A Neo-Boasian Conception of Cultural Boundaries
IRA BASHKOW,
IRA BASHKOW
Department of Anthropology, University of Virginia, Charlottesville, VA 22904-4120
Search for more papers by this author
IRA BASHKOW,
IRA BASHKOW
Department of Anthropology, University of Virginia, Charlottesville, VA 22904-4120
Search for more papers by this authorAbstract
For the past 30 years, anthropology's critics have repeatedly questioned the notion of “cultural boundaries,” arguing that concepts of culture inappropriately posit stable and bounded “islands” of cultural distinctiveness in an ever-changing world of transnational cultural “flows.” This issue remains an Achilles' heel—or at least a recurring inflamed tendon—of anthropology. However, in the conception of boundaries, we still have much to learn from Boasian anthropologists, who conceived of boundaries not as barriers to outside influence or to historical change, but as cultural distinctions that were irreducibly plural, perspectival, and permeable. In this article, I retheorize and extend the Boasians' open concept of cultural boundaries, emphasizing how people's own ideas of “the foreign”—and the “own” versus the “other” distinction—give us a way out of the old conundrum in which the boundedness of culture, as conceived in spatial terms, seems to contradict the open-ended nature of cultural experience.
References Cited
- Abbott, Andrew 2001 Time Matters: On Theory and Method. Chicago : University of Chicago Press.
- Abu-Lughod, Lila 1991 Writing against Culture. In Recapturing Anthropology: Working in the Present. Richard Fox, ed. Pp. 137–162. Santa Fe , NM : School of American Research Press.
- Appadurai, Arjun 1988 Putting Hierarchy in Its Place. Cultural Anthropology 3(1): 36–49.
10.1525/can.1988.3.1.02a00040 Google Scholar
- Appadurai, Arjun 1996 Modernity at Large: Cultural Dimensions of Globalization. Minneapolis : University of Minnesota Press.
- Talal Asad, ed. 1973 Anthropology and the Colonial Encounter. Atlantic Highlands , NJ : Humanities Press.
- Banton, Michael 1983 Racial and Ethnic Competition. Cambridge : Cambridge University Press.
- Barber, Benjamin 1995 Jihad vs. McWorld. New York : Times Books.
- Barth, Frederik 1998 [1969] Introduction. In Ethnic Groups and Boundaries: The Social Organization of Culture Difference. Frederik Barth, ed. Pp. 9–38. Prospect Heights , IL : Waveland Press.
- Bashkow, Ira 1991 The Dynamics of Rapport in a Colonial Situation: David Schneider's Fieldwork on the Islands of Yap. In Colonial Situations. George Stocking, ed. Pp. 170–242. Madison : University of Wisconsin Press.
- Bashkow, Ira 1999 “Whitemen” in the Moral World of Orokaiva of Papua New Guinea. Ph.D. dissertation, Department of Anthropology, University of Chicago.
- Bashkow, Ira 2000 “Whitemen” Are Good to Think With: How Orokaiva Morality Is Reflected on Whitemen's Skin “Whiteness in the Field,” theme issue, Identities. Global Studies in Culture and Power 7(3): 281–332.
- In press The Meaning of Whitemen: Race and Modernity in the Orokaiva Cultural World. Chicago : University of Chicago Press.
- Benedict, Ruth 1923 The Concept of the Guardian Spirit in North America. Memoirs of the American Anthropological Association, 29. Menosha , WI : American Anthropological Association.
- Benedict, Ruth 1934 Patterns of Culture. Boston : Houghton Mifflin.
- Bhabha, Homi 1994 The Location of Culture. London : Routledge.
- Boas, Franz 1938 [1911] The Mind of Primitive Man. Rev. edition. New York : Free Press.
- Boas, Franz 1940 [1887] The Study of Geography. In Race, Language and Culture. Pp. 639–647. Chicago : University of Chicago Press.
- Boas, Franz 1940 [1896] The Limitations of the Comparative Method of Anthropology. In Race, Language and Culture. Pp. 270–280. Chicago : University of Chicago Press.
- Boas, Franz 1940 [1912] Changes of Bodily Form in Descendents of Immigrants. In Race, Language and Culture. Pp. 60–75. Chicago : University of Chicago Press.
- Boas, Franz 1940 [1920] The Methods of Ethnology. In Race, Language and Culture. Pp. 281–289. Chicago : University of Chicago Press.
- Boas, Franz 1940 [1929] The Classification of American Indian Languages. In Race, Language and Culture. Pp. 219–225. Chicago : University of Chicago Press.
- Boas, Franz 1940 [1932] The Aims of Anthropological Research. In Race, Language and Culture. Pp. 243–259. Chicago : University of Chicago Press.
- Boas, Franz 1964 [1888] The Central Eskimo. Lincoln : University of Nebraska Press.
- Boas, Franz 1966a [1911] Introduction to Handbook of American Indian Languages. Preston Holder, ed. Lincoln : University of Nebraska Press.
- Boas, Franz 1966b Kwakiutl Ethnography. Helen Codere, ed. Chicago : University of Chicago Press.
- Boas, Franz 1974 [1887] The Principles of Ethnological Classification. In The Shaping of American Anthropology, 1883-1911: A Franz Boas Reader. George W. Stocking, ed. Pp. 61–67. New York : Basic Books.
- Boas, Franz 1974 [1889] The Aims of Ethnology. In The Shaping of American Anthropology, 1883-1911: A Franz Boas Reader. George W. Stocking, ed. Pp. 67–71. New York : Basic Books.
- Boas, Franz 1974 [1894] Human Faculty as Determined by Race. In The Shaping of American Anthropology, 1883-1911: A Franz Boas Reader. George W. Stocking, ed. Pp. 221–242. New York : Basic Books.
- Boon, James 1999 Verging on Extra-Vagance: Anthropology, History, Religion, Literature, Arts… Showbiz. Princeton : Princeton University Press.
- Brightman, Robert 1995 Forget Culture: Replacement, Transcendence, Relexification. Cultural Anthropology 10(4): 509–546.
- Chen, Xiaomei 1992 Occidentalism as Counterdiscourse: “He Shang” in Post-Mao China. Critical Inquiry 18(4): 686–712.
- Clifford, James 1988 The Predicament of Culture: Twentieth Century Ethnography, Literature, and Art. Cambridge , MA : Harvard University Press.
10.2307/j.ctvjf9x0h Google Scholar
- James Clifford, and George Marcus, eds. 1986 Writing Culture: The Poetics and Politics of Ethnography. Berkeley : University of California Press.
10.1525/9780520946286 Google Scholar
- Crystal, David 1987 The Cambridge Encyclopedia of Language. Cambridge : Cambridge University Press.
- Darnell, Regna 2001 Invisible Genealogies: A History of Americanist Anthropology. Lincoln : University of Nebraska Press.
- Dorian, Nancy 1998 Western Language Ideologies and Small-Language Prospects. In Endangered Languages: Language Loss and Community Response. Lenore Grenoble and Lindsay Whaley, eds. Pp. 3–21. Cambridge : Cambridge University Press.
10.1017/CBO9781139166959.002 Google Scholar
- Fabian, Johannes 1983 Time and the Other. New York : Columbia University Press.
- Akhil Gupta, and James Ferguson, eds. 1997 Culture, Power, Place: Explorations in Critical Anthropology. Durham , NC : Duke University Press.
10.1215/9780822382089 Google Scholar
- Hale, Grace Elizabeth 1998 Making Whiteness: The Culture of Segregation in the South, 1890-1940. New York : Vintage Books.
- Handler, Richard 1983 The Dainty and the Hungry Man: Literature and Anthropology in the Work of Edward Sapir. In Observers Observed. George Stocking, ed. Pp. 208–231. Madison : University of Wisconsin Press.
- Handler, Richard 1985 On Dialogue and Destructive Analysis: Problems in Narrating Nationalism and Ethnicity. Journal of Anthropological Research 41(2): 171–182.
- Handler, Richard 1988 Nationalism and the Politics of Culture in Quebec. Madison : University of Wisconsin Press.
- Handler, Richard, and Daniel Segal 1990 Jane Austen and the Fiction of Culture. Lanham , MD : Rowman and Littlefield.
- Harris, Marvin 1979 Cultural Materialism: The Struggle for a Science of Culture. New York : Vintage Books.
- Hays, Terence 1993 The New Guinea Highlands: Region, Culture Area, or Fuzzy Set. Current Anthropology 34(2): 141–164.
- Hegeman, Susan 1999 Patterns for America: Modernism and the Concept of Culture. Princeton : Princeton University Press.
10.1515/9781400823222 Google Scholar
- Herskovits, Melville 1924 A Preliminary Consideration of the Culture Areas of Africa. American Anthropologist 26(1): 50–63.
10.1525/aa.1924.26.1.02a00050 Google Scholar
- Hymes, Dell, and John Fought. 1981 American Structuralism. The Hague : Mouton.
10.1515/9783110879285 Google Scholar
- Kahn, Joel 1989 Culture: Demise or Resurrection? Critique of Anthropology 9(2): 5–25.
10.1177/0308275X8900900202 Google Scholar
- Kapchan, Deborah, and Pauline Turner Strong 1999 Theorizing the Hybrid. Journal of American Folklore 112(445): 239–253.
- Kearney, Michael 1995 The Local and the Global: The Anthropology of Globalization and Transnationalism. Annual Reviews in Anthropology 24: 547–565.
- Kroeber, Alfred 1931 The Culture-Area and Age-Area Concepts of Clark Wissler. In Methods in Social Science, a Case Book. Stuart Rice, ed. Pp. 248–265. Chicago : University of Chicago Press.
- Kroeber, Alfred 1948 [1923] Anthropology. Rev. edition. New York : Harcourt, Brace.
- Leclerc, Gérard 1972 Anthropologie et colonialisme, essai sur l'histoire de l'africanisme (Anthropology and colonialism: An essay on the history of Africanist anthropology). Paris : Fayard.
- Lederman, Rena 1998 Globalization and the Future of Culture Areas: Melanesian-ist Anthropology in Transition. Annual Reviews in Anthropology 27: 427–449.
- Linton, Ralph 1937 One Hundred Percent American. American Mercury 40 (April): 427–429.
- Lopez, Ian Haney 1996 White by Law: The Legal Construction of Race. New York : New York University Press.
- Lowie, Robert 1921 Primitive Society. London : Routledge and Kegan Paul.
- Lowie, Robert 1935 The History of Ethnological Theory. New York : Rinehart.
- Manganaro, Marc 2002 Culture, 1922. Princeton : Princeton University Press.
- Marcus, George 1998 Ethnography through Thick and Thin. Princeton : Princeton University Press.
- George Marcus, and Michael Fischer, eds. 1986 Anthropology as Cultural Critique. Chicago : University of Chicago Press.
- Mead, Margaret 1935 Sex and Temperament in Three Primitive Societies. New York : Morris Quill.
- Mead, Margaret 1938 The Mountain Arapesh, vol. 1: An Importing Culture. Anthropological Papers of the American Museum of Natural History, vol. 36, pt. 3.
- Mintz, Sidney 1998 The Localization of Anthropological Practice. Critique of Anthropology 18(2): 117–133.
- Henrietta Moore, ed. 1999 Anthropological Theory Today. Cambridge : Polity Press.
- Narayan, Kirin 1993 How Native Is a “Native” Anthropologist? American Anthropologist 95(3): 671–686.
- Obeyesekere, Gananath 1992 The Apotheosis of Captain Cook: European Mythmaking in the Pacific. Princeton : Princeton University Press.
10.1515/9781400843848 Google Scholar
- Patrol Reports 1909-74 Kokoda, Buna, Higaturu, and Popondetta Administrative Patrol Reports. Archived material, Papua New Guinea National Archives, Port Moresby, Papua New Guinea.
- Pletsch, Carl 1981 The Three Worlds, or the Division of Social Scientific Labor, circa 1950-1975. Comparative Studies in Society and History 23(4): 565–590.
- Rafael, Vicente 1994 The Culture of Area Studies in the United States. Social Text 41: 91–111.
10.2307/466834 Google Scholar
- Robbins, Joel 2004 Becoming Sinners: Christianity and Moral Torment in a Papua New Guinea Society. Berkeley : University of California Press.
10.1525/9780520937086 Google Scholar
- Sahlins, Marshall 1985 Islands of History. Chicago : University of Chicago Press.
- Said, Edward 1978 Orientalism. New York : Vintage Books.
- Sapir, Edward 1949 [1916] Time Perspective in Aboriginal American Culture: A Study in Method. In Selected Writings in Language Culture, and Personality. David Mandlebaum, ed. Pp. 389–462. Berkeley : University of California Press.
- Sapir, Edward 1949 [1924] Culture, Genuine and Spurious. In Selected Writings in Language, Culture, and Personality. David Mandlebaum, ed. Pp. 308–331. Berkeley : University of California Press.
- Sapir, Edward 1949 [1927] Anthropology and Sociology. In Selected Writings in Language, Culture, and Personality. David Mandlebaum, ed. Pp. 332–345. Berkeley : University of California Press.
- Sapir, Edward 1949 [1931] Fashion. In Selected Writings in Language Culture, and Personality. David Mandlebaum, ed. Pp. 373–381. Berkeley : University of California Press.
- Sapir, Edward 1949 [1932a] Cultural Anthropology and Psychiatry. In Selected Writings in Language, Culture, and Personality. David Mandlebaum, ed. Pp. 509–521. Berkeley : University of California Press.
- Sapir, Edward 1949 [1932b] Group. In Selected Writings in Language, Culture, and Personality. David Mandlebaum, ed. Pp. 357–364. Berkeley : University of California Press.
- Sapir, Edward 1949 [1938] Why Cultural Anthropology Needs the Psychiatrist. In Selected Writings in Language, Culture, and Personality. David Mandlebaum, ed. Pp. 569–577. Berkeley : University of California Press.
- Sapir, Edward 1994 The Psychology of Culture: A Course of Lectures. Judith Irvine, ed. and reconstructor. Berlin : Mouton de Gruyter.
- Sax, William 1998 The Hall of Mirrors: Orientalism, Anthropology, and the Other. American Anthropologist 100(2): 292–301.
- Segal, Daniel 2001 Anthropology of Multiculturalism. In International Encyclopedia of the Social and Behavioral Sciences, N. J. Smelser and P. B. Baltes, eds. Pp. 10179–10184. New York : Elsevier Science.
10.1016/B0-08-043076-7/00917-7 Google Scholar
- Silverstein, Michael 2004 Boasian Cosmographic Anthropology and the Sociocentric Component of Mind. History of Anthropology 10: 131–157.
- Stocking, George 1974 The Shaping of American Anthropology, 1883-1911: A Franz Boas Reader. George W. Stocking, ed. New York : Basic Books.
- Stocking, George 1992 The Ethnographer's Magic and Other Essays in the History of Anthropology. Madison : University of Wisconsin Press.
- Urban, Greg 2001 Metaculture: How Culture Moves through the World. Minneapolis : University of Minnesota Press.
- Wagner, Roy 1975 The Invention of Culture. Chicago : University of Chicago Press.
- Williams, F. E. 1930 Orokaiva Society. London : Oxford University Press.
- Wissler, Clark 1917 The American Indian: An Introduction to the Anthropology of the New World. New York : Douglas McMurtrie.
- Wolf, Eric 1972 Europe and the People without History. Berkeley : University of California Press.
- Yans-McLaughlin, Virginia 1984 Science, Democracy, and Ethics: Mobilizing Culture and Personality for World War II. In Malinowski, Rivers, Benedict, and Others. George Stocking, ed. Pp. 184–217. Madison : University of Wisconsin Press.
