Best New Journal

2010
Winner: Literature in the Early American Republic
Honorable Mention: Black Camera

2009
Winner: Contemporary Women's Writing
Honorable Mention: Early Modern Women & Journal of Late Antiquity

2008
Winner: Community Literacy Journal

2007
Winner: Borrowers and Lenders: The Journal of Shakespeare and Appropriation
Runner-Up: American Naturalism Editors

2006
Winner: Literal
Runner-Up: Material Religion

2005
Winner: Labor
Runner-up: Latino Studies
Belletristic Journal Winner: Ninth Letter
Runner-up: literal: Latin American Voices

2004
Winner: Partial Answers: A Journal of Literature and the History of Ideas

2003
Winner: American Journal of Bioethics

2002
Winner: Philosophia Africana

2001
Winner: Pedagogy

2000
Winner: The Hedgehog Review

1999
Winner: Book History

1998
Winner: Rhetoric and Public Affairs

1997
Winner: Feminist Economics

1996
Winner: Angelaki

1995
Winner: positions: east asia cultures critique
Runner-up: Modernism/modernity

1994
Winner: North Carolina Literary Review
Runner up: Journal of Information Ethics

1993
Winner: Narrative
Runner-up: American Short Fiction

1992
Winner: Public Culture
Honorable mentions: Colonial Latin American Literature, Joyce Studies Annual, Journal of Indigenous Culture

1991
Winner: Diaspora: A Journal of Transnational Studies
Honorable mentions: Manoa, Hellas

1990
Winner: Journal of World History
Honorable mentions: Journal of Women's History, American Literary History

1989
Winner: The Yale Journal of Criticism

1988
Winner: The Gettysburg Review

1987
Winner: Portuguese Studies

1986
Winner: Studies in American Drama, 1945–Present

1985
Winner: Journal of the Society for Armenian Studies

1984
Winner: South Central Review

1983
Winner: Rhetorica