Full text loading...
Review Article
Free
Integrating the Civil–Military Relations Subfield
- Risa A. Brooks1
- Vol. 22:379-398 (Volume publication date May 2019) https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-polisci-060518-025407
- First published as a Review in Advance on January 30, 2019
-
Copyright © 2019 by Annual Reviews. All rights reserved
Abstract
The subfield of civil–military relations has experienced a remarkable revitalization in recent years, yielding a wealth of intriguing insights. Yet, despite these auspicious developments, research remains unnecessarily divided across multiple dimensions: along the subdisciplinary boundaries of comparative, international, and American politics; within these subdisciplines by independent and dependent variables; by regional focus; by regime type analyzed (democratic, democratizing versus authoritarian); and by scholars' emphasis on normative versus positive analysis. This article aims to bridge existing divides and reduce fragmentation. It proposes several pathways forward, including proposing innovations in deductive theorizing, developing new analytical frameworks, and synthesizing and adjudicating empirical findings. It also suggests ways of bridging to research beyond the study of civil–military relations, such as that on the global phenomenon of democratic backsliding, the efficacy of nonviolent strategies of political struggle, military effectiveness, and the causes and outcomes of interstate war.
Article metrics loading...
Literature Cited
- Aksoy D, Carter DB, Wright J 2015. Terrorism and the fate of dictators. World Politics 67:3423–68
- Albrecht H, Eibl F 2018. How to keep officers in the barracks: causes, agents, and types of military coups. Int. Stud. Q. 62:1315–28
- Albrecht H, Ohl D 2016. Exit, resistance, loyalty: military behavior during unrest in authoritarian regimes. Perspect. Politics 14:138–52
- Allen NDF 2018. Assessing a decade of U.S. military strategy in Africa. Orbis 62:4655–69
- Atkinson C 2006. Constructivist implications of material power: military engagement and the socialization of states, 1972–2000. Int. Stud. Q. 50:3509–37
- Avant D 1994. Political Institutions and Military Change: Lessons from Peripheral Wars Ithaca, NY: Cornell Univ. Press
- Avant D 1996–1997. Are the reluctant warriors out of control?. Secur. Stud. 6:251–90
- Bacevich A 2007. Elusive bargain: the pattern of U.S. civil–military relations since World War II. Long War: A History of U.S. National Security Policy Since World War II A Bacevich 207–65 New York: Cambridge Univ. Press
- Bacevich A 2013. The New American Militarism New York: Oxford Univ. Press, 2nd ed..
- Barany Z 2012. The Soldier and the Changing State: Building Democratic Armies in Africa, Asia, Europe and the Americas Princeton, NJ: Princeton Univ. Press
- Barany Z 2016. How Armies Respond to Revolutions and Why Princeton, NJ: Princeton Univ. Press
- Belkin A, Schofer E 2003. Toward a structural understanding of coup risk. J. Confl. Resolut. 47:5594–620
- Bell C 2016. Coup d'état and democracy. Comp. Political Stud. 49:91167–200
- Bell C, Sudduth JK 2017. The causes and outcomes of coup during civil war. J. Confl. Resolut. 61:71432–455
- Bellin E 2012. Reconsidering the robustness of authoritarianism in the Middle East: lessons from the Arab Spring. Comp. Politics 44:2127–49
- Betts RK 1991 (1977). Soldiers, Statesmen, and Cold War Crises New York: Columbia Univ. Press
- Biddle S, Zirkle R 1996. Technology, civil-military relations, and warfare in the developing world. J. Strateg. Stud. 19:2171–212
- Blankshain J, Cohn L, Kriner D 2017. Was Abrams wrong? The political costs of military mobilization Paper presented at the Biennial Conference of the Inter-University Seminar on Armed Forces and Society Nov. 3–5 Reston, VA:
- Böhmelt T, Clayton G 2017. Auxillary force structure: paramilitary forces and progovernment militias. Comp. Political Studies 51:2197–237
- Böhmelt T, Pilster U 2015. The impact of institutional coup-proofing on coup attempts and coup outcomes. Int. Interact. 41:158–82
- Bou Nassif H 2015a. Generals and autocrats: how coup-proofing predetermined the military elite's behavior in the Arab Spring. Political Sci. Q. 130:2245–75
- Bou Nassif H 2015b. A military besieged: the armed forces, the police and the party in Bin ‘Ali's Tunisia, 1987–2011. Int. J. Middle East Stud. 47:165–87
- Brooks R 1998. Political–Military Relations and the Stability of Arab Regimes Adelphi Paper 324 New York: Oxford Univ. Press
- Brooks R 2006. An autocracy at war: explaining Egypt's military effectiveness, 1967 and 1973. Secur. Stud. 15/3:July–Sept.396–430
- Brooks R 2008. Shaping Strategy: The Civil–Military Politics of Strategic Assessment Princeton, NJ: Princeton Univ. Press
- Brooks R 2009. Militaries and political activity in democracies. 2009213–39
- Brooks R 2013. Abandoned at the palace: why the Tunisian military defected from the Ben Ali regime in January 2011. J. Strateg. Stud. 36:2205–20
- Brooks R 2016. How Everything Became War and the Military Became Everything: Tales from the Pentagon New York: Simon & Schuster
- Brooks R 2017. Military defection and the Arab Spring. Oxf. Res. Encycl. Politics Feb. 27. Retrieved Dec. 21, 2018. http://oxfordre.com/politics/view/10.1093/acrefore/9780190228637.001.0001/acrefore-9780190228637-e-26
- Bruneau TD 2013. Impediments to the accurate conceptualization of civil–military relations. The Routledge Handbook of Civil–Military Relations T Bruneau, FC Matei 13–21 London: Routledge
- Bruneau TD, Tollefson SD 2006. Who Guards the Guardians and How: Democratic Civil–Military Relations Austin, TX: Univ. Texas Press
- Burbach DT 2019. Partisan dimensions of confidence in the U.S. military, 1973–2016. Armed Forces Soc 45:2211–33
- Burk J 2001. The military's presence in American society, 1950–2000. See Feaver & Kohn 2001247–73
- Carey S, Colaresi MP, Mitchell NJ 2016. Risk mitigation, regime security, and militias: beyond coup-proofing. Int. Stud. Q. 60:59–72
- Castillo J 2014. Endurance in War: The National Sources of Military Cohesion Stanford, CA: Stanford Univ. Press
- Caverley JD, Savage JD 2017. When human capital threatens the Capitol: foreign aid in the form of military training and coups. J. Peace Res. 54:4542–57
- Cohen EA 2002. Supreme Command: Soldiers, Statesmen and Leadership in Wartime New York: Simon & Schuster
- Cook S 2007. Ruling, But Not Governing Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins Univ. Press
- Cortright D 2005. Soldiers in Revolt: GI Resistance During the Vietnam War Chicago: Haymarket Books
- Croissant A, Kuehn D, Chambers P, Wolf SO 2010. Beyond the fallacy of coup-ism: conceptualizing civilian control of the military in emerging democracies. Democratization 17:5950–75
- Davidson J 2013. The contemporary presidency: civil–military friction and presidential decision-making: explaining the broken dialogue. Presidential Stud. Q. 43:1129–45
- De Bruin E 2018. Preventing coups d'état: how counterbalancing works. J. Confl. Resolut. 62:71433–58
- Decaulo S 1989. Modalities of civil–military stability in Africa. J. Modern Afr. Stud. 27:4547–78
- Dempsey JK 2010. Our Army: Soldiers, Politics, and American Civil–Military Relations Princeton, NJ: Princeton Univ. Press
- Desch MC 1999. Civilian Control of the Military: The Changing Security Environment Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins Univ. Press
- Desch MC 2001. Explaining the gap: Vietnam, the Republicanization of the South, and the end of the mass army. 2001289–325
- Fallows J 2015. The tragedy of the American military. Atlantic Jan./Feb. https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2015/01/the-tragedy-of-the-american-military/383516/
- Feaver PD 1999. Civil–military relations. Annu. Rev. Political Sci. 2:211–41
- Feaver PD 2003. Armed Servants: Agency, Oversight, and Civil–Military Relations Cambridge, MA: Harvard Univ. Press
- Feaver PD 2016. Civil–military relations and policy: a sampling of a new wave of scholarship. J. Strateg. Stud. 40:1/2325–42
- Feaver PD, Gelpi C 2005. Choosing Your Battles: American Civil–Military Relations and the Use of Force Princeton, NJ: Princeton Univ. Press
- Feaver PD, Hikotani T, Narine S 2005. Civilian control and civil–military gaps in the United States, Japan and China. Asian Perspect 29:1233–71
- Feaver PD, Kohn RH 2001. Soldiers and Civilians: The Civil–Military Gap and American National Security Cambridge, MA: MIT Press
- Finer SE 1962. The Man on Horseback: The Role of the Military in Politics London: PallMall
- Fordham B 2001. Military interests and civilian politics: the influence of the civil–military gap on peacetime military policy. 2001327–61
- Gassebner M, Gutman J, Voigt S 2016. When to expect a coup d'etat? An extreme bounds analysis of coup determinants. Public Choice 169:3293–313
- Glassmeyer K, Sambanis N 2008. Rebel–military integration and civil war termination. J. Peace Res. 43:3365–84
- Golby J, Karlin M 2018. Why “best military advice” is bad for the military—and worse for civilians. Orbis 68:1137–53
- Golby J, Feaver PD, Dropp K 2017. Elite military cues and public opinion about the use of military force. Armed Forces Soc 44:144–71
- Greitens S 2016. Dictators and Their Secret Police: Coercive Institutions and State Violence Cambridge, UK: Cambridge Univ. Press
- Grewal S 2019. Military defection during localized protests: the case of Tataouine. Int. Stud. Q. In press
- Harkness KA 2016. The ethnic army and the state: explaining coup traps and the difficulties of democratization in Africa. J. Confl. Resolut. 60:4587–616
- Harkness KA 2017. Military loyalty and the failure of democratization in Africa. Democratization 24:5801–28
- Hunter W 1998. Negotiating civil–military relations in post-authoritarian Argentina and Chile. Int. Stud. Q. 42:2295–317
- Huntington SP 1957. The Soldier and the State: The Theory and Politics of Civil–Military Relations Cambridge, MA: Harvard Univ. Press
- Huntington SP 1991. The Third Wave: Democratization in Changing Societies Norman, OK: Univ. Oklahoma Press
- Janowitz M 1960. The Professional Soldier: A Social and Political Portrait Glencoe, IL: Free Press
- Johnson PL 2017. Virtuous shirking: social identity, military recruitment, and unwillingness to repress PhD Diss. Univ. Calif. Davis Davis, CA:
- Johnson PL, Thurber C 2017. The security force ethnicity project: introducing a new dataset. Conflict Manag. Peace Sci. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/0738894217709012
- Kandil H 2012. Soldiers, Spies and Statesmen. Egypt's Road to Revolt Brooklyn, NY: Verso
- Ketchley N 2017. Egypt in a Time of Revolution Cambridge, UK: Cambridge Univ. Press
- Kohn RH 1994. Out of control: the crisis of civil–military relations. Natl. Interest 35:3–17
- Kriner DL 2010. After the Rubicon: Congress, Presidents and the Politics of Waging War Chicago: Univ. Chicago Press
- Kurlantzick J 2018. People abroad are asking their militaries to save their democracies. It won't work. Washington Post Apr. 13:201
- Lagasse P, Saideman SM 2017. Public critic or secretive monitor: party objectives and legislative oversight of the military in Canada. West Eur. Politics 40:1119–38
- Lee CA 2015. The politics of military operations PhD Diss. Stanford Univ. Stanford, CA:
- Lee T 2015. Defect or Defend: Military Responses to Popular Protests in Authoritarian Asia Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins Univ. Press
- Liebert H, Golby J 2017. Midlife crisis? The all-volunteer force at 40. Armed Forces Soc 43:1115–38
- Lupton D 2017. Out of the service, into the House: military experience and congressional war oversight. Political Res. Q. 70:2327–39
- Mahoney-Norris KA 2008. The retired officer and the state. Inside Defense: Understanding the U.S. Military in the 21st Century DS Reveron, JH Stiehm 205–20 New York: Palgrave Macmillan
- Marinov N, Goemans H 2014. Coups and democracy. Br. J. Political Sci. 44:4799–825
- McLauchlin T 2010. Loyalty strategies and military defection in rebellion. Comp. Politics 42:3333–50
- McLauchlin T, La Parra-Perez A 2018. Disloyalty and logics of fratricide in civil war: executions of officers in Republican Spain, 1936–1939. Comp. Political Stud. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/0010414018774373
- McMahon RB, Slanchev B 2015. The guardianship dilemma: regime security through and from the armed forces. Am. Political Sci. Rev. 109:2297–313
- Milner HV, Tingley D 2015. Sailing the Water's Edge: The Domestic Politics of American Foreign Policy Princeton, NJ: Princeton Univ. Press
- Morency-Laflamme J 2018. A question of trust: military defection during regime crises in Benin and Togo. Democratization 25:3464–80
- N'Diaye B 2001. Ivory Coast's civilian control strategies 1961–1998: a critical assessment. J. Political Mil. Sociol. 28:2246–70
- Nielsen SC, Snider DM 2009. American Civil–Military Relations: The Soldier and the State in a New Era Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins Univ. Press
- Nordlinger EA 1977. Soldiers in Politics: Military Coups and Governments Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall
- O'Donnell GA, Schmitter P, Whitehead L 1986. Transitions from Authoritarian Rule Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins Univ. Press
- Owens M 2011. U.S. Civil–Military Relations After 9/11: Renegotiating the Civil–Military Bargain New York: Continuum
- Perlmutter A, Leogrande W 1982. The party in uniform: toward a theory of civil–military relations in communist systems. Am. Political Sci. Rev. 76:4778–89
- Pilster U, Böhmelt T 2011. Coup-proofing and military effectiveness in interstate wars, 1967–99. Confl. Manag. Peace Sci. 28:41–20
- Pilster U, Böhmelt T 2012. Do democracies engage less in coup-proofing? On the relationship between regime type and civil-military relations. Foreign Policy Anal 8:4355–72
- Pion-Berlin D 1997. Through Corridors of Power: Institutions and Civil–Military Relations in Argentina University Park, PA: Pa. State Univ. Press
- Pion-Berlin D, Esparza D, Grisham K 2012. Staying quartered: civilian uprisings and military disobedience in the twenty-first century. Comp. Political Studies 42:7230–59
- Piplani V, Talmadge C 2016. When war helps civil–military relations: prolonged interstate conflict and the reduced risk of coups. J. Confl. Resolut. 60:81368–94
- Posen B 1984. The Sources of Military Doctrine: France, Britain, and Germany between the World Wars. Cornell Stud. Secur. Aff Ithaca, NY: Cornell Univ. Press
- Powell JM 2012. Determinants of the attempting and outcome of coups d'état. J. Confl. Resolut. 56:61017–40
- Powell JM, Thyne CL 2011. Global instances of coups from 1950 to 2010: a new dataset. J. Peace Res. 48:2249–59
- Quinlivin J 1999. Coup-proofing: its practice and consequences in the Middle East. Int. Secur. 24:Fall131–65
- Rahbek-Clemmensen J, Archer EM, Barr J, Belkin A, Guerrero M et al. 2012. Conceptualizing the civil–military gap: a research note. Armed Forces Soc 38:4669–78
- Rapp WE 2015. Civil-military relations: the role of military leaders in strategy making. Parameters 45:313–26
- Recchia S 2015. Reassessing the Reluctant Warriors: U.S. Civil–Military Relations and Multilateral Intervention Ithaca, NY: Cornell Univ. Press
- Ricks TE 1997. The widening gap between the military and society. Atlantic Monthly July 280:166–78
- Roessler P 2016. Ethnic Politics and State Power in Africa: The Logic of the Coup–Civil War Trap Cambridge, UK: Cambridge Univ. Press
- Ruffa C, Dandeker C, Vennesson P 2013. Soldiers drawn into politics? The influence of tactics in civil–military relations. Small Wars Insurgencies 24:2322–34
- Schake K, Mattis J 2016. Warriors and Citizens: American Views of Our Military Stanford, CA: Hoover Inst. Press
- Sechser T 2004. Are soldiers less war-prone than statesmen?. J. Confl. Resolut. 48:5746–74
- Shields P 2017. Symposium: roundtable on the ethics of senior officer resignation in the United States. Armed Forces Soc 43:13–4
- Singh N 2014. Seizing Power: The Strategic Logic of Military Coups Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins Univ. Press
- Snider DM, Matthews LJ 2005. The Future of the Army Profession New York: McGraw-Hill Primis, 2nd ed..
- Stacher J 2012. Adaptable Autocrats: Regime Power in Egypt and Syria Stanford, CA: Stanford Univ. Press
- Stepan A 1973. The new professionalism of internal warfare and military role expansion. Authoritarian Brazil: Origins, Politics and Future A Stepan 47–69 New Haven, CT: Yale Univ. Press
- Stepan A 1988. Rethinking Military Politics: Brazil and the Southern Cone Princeton, NJ: Princeton Univ. Press
- Strachan H 1997. The Politics of the British Army Oxford, UK: Oxford Univ. Press
- Sudduth JK 2017. Strategic logic of elite purges in dictatorships. Comp. Political Stud. 50:131768–1801
- Svolik M 2012. The Politics of Authoritarian Rule Cambridge, UK: Cambridge Univ. Press
- Talmadge C 2015. The Dictator's Army: Battlefield Effectiveness in Authoritarian Regimes Ithaca, NY: Cornell Univ. Press
- Taylor BD 2003. Politics and the Russian Army: Civil–Military Relations, 1689–2000 Cambridge, UK: Cambridge Univ. Press
- Thompson WR 1973. Grievances of Military Coup-Makers Beverly Hills, CA: Sage
- Ulrich MP 2015. “Cashing in” stars: Does the professional ethic apply in retirement?. Strategic Stud. Q. 9:3102–25
- Urben HA 2013. Party, politics and deciding what is proper: army officers' attitudes after two long wars. Orbis 57:3351–68
- Van Evera S 1984. The cult of the offensive and the origins of the First World War. Int. Secur. 9:Summer58–107
- Waldner D, Lust E 2018. Unwelcome change: coming to terms with democratic backsliding. Annu. Rev. Political Sci. 21:93–113
- Weeks J 2012. Strongmen and straw men: authoritarian regimes and the initiation of international conflict. Am. Political Sci. Rev. 106:2326–47
- White P 2017. Crisis and crisis generations: the long-term impact of international crises on military political participation. Secur. Stud. 26:4575–605
- Wright J, Geddes B, Frantz E, Derpanopoulos G 2016. Are coups good for democracy?. Washington Post Monkey Cage Blog Feb. 22. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/monkey-cage/wp/2016/02/22/are-coups-good-for-democracy/?utm_term=.e301d1284846
- Article Type: Review Article
Most Read This Month
Most Cited Most Cited RSS feed
-
-
-
-
Discursive Institutionalism: The Explanatory Power of Ideas and Discourse
Vol. 11 (2008), pp. 303–326
-
-
-
-
-
The Origins and Consequences of Affective Polarization in the United States
Vol. 22 (2019), pp. 129–146
-
-
-
-
-
Public Attitudes Toward Immigration
Vol. 17 (2014), pp. 225–249
-
-
-
-
-
Economic Determinants of Electoral Outcomes
Vol. 3 (2000), pp. 183–219
-
- More Less