Field estimation of variation in host plant use between local populations of pea aphids from two crops

Abstract. 1. In a reciprocal transplant experiment on pea aphids (Acyrthosiphon pisum (Harris)), the relative performance of clones collected from nearby alfalfa and red clover fields was tested by allowing clonal replicates to develop on both crops under field conditions.

2. Populations from alfalfa and red clover differed in relative survivorship and probabilities of reproduction on the two crops. Clones had significantly higher performance on the crop from which they were collected (the ‘home’ crop) than they did on the other crop.

3. Evidence is presented that previous experience on these host plants cannot account for the increased probability of reproduction observed on the ‘home’ crop. Thus, the differences between these two populations in their relative performance on alfalfa and clover are likely to be genetically based.

4. These results illustrate that local adaptation to different host plants can occur within small geographical areas, despite the high probability that migrants are exchanged between nearby fields of the two crops.

5. Experimental designs of the type described here permit estimation of patterns of genetic variation within and between insect populations. When applied to pest species, such designs will facilitate the study of evolution in agricultural systems.