Human dental reduction: Natural selection or the probable mutation effect
James M. Calcagno
Department of Sociology/Anthropology, Loyola University of Chicago, Chicago, Illinois 60626
Search for more papers by this authorKathleen R. Gibson
Department of Anatomical Sciences, University of Texas Dental Branch, Houston, Texas 77225
Search for more papers by this authorJames M. Calcagno
Department of Sociology/Anthropology, Loyola University of Chicago, Chicago, Illinois 60626
Search for more papers by this authorKathleen R. Gibson
Department of Anatomical Sciences, University of Texas Dental Branch, Houston, Texas 77225
Search for more papers by this authorAbstract
Dental reduction has been sufficiently widespread among human populations to render the phenomenon of reduced tooth size worthy of scientific explanation. One of the most controversial models invoked to explain structural reduction in organisms is referred to as the “probable mutation effect” (PME). According to this model, structures no longer functional owing to ecological or cultural changes will experience a relaxation of selection pressure, permitting an accumulation of mutations in the population that inevitably will result in the reduction in size or the loss of the concerned structure. Although the PME continues to be offered as a viable explanation of human dental reduction, it is based upon several premises that modern dental clinical experience fails to support. Known enzyme defects resulting from mutations, factors predisposing to dental infections, and the deleterious effects of teeth that are too large or too small reveal that the PME does not logically account for the reduction of tooth size. Given such information, this paper proposes models of dental reduction based upon natural selection, which, unlike the PME, are testable in both modern and archaeological populations. The integration of clinical and skeletal data permits a more thorough understanding of dental reduction in the hominid fossil record.
Literature Cited
- Anderson DL, and Popovitch F (1977) Dental reduction and dental caries. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 47: 381–386.
- Armelagos GJ (1968) Paleopathology of Three Archaeological Populations from Sudanese Nubia. Boulder: Ph.D. Dissertation, University of Colorado.
- Avis V (1959) The relation of the temporal muscle to the form of the coronoid process. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 17: 99–104.
- Avis V (1961) The significance of the angle of the mandible. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 19: 55–61.
- Bailit HL, and Friedlaender JS (1966) Tooth size reduction: A hominid trend. Am. Anthropol. 68: 665–672.
- Barber CG, Green LJ, and Cox GJ (1963) Effects of the physical consistency of diet on the condylar growth of the rat mandible. J. Dent. Res. 42: 848–851.
- Beecher RM, and Corrucini RS (1981) Effects of dietary consistency on craniofacial development in the rat. Angle Orthod. 51: 61–69.
- Begg PR (1954) Stone age man's dentition. Am. J. Orthod. 40: 298–312, 373–383, 462–475, 517–531.
- Brabant H (1967) Comparison of the characteristics and anomalies of the deciduous and the permanent dentition. J. Dent. Res. 46: 897–902.
- Brabant HE (1971) The human dentition during the Megalithic Era. In: AA Dahlberg (ed.): Dental Morphology and Evolution. Chicago: University of Chicago Press pp. 283–297.
- Brabant H, and Twiesselmann F (1964) Observations sur l'evolution de la denture permanente humaine en Europe occidentale. Bull. Group. Int. Rech. Sci. Stomatol. 7: 11–84.
- Brace CL (1963) Structural reduction in evolution. Am Nat. 97: 39–49.
- Brace CL (1964) The probable mutation effect. Am. Nat. 98: 453–455.
- Brace CL (1967) Evironment, tooth form and size in the Pleistocene. J. Dent. Res. 46: 809–816.
- Brace CL (1978) Tooth reduction in the Orient. Asian Perspectives 19: 203–219.
- Brace CL (1979) Krapina, “Classic” Neanderthals, and the evolution of the European face. J. Hum. Evol. 8: 527–550.
- Brace CL (1980a) Australian tooth-size clines and the death of a stereotype. Curr. Anthropol. 21: 141–164.
- Brace CL (1980b) Tooth size and Austronesian origins. In: PB Naylor (ed.): Proceedings of the Second Eastern Conference on Austronesian Languages. Ann Arbor: Michigan Series in South and Southeast Asian Languages and Linguistics, 15, pp. 167–180.
- Brace CL, and Hinton RJ (1981) Oceanic tooth-size variation as a reflection of biological and cultural mixing. Curr. Anthropol. 22: 549–569.
- Brace CL, and Mahler PE (1971) Post-Pleistocene changes in the human dentition. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 34: 191–203.
- Brace CL, and Montagu MFA (1965) Man's Evolution: An Introduction to Physical Anthropology. New York: Macmillan Co.
- Brace CL, and Nagai M (1982) Japanese tooth size. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 59: 399–411.
- Brace CL, Rosenberg KR, and Hunt KD (1987) Gradual change in human tooth size in the late Pleistocene and post-Pleistocene. Evolution 41: 705–720.
- Brace CL, and Ryan, AS (1980) Sexual dimorphism and human tooth size differences. J. Hum. Evol. 9: 417–435.
- Brace CL, Shao X-Q, and Zhang Z-B (1984) Prehistoric and modern tooth size in China. In FH Smith and F Spencer (eds.): The Origins of Modern Humans. New York: Alan R. Liss, Inc., pp. 485–516.
- Brose DS, and Wolpoff M (1971) Early Upper Paleolithic man and late Middle Paleolithic tools. Am. Anthropol. 73: 1156–1194.
- Brothwell DR (1963a) Digging Up Bones. London: British Museum of Natural History.
- Brothwell DR (1963b) The macroscopic dental pathology of some earlier human populations. In DR Brothwell (ed.): Dental Anthropology. New York: Macmillan, pp. 271–288.
10.1016/B978-0-08-009823-4.50019-7 Google Scholar
- Brown K (1983) Evolution and development of the dentition. In RJ Jorgenson (ed.): Dentition: Genetic Effects. ( Birth Defects: Original Article Series, Vol. 19, No. 1) New York: Alan R. Liss, Inc., Fifth Symposium of the Society of Craniofacial Genetics, pp. 29–66.
- Brues AM (1966) Probable mutation effect and the evolution of hominid teeth and jaws. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 25: 169–170.
- Brues AM (1968) Mutation and selection. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 29: 437–439.
- Byles RH (1972) Limiting conditions for the operation of the Probable Mutation Effect. Soc. Biol. 19: 29–34.
- Calcagno JM (1984) Human Dental Evolution in Post-Pleistocene Nubia. Lawrence: Ph.D. Dissertation, University of Kansas.
- Calcagno JM (1986) Dental reduction in post-Pleistocene Nubia. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 70: 349–363.
- Carlson DS (1976a) Temporal variation in prehistoric Nubian crania. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 45: 467–484.
- Carlson DS (1976b) Patterns of morphological variation in the human midface and upper face. In JA Mc-Namara (ed.): Factors Affecting the Growth of the Midface. Ann Arbor: Center for Human Growth and Development, Craniofacial Growth Series, Monograph 6, University of Michigan, pp. 277–299.
- Carlson DS, and Van Gerven DP (1977) Masticatory function and post-Pleistocene evolution in Nubia. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 46: 495–506.
- Carlson DS, and Van Gerven DP (1979) Diffusion, biological determinism, and biocultural adaptation in the Nubian corridor. Am. Anthropol. 81: 561–580.
- Cavalli-Sforza LL, and Bodmer WF (1971) The Genetics of Human Populations. San Francisco: W.H. Freeman.
- Childs GC, and Courville CB (1942) Thrombosis of cavernous sinus secondary to dental infection. Parts I, II, and III. Am. J. Orthod. Oral Surg. 28: 367–373, 402–413, 458–468.
10.1016/S0096-6347(42)90623-9 Google Scholar
- Chosach A, Eidelmann E, and Cohen T (1975) Hypodontia: A polygenic trait—A family study among Israeli Jews. J. Dent. Res. 54: 16–19.
- Corrucini RS, and Beecher RM (1982) Occlusal variation related to a soft diet in a nonhuman primate. Science 218: 74–76.
- Corrucini RS, Potter RHY, and Dahlberg A (1983) Changing occlusal variation in Pima Amerinds. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 62: 317–324.
- Corrucini RS, and Whitley LD (1983) Occlusal variation in a rural Kentucky community. Am. J. Orthod. 78: 250–262.
- Dahlberg AA (1963) Dental evolution and culture. Hum. Biol. 35: 237–249.
- Dirks OB (1965) The distribution of caries resistance in relation to tooth surfaces. In GEW Wolstenholme M O'Connor (eds.): Caries-Resistant Teeth. Boston: Little, Brown, and Co., pp. 66–83.
10.1002/9780470719398.ch4 Google Scholar
- Dixon OJ (1929) Dental infections as cause of cavernous sinus thrombosis. Dent. Cosmos 71: 121.
- Endler JA (1986) Natural Selection in the Wild. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
- Formicola V (1987) Neolithic transition and dental changes: The case of an Italian site. J. Hum. Evol. 16: 231–239.
- Frayer DW (1977) Metric changes in the Upper Paleolithic and Mesolithic. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 46: 109–120.
- Frayer DW (1978) The Evolution of the Dentition in Upper Paleolithic and Mesolithic Europe. Lawrence: University of Kansas Publications in Anthropology, 10.
- Frayer DW (1980) Sexual dimorphism and cultural evolution in the Late Pleistocene and Holocene of Europe. J. Hum. Evol. 9: 399–415.
- Frayer DW (1984) Biological and cultural change in the European Late Pleistocene and Early Holocene. In: FH Smith and F Spencer (eds.): The Origin of Modern Humans. New York: Alan R. Liss, Inc., pp. 211–250.
- Garn SM, Lewis AB, and Walenga AJ (1969) Crown-size profile patterns and presumed evolutionary “trends”. Am. Anthropol. 71: 79–84.
- Ghafari J, and Heeley JD (1982) Condylar adaptation to muscle alteration in the rat. Angle Orthod. 52: 26–37.
- Goodman AH, Armelagos GJ, Van Gerven DP, and Calcagno JM (1986) Diet and post-Mesolithic craniofacial and dental evolution in Sudanese Nubia. In AR David (ed.): Science in Egyptology. Manchester: Manchester University Press, pp. 201–210.
- Grainger RM, Paynter KJ, Honey L, and Lewis, DW (1966) Epidemiologic studies of tooth morphology. J. Dent. Res. 45: 693–702.
- Greene DL (1967) Dentition of Meroitic, X-Group, and Christian Populations from Wadi Halfa, Sudan. Salt Lake City: University of Utah Press.
- Greene DL (1970) Environmental influences on Pleistocene hominid dental evolution. Bioscience 20: 276–279.
- Greene DL (1972) Dental anthropology of early Eygpt and Nubia. J. Hum. Evol. 1: 315–324.
- Greene DL, Ewing GH, and Armelagos GJ (1967) Dentition of a Mesolithic population from Wadi Halfa, Sudan. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 27: 41–55.
- Grunberg H (1963) The Pathology of Development: A Study of Inherited Skeletal Disorders in Animals. Oxford: Blackwell Scientific Publications.
- Hanke MT (1933) Diet and Dental Health. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
- Harvold EP (1975) Experiments on mandibular morphogenesis. In JA McNamara (ed.): Determinants of Mandibular Form and Growth. Ann Arbor: Center for Human Growth and Development, Craniofacial Growth Series, Monograph 4, University of Michigan, pp. 155–178.
- Harvold EP, Vargervik K, and Chierici C (1973) Primate experiments on oral sensation and dental malocclusions. Am. J. Orthod. 63: 494–508.
- Haymaker W (1945) Fatal infections of the central nervous system after tooth extraction. Am. J. Orthod. Oral Surg. 31: 117.
- Hinton RJ (1983) Relationships between mandibular joint size and craniofacial size in human groups. Arch. Oral Biol. 28: 37–43.
- Hinton RJ, Smith MO, and Smith FH (1980) Tooth size changes in prehistoric Tennessee Indians. Hum. Biol. 52: 229–245.
- Holloway RL (1966) Structural reduction through the “Probable Mutation Effect”: A critique with questions regarding human evolution. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 25: 7–11.
- Hoyte DAN, and Enlow DH (1966) Wolff's Law and the problem of muscle attachment on resorptive surfaces of bone. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 24: 205–214.
- Hunt EE (1960) The continuing evolution of modern man. Cold Spring Harbor Symp. Quant. Biol. 24: 245–254.
- Hunter WS (1967) Tooth size and approximal decay in human teeth. Arch. Oral Biol. 12: 313–316.
- Kamp EM, Drost J, Huis in't Veld JHJ, van Palenstein Helderman WH, and Dirks OB (1983) Reproducibility of dental caries in Balb/c mice induced by the bacterium Streptococcus mutans. Archs. Oral Biol. 28: 153–158.
- Keene HJ (1964) Third molar agenesis, spacing and crowding of the teeth and tooth size in caries resistant naval recruits. Am. J. Orthod. 50: 445–451.
- Keene HJ (1965) The relationship between third molar agenesis and the morphologic variability of the molar teeth. Angle Orthod. 35: 289–298.
- Keene HJ (1967) Dental evolution in the borderland between pathology and normality. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 27: 245.
- Keene HJ (1971) Epidemiologic study of tooth size variability in caries free naval recruits. J. Dent. Res. 50: 1331–1345.
- Klatsky M, and Fisher RL (1953) The Human Masticatory Apparatus: An Introduction to Dental Anthropology. Brooklyn: Dental Items of Interest Publ. Co. Inc.
- Koepf SW, Rosedale RS, and Learni GE (1937) Infection of the Gasserian ganglion following tooth extraction. J. Am. Dent. A24: 1843–1846.
- Kraus BS (1957) The genetics of the human dentition. J. Forensic Sci. 2: 419–427.
- Kraus BS (1962) Areas of research in dental genetics. In C Witkop (ed.): Genetics and Dental Health. New York: McGraw-Hill.
- Kraus BS, and Jordan RE (1965) The Human Dentition Before Birth. Philadelphia: Lea and Febiger.
- Kraus BS, Wise WJ, and Frei RH (1959) Heredity and the craniofacial complex. Am. J. Orthod. 45: 172–217.
10.1016/0002-9416(59)90076-4 Google Scholar
- Krogman WM (1967) The role of genetic factors in the human face, jaws, and teeth: A review. Eug. Rev. 59: 165–192.
- Larsen CS (1981) Skeletal and dental adaptations to the shift to agriculture on the Georgia coast. Curr. Anthropol. 22: 422–423.
- Lasker GW (1950) Genetical analysis of racial traits of the teeth. Cold Spring Harbor Symp. Quant. Biol. 15: 191–203.
- LeBlanc SA, and Black B (1974) A long-term trend in tooth size in the Eastern Mediterranean. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 41: 417–422.
- Lombardi AV (1975) A factor analysis of morphogenetic fields in human dentition. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 42: 99–104.
- Macchiarelli R, and Bondioli L (1986) Post-Pleistocene reductions in human dental structure: A reappraisal in terms of increasing population density. Hum. Evol. 1: 405–417.
10.1007/BF02436617 Google Scholar
- Martin L, and Boyd A (1984) Rates of enamel formation in relation to enamel thickness in hominoid primates. In RW Fearnhead Suza (eds.): Tooth Enamel IV. Amsterdam: Elsevier Science Publishers, pp. 447–451.
- McKee JK (1984) A genetic model of dental reduction through the probable mutation effect. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 65: 231–241.
- McFarland P (Personal communication). Postgraduate School of Dentistry, University of Texas Dental Branch, Houston.
- JA Mc Namara. (ed.) (1975) Determinants of Mandibular Form and Growth. Ann Arbor: Center for Human Growth and Development, Craniofacial Growth Series, Monograph 4, University of Michigan.
- Mead S (1933) Oral Surgery. St. Louis: The C.V. Mosby Company.
- Moorrees CAF (1962) Genetic considerations in dental anthropology. In C Witkop (ed.): Genetics and Dental Health. New York: McGraw-Hill.
- Mucci RJ (1982) The Role of Attrition in the Etiology of Third Molar Impactions: Confirming the Begg Hypothesis. Chicago: Unpublished Master's Thesis, University of Illinois at Chicago.
- Nute PE, and Stamatoyannopoulos G (1984) Estimating mutation rates using abnormal human hemoglobins. Yrbk. Phys. Anthropol. 27: 135–151.
- Osborne RH (1962) Application of twin studies to dental research. In C Witkop (ed.): Genetics and Dental Health. New York: McGraw-Hill.
- Oppenheimer A (1964) Tool use and crowded teeth in Australopithecinae. Curr. Anthropol. 5: 419–421.
- Osborne RH (1963) Respective role of twin, sibling, family, and population methods in dentistry and medicine. J. Dent. Res. 42: 1276–1287.
- Osborne RH, Horowitz SL, and DeGeorge FV (1958) Genetic variation in tooth dimensions: A twin study of the permanent anterior teeth. Am. J. Hum. Genet. 10: 350–356.
- Paynter KJ, and Grainger RM (1961) Influence of nutrition and genetics on morphology and caries susceptibility. J. Am. Med. Assoc. 177: 306–309.
- Paynter KJ, and Grainger RM (1962) Relationship of morphology and size of teeth to caries. Int. Dent. J. 12: 147–160.
- Potter RH, Nance WE, Yu PL, and Davis WB (1976) A twin study of dental dimensions: II. Independent genetic determinants. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 44: 397–412.
- Pratt L (1943) Experimental masseterectomy in the laboratory rat. J. Mammol. 24: 204–211.
10.2307/1374804 Google Scholar
- Prout T (1964) Observations on structural reduction in evolution. Am. Nat. 98: 239–249.
- Sciulli PW (1979) Size and morphology of the permanent dentition in prehistoric Ohio Valley Amerindians. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 50: 615–628.
- Scott JH (1957) Muscle growth and function in relation to skeletal morphology. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 15: 197–234.
- Smith FH, Smith MO, and Hinton RJ (1980) Evolution of tooth size in the prehistoric inhabitants of the Tennessee Valley. Tennessee Anthropological Association, Miscellaneous Paper 5: 81–103.
- Smith P (1977a) Selective pressures and dental evolution in hominids. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 47: 453–458.
- Smith P (1977b) Regional variation in tooth size and pathology in hominids. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 47: 459–466.
- Smith P (1979) Regional diversity in epipaleolithic populations. OSSA 6: 243–250.
- Smith P (1982) Dental reduction: Selection or drift? In B Kurten (ed.): Teeth: Form, Function, and Evolution. New York: Columbia University Press, pp. 366–379.
- Sofaer JA (1969a) Aspects of the tabby-crinkled-downless syndrome. I. The development of tabby teeth. J. Embryol. Exp. Morphol. 22: 181–205.
- Sofaer JA (1969b) Aspects of the tabby-crinkled-downless syndrome. II. Observations on the reaction to changes of genetic background. J. Embryol. Exp. Morphol. 22: 207–227.
- Sofaer JA (1973) A model relating developmental interaction and differential evolutionary reduction of tooth size. Evolution 27: 427–434.
- Sofaer JA, Bailit HL, and MacLean CJ (1971a) A developmental basis for differential tooth reduction during hominid evolution. Evolution 25: 509–517.
- Sofaer JA, Chung CS, Niswander JD, and Runck DW (1971b) Developmental interaction, size and agenesis among maxillary incisors. Hum. Biol. 43: 36–45.
- Stevenson AC, and Kerr CB (1967) On the distribution of frequencies of mutation to genes determining harmful traits in man. Mutat. Res. 4: 339–352.
- Stewart RE, and Prescott GH (1976) Oral Facial Genetics. St. Louis: C.V. Mosby Company.
- Stout BF (1931) Septic cavernous sinus thrombosis. J. Lab. Clin. Med. 17: 28.
- Suarez BK (1974) The Genetics of Tooth Size in Man. Los Angeles: Ph.D. Dissertation, UCLA.
- Sung CCW, and Sung RY (1947) Some clinical observations concerning Noma. Am. J. Orthod. Surg. 33: 284–289.
- Suzuki H (1969) Microevolutional changes in the Japanese population from the Prehistoric Age to the present-day. J. Fac. Sci., Univ. Tokyo, Sec. V: Anthropology, 3 ( 4 ): 279–309.
- Ten Cate AR (1985) Oral Histology. St. Louis: The C.V. Mosby Company.
- Thoma K (1948) Oral Surgery ( Volumes 1 and 2 ). St. Louis: The C.V. Mosby Company.
- Townsend GC (1983) Tooth size in children and young adults with trisomy 21 (Down) syndrome. Archs. Oral Biol. 28: 159–166.
- Townsend GC, and Brown T (1983) Molar size sequence in Australian Aboriginals. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 60: 69–74.
- Van Reenen JF (1966) Dental features of a low caries primitive population. J. Dent. Res. 45: 703–713.
- Vogel F, and Motulsky AG (1986) Human Genetics: Problems and Approaches, 2nd ed. Berlin: Springer-Verlag.
10.1007/978-3-662-02489-8 Google Scholar
- Washburn SL (1947) The relation of the temporal muscle to the form of the skull. Anat. Rec. 99: 239–248.
- Watt PG, and Williams HM (1951) The effect of the physical consistency of food on the growth and development of the mandible and maxilla of the rat. Am. J. Orthod. 37: 895–928.
- Williams RC (1978) The probable mutation effect: Neutral alleles and structural reduction. Hum. Biol. 50: 173–181.
- Wolff J (1892) Das Gesetz der Transformation der Knochen. Berlin: A. Hirchwild.
- Wolpoff MH (1969) The effect of mutations under conditions of reduced selection. Soc. Biol. 16: 11–23.
- Wolpoff MH (1971) Metric Trends in Hominid Dental Evolution. Cleveland: Case Western Reserve University Press.
- Wolpoff MH (1975) Dental reduction and the PME. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 43: 307–308.
- Woolf CM (1971) Missing maxillary lateral incisors: A genetic study. Am. J. Hum. Genet. 23: 280–296.
- Wright S (1929) Fisher's theory of dominance. Am. Nat. 68: 274–279.
10.1086/280260 Google Scholar
- Wright S (1931) Evolution in Mendelian populations. Genetics 16: 97–159.
- Wright S (1964) Pleiotropy in the evolution of structural reduction and of dominance. Am. Nat. 98: 65–69.
- y'Edynak G (1978) Culture, diet, and dental reduction in Mesolithic forager-fishers of Yugoslavia. Curr. Anthropol. 19: 616–618.
- y'Edynak G, and Fleisch S (1983) Microevolution and biological adaptability in the transition from food-collecting to food-producing in the Iron Gates of Yugoslavia. J. Hum. Evol. 12: 279–296.
10.1016/S0047-2484(83)80150-X Google Scholar