir Cecil Beaton - GIGI
   Walter Plunkett - SOME CAME RUNNING

Documentary (Features)
   James Carr - Producer ANTARCTIC CROSSING
   Robert Snyder - Producer THE HIDDEN WORLD
   Nathan Zucker - Producer PSYCHIATRIC NURSING
Ben Sharpsteen - Producer WHITE WILDERNESS

Documentary (Shorts)
Ben Sharpsteen - Producer AMA GIRLS
   Kenneth G. Brown - Producer EMPLOYEES ONLY
   Ian Ferguson - Producer JOURNEY INTO SPRING
   Tom Daly - Producer THE LIVING STONE
   Thorold Dickinson - Producer OVERTURE

Film Editing
   William Ziegler - AUNTIE MAME
   William A. Lyon & Al Clark - COWBOY
   Frederic Knudtson - THE DEFIANT ONES
Adrienne Fazan - GIGI
   William Hornbeck - I WANT TO LIVE!

Music: Scoring of a Dramatic or Comedy Picture
Rules changed this year to two Awards: One Award for Scoring of a Dramatic or Comedy Picture, and one Award for Scoring of a Musical Picture.
   Jerome Moross - THE BIG COUNTRY
Dimitri Tiomkin - THE OLD MAN AND THE SEA
   David Raksin - SEPARATE TABLES
   Oliver Wallace - WHITE WILDERNESS
   Hugo Friedhofer - THE YOUNG LIONS

Music: Scoring of a Musical Picture
Rules changed this year to two Awards: One Award for Scoring of a Dramatic or Comedy Picture, and one Award for Scoring of a Musical Picture.
   Yuri Faier & Gennady Rozhdestvensky - THE BOLSHOI BALLET
   Ray Heindorf - DAMN YANKEES
Andre Previn - GIGI
   Lionel Newman - MARDI GRAS
   Alfred Newman & Ken Darby - SOUTH PACIFIC

Music: Song
   Sammy Fain - Music, Paul Francis Webster - Lyrics MARJORIE MORNINGSTAR "A Very Precious Love"
   Jimmy Van Heusen - Music, Sammy Cahn - Lyrics SOME CAME RUNNING "To Love and Be Loved"
Frederick Loewe - Music, Alan Jay Lerner - Lyrics GIGI "Gigi"
   Sammy Fain - Music, Paul Francis Webster - Lyrics A CERTAIN SMILE "A Certain Smile"
   Jay Livingston & Ray Evans - Music & Lyrics HOUSEBOAT "Almost in Your Arms (Love Song from Houseboat)"

Short Subjects (Cartoons)
John W. Burton - Producer KNIGHTY KNIGHT BUGS
   Walt Disney - Producer PAUL BUNYAN
   William M. Weiss - Producer SIDNEY'S FAMILY TREE

Short Subjects (Live Action Subjects)
Walt Disney - Producer GRAND CANYON
   Ian Ferguson - Producer JOURNEY INTO SPRING
   John Patrick Hayes - Producer THE KISS
   SNOWS OF AORANGI
  James A. Lebenthal - Producer T IS FOR TUMBLEWEED

Sound
   Gordon Sawyer (Samuel Goldwyn Studio Sound Department) I WANT TO LIVE!
Fred Hynes (Todd-AO Sound Department) SOUTH PACIFIC
   Leslie I. Carey (Universal-International Studio Sound Department) A TIME TO LOVE AND A TIME TO DIE
   George Dutton (Paramount Studio Sound Department) VERTIGO
   Carl Faulkner (20th Century-Fox Studio Sound Department) THE YOUNG LIONS

Special Effects
Tom Howard - Special Effects (Visual) tom thumb
   A. Arnold Gillespie - Special Effects (Visual), Harold Humbrock - Special Effects (Audible) TORPEDO RUN

Scientific Or Technical
Class I (Statuette):
No award given for 1958.

Class II (Plaque):
Don W. Prideaux & Leroy G. Leighton (Lamp Division of General Electric Company) - For the development and production of an improved 10 kilowatt lamp for motion picture set lighting.
Panavision, Inc. - For the design and development of the Auto Panatar anamorphic photographic lens for 35mm CinemaScope photography.

Class III (Citation):
Willy Borberg (General Precision Laboratory) - For the development of a high speed intermittent movement for 35mm motion picture theatre projection equipment.
Fred Ponedel, George Brown & Conrad Boye (Warner Bros. Special Effects Department) - For the design and fabrication of a new rapid fire marble gun.

Honorary and Other Awards
Maurice Chevalier - For his contributions to the world of entertainment for more than half a century. Winner presented a Statuette.

Irving G. Thalberg Memorial Award
Jack L. Warner

Jean Hersholt Humanitarian Award
No award given for 1958.

FIRSTS
· Sidney Poitier's nomination for The Defiant Ones was the first for a black actor.
· Gigi broke the record for the most Oscars® for a single film: 9.
· Although Vincente Minnelli had nearly 40 films to his credit, Gigi was his first and only win.
· Maureen Stapleton was nominated for her screen debut.

RULE CHANGES
· Anti-Communist clause dropped.
· Cinematography again divided into separate Color and Black & White Awards; Musical Scoring again divided into musical and non-musical films.

SINS OF OMISSION
Picture: Vertigo, Touch of Evil, Some Came Running, The Last Hurrah
Director: Alfred Hitchcock - Vertigo
Actor: James Stewart - Vertigo
Actress: Kim Novak - Vertigo
Supporting Actor: Maurice Chevalier - Gigi
Supporting Actress: Hermione Gingold - Gigi
Song: "Hard-Headed Woman," "I Remember It Well," "Teacher's Pet," "Thank Heaven for Little Girls"
Foreign Language Film: Ansiktet (The Magician) - Sweden

UNMENTIONABLES
· The year's biggest scandal was the Elizabeth Taylor - Eddie Fisher - Debbie Reynolds triangle. Taylor went from grieving widow to The Woman You Love to Hate.
· Deborah Kerr's affair with writer Paul Viertel and subsequent divorce from longtime husband Tony Bartley cost her the custody of her two children.
· Clifton Webb claimed to have been so shaken up by Susan Hayward's performance in I Want to Live! as a woman who walks bravely into the gas chamber that he sent producer Walter Wanger the bill for a fifth of Scotch.
· MGM treated Gigi like a Broadway show and opened it in a legitimate theater on the Great White Way. It ran for six months at the Royale Theatre, then moved to a regular movie theater for close to a year.
· Nominee Cara Williams made news due to her impending divorce from John Drew Barrymore: "We'll never reconcile because the three of us would never be happy together -- John, myself and his psychiatrist."
· Awards show producer Jerry Wald's fashion dictate this year? "There will be no cleavage on this year's Oscar® Awards show... If you need any help, a wardrobe mistress backstage is equipped with enough lace to make a mummy."
· Ingrid Bergman triumphantly returned to Hollywood just before the ceremony. The Awards show was her first public appearance in Tinseltown since she left the US in 1949 to be with Roberto Rossellini.
· Producer Harold Hecht accepted Wendy Hiller's Supporting Actress Award: "It's a great honor to accept this great honor for a great actress."
· Jayne Mansfield and Inger Stevens were two of the women who modeled for the Costume Awards. Mansfield, who was wearing one of Cecil Beaton's creations for Gigi, stood by him at the podium as he accepted his Award.
· Foreign Language Film winner Jacques Tati criticized the Academy for not fully appreciating America's own film comedians in their heyday. In his acceptance speech, he stated "If Hollywood had not done so many funny pictures, I would not be here tonight." Referring to his winning film Mon oncle he concluded, "For all those great comedians, I am not the uncle, but the nephew. I respect Hollywood."
· Anthony Franciosa, Robert Wagner and Rock Hudson were supposed to come out and sing a response to the "little girls" who'd sung "We're glad you're not young anymore" to Maurice Chevalier. Producer Wald axed the number at the last minute.
· Best Director Vincente Minnelli accepted his Award by calling it "just about the proudest moment of my life." This sentiment was slightly undercut by the fact that he was simultaneously scratching his eye with his middle finger.
· As Best Actress Susan Hayward returned to the stage to take another bow, her producer Walter Wanger said to a friend, "Thank heavens, now we all can relax. Susie got what she's been chasing for twenty years."
· To close the show, Mitzi Gaynor strolled out and burst into "There's No Business Like Show Business." As she charged into the second chorus, a part of the stage behind her rose from below with all the winners and presenters standing side by side and singing along. After two more choruses, Wald signaled to Jerry Lewis. There were 20 minutes of airtime left! Keep on singing! Lewis yelled, "Another twenty times!" As the orchestra kept playing, a few people decided that they might as well start dancing. The two lines dissolved into dancing couples. Dean Martin waltzed by the podium and grabbed himself a statuette. Watching the spectacle on TV at home, Spencer Tracy said, "My God, have we fallen to this?" After extended ad-libs from Lewis, some of the dancing celebrities thought it best to disappear from the stage and many members of the audience were well on their way out of the theater. As Lewis picked up a trumpet and began hitting flat notes, NBC turned its cameras off and filled out the rest of the time slot with a short film about pistols.


And, of course, here's the place where I have to put the disclaimer: This page was created for my own personal use and was intended for educational and entertainment purposes only. "Oscar" and "Academy Awards" are registered trademarks of the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences. The "Oscar" Statuette is copyrighted by the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences. These pages are neither authorized nor endorsed by the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences. I cannot take responsibility for any errors or omissions on these pages; i.e., if you lose a bet because of something I missed, don't expect me to pay it off!

Sidebar highlights come from several sources, most notably The Academy Awards® - The Complete Unofficial History, by Gail Kinn & Jim Piazza, and Inside Oscar® - The Unofficial History of the Academy Awards®, by Mason Wiley & Damien Bona.

This page is authored by Gary Moody. If you have comments or questions about the page, please e-mail me at gary@theoscarsite.com.