Introduction
Thyroid hormone (TH) action is mediated through specific TH receptors (TRs) functioning as ligand‐dependent transcription factors that increase or decrease the expression of target genes, depending on whether the gene promoters contain, respectively, positively or negatively regulated TH response elements (
Yen and Chin, 1994;
Mangelsdorf et al., 1995). On positive TH response elements, the unliganded TRs suppress basal gene transcription activity by interacting with co‐repressors such as nuclear co‐repressor (NCoR), silencing mediator of retinoic acid (SMRT) and triiodothyronine (T
3) receptor‐associating co‐factor (TRAC) (
Chen and Evans, 1995;
Hörlein et al., 1995;
Kurokawa et al., 1995;
Sande and Privalsky, 1996), associated with histone deacetylase via an intermediate factor (
Nagy et al., 1997). Conformational changes of the TR, produced by T
3 binding, release the co‐repressor complex and recruit co‐activators such as steroid receptor co‐activator 1 (SRC‐1), transcriptional intermediary factor 2 (TIF2) and p300/cAMP response element‐binding protein‐interacting protein (p/CIP) (
Oñate et al., 1995;
Voegel et al., 1996;
Hayashi et al., 1997;
Torchia et al., 1997), all exhibiting histone acetyltransferase activity. The latter modifies the structure of the chromatin and, through loosening the nucleosome at the site of the promoter, activates gene transcription (
Adams and Workman, 1993;
Wolffe and Pruss, 1996).
In vitro experiments show that promoter sequences of genes regulated negatively by TH are stimulated by the unliganded TR and repressed with the addition of TH, by mechanisms that are not well understood (
Hollenberg et al., 1995;
Tagami et al., 1997). These experiments serve as prototypes for the
in vivo effects of TH on thyrotropin (TSH) gene expression.
Resistance to thyroid hormone (RTH) is an inherited syndrome of variable tissue hyposensitivity to thyroid hormone (
Refetoff and Weiss, 1997). The diagnostic features of the syndrome are elevated free TH concentrations in serum without the expected suppression of TSH. RTH is caused by mutations in the
TRβ gene that have been identified in affected subjects belonging to >150 families (
Announcement, 1994; unpublished observation). Most commonly, mutations are located in the ligand‐binding domain of the TRβ, which reduce its affinity for TH and interfere with the function of the wild‐type TR to produce dominantly inherited RTH (
Adams et al., 1994;
Hayashi et al., 1995). Recently, some mutant TRβs were found to have impaired interaction with one of the co‐factors involved in the regulation of TH action (
Yoh et al., 1997;
Collingwood et al., 1998;
Liu et al., 1998;
Tagami et al., 1998). Pertinent to the current work are mutant TRβs with reduced ligand‐dependent transactivation that appears to be due in part to a weaker interaction with the co‐activator, SRC‐1 (
Collingwood et al., 1998;
Liu et al., 1998). The identification of RTH in the absence of mutations in the TRβ or TRα genes (
Weiss et al., 1996) lends further support to the hypothesis that defective co‐factors could, by themselves, cause RTH.
In vitro studies have shown that SRC‐1, first identified as steroid receptor co‐activator (
Oñate et al., 1995), functions as a co‐activator of other nuclear receptors, including the TR (
Jeyakumar et al., 1997;
Feng et al., 1998). Also known as the nuclear co‐activator 1 (NcoA‐1), SRC‐1 is widely distributed in tissues that express TRs, including the pituitary gland (
Misti et al., 1998). The opportunity to establish the physiological role of SRC‐1 in the mediation of TH action and to determine whether or not this ubiquitous co‐activator may be involved in the syndrome of RTH arose with the development of mice deficient in SRC‐1 (SRC‐1
−/−) (
Xu et al., 1998). Though fertile, these mice exhibit partial resistance to sex steriod hormones as evidenced by decreased growth and development of target tissues and reduced responses to estrogen and androgen.
Our studies show that the SRC−/− mice exhibit the cardinal features of RTH in humans, namely increased serum free TH [thyroxine (T4) and T3] levels, associated with high concentration of TSH. Furthermore, compared with the wild‐type (SRC‐1+/+) mice, larger amounts of l‐T3 were required to suppress their serum TSH. In contrast, upregulation of TSH by TH deprivation was not impaired in the SRC−/− mouse.
The SRC‐1 knock‐out mouse provides a model for the detailed investigation of the regulation of TH action in the absence of one specific co‐activator, SRC‐1, through hormonal manipulations that could not be carried out in humans.
Discussion
In this study we demonstrate that SRC‐1 is an important
in vivo enhancer of TH‐dependent action. Mice deficient in SRC‐1 display resistance to thyroid hormone as evidenced by the elevated serum TSH levels despite high serum free T
4 and T
3. The increase in TH concentration is TSH‐driven, since suppression of TSH by the administration of supraphysiological doses of
l‐T
3 resulted in reduction of endogenous T
4 to levels one‐tenth of the baseline level. Further evidence for the reduced sensitivity of the thyrotroph to TH was obtained by the demonstration that administration of
l‐T
3, in doses that almost completely suppress the serum TSH of SRC‐1
+/+ mice, had only a partial suppressive effect on TSH and T
4 in SRC‐1
−/− mice. A 4‐fold higher dose of
l‐T
3 is required to produce TSH suppression in the SRC‐1
−/− mouse (0.020 ± 0.10 ng/ml) of equal magnitude as that in the SRC‐1
+/+ mouse (0.016 ± 0.011 ng/ml). Thus as observed previously
in vitro (
Tagami et al., 1997), the co‐activator SRC‐1 also behaves as a co‐repressor
in vivo when it interacts with a gene that is negatively regulated by TH.
The reduced sensitivity of SRC‐1−/− mice to l‐T3 was independent of their higher baseline T4 and TSH levels because it was also observed when pre‐treatment levels of these hormones were equalized in SRC‐1−/− and SRC‐1+/+ mice by induction of hypothyroidism. Notably, the absence of SRC‐1 did not affect the full ligand‐independent stimulation of TSH. Presumably this effect is mediated through the association of the unliganded receptor with one of the co‐repressors (NcoR or SMRT). The latter act as co‐activators on genes negatively regulated by TH by a mechanism that is not well understood.
While there is ample
in vitro evidence that SRC‐1 potentiates the effect of TH on the regulation of TR target genes (
Jeyakumar et al., 1997;
Feng et al., 1998;
Tagami et al., 1998), the current study demonstrates for the first time that this effect also holds true
in vivo. The study also shows that a receptor co‐activator other than a TR can produce RTH. This possibility has been suspected previously in one family that fully expressed the RTH phenotype in the absence of mutations in either the TRβ or TRα genes (
Weiss et al., 1996). Our preliminary data, using crude nuclear extracts from fibroblasts of affected members from this family, suggested the involvement of a protein co‐factor that associates with TRβ. It is also likely that the role of SRC‐1 in the mediation of the dominant‐negative effect of mutant TRβs is more important than currently suspected (
Tagami et al., 1998).
The precise mechanism whereby SRC‐1 deficiency produces RTH remains a matter of speculation. If CBP binds more strongly to the T
3‐TR/SRC‐1 complex than to the T
3‐TR alone, then the absence of SRC‐1 should reduce the efficacy of ligand‐mediated TR effect. By the same token, in dominantly inherited RTH without TR mutation, the putatively defective SRC‐1 molecule could engage the T
3‐TR to form an inactive complex that will compete for binding to the target gene promoters and thus exert dominant‐negative effect. Furthermore, a state of SCR‐1 deficiency may develop in the pituitary gland of subjects with mutant TRβs because of the failure to respond to the TH‐mediated upregulation of SRC‐1 (
Misti et al., 1998). Since SRC‐1 does not associate with unliganded TRs (
Yoh et al., 1997;
Collingwood et al., 1998;
Liu et al., 1998;
Tagami et al., 1998), it is not surprising that serum TSH concentrations were not perturbed in TH‐deprived SRC‐1
−/− mice.
In order to compare the magnitude of RTH in SRC‐1 deficient mice with that observed in mice deficient in TRβ (
Forrest et al., 1996;
Weiss et al., 1997), TRβ2 isoform only (
Abel et al., 1998), TRα (
Gauthier et al., 1999), TRα1 isoform only (
Wikstsöm et al., 1998), and combined TRβ and TRα (
Gauthier et al., 1999), we graded the relative resistance of the pituitary thyrotrophs to TH. This is expressed as the magnitude of TSH increase, and to lesser extent T
4, relative to those in the corresponding wild‐type controls: wild type = TRα1 = TRα < TRβ2 = SRC‐1 < TRβ << TRβ and TRα. Activation of TSH in the absence of ligand is not impaired in mice lacking the
SRC‐1 or the
TRβ gene (
Weiss et al., 1997). These results, together with the similarly high TSH levels in the combined TRβ and TRα knock‐out mice (
Gauthier et al., 1999), indicate that neither co‐activator nor TRs are required for full expression of TSH.
Materials and methods
Generation and handling of animals
SRC‐1 deficient (knock‐out or SRC‐1
−/−) mice have a targeted mutation that inserted an in‐frame stop codon at the Met381 position and deleted ∼9 kb of genomic sequence extending downstream of Met381. This eliminated all SRC‐1 functional domains for trasciptional activiation, histone acetyltransferase activity and interactions with nuclear receptors: CBP, P300 and p/CAF (
Xu et al., 1998). The SRC‐1
−/− gene defect was maintained on a hybrid genetic background of parental C57B1/6J and 129/SV mouse strains. Heterozygous SRC‐1
−/+ mice were interbred to generate litters containing homozygous SRC‐1
−/− and SRC‐1
+/+ progeny. The genotype of mice was confirmed by analysis of tail DNA as described previously (
Xu et al., 1998).
Mice were weaned on the fourth week after birth and were fed Purina Rodent Chow (0.8 p.p.m. iodine) ad libitum and tap water. They were housed, five mice per cage, in an environment with a controlled temperature of 19°C and 12 h alternating darkness and artificial light cycles. All animal experiments were performed according to approved protocols at Baylor College of Medicine and the University of Chicago.
All mice were 60–70 days old at the beginning of each experiment. Weights of SRC‐1+/+ and SRC−/− mice overlapped and mean ± SD were 25.1 ± 2.7 versus 27.8 ± 1.5 g, respectively. TH deficiency was induced by feeding with low iodine (Lo I) diet supplemented with 0.15% propylthiouracil (PTU) purchased from Harlan Teklad Co. (Madison, WI).
At various intervals, ∼300 μl of blood were obtained by retro‐orbital vein puncture under light methoxyflurane (Pitman Moore, Mundelein, IL) anesthesia. Experiments were terminated by exsanguination by the same method. Serum was separated by centrifugation and stored at −20°C until analyzed in the same assay for each experiment.
Induction of hypothyroidism and treatment with TH
Thyroid hormone deficiency was induced in male SRC‐1−/− and SRC‐1+/+ mice (12 in each group) by feeding Lo I/PTU diet. On the eleventh day, groups (6 mice each) of SRC‐1−/− and SRC‐1+/+ mice were injected once daily for 4 days with the vehicle only and others received 0.2 μg of l‐T3/mouse/daily (∼0.8 μg/100 g body weight/day) while the Lo I/PTU diet was continued. Twelve to 16 h after the last injection, the experiment was terminated by exsanguination. l‐T3, dissolved in phosphate‐buffered saline and 0.002% human serum albumin as a vehicle, was given by intraperitoneal injection in a total volume of 0.2–0.3 ml. A stock solution of l‐T3 (Sigma, St Louis, MO) was prepared in water containing 4 mM NaOH and kept at 4°C, protected from light. The concentration of l‐T3 was confirmed by RIA (Diagnostic Products, Los Angeles, CA). Blood samples were obtained at baseline, on the fifth and tenth days after the initiation of the Lo I/PTU diet and at the termination of the experiment on day 14.
In a separate experiment, l‐T3 was given, using the same schedule, to mice with no prior induction of hypothyroidism but in two consecutive incremental doses. The first dose of 0.05 μg l‐T3/mouse/day, given for 4 days, was followed by 0.2 μg l‐T3/mouse/day for 4 additional days. Blood samples were obtained at baseline, before treatment, and 12–16 h after the last dose injection of each incremental l‐T3 dose. There were 10 male mice of each phenotype.
The doses of l‐T3 given to intact and thyroid hormone deficient animals were derived from previous experiments. They were optimized to achieve a partial suppression of serum TSH in order to make evident the differences between wild‐type and SRC‐1−/− mice. A 4‐fold lower dose of l‐T3 was required in intact, as compared to hypothyroid mice to produce a similar suppressive effect on serum TSH.
Measurements of TH and TSH concentrations in serum
Serum TSH was measured in 50 μl of serum using a sensitive, heterologous, disequilibrium double antibody precipitation radioimmunoassay as previously described (
Weiss et al., 1997). The sensitivity of this assay ranged from 0.01–0.02 ng/ml with intra‐assay coefficients of variation of 16, 19 and 10% at 0.04, 0.4 and 4 ng/ml, respectively. Samples containing >5 ng TSH/ml were 5‐fold diluted with a TSH‐deficient mouse serum.
Serum T4 and total T3 concentrations were measured by a double antibody precipitation RIA (Diagnostic Products, Los Angeles, CA) using 25 and 50 μl of serum, respectively. The sensitivity of these assays were 0.2 μg T4/dl (2.6 nmol/l) and 20 ng T3/dl (0.5 nmol/l). The inter‐assay co‐efficients of variation were 5.4, 4.2 and 3.6% at 3.8, 9.4 and 13.7 μg/dl for T4; and 7.7, 7.1 and 6.2% at 32, 53 and 110 ng/dl for T3. Free T4 and free T3 was estimated by the free indexes (FT4I and FT3I) using the respective total hormone values and the resin T4 uptake test.
Data presentation and statistics
Values are reported as mean ± SD.
p values were calculated using the Student's
t‐test. Values corresponding to the respective limits of the assays sensitivities were assigned to samples that measured below the detectable range. Only one SRC
−/− mouse on Lo I/PTU diet that was given the vehicle died before completion of the experiment. One SRC‐1
+/+ mouse on Lo I/PTU diet that was given L‐T
3 had a serum TSH level of 1.63 ng/ml prior to the initiation of treatment and was determined to be an outlier by a two‐tailed test with a significance level of <0.05 (
Grubbs, 1969;
Grubbs and Beck, 1972).