At the level of the organism, previous studies have indicated that autophagy has an important role in the homeostasis of the central nervous system (CNS). For example, deletion of key autophagy regulators (ATG5, ATG7) in the CNS leads to progressive accumulation of ubiquitin‐containing aggregates and neurodegeneration (
Hara et al, 2006;
Komatsu et al, 2006), whereas deletion of Ambra1, a component of the Beclin‐1/Vps34 complex, causes major neural tube defects (
Fimia et al, 2007). To determine whether MCL‐1 regulates autophagy in the CNS, we examined the consequences of MCL‐1 deletion in post‐mitotic cortical neurons. Mice homozygous for a floxed MCL‐1 allele (MCL‐1
flox/flox) were crossed with animals carrying a CamKIIα Cre transgene, resulting in the expression of the Cre recombinase in neurons of the cortex, hippocampus and, to a lesser extent, striatum (
Casanova et al, 2001). MCL‐1
Δ/Δ mice were born at the expected ratio, but were smaller in size (
Figure 5A) and had a median lifespan of 49 days, with a few animals surviving to 3 months (see Figure 8E). Recombination of the floxed alleles was confirmed by western blot of tissue from the cortex of P14 animals (
Figure 5B). No change in protein expression was observed for BAX and BCL‐X
L (
Figure 5B), suggesting that there were little compensatory changes in these other BCL‐2 homologues highly expressed in the brain. Cresyl violet staining of brain sections revealed progressive cellular loss in cortical layers adjacent to the corpus callosum in MCL‐1
Δ/Δ animals, with extensive loss evident by P14 (
Figure 5C). As we hypothesised that MCL‐1 loss would result in increased autophagy, we measured several autophagic markers in MCL‐1
Δ/Δ mice. Brain sections from control and MCL‐1
Δ/Δ mice were stained for endogenous LC3, which appears as punctate staining in the cytosol of autophagic cells. As shown in
Figure 5E, LC3‐positive cells lined the cortical region where cell loss was observed in P14 MCL‐1
Δ/Δ animals, while minimal staining was present in control mice. Higher magnification images of the affected region confirmed punctate LC3 staining in cells of mutant, but not control animals (
Figure 5G; quantification in
Figure 5D). Co‐staining with the neuronal marker NeuN confirmed that neurons, but not glia, were affected (
Figure 5H). To further substantiate these results, the cortex of P14 control and MCL‐1
Δ/Δ mice was examined by electron microscopy. Compared with control, multiple vesicles containing portions of cytoplasm, including mitochondria, were present in the cortex of MCL‐1
Δ/Δ mice (
Figure 5F and I; asterisks denote autophagosomal structures; arrows denote mitochondria). These structures were delineated by a double membrane, indicative of autophagosomes (
Figure 5I, arrowheads point to the double membrane). As accumulation of autophagosomes could reflect a decrease in their clearance, we also determined p62 levels in MCL‐1
Δ/Δ brains as a measure of lysosomal degradation of autophagosomes. As shown in
Figure 6A, p62 levels were decreased in MCL‐1
Δ/Δ cortical extracts, suggesting that loss of MCL‐1 does not prevent lysosomal degradation of the autophagosomes. Altogether, these results indicate that the deletion of MCL‐1 in cortical neurons results in the deregulated activation of autophagy.
In addition to its role in the regulation of autophagy, MCL‐1 has a well‐characterised antiapoptotic role during development, including in the CNS (
Opferman et al, 2003,
2005;
Arbour et al, 2008). To determine whether MCL‐1 has a similarly important antiapoptotic role in post‐mitotic neurons, we analysed MCL‐1
Δ/Δ mice for the presence of apoptotic markers. The activated form of BAX (6A7‐reactive) and caspase‐3 were first detected at P7 in MCL‐1
Δ/Δ mice and were increased by P14 (
Figure 6B), suggesting that apoptosis is activated to some extent in these animals. To determine the relationship between autophagy and apoptosis activation, we further analysed BAX activation in relation to LC3 staining. In P7 MCL‐1
Δ/Δ mice, virtually all (97±3%) NeuN‐positive neurons were also positive for LC3 (
Figure 5H), while only 18±5% of the cells were positive for active BAX (
Figure 6B). These BAX‐positive cells are neurons with activated autophagy, as they co‐stained with LC3 (
Figure 6C). In addition, while there are no new cortical neurons generated after birth, the number of LC3‐positive neurons decreased at P14 compared with P7 with a concomitant increase in both active BAX and active caspase‐3‐positive cells that paralleled cellular loss. This suggests that a subset of the neurons that initially activate autophagy in response to MCL‐1 deletion undergo apoptosis over time, although we cannot exclude the possibility that apoptosis and autophagy are concomitantly activated in this subset of neurons. Nevertheless, the idea that autophagic MCL‐1 KO neurons eventually activate apoptosis is supported by the observation that while all BAX‐positive cells were also positive for LC3 at P7, a portion of these cells (8%) was LC3‐negative by P14 (
Figure 6C; quantification in Figure 8D), in accordance with the notion that apoptosis can inhibit autophagy (
Luo and Rubinsztein, 2010).
To further examine the effect of MCL‐1 loss on apoptosis in post‐mitotic neurons in a system where dying cells are more readily tractable, we deleted MCL‐1 from MCL‐1
flox/flox neurons in culture, which activates an autophagic response (
Figure 3G), and analysed the cells for the presence of apoptotic markers. There was no increase in apoptosis in MCL‐1 knockout neurons compared with control neurons for up to 10 days in culture, as determined by caspase‐3‐dependent cleavage of p130
CAS into a 31 kDa fragment (
Kook et al, 2000) (
Figure 6D) and cytochrome
c release (
Figure 6E). Altogether, these results suggest that the primary cellular response to MCL‐1 deletion in neurons is the induction of autophagy, consistent with our results in cell lines (
Figures 1,
2,
3).