if this is it for new features - my S4 will be with me for another year ...
Again, it doesn’t tell you anything significant
By the time you have a significantly changed A-a gradient or VQ mismatch from a viral related exacerbation, you’ll already be in the hospital with O2 monitors
The lungs work a little differently with pathology than the heart does especially with serious illnesses. With the heart there is a lot more “silent” pathophysiolgy. With the lungs, not so much.
You can bet Apple’s advertising will let people think they need it though especially during a pandemic lol. Non medical people don’t quite understand how oxygen saturation tells pathology and how, more or less, useless it is outside of a hospital.
andthat Covid pneumonia initially causes a form of oxygen deprivation we call “silent hypoxia”
when Covid pneumonia first strikes, patients don’t feel short of breath, even as their oxygen levels fall
In about 216 hours, (+-) we will find out if Jon was right.Jon P. said next week though.
While I agree with you, I want to mention my comment came from when I went to the dr. for bronchitis and the oxygen saturation was one of the results they went over with me. I wasnt short of breath but I went in bc i knew something wasnt right. An app that would tell me that could help make the decision for people to go in. I know it would be too early to trust it, but might be better than nothing?Again, it doesn’t tell you anything significant
By the time you have a significantly changed A-a gradient or VQ mismatch from a viral related exacerbation, you’ll already be in the hospital with O2 monitors
The lungs work a little differently with pathology than the heart does especially with serious illnesses. With the heart there is a lot more “silent” pathophysiolgy. With the lungs, not so much.
You can bet Apple’s advertising will let people think they need it though especially during a pandemic lol. Non medical people don’t quite understand how oxygen saturation tells pathology and how, more or less, useless it is outside of a hospital.
Really torn on whether or not to upgrade from S5 to S6 this year. Apple watch is still very much an early device and each gen seems to add more features similar to early versions of the iPhone. Of course, after time, the innovations slow down.
Really missing better battery life from the S5. If they improve the battery, maybe I'll update but considering pictures of the S6 battery leaked and showed little difference over S5 battery, I'll probably be disappointed this year.
Are you a med student, RN, MD, or PA?
If he's to be prove wrong AGAIN? I know Apple will release an iPhone in the month of September.In about 216 hours, (+-) we will find out if Jon was right.
While I agree with you, I want to mention my comment came from when I went to the dr. for bronchitis and the oxygen saturation was one of the results they went over with me. I wasnt short of breath but I went in bc i knew something wasnt right. An app that would tell me that could help make the decision for people to go in. I know it would be too early to trust it, but might be better than nothing?
Otherwise, I dont know what the point of it would be? How would they sell the pro's of something if it actually doesnt mean anything?
Out of curiosity, have you read https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/20/opinion/sunday/coronavirus-testing-pneumonia.html which seems to indicate
and
Granted, the piece is an Opinion, and not peer reviewed, and Dr. Levitan expresses how surprising this was to him and his colleagues, so your point is still valid.
Can not believe that my Apple Watch version 1 is still running from the original launch of the watches. I think it is time to upgrade
From where do you know? Release or announce?If he's to be prove wrong AGAIN? I know Apple will release an iPhone in the month of September.
I appreciate you taking the time to inform us on the merits (or rather lack thereof) that many of us have misconstrued. I hope you will continue to do so as time permits.An absolutely game changing feature would be non invasive glucose monitoring
Relatively speaking, oxygen monitoring is a useless feature. It’s like a nice add on, but nothing integral
I’d say the hand washing and breathing features have more practical and functional use than the oxygen sat.
[automerge]1598908156[/automerge]
MD.
Wrist based (or cuffless) blood pressure monitors are too inaccurate to be dependable. If Apple is working on one, it's probably at least 2 years or out.i wonder when it will measure blood pressure...
Are you a med student, RN, MD, or PA?
Not only that, you can feel breathless and have a perfect pulse oximetry reading
I appreciate you taking the time to inform us on the merits (or rather lack thereof) that many of us have misconstrued. I hope you will continue to do so as time permits.
Not how it works. Your SaO2 won’t meaningfully change with exercise, nor meaningfully improve with fitness.O2 saturation would come in handy to roughly gauge fitness and lung performance over extended exercising. It would be a nice, good-to-know, feature.
As soon as Apple (or someone) invents a watch band (or accessory) that can tighten hard enough to occlude the arteries running past it.i wonder when it will measure blood pressure...
As an MD, I tend to agree. Occult viral hypoxemia might be an exception, though.The oxygen sat is a big sales gimmick. Very little actual medical benefit to be gained. It’s a neat feature, might be helpful for chronic COPD patients on home O2 or something. For everyone else it’s a feature that is nice and will have significant advertising behind it, but in practical medical terms much less useful than a heart rate sensor or ecg
I think non medical people doesn’t understand how little an O2 sat monitor tells you outside of acute settings, that the advertising is really going to be a big thing here
If AW6 has pulse oximetry, I really hope the baseline can be customized. There are plenty of folks with a baseline in the 80s who wouldn’t want to be forced to choose between being alerted all the time or turning the darned thing off.I agree. It also has plenty of other health related user benefits. The problem is, it is probably going to be an on demand feature like the ECG. And if that is the case, which I believe it will be, many people who could benefit the most from said feature, may often forget to take a on demand reading.
Ideally, I would like to see the SPo2 feature take automated checks at several periods throughout the day and alert the user with a visual and haptic alert if his or her oxygen level falls below 90. And if it were to fall below 80, an automatic count down would commence much like Fall Detection. And if the user does not respond, EMS is alerted and dispatched.
Edited to add: Having test done a consistent times would be beneficial to one’s doctor, in my opinion.
Damn right, and then some. There are a couple of such devices in the works, and I’m just waiting for the IPO.An absolutely game changing feature would be non invasive glucose monitoring
I think the general public will be mis sold pulse oximetry if it’s included amidst of the covid pandemic
What in the world are you talking about and what in the world your targeting American people for LOL WHAT???This reflects the Apple board of directors getting increasingly older, and also a very unhealthy trend of constant monitoring of biomarkers.
The American people, and to some extent people in Europe, don't need this. They need to start fasting and exercising.
No! that's the problem. we're tired of waiting.Let's wait and WATCH... next week or next month
Blood oxygen monitoring would be a useful feature amid the ongoing pandemic, as the virus can cause oxygen levels to drop, and people experiencing reduced oxygen intake need emergency help.
As an MD, I tend to agree. Occult viral hypoxemia might be an exception, though.
If AW6 has pulse oximetry, I really hope the baseline can be customized. There are plenty of folks with a baseline in the 80s who wouldn’t want to be forced to choose between being alerted all the time or turning the darned thing off.
I agree. And that’s something I worry about. That’s why I pointed out it’s a “relatively useless” feature, albeit a nice one to have
However, given Apple is having some sleep tracking function, I can see practical use for detecting sleep apnea that is undiagnosed. That is probably the limits of genuinely useful function though, for people who are otherwise healthy.
If you have a chronic illness with some sort of condition as I mentioned in a previous post, then the discussion changes and it will have practical benefit for you.