Expertise and the PhD: Between depth and a flat place
Robyn Barnacle
School of Graduate Research, RMIT University, Melbourne, Australia
Search for more papers by this authorChristine Schmidt
School of Graduate Research, RMIT University, Melbourne, Australia
Search for more papers by this authorDenise Cuthbert
School of Graduate Research, RMIT University, Melbourne, Australia
Search for more papers by this authorRobyn Barnacle
School of Graduate Research, RMIT University, Melbourne, Australia
Search for more papers by this authorChristine Schmidt
School of Graduate Research, RMIT University, Melbourne, Australia
Search for more papers by this authorDenise Cuthbert
School of Graduate Research, RMIT University, Melbourne, Australia
Search for more papers by this authorAbstract
Expertise is under sustained interrogation. We see it in so-called edu-scepticism and pessimism about graduates’ apparently diminishing employment prospects, challenges to the role of Higher Education institutions as arbiters of knowledge and post-truth rhetoric more broadly. This paper examines how the PhD is being discursively positioned in this context. We ask what these changing conceptions of expertise, education and work mean for how PhD-level expertise is understood. Drawing on a range of sources, from the scholarly to the wider media, we draw together five exemplar models of expertise to expose the transforming ratio between generalist, transferable skills and specialist knowledge. The evident diminution of specialisation raises numerous issues for the PhD as it is increasingly called upon to serve multiple and potentially contradictory needs: an innovation society on the one hand and the discipline on the other. Reconciling the tension between depth and breadth is an important issue for a degree whose hallmark is—or at least has been—depth.
REFERENCES
- Academic Council CIT. (2012). Framework for professional doctorates in CIT. Retrieved from https://www.cit.ie/contentfiles/postgrad/Policy Docs/Framework for Professional Doctorate (AC, 2012).pdf
- ACOLA. (2016). Media release: Renaissance reborn: Mixing skills for smarter firms. Retrieved from https://acola.org.au/wp/110-media-release-renaissance-reborn-mixing-skills-for-smarter-firms/
- Addis, M., & Winch, C. (2017). Introduction. Journal of Philosophy of Education, 51(3), 557–573. https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-9752.12250
- Akay, E. (2015). Which letter-shaped will future employees and leaders be? Retrieved from https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/which-letter-shaped-future-employees-leaders-esin-akay
- Anders Ericsson, K., Prietula, M. J., & Cokely, E. T. (2007). The making of an expert. Business Review, July-August. Retrieved from https://hbr.org/2007/07/the-making-of-an-expert
- Aoun, J. E. (2017). Robot-proof: Higher education in the age of artificial intelligence [Kindle DX version]. Retrieved from Amazon.com
10.7551/mitpress/11456.001.0001 Google Scholar
- Australian Government. (2011). Research skills for an innovative future: A research workforce strategy to cover the decade to 2020 and beyond. Retrieved from https://docs.education.gov.au/system/files/doc/other/research_skills_for_an_innovative_future.pdf
- Australian Government. (2016). Driving innovation, fairness and excellence in Australian higher education. Retrieved from https://docs.education.gov.au/system/files/doc/other/he_reform_paper_driving_innovation_fairness_and_excellence_3_may_2016.pdf
- Barnacle, R., & Dall’Alba, G. (2011). Research degrees as professional education? Studies in Higher Education, 36(4), 459–470. https://doi.org/10.1080/03075071003698607
- Barnacle, R., & Dall’Alba, G. (2017). Committed to learn: Student engagement and care in higher education. Higher Education Research & Development, 36(7), 1326–1338. https://doi.org/10.1080/07294360.2017.1326879
- Barnett, R. (2015). Understanding the university: Institution, idea, possibilities. Foundations and futures of education. Abingdon, UK: Routledge.
10.4324/9781315678245 Google Scholar
- Barnett, R. (2017). The ecological university: A feasible utopia. Abingdon, UK: Routledge.
10.4324/9781315194899 Google Scholar
- Borrell-Damian, L., Brown, T., Dearing, A., Font, J., Hagen, S., Metcalfe, J., & Smith, J. (2010). Collaborative doctoral education: University–industry partnerships for enhancing knowledge exchange. Higher Education Policy, 23, 493–514.
- Brey, P. (2001). Hubert Dreyfus: Humans versus computers. In H. Achterhuis (Ed.), American philosophy of technology: The empirical turn (pp. 37–63). Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press.
- Bridgstock, R. (2015). KEY-shaped people, not T-shaped people—Disciplinary agility and 21st century work. Retrieved from https://www.futurecapable.com/?p=102
- Carey, K. (2015). The end of college: Creating the future of learning and the University of Everywhere [Kindle DX version]. Retrieved from Amazon.com
- Christensen, C. M., Eyring, H. J., & Grout, D. (2011). The innovative university: Changing the DNA of higher education from the inside out. Retrieved from https://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/RMIT/detail.action?docID=697739
- Clark, D. (2016). 4 lessons from the global financial crisis and austerity. Retrieved from https://policypress.wordpress.com/2016/02/18/4-lessons-from-the-global-financial-crisis-and-austerity/
- Clark, W. (2006). Academic charisma and the origins of the research university. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
- Clarke, G., & Lunt, I. (2014). International comparisons in postgraduate education: Quality, access and employment outcomes. Retrieved from https://www.hefce.ac.uk/media/hefce/content/pubs/indirreports/2014/International,comparisons, in, PG, education/International%20comparisons%20in%20postgraduate%20education%20-%20quality,%20access%20and%20employment%20outcomes.pdf
- Collins, H. M., & Evans, R. (2002). The third wave of science studies: Studies of expertise and experience. Social Studies of Science, 32(2), 235–296. https://doi.org/10.1177/0306312702032002003
- Cowan, P. (2017). Are ‘edusceptics’ right to portray higher education as a big con? Retrieved from https://www.timeshighereducation.com/features/are-edusceptics-right-portray-higher-education-big-con
- Cox, M. F., Adams, S. G., & Omer, I. S. (2011). Creating comprehensive educational experiences for the 21st century Ph.D. In D. M. Callejo Pérez, S. M. Fain, & J. J. Slater (Eds.), Higher education and human capital: Re/thinking the doctorate in America (pp. 3–18). Rotterdam, The Netherlands: Sense.
- Cryer, P. (1998). Transferable skills, marketability and lifelong learning: The particular case of postgraduate research students. Studies in Higher Education, 23(2), 207–216. https://doi.org/10.1080/03075079812331380394
- Cuthbert, D., & Molla, T. (2015a). PhD crisis discourse: A critical approach to the framing of the problem and some Australian ‘solutions’. Higher Education, 69, 33–53. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10734-014-9760-y
- Cuthbert, D., & Molla, T. (2015b). The politicization of the PhD and the employability of doctoral graduates: An Australian case study in a global context. In D. E. Neubauer & K. Ghazali (Eds.), Technology and workplace skills for the twenty-first century: Asia Pacific universities in the globalized economy (pp. 95–111). New York, NY: Palgrave Macmillan.
10.1057/9781137491923_8 Google Scholar
- Cyranoski, D., Gilbert, N., Ledford, H., Nayar, A., & Yahia, M. (2011). Education: The PhD factory. Nature News, 472(7343), 276–279. https://doi.org/10.1038/472276a
- Dreyfus, H. L., & Dreyfus, S. E. (1986). Mind over machine: The power of human intuition and expertise in the era of the computer. New York, NY: Free Press.
- Dreyfus, H. L., & Dreyfus, S. E. (1988). Making a mind versus modeling the brain: Artificial Intelligence back at a branchpoint. Daedalus, 117(1), 15–43.
- Evans, T., Evans, B., & Marsh, H. (2008). Australia. In M. Nerad & M. Heggelund (Eds.), Toward a global PhD? Forces and forms in doctoral education worldwide (pp. 171–203). Seattle, WA: University of Washington Press.
- Fell, T., Flint, K., & Haines, I. (2011). Professional doctorates in the UK 2011. Retrieved from https://www.ukcge.ac.uk/media/download.aspx?MediaId=1281
- Finkel, A. (2016). Opening keynote: Innovation and science postgraduate research education forum. Retrieved from https://www.chiefscientist.gov.au/wp-content/uploads/29-July-Council-of-Deans-of-Science-DR-ALAN-FINKEL-AO.pdf
- Garrett, S. K., Caldwell, B. S., Harris, E. C., & Gonzalez, M. C. (2009). Six dimensions of expertise: A more comprehensive definition of cognitive expertise for team coordination. Theoretical Issues in Ergonomics Science, 10(2), 93–105. https://doi.org/10.1080/14639220802059190
10.1080/14639220802059190 Google Scholar
- Gibbs, P. (2017). Why universities should seek happiness and contentment. London, UK: Bloomsbury Academic.
- Gilbert, R., Balatti, J., Turner, P., & Whitehouse, H. (2004). The generic skills debate in research higher degrees. Higher Education Research & Development, 23(3), 375–388. https://doi.org/10.1080/0729436042000235454
10.1080/0729436042000235454 Google Scholar
- Gladwell, M. (2008). Outliers: The story of success. Boston, MA: Little, Brown.
- Glover, B. (2017). Professor Barney Glover’s address to the National Press Club. Retrieved from https://www.universitiesaustralia.edu.au/Media-and-Events/media-releases/Professor-Barney-Glover -.WXaXCtOGPOQ
- Golde, C. M. (2006). Preparing stewards of the discipline. In C. M. Golde & Walker (Eds.), Envisioning the future of doctoral education (pp. 3–20). San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
- Golde, C. M., & Walker, G. E. (2006). Envisioning the future of doctoral education: Preparing stewards of the discipline. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
- Gould, J. (2015, December 3). How to build a better PhD. Nature, 528, 22–25. https://doi.org/10.1038/528022a
- Group of Eight (Go8) Australia. (2013). The changing PhD. Canberra, Australia: Author.
- Group of Eight (Go8) Australia. (2017). Go8 warn: Research university achievements and values under attack. Canberra, Australia: Author. Retrieved from https://www.go8.edu.au/article/go8-warn-research-university-achievements-and-values-under-attack
- Grundmann, R. (2017). The problem of expertise in knowledge societies. Minerva, 55, 25–48. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11024-016-9308-7
- Hancock, S., Hughes, G., & Walsh, E. (2017). Purist or pragmatist? UK doctoral scientists’ moral positions on the knowledge economy. Studies in Higher Education, 42(7), 1244–1258. https://doi.org/10.1080/03075079.2015.1087994
- Harman, G. (2002). Producing PhD graduates in Australia for the knowledge economy. Higher Education Research & Development, 21, 179–190. https://doi.org/10.1080/07294360220144097
10.1080/07294360220144097 Google Scholar
- Higher Education Commission. (2012). Postgraduate education: An independent enquiry by the higher education commission. Retrieved from https://www.policyconnect.org.uk/hec/sites/site_hec/files/report/329/fieldreportdownload/hec-postgraduateeducationreport.pdf
- Jackson, A. E. (2017). Google and 14 more companies that no longer require a degree—Apply now. Retrieved from https://www.glassdoor.com/blog/no-degree-required/
- Johansson, F. (2006). The medici effect: What elephant and epidemics can teach us about innovation. Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press.
- Kotzee, B., & Smit, J. (2017). Two social dimensions of expertise. Journal of Philosophy of Education, 51(3), 640–654. https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-9752.12255
- Krook, J. (2017). Degrees of separation: Companies shed degree requirements to promote merit over qualifications. The Conversation. Retrieved from https://theconversation.com/degrees-of-separation-companies-shed-degree-requirements-to-promote-merit-over-qualifications-76150
- Lam, B. (2015). The best job candidates don’t always have college degrees. Retrieved from https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2015/09/ernest-young-degree-recruitment-hiring-credentialism/406576/
- Lunt, I., McAlpine, L., & Mills, D. (2014). Lively bureaucracy? The ESRC’s Doctoral Training Centres and UK universities. Oxford Review of Education, 40(2), 151–169. https://doi.org/10.1080/03054985.2013.862167
- Lynda.com. (2017). About us. Retrieved from https://www.lynda.com/aboutus/
- Mansharamani, V. (2012). All hail the generalist. Retrieved from https://hbr.org/2012/06/all-hail-the-generalist
- Mars, M. M., Bresonis, K., & Szelényi, K. (2014). Science and engineering doctoral student socialization, logics, and the national economic agenda: Alignment or disconnect? Minerva, 52(3), 351–379. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11024-014-9256-z
- Monkman, E., & Seagull, B. (2017). Monkman and Seagull’s polymathic adventure. Retrieved from https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b091szlz
- Mowbray, S., & Halse, C. (2010). The purpose of the PhD: Theorising the skills acquired by students. Higher Education Research & Development, 29(6), 653–664. https://doi.org/10.1080/07294360.2010.487199
- Mukherjee, S. (2017). A.I. versus M.D.: What happens when diagnosis is automated? Retrieved from https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2017/04/03/ai-versus-md
- Nichols, T. (2017). The crisis of expertise. Retrieved from https://aeon.co/essays/its-time-to-reboot-the-relationship-between-expertise-and-democracy
- Noveck, B. S. (2016). Enough of experts? Data, democracy and the future of expertise. Retrieved from https://www.socialsciencespace.com/2016/11/enough-experts-data-democracy-future-expertise/
- Oliver, B. (2015). Redefining graduate employability and work-integrated learning: Proposals for effective higher education in disrupted economies. Journal of Teaching and Language for Graduate Employability, 6(1), 56–65.
10.21153/jtlge2015vol6no1art573 Google Scholar
- O’Reilly, T. (2015). Networks and the nature of the firm. Retrieved from https://medium.com/the-wtf-economy/networks-and-the-nature-of-the-firm-28790b6afdcc
- Pole, C. (2000). Technicians and scholars in pursuit of the PhD: Some reflections on doctoral study. Research Papers in Education, 15(1), 95–111. https://doi.org/10.1080/026715200362961
10.1080/026715200362961 Google Scholar
- Ražem (Ur.), D. (2015). STEM education: To build a scientist. Nature, 523, 371–373. https://doi.org/10.1038/nj7560-371a
10.1038/nj7560-371a Google Scholar
- Readings, B. (1997). The university in ruins. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
- Research Council UK (RCUK). (2010). Review of progress in implementing the recommendations of Sir Gareth Roberts, regarding employability and career development of PhD students and research staff: A report for Research Councils UK by an Independent Review Panel. Retrieved from https://www.rcuk.ac.uk/documents/skills/IndependentReviewHodge-pdf/
- Shafik, M. (2017). Experts must fight back. Retrieved from https://www.timeshighereducation.com/opinion/experts-must-fight-back
- Sher, B. (2006). Refuse to choose! A revolutionary program for doing everything that you love. New York, NY: Holtzbrinck.
- Simmons, M. (2015). How one life hack from a self-made billionaire leads to exceptional success. Retrieved from https://www.forbes.com/sites/michaelsimmons/2015/03/23/how-one-life-hack-from-a-self-made-billionaire-leads-to-exceptional-success/3/ - 10bb93e54124
- Simmons, M., & Chew, I. (2016). How to think like Elon Musk. Retrieved from https://fortune.com/2016/08/11/how-to-think-like-elon-musk/
- Skovholt, T. M., & Jennings, L. (2016). A brief history of expertise. In Master therapists: Exploring expertise in therapy and counseling ( 10th anniversary ed.). Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press. Retrieved from https://www.oxfordclinicalpsych.com/view/10.1093/med:psych/9780190496586.001.0001/med-9780190496586-chapter-1?rskey=PAEDvk&result=6
- Susskind, R., & Susskind, D. (2015). The future of the professions: How technology will transform the work of human experts [Kindle DX version]. Retrieved from Amazon.com
- Turner, S. (2001). What is the problem with experts? Social Studies of Science, 31(1), 123–149. https://doi.org/10.1177/030631201031001007
- Turner, S. P. (2010). Normal accidents of expertise. Minerva, 48, 239–258. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11024-010-9153-z
- Universities Australia. (2016). Keep it clever: Policy statement 2016. Retrieved from https://www.universitiesaustralia.edu.au/news/policy-papers/Keep-it-Clever-Policy-Statement-2016#.Wyh2IlOFM3E
- Universities Australia. (2017). Startup smarts: Universities and the startup economy. Retrieved from https://www.universitiesaustralia.edu.au/ArticleDocuments/212/Startup_web2.pdf.aspx
- University of British Columbia. (2018). Graduate pathways to success. Retrieved from https://www.grad.ubc.ca/current-students/graduate-pathways-success
- Vitae: CRAC. (2016). What do research staff do next? Cambridge, UK: CRAC. Retrieved from https://www.vitae.ac.uk/vitae-publications/reports/vitae-what-do-research-staff-do-next-2016.pdf
- Wapnick, E. (2015). Why some of us don’t have one true calling. Retrieved from https://www.ted.com/talks/emilie_wapnick_why_some_of_us_don_t_have_one_true_calling - t-281852
- Wapnick, E. (2017). Why you should stop striving for ‘mastery’, and what to aim for instead. Retrieved from https://puttylike.com/why-you-should-stop-striving-for-mastery-and-what-to-aim-for-instead/
- Winch, C. (2017). Professional knowledge, expertise and perceptual ability. Journal of Philosophy of Education, 51(3), 673–688. https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-9752.12257
- Ylijoki, O.-H., & Henriksson, L. (2017). Tribal, proletarian and entrepreneurial career stories: Junior academics as a case in point. Studies in Higher Education, 42(7), 1292–1308. https://doi.org/10.1080/03075079.2015.1092129