The Wayback Machine - https://web.archive.org/web/20080917145158/http://livenews.com.au:80/Articles/2008/09/09/Wikipedia_attacked_over_porn_pages
Macquarie Network ::: 2GB | 2CH | LIVENEWS | RUGBYLEAGUELIVE | WHAT CAREER | AMAZING AUSTRALIANS :::
Thursday, 18 September 2008

Wikipedia attacked over porn pages

9/09/2008 3:27:00 PM.  | Richard Maxton
Wikipedia has come under fire for allowing graphic videos and photographs on its articles, with some the site's editors agreeing some pages are becoming pornographic.

Child protection campaigners say graphic sexual content appears on many Wikipedia entries, displayed without any warning or age verification.

Videos of masturbation and ejaculation as well as photos from "hardcore" porn films can be found within the online encyclopedia's pages.

Wikipedia relies on users to provide content - abandoning formal editing and censoring processes - and as such the accuracy and appropriateness of its articles are continually in question.

One Wikipedia editor, who has been been trying to have an 18-video of a man ejaculating removed, has told News Ltd much of Wikipedia's contentious content is "overkill".

"A video of a woman giving herself a breast exam would be educational and ... a video of a man giving himself a testicle exam would be educational in relevant articles," the user says.

"Images alone are not enough for those processes, but a video of a man ejaculating - when there is an image that shows it stage by stage - is not needed."

Head of child protection agency Childwise, Bernadette McMeniman, says while she supports sex education, displaying sexualised images in a freely available online encyclopedia "crosses the line".

"Does that mean that when you type in 'murder', you should actually see someone murdering someone else?" she told News Ltd.

"Do we really need to see a woman masturbating on Wikipedia? Do we really need to see so many seconds of ejaculation?"

Many "obscene" images have been removed on the back of arguments that they do not contribute to an article and appear to be shown for titillation, not education.

On a discussion page, one user complained a photograph of female genitalia was too sexualised for the site.

"I don't think that (Wikipedia) is the place for this ... even in medical school, you deal mostly with diagrams - not French manicured nails."

Wikipedia's policy is that "no censorship" is applied to the online encyclopedia, except in cases of article vandalism.

"Obviously inappropriate content (such as an irrelevant link to a shock site, or clear vandalism) is usually removed quickly," the site says.

"However, some articles may include objectionable text, images, or links where they are relevant to the content - such as the articles about the penis or pornography."

COMMENTS

Tuesday, 09 September 2008

Bernadette McMeniman says "Does that mean that when you type in 'murder', you should actually see someone murdering someone else?" Yes Bernadette. Murder is real and just like the books in your public library, you can find real images and footage of murder in online encylopedias. One of the most famous examples being the street execution of Viet Cong Captain Nguyen Van Lem: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Image:Nguyen.jpg Shall we censor that to? Michael - SomebodyThinkoftheChildren.com

Posted by: Michael Meloni, Brisbane

 

Tuesday, 09 September 2008

It is indeed true that Wikipedia is not censored for the protection of minors. However, there is an option available for parents to keep their children from seeing images there that they may consider offensive or upsetting. See here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Options_to_not_see_an_image

Posted by: Modemac Modemac, Boston, Massachusetts

 

Wednesday, 10 September 2008

nothing worse there that a quick google search wouldnt return either.. id suggest if porn offends ye, stop searching the internet for it.

Posted by: mr pervy, the shrubbery

 
 

YOUR SAY




 


 

500 characters maximum. 500 characters left.


 

* Required field

 
Register to receive daily news and sports details

YOUR SAY

Recycle??? I used to collect all cardboard from work, break it down flat and cage it. when baled it'd get picked up and sent from... Nick Again, Maryborough on Calls for bottle recycling scheme

This has been dismissed as a joke in US media, I'm hoping for a McCain/Palin victory! You go McCain!... Patricia S, Sydney on Adviser says McCain helped create the BlackBerry

FINALLY, in Australia we have the richest Labor leader up against the richest Liberal leader, guess who is going to pay for this fiasco people.....that's... keith rowland, tweed heads on Turnbull sharpens his sword against Labor leaders

Superannuation, Hmmmm sounds Tasty........Sorry susan, Me thinks the quiet on the Super maybe the sign that its Safe. Safely Scuppered by Folding financial giant????? Get... Nick Again, Maryborough on MP who used Parliament to beef about stroganoff cops heat

Psst. It's "Artemis Fowl," not "Foul." Unless you were editorializing. ;)... Jillian Shumaker, Morgantown WV on New Hitchhiker's Guide book penned by Artemis Foul author