Do they know something we don’t? Diffusion of repression in authoritarian regimes
Abstract
The use of repressive strategies by authoritarian regimes received a great deal of attention in the literature, but most explanations treat repression as the product of domestic events and factors. However, the similarity in repressive actions during the Arab Spring or the intense collaboration in dissident disappearances between the military regimes of Latin America indicate a transnational dimension of state repression and authoritarian interdependence that has gone largely understudied. The article develops a theory of diffusion of repression between autocracies between institutionally and experientially similar autocracies. It proposes that the high costs of repression and its uncertain effect on dissent determines autocracies to adjust their levels of repression based on information and knowledge obtained from their peers. Autocracies’ own experience with repression can offer suboptimal and incomplete information. Repression techniques and methods from other autocracies augment the decisionmaking regarding optimal levels of repression for political survival. Then, autocracies adjust their levels of repression based on observed levels of repression in their institutional and experiential peers. The results indicate that authoritarian regimes emulate and learn from regimes with which they share similar institutions. Surprisingly, regimes with similar dissent experience do not emulate and learn from each other. The results also indicate that regional conflict does not affect autocracies’ levels of repression.
Get full access to this article
View all access and purchase options for this article.
References
Abbas Hassan (2011) The dynamics of the uprising in Syria. Arab Reform Initiative, Arab Reform Brief 51, October (http://www.arab-reform.net/en/node/431).
Abouharb M Rodwan, Cingranelli David (2007) Human Rights and Structural Adjustment. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Anselin Luc (1988) Spatial Econometrics: Methods and Models. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic.
Bader Julia (2015) China, autocratic patron? An empirical investigation of China as a factor in autocratic survival. International Studies Quarterly 59(1): 23–33.
Bamert Justus, Gilardi Fabrizio, Wasserfallen Fabio (2015) Learning and the diffusion of regime contention in the Arab Spring. Research & Politics 2(3): 1–9.
Bank André, Edel Mirjam (2015) Authoritarian regime learning: Comparative insights from the Arab uprisings (https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2615708).
Baybeck Brady, Berry William D, Siegel David A (2011) A strategic theory of policy diffusion via intergovernmental competition. Journal of Politics 73(1): 232–247.
Bell Sam R, Chad Clay K, Murdie Amanda (2012) Neighborhood watch: Spatial effects of human rights INGOs. Journal of Politics 74(2): 354–368.
Bennett Colin J (1991) What is policy convergence and what causes it? British Journal of Political Science 21(2): 215–233.
Böhmelt Tobias, Clayton Govinda (2018) Auxiliary force structure: Paramilitary forces and progovernment militias. Comparative Political Studies 51(2): 197–237.
Böhmelt Tobias, Ruggeri Andrea, Pilster Ulrich (2017) Counterbalancing, spatial dependence, and peer group effects. Political Science Research and Methods 5(2): 221–239.
Bormann Nils-Christian, Hammond Jesse (2016) A slippery slope: The domestic diffusion of ethnic civil war. International Studies Quarterly 60(4): 587–598.
Braithwaite Alex, Braithwaite Jessica Maves, Kucik Jeffrey (2015) The conditioning effect of protest history on the emulation of nonviolent conflict. Journal of Peace Research 52(6): 697–711.
Bueno de Mesquita Bruce, Smith Alastair, Siverson Randolph M, Morrow James D (2003) The Logic of Political Survival. Cambridge, MA: MIT University Press.
Buhaug Halvard, Gleditsch Kristian Skrede (2008) Contagion or confusion? Why conflicts cluster in space. International Studies Quarterly 52(2): 215–233.
Carey Sabine C (2006) The dynamic relationship between protest and repression. Political Research Quarterly 59(1): 1–11.
Carey Sabine C (2010) The use of repression as a response to domestic dissent. Political Studies 58(1): 167–186.
Cheibub José Antonio, Gandhi Jennifer, Vreeland James Raymond (2010) Democracy and dictatorship revisited. Public Choice 143(1–2): 67–101.
Cingranelli David L, Richards David L (2010) The Cingranelli and Richards (CIRI) Human Rights Data project. Human Rights Quarterly 32(2): 401–424.
Coppedge Michael, Gerring John, Lindberg Staffan I, Skaaning Svend-Erik, Teorell Jan, Altman David, Andersson Frida, Bernhard Michael, Steven Fish M, Glynn Adam, Hicken Allen, Knutsen Carl Henrik, McMann Kelly, Mechkova Valeriya, Miri Farhad, Paxton Pamela, Pemstein Daniel, Sigman Rachel, Staton Jeffrey, Zimmerman Brigitte (2016) V-Dem codebook v6. Varieties of Democracy (V-Dem) project (https://www.v-dem.net/en/data/data-version-6/).
Danneman Nathan, Ritter Emily Hencken (2014) Contagious rebellion and preemptive repression. Journal of Conflict Resolution 58(2): 254–279.
Davenport Christian (1996) The weight of the past: Exploring lagged determinants of political repression. Political Research Quarterly 49(2): 377–403.
Davenport Christian (2007a) State repression and political order. Annual Review of Political Science 10: 1–23.
Davenport Christian (2007b) State repression and the tyrannical peace. Journal of Peace Research 44(4): 485–504.
Davis David R, Ward Michael D (1990) They dance alone: Deaths and the disappeared in contemporary Chile. Journal of Conflict Resolution 34(3): 449–475.
Desmarais Bruce A, Harden Jeffrey J, Boehmke Frederick J (2015) Persistent policy pathways: Inferring diffusion networks in the American states. American Political Science Review 109(2): 392–406.
Downs George W, Rocke David M, Barsoom Peter N (1996) Is the good news about compliance good news about cooperation? International Organization 50(3): 379–406.
Elhorst J Paul (2014) Spatial panel data models. In: Paul Elhorst J (ed.) Spatial Econometrics: From Cross-Sectional Data to Spatial Panels. Berlin & Heidelberg: Springer, 37–93.
Elkins Zachary, Simmons Beth (2005) On waves, clusters, and diffusion: A conceptual framework. Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 598(1): 33–51.
Escribà-Folch Abel (2013) Repression, political threats, and survival under autocracy. International Political Science Review 34(5): 543–560.
Fariss Christopher J (2014) Respect for human rights has improved over time: Modeling the changing standard of accountability. American Political Science Review 108(2): 297–318.
Fearon James D, Laitin David D (2003) Ethnicity, insurgency, and civil war. American Political Science Review 97(1): 75–90.
Fjelde Hanne (2010) Generals, dictators, and kings: Authoritarian regimes and civil conflict, 1973–2004. Conflict Management and Peace Science 27(3): 195–218.
Frantz Erica, Kendall-Taylor Andrea (2014) A dictator’s toolkit: Understanding how co-optation affects repression in autocracies. Journal of Peace Research 51(3): 332–346.
Franzese Robert J, Hays Jude C (2007) Spatial econometric models of cross-sectional interdependence in political science panel and time-series–cross-section data. Political Analysis 15(2): 140–164.
Franzese Robert J, Hays Jude C (2008) Interdependence in comparative politics substance, theory, empirics, substance. Comparative Political Studies 41(4–5): 742–780.
Gandhi Jennifer (2008) Political Institutions under Dictatorship. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Geddes Barbara, Wright Joseph, Frantz Erica (2014) Autocratic breakdown and regime transitions: A new dataset. Perspectives on Politics 12(2): 313–331.
Gilardi Fabrizio (2010) Who learns from what in policy diffusion processes? American Journal of Political Science 54(3): 650–666.
Gilardi Fabrizio (2012) Transnational diffusion: Norms, ideas, and policies. In: Carlsnaes Walter, Risse Thomas, Simmons Beth A (eds) Handbook of International Relations. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage, 453–477.
Gilardi Fabrizio (2016) Four ways we can improve policy diffusion research. State Politics & Policy Quarterly 16(1): 8–21.
Gleditsch Kristian Skrede (2002) Expanded trade and GDP data. Journal of Conflict Resolution 46(5): 712–724.
Gleditsch Kristian Skrede, Ward Michael D (2001) Measuring space: A minimum-distance database and applications to international studies. Journal of Peace Research 38(6): 739–758.
Gleditsch Kristian Skrede, Ward Michael D (2006) Diffusion and the international context of democratization. International Organizations 60(4): 911–933.
Gleditsch Nils Petter, Wallensteen Peter, Eriksson Mikael, Sollenberg Margareta, Strand Håvard (2002) Armed Conflict 1946–2001: A new dataset. Journal of Peace Research 39(5): 615–637.
Goldstein Robert Justin (1978) Political Repression in Modern America from 1870 to the Present. Chicago, IL: University of Illinois Press.
Greitens Sheena Chestnut (2016) Dictators and their Secret Police: Coercive Institutions and State Violence. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Hays Jude C, Kachi Aya, Franzese Robert J (2010) A spatial model incorporating dynamic, endogenous network interdependence: A political science application. Statistical Methodology 7(3): 406–428.
Hegre Håvard, Ellingsen Tanja, Gates Scott, Gleditsch Nils Petter (2001) Toward a democratic civil peace? Democracy, political change, and civil war, 1816–1992. American Political Science Review 95(1): 33–48.
Heydemann Steven, Leenders Reinoud (2014) Authoritarian learning and counterrevolution. In: Lynch Marc (ed.) The Arab Uprisings Explained: New Contentious Politics in the Middle East. New York: Columbia University Press, 75–92.
Hill Daniel W, Jones Zachary M (2014) An empirical evaluation of explanations for state repression. American Political Science Review 108(3): 661–687.
Kahneman Daniel, Slovic Paul, Tversky Amos, eds (1982) Judgment under Uncertainty: Heuristics and Biases. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Koremenos Barbara, Lipson Charles, Snidal Duncan (2001) The rational design of international institutions. International Organization 55(4): 761–799.
Leeds Brett Ashley (1999) Domestic political institutions, credible commitments, and international cooperation. American Journal of Political Science 43(4): 979–1002.
Lichbach Mark Irving (1987) Deterrence or escalation? The puzzle of aggregate studies of repression and dissent. Journal of Conflict Resolution 31(2): 266–297.
Lynch Marc (2014) The Arab Uprisings Explained: New Contentious Politics in the Middle East. New York: Columbia University Press.
Mattes Michaela, Rodríguez Mariana (2014) Autocracies and international cooperation. International Studies Quarterly 58(3): 527–538.
Maves Jessica, Braithwaite Alex (2013) Autocratic institutions and civil conflict contagion. Journal of Politics 75(2): 478–490.
McSherry J Patrice (2002) Tracking the origins of a state terror network: Operation Condor. Latin American Perspectives 29(1): 38–60.
Miller Michael K, Joseph Michael, Ohl Dorothy (2018) Are coups really contagious? An extreme bounds analysis of political diffusion. Journal of Conflict Resolution 62(2): 410–441.
Mitchell Neil J, McCormick James M (1988) Economic and political explanations of human rights violations. World Politics 40(4): 476–498.
Moore Will H (1998) Repression and dissent: Substitution, context, and timing. American Journal of Political Science 42(3): 851–873.
Moore Will H (2000) The repression of dissent: A substitution model of government coercion. Journal of Conflict Resolution 44(1): 107–127.
Neumayer Eric, Plümper Thomas, Epifanio Mariaelisa (2014) The ‘peer-effect’ in counterterrorist policies. International Organizations 68(1): 211–234.
Nordås Ragnhild, Davenport Christian (2013) Fight the youth: Youth bulges and state repression. American Journal of Political Science 57(4): 926–940.
Odinius Daniel, Kuntz Philipp (2015) The limits of authoritarian solidarity: The Gulf monarchies and preserving authoritarian rule during the Arab Spring. European Journal of Political Research 54(4): 639–654.
Ortmann Stephan, Thompson Mark R (2014) China’s obsession with Singapore: Learning authoritarian modernity. Pacific Review 27(3): 433–455.
Plümper Thomas, Neumayer Eric (2010) Model specification in the analysis of spatial dependence. European Journal of Political Research 49(3): 418–442.
Plümper Thomas, Troeger Vera E, Manow Philip (2005) Panel data analysis in comparative politics: Linking method to theory. European Journal of Political Research 44(2): 327–354.
Popovic Srdja, Joksic Mladen (2014) The secret of political jiu jitsu. Foreign Policy 3(March) (https://foreignpolicy.com/2014/03/03/the-secret-of-political-jiu-jitsu/).
Rivera Mauricio (2017) Authoritarian institutions and state repression: The divergent effects of legislatures and opposition parties on personal integrity rights. Journal of Conflict Resolution 61(10): 2183–2207.
Salehyan Idean (2007) Transnational rebels: Neighboring states as sanctuary for rebel groups. World Politics 59(2): 217–242.
Salehyan Idean, Gleditsch Kristian Skrede (2006) Refugees and the spread of civil war. International Organization 60(2): 335–366.
Shambaugh David L (2008) China’s Communist Party: Atrophy and Adaptation. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
Shellman Stephen M (2006) Process matters: Conflict and cooperation in sequential government–dissident interactions. Security Studies 15(4): 563–599.
Shipan Charles R, Volden Craig (2012) Policy diffusion: Seven lessons for scholars and practitioners. Public Administration Review 72(6): 788–796.
Simmons Beth A, Dobbin Frank, Garrett Geoffrey (2007) The global diffusion of public policies: Social construction, coercion, competition or learning? Annual Review of Sociology 33: 449–472.
Soest Christian (2015) Democracy prevention: The international collaboration of authoritarian regimes. European Journal of Political Research 54(4): 623–638.
Sullivan Christopher M (2017) Undermining resistance: Mobilization, repression, and the enforcement of political order. Journal of Conflict Resolution 60(7): 1163–1190.
Svolik Milan W (2012) The Politics of Authoritarian Rule. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Thoms Oskar NT, Ron James (2007) Do human rights violations cause internal conflict? Human Rights Quarterly 29(3): 674–705.
Tobler Waldo R (1970) A computer movie simulating urban growth in the Detroit region. Economic Geography 46(June): 234–240.
Tolstrup Jakob (2015) Black knights and elections in authoritarian regimes: Why and how Russia supports authoritarian incumbents in post-Soviet states. European Journal of Political Research 54(4): 673–690.
Ulfelder Jay (2005) Contentious collective action and the breakdown of authoritarian regimes. International Political Science Review 26(3): 311–334.
Ulrichsen Kristian Coates (2013) Bahrain’s uprising: Regional dimensions and international consequences. Stability: International Journal of Security and Development 2(1). https://doi.org/10.5334/sta.be.
Ward Hugh, Cao Xun (2012) Domestic and international influences on green taxation. Comparative Political Studies 45(9): 1075–1103.
Ward Michael D, Gleditsch Kristian Skrede (2008) Spatial Regression Models. London: Sage.
Way Lucan A (2015) The limits of autocracy promotion: The case of Russia in the ‘near abroad’. European Journal of Political Research 54(4): 691–706.
Wilson Matthew C (2014) A discreet critique of discrete regime type data. Comparative Political Studies 47(5): 689–714.
Wintrobe Ronald (2000) The Political Economy of Dictatorship. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Wood Reed M, Gibney Mark (2010) The Political Terror Scale (PTS): A re-introduction and a comparison to CIRI. Human Rights Quarterly 32(2): 367–400.
Yom Sean (2016) Collaboration and community amongst the Arab monarchies. Transnational Diffusion and Cooperation in the Middle East 21(August): 30–34.
Biographies
ROMAN-GABRIEL OLAR, b. 1989; PhD in Government (University of Essex, 2018); Assistant Professor, Trinity College Dublin (2018– ); current research interests: authoritarianism, repression, contentious politics.
