Make me authentic, but not here: Reflexive struggles with academic identity and authentic leadership
Abstract
This article presents a reflexive auto-ethnography of the experience of teaching authentic leadership to MBA students. It traces parallels between the challenges of authentic leadership and the challenges of academic identity work, grounded specifically in the experience of having to teach something one does not fully endorse. Both authentic leadership and academic identity work emerge as struggle – riddled with false starts, best intentions and self-deception, and entwined in the politics of pragmatism, idealism, ambition and survival. The subject position of the mature entrant to academia who is also an ‘early career scholar’ is likened to an awkward adolescent, experimenting with shades of independence/dependence, resistance/compliance and voice/silence. Based on these reflections, having authentic leadership on the curriculum involves a particular kind of identity regulation for students and academics alike, running counter to philosophical notions of authenticity as striving for one’s own way in the world. Authentic leadership will only flourish in the business school if academics muster the courage to acknowledge its relevance for our own role as teacher-leaders, rather than simply teaching or writing to its abstract, ideological appeal.
Get full access to this article
View all access and purchase options for this article.
References
Alvesson M, Sveningsson S (2013) Authentic leadership critically reviewed. In: Ladkin D, Spiller C (eds) Authentic Leadership: Clashes, Convergences and Coalescences. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing, 39–54.
Alvesson M, Willmott H (2002) Identity regulation as organizational control: Producing the appropriate individual. Journal of Management Studies 39(5): 619–644.
Alvesson M, Ashcraft KL, Thomas R (2008) Identity matters: Reflections on the construction of identity scholarship in organization studies. Organization 15(1): 5–28.
Ashcraft KL, Allen BJ (2009) Politics even closer to home: Repositioning CME from the standpoint of communication studies. Management Learning 40(1): 11–30.
Ashforth BE, Mael F (1989) Social identity theory and the organization. Academy of Management Review 14(1): 20–39.
Avolio BJ, Gardner WL (2005) Authentic leadership development: Getting to the root of positive forms of leadership. The Leadership Quarterly 16(3): 315–338.
Barth RS (2004) Learning by Heart. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
Bass B, Steidlmeier P (2004) Ethics, character and authentic transformational leadership behaviour. In: Ciulla JB (ed.) Ethics, the Heart of Leadership. Westport, CT: Praeger Publishers, 175–196.
Bathurst R, Cain T (2013) From authenticity to communitas: An ecology of leadership. In: Ladkin D, Spiller C (eds) Authentic Leadership: Clashes, Convergences and Coalescences. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing, 195–207.
Beddoes-Jones F, Swailes S (2015) Authentic leadership: Development of a new three pillar model. Strategic HR Review 14(3): 94–99.
Boje DM, Helmuth CA, Saylors R (2013) Spinning authentic leadership living stories of the self. In: Ladkin D, Spiller C (eds) Authentic Leadership: Clashes, Convergences and Coalescences. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing, 271–278.
Cooper CD, Scandura TA, Schriesheim CA (2005) Looking forward but learning from our past: Potential challenges to developing authentic leadership theory and authentic leaders. The Leadership Quarterly 16(3): 475–493.
Cortese CG (2005) Learning through teaching. Management Learning 36(1): 87–115.
Costas J, Fleming P (2009) Beyond dis-identification: A discursive approach to self-alienation in contemporary organizations. Human Relations 62(3): 353–378.
Costas J, Taheri A (2012) ‘The return of the primal father’ in postmodernity? A Lacanian analysis of authentic leadership. Organization Studies 33(9): 1195–1216.
Cunliffe AL (2009) The philosopher leader: On relationalism, ethics and reflexivity – A critical perspective to teaching leadership. Management Learning 40(1): 87–101.
Eagly AH (2005) Achieving relational authenticity in leadership: Does gender matter? The Leadership Quarterly 16(3): 459–474.
Ellis C (2004) The Ethnographic I: A Methodological Novel about Autoethnography. Walnut Creek, CA: AltaMira Press.
Finlay L (2003) Through the looking glass: Intersubjectivity and hermeneutic reflection. In: Finlay L, Gough B (eds) Reflexivity: A Practical Guide for Researchers in Health and Social Sciences. Oxford: Blackwell, 105–119.
Ford J, Harding N (2011) The impossibility of the ‘true self’ of authentic leadership. Leadership 7(4): 463–479.
Ford J, Harding N, Learmonth M (2010) Who is it that would make business schools more critical? Critical reflections on critical management studies. British Journal of Management 21(1): 71–81.
Gabriel Y (1999) Beyond happy families: Re-evaluation of the control-resistance-identity triangle. Human Relations 52(2): 179–203.
Gagnon S (2008) Compelling identity: Selves and insecurity in global, corporate management development. Management Learning 39(4): 375–391.
Gardiner RA (2011) Critique of the discourse of authentic leadership. International Journal of Business and Social Science 2(15): 99–104.
Gardner WL, Cogliser CC, Davis KM, et al. (2011) Authentic leadership: A review of the literature and research agenda. The Leadership Quarterly 22(6): 1120–1145.
Goffee R, Jones G (2013) Authentic followership in the knowledge economy. In: Ladkin D, Spiller C (eds) Authentic Leadership: Clashes, Convergences and Coalescences. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing, 208–219.
Guignon CB (2004) On Being Authentic. Abingdon: Routledge.
Guthey E, Jackson B (2005) CEO portraits and the authenticity paradox. Journal of Management Studies 42(5): 1057–1082.
Harris P, Thiel B, Currie J (1998) Success, gender and academic voices: Consuming passion or selling the soul? Gender and Education 10(2): 133–148.
Harter S (2012) The Construction of the Self: Developmental and Sociocultural Foundations. 2nd edn. New York: Guilford Press.
Harter S, Waters PL, Whitesell NR (1997) Lack of voice as a manifestation of false self-behavior among adolescents: The school setting as a stage upon which the drama of authenticity is enacted. Educational Psychologist 32(3): 153–173.
Hoy WK, Henderson JE (1983) Principal authenticity, school climate, and pupil control orientation. Alberta Journal of Educational Research 29(2): 123–130.
Humphreys M (2005) Getting personal: Reflexivity and autoethnographic vignettes. Qualitative Inquiry 11(6): 840–860.
Jensen SM, Luthans F (2006) Entrepreneurs as authentic leaders: Impact on employees’ attitudes. Leadership & Organization Development Journal 27(8): 646–666.
Kärreman D, Alvesson M (2009) Resisting resistance: Counter-resistance, consent and compliance in a consultancy firm. Human Relations 62(8): 1115–1144.
Knights D, Clarke C (2014) It’s a bittersweet symphony, this life: Fragile academic selves and insecure identities at work. Organization Studies 35(3): 335–357.
Ladkin D, Spiller C (eds) (2013) Authentic Leadership: Clashes, Convergences and Coalescences. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing.
Lambert L (2003) Leadership redefined: An evocative context for teacher leadership. School Leadership & Management 23(4): 421–430.
Latour B (1988) The politics of explanation. In: Woolgar S (ed.) Knowledge and Reflexivity: New Frontiers in the Sociology of Knowledge. London: SAGE, 155–176.
Lawler J, Ashman I (2012) Theorizing leadership authenticity: A Sartrean perspective. Leadership 8(4): 327–344.
Learmonth M, Humphreys M (2012) Autoethnography and academic identity: Glimpsing business school doppelgängers. Organization 19(1): 99–117.
Liu H, Cutcher L, Grant D (2015) Doing authenticity: The gendered construction of authentic leadership. Gender, Work and Organization 22(3): 237–255.
Merleau-Ponty M (1968) The Visible and the Invisible (trans. Lingis A). Evanston, IL: Northwestern University Press.
Nicholson H, Carroll B (2013a) Identity undoing and power relations in leadership development. Human Relations 66(9): 1225–1248.
Nicholson H, Carroll B (2013b) So you want to be authentic in your leadership: To whom and for what end? In: Ladkin D, Spiller C (eds) Authentic Leadership: Clashes, Convergences and Coalescences. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing, 286–301.
Nyberg D, Sveningsson S (2013) Paradoxes of authentic leadership: Leader identity struggles. Leadership.
Petriglieri G, Wood JD, Petriglieri JL (2011) Up close and personal: Building foundations for leaders’ development through the personalization of management learning. The Academy of Management Learning and Education 10(3): 430–450.
Pollner M (1991) Left of ethnomethodology: The rise and decline of radical reflexivity. American Sociological Review 56: 370–380.
Reedy P (2008) Mirror, mirror, on the wall: Reflecting on the ethics and effects of a collective critical management studies identity project. Management Learning 39(1): 57–72.
Shamir B, Eilam G (2005) “What’s your story?” A life-stories approach to authentic leadership development. The Leadership Quarterly 16(3): 395–417.
Shaw J (2010) Papering the cracks with discourse: The narrative identity of the authentic leader. Leadership 6(1): 89–108.
Sparrowe RT (2005) Authentic leadership and the narrative self. The Leadership Quarterly 16(3): 419–439.
Spicer A (2011) Guilty lives: The authenticity trap at work. Ephemera: Theory and Politics in Organization 11(1): 46–62.
Sveningsson S, Alvesson M (2003) Managing managerial identities: Organizational fragmentation, discourse and identity struggle. Human Relations 56(10): 1163–1193.
Taylor SS (2013) Authentic leadership and the status trap. In: Ladkin D, Spiller C (eds) Authentic Leadership: Clashes, Convergences and Coalescences. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing, 176–187.
Thomas R, Davies A (2005) Theorizing the micro-politics of resistance: New public management and managerial identities in the UK public services. Organization Studies 26(5): 683–706.
Tomkins L, Simpson P (2015) Caring leadership: A Heideggerian perspective. Organization Studies 36(8): 1013–1031.
Tomkins L, Ulus E (2016) ‘Oh, was that “experiential learning”?!’ Spaces, synergies and surprises with Kolb’s learning cycle. Management Learning 47(2): 158–178.
Toor S, Ofori G (2009) Authenticity and its influence on psychological well-being and contingent self-esteem of leaders in Singapore construction sector. Construction Management & Economics 27(3): 299–313.
Tourish D (2013) The Dark Side of Transformational Leadership: A Critical Perspective. London: Routledge.
Walumbwa FO, Avolio BJ, Gardner WL, et al. (2008) Authentic leadership: Development and validation of a theory-based measure. Journal of Management 34(1): 89–126.
Watson TJ (2008) Managing identity: Identity work, personal predicaments and structural circumstances. Organization 15(1): 121–143.
York-Barr J, Duke K (2004) What do we know about teacher leadership? Findings from two decades of scholarship. Review of Educational Research 74(3): 255–316.
Yukl G (1999) An evaluation of conceptual weaknesses in transformational and charismatic leadership theories. The Leadership Quarterly 10(2): 285–305.
Cite article
Cite article
Cite article
OR
Download to reference manager
If you have citation software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice
Information, rights and permissions
Information
Published In
Article first published online: January 12, 2017
Issue published: July 2017
Keywords
Authors
Metrics and citations
Metrics
Article usage*
Total views and downloads: 2315
*Article usage tracking started in December 2016
Altmetric
See the impact this article is making through the number of times it’s been read, and the Altmetric Score.
Learn more about the Altmetric Scores
Articles citing this one
Receive email alerts when this article is cited
Web of Science: 19 view articles Opens in new tab
Crossref: 0
-
The pedagogical potential of identity work in leadership education – C...
-
Agential explanations: how employee participation is enhanced in norma...
-
A Bibliometric Study of Authentic Leadership
-
Sensing as a Leadership Competence: Determining Situational Authentici...
-
Learning to manage as learning to fail: The lessons of running
-
Global South Doctoral Students and University Employment Services: Per...
-
Critical management education: Selected auto-ethnographic vignettes on...
-
Must I Grow a Pair of Balls to Theorize about Theory in Organization a...
-
Academic identities and sense of place: A collaborative autoethnograph...
-
Non-naïve organizational positivity through a generative paradox pedag...
-
Thematic analysis without paradox: sensemaking and context
-
Impossible or just irrelevant? Unravelling the ‘authentic leadership’ ...
-
Management education through autoethnography
-
Fostering Workplace Innovation through CSR and Authentic Leadership: E...
-
“Aliens” in the United States: A Collaborative Autoethnography of Fore...
-
Is age just a number? Credibility and identity of younger academics in...
-
Mindful reflexivity: Unpacking the process of transformative learning ...
-
A reconceptualization of authentic leadership: Leader legitimation via...
-
Differentiated evolution rather than revolution
-
Critical complicity: The feel of difference at work in home and field
-
Reforming the MBA: a survey of elite British universities
-
Authentic Leadership in HRD—Identity Matters! Critical Explorations on...
-
Authentic Leadership and Talent Development: Fulfilling Individual Pot...
Figures and tables
Figures & Media
Tables
View Options
Get access
Access options
If you have access to journal content via a personal subscription, university, library, employer or society, select from the options below:
loading institutional access options
Alternatively, view purchase options below:
Purchase 24 hour online access to view and download content.
Access journal content via a DeepDyve subscription or find out more about this option.
